
==== Front
Int J Sports Phys Ther
Int J Sports Phys Ther
2159
International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy
2159-2896
NASMI Website: International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy

38439782
92703
10.26603/001c.92703
Original Research
The Effect of Exercise-Induced Central Fatigue on Cervical Spine Joint Position Error, Strength, and Endurance
Vintimilla Antonio 1
Hooper Troy
James C. Roger
Lu Ho Cheng
Natesan Karthick
Kapila Jeegisha
Sizer Phil
1 Rehabilitation Sciences Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center https://ror.org/033ztpr93
Corresponding author: Antonio Vintimilla, PT, DPT, PhD(c) Mailing Address: 3601 4th St, Lubbock, TX, 79430 Email Address: antoniovintimilla94@gmail.com Phone: (682) 561-7588
2 3 2024
2024
19 3 290300
9 10 2023
6 1 2024
© The Author(s)
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (4.0) which permits non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Background

Fatigue is common in sports, impairing performance and increasing injury risk, yet little is known regarding fatigue and concussion. Impaired neck neuromuscular function may contribute to concussion at baseline, where central fatigue may further impair neck function resulting in increased concussion risk. These effects may be magnified in athletes with a history of concussion.

Purpose

To determine the effect of exercise induced central fatigue on neck joint position error, strength, and endurance in healthy subjects and those with a history of concussion. The investigators hypothesized that EICF would have a negative effect on all variables.

Study Design

Healthy subjects were examined using a single factor, within-subjects repeated measures design. Concussion history subjects were examined using a single-subject design.

Methods

Nineteen healthy subjects and five subjects with a history of concussion were recruited for the study. Cervical joint position error, muscle strength, and neck flexor endurance were tested before and after exercise induced fatigue.

Results

There was a significant increase in constant (p = 0.0027) and absolute joint position error (JPE) (p < 0.001); decrease in neck flexor endurance (p < 0.001); and decrease neck strength into cervical flexion (p = 0.01) in healthy subjects following fatigue. Among concussion history subjects, five demonstrated a significant increase in absolute and constant JPE (p < 0.05); four demonstrated a significant decrease in neck flexor endurance (p < 0.05); one in neck flexion muscle strength (p < 0.05); and three in neck extension and rotation muscle strength (p < 0.05) following fatigue.

Conclusions

Cervical neuromuscular function deteriorated following fatigue in healthy subjects. Resulting impairments may affect force alterations in cervical control, potentially increasing concussion risk. Concussion history subjects descriptively demonstrated similar results, however further research should examine formal comparisons involving subjects with and without concussion history.

Level of Evidence

3b

concussion
neck pain
motor control
fatigue
==== Body
pmcIntroduction

Fatigue is a complex physiological state that often results in impaired bodily function.1,2 Fatigue has various etiologies with one of the most common being physical exercise, otherwise known as exertion fatigue.2,3 There are two primary fatigue types which result from exertion: peripheral and central. Peripheral fatigue pertains to that involving the peripheral nervous system, particularly the neuromuscular junction, and the working skeletal muscle. It is thought to be isolated to working muscles with minimal distal effects, though it may put the involved tissue at increased injury risk.4

Central fatigue arises from the central nervous system with sustained exercise, potentially serving as protection from catastrophic homeostatic disruption.1,5 It is generally thought of as whole-body cardiovascular fatigue, also known as exercise-induced central fatigue (EICF). In a centrally fatigued state, there is a net reduction in spinal mediated reflexes, producing an increased difficulty activating motor neurons and a decline in motor unit firing rates. These changes are facilitated by presynaptic modulation and autogenic inhibition of muscle spindle, Golgi tendon organ, and small diameter muscle-afferent inputs.1,6 In athletes, these effects are accompanied by the concern of diminished (worse) athletic performance, as several authors have reported balance, landing, throwing, and running impairments in athletes in a fatigued state, among others.7–9

Another major component of EICF is psychological, or mental fatigue. While not strictly exertion induced, mental fatigue plays a significant role in the physical impairments seen with EICF, including central components such as cognitive processing, contributing to mental fatigue onset with sustained exercise.2,10 Mental fatigue does not directly affect maximal voluntary muscle contraction. Instead, it appears to alter the individual’s perception of an expended effort, which may affect maximal voluntary muscle contraction.11,12 Ultimately, task failure with EICF is a complex multisystem phenomenon.

At the mercy of the previously described physiological and physical manifestations, EICF is accepted as an increased risk factor for numerous different injuries.13,14 However, the effect of EICF on the head and neck region is not well understood. This interaction is important due to potential implications for head injury, particularly concussion. In sport, concussion incidence tends to increase in the second half of the season and the second half of single sporting events, yet evidence explaining why this occurs is unavailable.15,16 A study performed on professional hockey players found that increased play time over a game correlated with increased concussion incidence, suggesting in-game fatigue may be a cause.17 However, the question remains, why would fatigue increase concussion incidence? One prospective explanation involves aspects of performance of the head and neck.

Impaired cervical spine (CS) proprioception, muscle strength, and endurance increase the risk of suffering a concussion.18–20 Fatigue may further compromise the CS and increase concussion risk. Among available evidence, central fatigue has been found to increase CS angle reproduction error in healthy adults.21 Fatigue may reveal these subclinical deficiencies that could contribute to undetected concussion risk, particularly in the head and neck, affecting athletes’ ability to sufficiently mitigate forces on structures within the region. This effect may be more pronounced in athletes with a history of concussions, as they may have long-lasting neurophysiological deficits.22–24

Therefore, the purpose of this study was to determine the effect of exercise induced central fatigue on neck joint position error, strength, and endurance in healthy subjects and those with a history of concussion. The investigators hypothesized that EICF would have a negative effect on all variables. This analysis will inform understanding of head and neck functional abilities in a fatigued state, as well as the impact on concussion risk and injury prevention strategies.

Methods

This study was conducted in two phases. Phase 1 involved CS performance testing in healthy subjects pre- and post-fatigue. Phase 2 examined CS performance in a small sample of subjects with concussion history pre- and post-fatigue. Both groups read and signed an informed consent approved by the associated IRB prior to participation.

Phase 1

Experimental Design

Group testing was performed using a single factor, within-subjects repeated measures design. Data were collected pre- and post-fatigue to determine differences in JPE, neck flexor endurance, and CS muscle strength.

Subjects

Subjects were healthy males and females between 18 and 50 years of age. Exclusion criteria were adapted based on absolute contraindications outlined in American College of Sports Medicine Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription as follows: (1) Pregnancy by self-report; (2) Physical disability with limited ability to participate in the testing; or (3) Any of the following conditions diagnosed by a health care provider and conveyed by subject self-report that would have prevented safe and adequate cardiovascular fatigue testing: (a) Hypertension; (b) Circulatory condition; (c) Cardiac condition; (d) Pulmonary condition; (e) Thyroid condition; or (f) History of cerebrovascular accident.25 Additional exclusion criteria included: (1) History of concussion within the prior year; (2) Current neck pain that required health care intervention or that significantly impaired daily functional activities; (3) Active headache or migraine that required health care intervention or that significantly impaired daily functional activities; or (4) History of head or neck surgery.

Experimental Procedure

All testing was performed by the same investigator. This investigator had previously demonstrated strong intra-rater reliability with all testing procedures. A second investigator recorded the data values, blinding the first investigator to the results. Testing began with JPE measurement in order to avoid the effects of neck muscle fatigue. The strength and endurance testing order was randomized to avoid an order effect.

Joint position error was tested by active rotation angle reproduction.26,27 Subjects were seated in a chair, wearing a disposable eye cover. They were instructed to sit as upright as possible with their hands positioned in their lap. Their knees were placed at 90 degrees of flexion and their feet were positioned on specific markings on the ground. Subjects self-determined their neutral head position and were then passively moved to 20 degrees of cervical rotation to either side, so that this position would serve as a starting point for each rotation direction, respectively. The compass app was “zeroed” at that 20-degree position. Subjects were instructed to memorize this position and replicate it following active movement into maximal cervical rotation in each direction. Subjects were asked to determine when they feel they had relocated the 20-degree angle position, and the actual position was recorded in degrees. Following familiarization, subjects performed one bilateral rotation practice trial and six bilateral testing trials.

Two different error scores were obtained from the raw JPE values: absolute error and constant error. Absolute error is defined as the mean of the total deviation from the starting point over the trials, ignoring positive (overshoot) and negative (undershoot) values. This value represents the overall magnitude of error among the trials without considering the direction. Constant error is defined as the mean of the raw error over the trials incorporating the positive and negative values in each trial. This value represents the average magnitude and, unlike absolute error, uses the direction of the error. Studies suggest that a combination of absolute and constant error is best suited for measuring JPE.28 These values are derived from the following equations:

Absolute Error = (absolute of raw error trial 1) + (trial 2)… + (trial 6)/6

Constant Error = (raw error trial 1) + (trial 2)… + (trial 6)/6

Neck endurance measurements were assessed via the neck flexor endurance test.29,30 For testing, subjects assumed a supine hook lying position with their hands on their abdomen. Subjects were then instructed to retract their chin and lift their head 2.5cm off the plinth while maintaining their chin retraction. The investigator drew a line across two adjacent skin folds on the subject’s anterolateral neck, then placed his index and middle fingers in a stacked position below the subject’s most posterior occiput. Subjects were asked to relax and rest their head on the investigator’s hand, and then maintain contact during the test procedure. Once they lifted the head high enough to unload the head’s weight from the investigator’s fingers while continuing to maintain light contact with the same fingers, the investigator moved those fingers side to side to provide tactile cuing for optimal positioning. Subjects were instructed to maintain their lifted position as long as possible. The test was terminated when any one of the following occurred for more than one second: (1) the drawn line edges no longer approximated each other; (2) the subject’s head rested on the investigator’s fingers; (3) subjects raised their head enough to no longer contact the investigator’s fingers. Additionally, the test was terminated if subjects were unwilling to continue. Test duration was recorded in seconds. All subjects performed one practice trial followed by one-minute rest. Next, all subjects performed three recorded trials with one-minute rest between each trial.

Measurements for CS muscle strength were assessed via a hand-held dynamometer (HHD; MicroFet2, Hoggan Scientific, Inc; Salt Lake City, UT, USA).31 Subjects were seated and restrained at the trunk and shoulder levels to reduce accessory trunk movement. One test trial included a strength test into cervical flexion, extension, and bilateral rotation. The investigator placed the HHD at the subject’s forehead for flexion, occiput for extension and lower jaw for rotation. Subjects were instructed to clench their jaw during rotation. They were instructed to perform maximal voluntary isometric contractions into each movement direction and hold each contraction for 5 seconds. All subjects performed one practice trial followed by 10-seconds rest. Next, all subjects performed three recorded trials with 10-seconds rest in-between each trial. Mean values were used for statistical analysis.

Fatigue Protocol

Following baseline testing, subjects began a modified Bruce treadmill test to induce central fatigue. The protocol was conducted as outlined in the American College of Sports Medicine Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription.25 Subjects were not tested for the purpose of cardiovascular assessment and therefore were not monitored via electrocardiogram. The test consisted of six 3-minute stages as follows:

1 – 1.7mph, 10 %GR

2 – 2.5mph, 12 %GR

3 – 3.4mph, 14 %GR

4 – 4.2mph, 16 %GR

5 – 5.0mph, 18 %GR

6 – 5.5mph, 20 %GR

Subjects were instructed to continue each test trial until they: (1) reached fatigue and could no longer continue; (2) reached 85% of their age predicated HRmax (whichever came first); or (3) desired to stop. Heart rate values were collected continuously using a chest monitor. Blood pressure values were collected at baseline and following protocol completion. Subjects were assumed to be centrally fatigued following each protocol completion.

To establish central fatigue effects on sensorimotor control, post-fatigue JPE, neck flexor endurance, and CS muscle strength measurements were conducted using the previously described procedures. Following the first fatigue event, JPE testing was performed. Subjects then returned to the treadmill and began the Bruce treadmill test one level below the previously terminated level to avoid recovery. Following the second fatigue event, either endurance or strength testing was performed in the same random order as in the pre-fatigue protocol. Subsequently, subjects again returned to the treadmill and began the Bruce Treadmill test one level below the previously terminated level. Following the last fatigue event, subjects performed the remaining out of strength and endurance testing.

Phase 2

Experimental Design

Phase-2 data were not used to test statistical hypotheses. This exploratory component used a multiple single-subject design to examine how a small sample of subjects with concussion history individually responded to the same experimental parameters.

Subjects

Inclusion and exclusion criteria for Phase-2 subjects were the same as Phase-1. However, Phase-2 subjects’ inclusion criteria required a history of at least three concussions within their lifetime. Subjects self-reported that they could participate in high-intensity exercise without symptoms, indicating that they had recovered from any previous concussion.

Experimental Procedure

Preparatory procedures, baseline testing, the fatigue protocol, and post-fatigue testing were conducted in the same manner as group testing in Phase-1.

Statistical Analysis

Data were analyzed using R (R Core Team, 3.6.1, Vienna, Austria) and RStudio Team (2020, Boston, MA).

Phase 1

Mean, median, standard deviation, 95%CI, skewness, and kurtosis were used to describe central tendency and dispersion. Shapiro Wilk test statistic and probability, density plotting, as well as skewness and kurtosis values were used to assess normality.

A prospective power analysis estimated 19 subjects to obtain a desired power of 80% (1-β=0.80) at a significance level of α= .05 (G-Power 3.1.7.9, Kiel, Germany), and a moderate effect size (Cohen’s d = 0.5). A paired t-test was used to determine differences in values for JPE, neck flexor endurance, and CS muscle strength before and after the fatiguing protocol. All parametric assumptions were satisfied. Bonferroni correction was used for JPE and strength variables post-hoc to correct for multiple comparisons and reduce the likelihood of a Type-1 error.32 Cohens d effect sizes are also reported.

Phase 2

Concussion history subjects’ data were analyzed using plots and mean, standard deviation, and percent change values. Analysis of mean differences was assessed using the two standard deviation band method. Two consecutive fatigue condition data points outside of the before fatigue conditions’ two standard deviation band was considered a statistically significant difference (p < 0.05).32

Results

Phase-1

The healthy group consisted of nine males and ten females with an average age of 32 years (SD = 8), average height of 1.7m (SD = 0.12), and average weight of 74.1kg (SD = 16.2). Mean values for the healthy group are summarized in Table 1.

193743 Table 1. Healthy group results

State	Constant JPE	Absolute JPE	Neck Flexor Endurance	CS Flexion strength	CS Extension Strength	CS Rotation Strength	
Pre-Fatigue	7.3°±4.1*	8°±3.6*	35.5s±10.4*	141N±34*	209N±76	124N±27	
Post-Fatigue	8.9°±4.5*	9.8°±3.9*	26.8s±7.6*	135N±28*	210N±88	119N±30	
* Significant p < 0.05, all others p > 0.05

Joint Position Error

There was a significant increase in constant (p = 0.003, Cohen’s d = 0.35) and absolute (p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.47) JPE with fatigue (Figure 1). Healthy subjects demonstrated a 20.7% and 21.8% increase in constant and absolute error with fatigue, respectively. Additionally, increased variance for constant JPE was observed post-fatigue, suggesting less accuracy and precision overall. This post-fatigue error was comprised of an increase in either under- or over-shooting for each subject, where overshooting occurred more frequently overall.

193799 Figure 1. Box plots representing mean constant JPE (A) and mean absolute JPE (B) in degrees, in healthy subjects pre- and post-fatigue.

Neck Flexor Endurance

There was a significant decrease in neck flexor endurance times with fatigue (p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.95) (Figure 2). Subjects demonstrated a 24.5% decrease in endurance times with fatigue.

193800 Figure 2. Box plot representing mean neck flexor endurance times in seconds, in healthy subjects pre- and post-fatigue.

Muscle Strength

There was a significant decrease in CS muscle strength into flexion (p = 0.01, Cohen’s d = 0.21) with fatigue. There was no significant strength difference into extension (p = 0.9) or rotation (p = 0.136) with fatigue (Figure 3). Subjects demonstrated a 4.7%, 0%, and 3.9% decrease in force production for flexion, extension, and rotation with fatigue, respectively.

193801 Figure 3. Box plots representing mean cervical flexion (A) extension (B), and rotation (C) muscle strength in Newtons, in healthy subjects pre- and post-fatigue.

Phase 2

Phase-2 consisted of five subjects with a history of at least three concussions within the lifetime. Subject demographics are summarized in Table 2.

193744 Table 2. Concussion History Subject Demographics

Subject	Age(years)	Sex	Height(m)	Weight(kg)	# concussions	Date of last concussion	
1	42	Male	1.85	88.5	12	July 2021	
2	25	Male	1.83	94.8	7	February 2020	
3	23	Female	1.5	58.9	6	2016	
4	28	Male	1.78	86.6	8	2011	
5	44	Male	1.57	65.3	3	2011	

Joint Position Error

Post-fatigue error was amplified in subjects with concussion history. There was a significant increase in constant JPE overall, where 4/5 subjects demonstrated a significant increase, while 1/5 subjects demonstrated a significant decrease in constant JPE with fatigue. Five of five subjects demonstrated a significant increase (p < 0.05) in absolute JPE with fatigue. Subjects with concussion history overall demonstrated a 30.2% and 50.2% increase in mean constant and absolute error, respectively. Moreover, subjects with concussion history demonstrated even greater variance following fatigue. Undershooting was observed more often than in healthy subjects, however overshooting was still observed more often overall. All concussion history subjects JPE trials have been nested together along with their mean for visualization (Figure 4). Subjects were previously individually analyzed where two consecutive data points outside of the two-standard deviation band was considered statistically significant (p < 0.05).

193802 Figure 4. Scatter plots representing all constant JPE (A) and absolute JPE (B) trials in degrees, in all concussion history subjects pre- and post-fatigue.

Neck Flexor Endurance

Neck flexor endurance impairments were amplified in subjects with concussion history. Four of five subjects demonstrated a significant decrease (p < 0.05) in neck flexor endurance following fatigue. Subjects with concussion history overall demonstrated a 44% decrease in mean endurance time overall. All concussion history subjects neck flexor endurance test (NFET) trials have been nested together along with their mean for visualization (Figure 5). Subjects were previously individually analyzed where two consecutive data points outside of the two-standard deviation band is statistically significant (p < 0.05).

193803 Figure 5. Scatter plot representing all neck flexor endurance trial times in seconds, in all concussion history subjects pre- and post-fatigue.

Muscle Strength

Cervical muscle strength results were mixed in subjects with concussion history. One of five subjects demonstrated a significant decrease in CS muscle strength into flexion with fatigue. Two of five subjects demonstrated a significant decrease, while 1/5 subjects demonstrated a significant increase in CS muscle strength into extension with fatigue. Three of five subjects demonstrated a significant decrease, while 1/5 subjects demonstrated a significant increase (p > 0.05) in CS muscle strength into rotation with fatigue. Subjects with concussion history overall demonstrated a 7.6%, 1.9% and 6.6% decrease in mean flexion, extension, and rotation force production, respectively. All concussion history subjects strength trials for flexion, extension, and rotation have been nested together with their mean for visualization (Figure 6). Subjects were previously individually analyzed where two consecutive data points outside of the two-standard deviation band is statistically significant (p < 0.05).

193804 Figure 6. Scatter plot representing all cervical flexion (A), extension (B), and rotation (C) cervical muscle strength trials in Newtons, in all concussion history subjects pre- and post-fatigue.

Discussion

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of exercise-induced central fatigue on cervical joint position error, muscular strength, and neck flexor endurance in healthy subjects. Additionally, a multiple single-subject design was used to determine how a small sample of subjects with concussion history responded to the same experimental parameters. Subjects were tested before and after a centrally fatiguing protocol. Central fatigue arises from the central nervous system and, unlike peripheral fatigue, produces widespread physiological effects.1,2 Central fatigue effects on the head-and-neck however, are not well understood. This interaction is important due to potential implications in concussion incidence and recovery. In a centrally fatigued state, systemic physiological functions are impaired, potentially compromising head-and-neck function and increasing concussion risk.1,2

Cervical spine proprioception, strength, and endurance have been previously examined with respect to their role in concussion and have been found as significant concussion predictors in males and females.18–20 Increased CS muscle strength is associated with an attenuated kinematic response to external forces applied to the head. Eckner et al. proposed increased CS strength to be a positive and modifiable risk factor for concussion.18 Farley et al. concluded that for every 10% increase in gross cervical rotation error there was a 5% increase in concussion rate among professional rugby players.19 Baker et al.33 found that neck flexor endurance was not predictive of increased concussion injury risk. However, preseason neck flexor endurance test times were 2.9 seconds lower in athletes who ended up concussed than those who did not. Additionally, they found that neck flexor endurance times improved predictably with concussion recovery in concussed athletes.33

While there is no direct evidence linking central fatigue to increased concussion risk, it is possible that central fatigue could impair head-and-neck function and, therefore, an athlete’s ability to respond quickly and effectively to collisions or impacts, leading to a higher likelihood of suffering a concussion. As a preliminary measure that could inform a person’s risk, a Bruce Protocol was used to confidently achieve 85% of their age-predicted maximal cardiovascular output and measure the predetermined variables in the subjects before and during a centrally fatigued state.25

Healthy subjects demonstrated a significant increase in constant and absolute JPE and a significant decrease in neck flexor endurance following central fatigue. Following fatigue, mean constant JPE was 8.9 degrees and absolute JPE was 9.8 degrees, surpassing typical JPE values of 2-5 degrees reported in the literature.28 These results are consistent with Okhravi et al., who found that general fatigue increased repositioning error of the head and neck in healthy subjects.21 All subjects with concussion history individually demonstrated a significant increase in error, where mean constant (7.3 degrees) and absolute (9.6 degrees) JPE post-fatigue surpassed typical JPE values reported in the literature as well.21

Despite an even distribution of males and females, the healthy group demonstrated an average pre-fatigue NFET time of 35.5 seconds, consistent with normative values for males reported in the literature (35.57±10.43 seconds).30 Following fatigue, the group mean fell to 26.8 seconds, below normative values for both males (35.57±10.43 seconds) and females (31.86±8.53 seconds) reported in the literature.30 Subjects with concussion history demonstrated an average NFET time of 27.1 seconds post-fatigue, below normative values for females reported in the literature despite consisting of only one female. Future research should involve a full group of subjects with concussion history to allow for formal comparisons.

Subjects across both groups demonstrated variable strength testing results. In healthy subjects, only a significant decrease in CS flexion strength was observed, accompanied by minimal, nonsignificant decreased changes across all other directions. There is no published physiological mechanism that could explain why CS flexion strength would decrease without significant changes in extension or rotation. Concussion incidence typically involves rotational impact forces, however no directional preferences in strength have been documented.18,20 Additionally, there is minimal data specifically addressing the effects of central fatigue on neck strength outcomes. The observed differences could be explained by chance or undetected error in methodology. Subjects with concussion history demonstrated minimal deficits overall. Subjects with a history of more frequent concussion incidence demonstrated significance across more test directions versus those with fewer concussions, however no conclusions can be drawn. Future research should further examine strength responses to EICF using more rigorous strength testing measures to better capture fatiguability.

Due to drastic group differences inferential statistics were not conducted between healthy subjects and those who had sustained concussion. Percent change for both groups can be found in Table 3, however, comparisons cannot be made or result in any inferential conclusions. Among subjects with concussion history, concussion volume may affect fatigue responses, as subjects with a greater number of concussions demonstrated more statistically significant variables than those with fewer.

193745 Table 3. Healthy and concussion history subject percent changes

Variable	%Change – Healthy	%Change – Concussion History	
Constant Joint Position Error	+21%	+30%	
Absolute Joint Position Error	+22%	+50%	
Neck Flexor Endurance	-24%	-44%	
Flexion Strength	-5%	-8%	
Extension Strength	0%	-2%	
Rotation Strength	-4%	-7%	

Previous authors have found impairments in gaze stability, sleep quality, and gait control long after concussion.34,35 Additionally, residual cognitive and linguistic deficits have been reported.36,37 Other investigators have discovered that athletes with concussion history have greater risk of presenting with more varied symptoms and higher symptom severity scores upon subsequent concussion.38 Future research should investigate whether central fatigue amplifies these existing impairments in those with concussion history, potentially increasing injury risk. Moreover, future research should examine fatigue effects on head-and-neck kinematics in the same subject sample.

This study had several limitations. Subjects included healthy subjects and a preliminary sample of subjects with a history of concussion to explore whether the measured parameters were influenced by the fatigue protocol. However, a full concussion history cohort suitable for inferential analysis could incorporate mixed models and allow comparisons between and within the two groups would be ideal in the future. Furthermore, the HHD used for strength testing only recorded the highest value of force detected. This instrument would not provide information regarding muscle activation and motor control. During testing, it was observed that both groups experienced greater difficulty performing each contraction, despite minimal quantitative differences. These observations suggest that an alternate tool, such as electromyography, may be well suited for further assessing muscle performance.39 Lastly, there was no head-and-neck kinematic assessment. Kinematic variables would provide a more in-depth functional assessment of fatigue effects on the head and neck and their implication in concussion.40

Conclusions

The current results suggest CS proprioception, strength, and endurance are impaired following central fatigue in healthy individuals. These effects may be more pronounced in those with a history of concussion, however further research is warranted. Athletes may be at an increased risk for injury occurrence and severity in a centrally fatigued state. Future studies should address the effect of exercise-induced central fatigue on head-and-neck kinematics and sensorimotor control, comparing a cohort of both healthy and previously concussed individuals.

Conflicts of interest

The authors report no conflicts of interest.

For inquires including access to additional data, contact antoniovintimilla94@gmail.com
==== Refs
Spinal and supraspinal factors in human muscle fatigue Physiological Reviews Gandevia S. C. 10 1 2001
81 4 1725 1789 0031-9333 10.1152/physrev.2001.81.4.1725 10.1152/physrev.2001.81.4.1725
Central and peripheral fatigue in physical exercise explained: A narrative review International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health Tornero-Aguilera José Francisco Jimenez-Morcillo Jorge Rubio-Zarapuz Alejandro Clemente-Suárez Vicente J. 25 3 2022
19 7 3909 1660-4601 10.3390/ijerph19073909 10.3390/ijerph19073909 35409591
Assessment of fatigue and recovery in sport: narrative review International Journal of Sports Medicine Bestwick-Stevenson Thomas Toone Rebecca Neupert Emma Edwards Kimberley Kluzek Stefan 25 4 2022
43 14 1151 1162 0172-4622 10.1055/a-1834-7177 10.1055/a-1834-7177
Components of fatigue: Mind and body Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research Carriker Colin R. 11 2017
31 11 3170 3176 1064-8011 10.1519/jsc.0000000000002088 10.1519/jsc.0000000000002088
Muscle fatigue: General understanding and treatment Experimental & Molecular Medicine Wan Jingjing Qin Zhen Wang Pengyuan Sun Yang Liu Xia 10 2017
49 10 e384 1226-3613 10.1038/emm.2017.194 10.1038/emm.2017.194 28983090
Recovery of central and peripheral neuromuscular fatigue after exercise Journal of Applied Physiology Carroll T. J. Taylor J. L. Gandevia S. C. 1 5 2017
122 5 1068 1076 8750-7587 10.1152/japplphysiol.00775.2016 10.1152/japplphysiol.00775.2016
Effect of fatigue caused by a simulated handball game on ball throwing velocity, shoulder muscle strength and balance ratio: A prospective study BMC Sports Science, Medicine and Rehabilitation Andrade Marília Santos de Carvalho Koffes Fabiana Benedito-Silva Ana Amélia da Silva Antonio Carlos de Lira Claudio Andre Barbosa 5 5 2016
8 1 13 2052-1847 10.1186/s13102-016-0038-9 10.1186/s13102-016-0038-9 27152198
The effect of fatigue on single-leg postural sway and its transient characteristics in healthy young adults Frontiers in Physiology Kozinc Žiga Trajković Nebojša Smajla Darjan Šarabon Nejc 18 8 2021
12 720905 1664-042X 10.3389/fphys.2021.720905 10.3389/fphys.2021.720905 34489739
Effects of fatigue on kinematics and kinetics during overground running: A systematic review The Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness Winter Sara Gordon Susan Watt Kerrianne Edizioni Minerva Medica 5 2017
57 6 0022-4707 10.23736/s0022-4707.16.06339-8 10.23736/s0022-4707.16.06339-8
The effects of moderate fatigue on dynamic balance control and attentional demands Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation Simoneau Martin Bégin François Teasdale Normand 28 9 2006
3 1 22 1743-0003 10.1186/1743-0003-3-22 10.1186/1743-0003-3-22 17007646
Endurance exercise-induced and mental fatigue and the brain Experimental Physiology Meeusen Romain Van Cutsem Jeroen Roelands Bart 2021
106 12 2294 2298 0958-0670 10.1113/ep088186 10.1113/ep088186 32176398
The effect of mental fatigue on cognitive and aerobic performance in adolescent active endurance athletes: Insights from a randomized counterbalanced, cross-over trial Journal of Clinical Medicine Slimani Maamer Znazen Hela Bragazzi Nicola Zguira Mohamed Tod David 3 12 2018
7 12 510 2077-0383 10.3390/jcm7120510 10.3390/jcm7120510 30513903
Acute effects of ACL injury-prevention warm-up and soccer-specific fatigue protocol on dynamic knee valgus in youth male soccer players International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health García-Luna Marco Andrés Cortell-Tormo Juan Manuel García-Jaén Miguel Ortega-Navarro Manuel Tortosa-Martínez Juan 4 8 2020
17 15 5608 1660-4601 10.3390/ijerph17155608 10.3390/ijerph17155608 32759692
Evaluating the effects of match-induced fatigue on landing ability; the case of the basketball game Int J Exerc Sci Liveris N Tsarbou C Tsimeas P D Papgeorgiou G Xergia S A Tsiokanos A 2021
14 6 768 778 34567377
Incidence and factors associated with concussion injuries at the 2011 to 2014 South African rugbyunion youth week tournaments Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine Mc Fie Sarah Brown James Hendricks Sharief Posthumus Michael Readhead Clint Lambert Mike September Alison V. Viljoen Wayne 9 2016
26 5 398 404 1050-642X 10.1097/jsm.0000000000000276 10.1097/jsm.0000000000000276
Game schedules and rate of concussions in the National Football League Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine Teramoto Masaru Cushman Daniel M. Cross Chad L. Curtiss Heather M. Willick Stuart E. 11 2017
5 11 2325967117740862 2325-9671 10.1177/2325967117740862 10.1177/2325967117740862 29226165
In-game fatigue influences concussions in National Hockey League players Research in Sports Medicine Stevens Sean T. Lassonde Maryse de Beaumont Louis Paul Keenan Julian 7 2 2008
16 1 68 74 1543-8627 10.1080/15438620701879020 10.1080/15438620701879020
Effect of neck muscle strength and anticipatory cervical muscle activation on the kinematic response of the head to impulsive loads The American Journal of Sports Medicine Eckner James T. Oh Youkeun K. Joshi Monica S. Richardson James K. Ashton-Miller James A. SAGE Publications 31 1 2014
42 3 566 576 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546513517869 10.1177/0363546513517869 24488820
Poor cervical proprioception as a risk factor for concussion in professional male rugby union players Physical Therapy in Sport Farley T. Barry E. Bester K. Barbero A. Thoroughgood J. De Medici A. Sylvester R. Wilson M.G. 5 2022
55 211 217 1466-853X 10.1016/j.ptsp.2022.03.010 10.1016/j.ptsp.2022.03.010 35526515
The potential role of the cervical spine in sports-related concussion: Clinical perspectives and considerations for risk reduction Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy Streifer Michael Brown Allison M. Porfido Tara Anderson Ellen Zambo Buckman Jennifer F. Esopenko Carrie Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy (JOSPT) 3 2019
49 3 202 208 0190-6011 10.2519/jospt.2019.8582 10.2519/jospt.2019.8582 30645949
A study on the effects of general fatigue on head and neck proprioception in healthy young adults Ortopedia Traumatologia Rehabilitacja Okhravi Seyed Zavveyeh Minoo Kalantari Khosro Baghban Alireza Karimi Mohammad Index Copernicus 10 2 2015
17 1 1 6 1509-3492 10.5604/15093492.1143513 10.5604/15093492.1143513
Differential effects of acute and multiple concussions on gait initiation performance Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Buckley Thomas A. Munkasy Barry A. Krazeise David A. Oldham Jessie R. Evans Kelsey M. Clouse Brandy 8 2020
101 8 1347 1354 0003-9993 10.1016/j.apmr.2020.03.018 10.1016/j.apmr.2020.03.018 32343972
Concussion history associated with increased postural control deficits after subsequent injury Physiological Measurement Murray N G Szekely B Moran R Ryan G Powell D Munkasy B A Buckley T A Guskiewicz K IOP Publishing 20 2 2019
40 2 024001 1361-6579 10.1088/1361-6579/aafcd8 10.1088/1361-6579/aafcd8
Balance regularity among former high school football players with or without a history of concussion Journal of Athletic Training Schmidt Julianne D. Terry Douglas P. Ko Jihyun Newell Karl M. Miller L. Stephen 1 2 2018
53 2 109 114 1062-6050 10.4085/1062-6050-326-16 10.4085/1062-6050-326-16 29332469
ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription Pescatello L S Wolters Kluwer/Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Health 2014

Sensorimotor control in individuals with idiopathic neck pain and healthy individuals: A systematic review and meta-analysis Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation de Zoete Rutger M.J. Osmotherly Peter G. Rivett Darren A. Farrell Scott F. Snodgrass Suzanne J. 6 2017
98 6 1257 1271 0003-9993 10.1016/j.apmr.2016.09.121 10.1016/j.apmr.2016.09.121 27771360
Comparative joint position error in patients with non-specific neck disorders and asymptomatic age-matched individuals South African Journal of Physiotherapy Quartey Jonathan Ernst Markus Bello Ajediran Oppong-Yeboah Bertha Bonney Emmanuel Acquaah Kow Asomaning Felix Foli Margaret Asante Sandra Schaemann Astrid Bauer Christoph 27 6 2019
75 1 2410-8219 10.4102/sajp.v75i1.568 10.4102/sajp.v75i1.568 31309165
Head repositioning accuracy to neutral: A comparative study of error calculation Manual Therapy Hill R Jensen P Baardsen T 4 2009
14 3 280 284 1356-689X 10.1016/j.math.2008.01.011 10.1016/j.math.2008.01.011
The deep neck flexor endurance test: Normative data scores in healthy adults PM Domenech Manuel A. Sizer Phil S. Dedrick Gregory S. McGalliard Michael K. Brismée Jean-Michel 2 2011
3 2 105 110 1934-1482 10.1016/j.pmrj.2010.10.023 10.1016/j.pmrj.2010.10.023
Deep neck flexor endurance in the adolescent and young adult: Normative data and associated attributes PM Jarman Nathan F. Brooks Toby James C. Roger Hooper Troy Wilhelm Mark Brismée Jean-Michel Domenech Manuel A. Kotara Stanley J. Sizer Phillip S. 16 2 2017
9 10 969 975 1934-1482 10.1016/j.pmrj.2017.02.002 10.1016/j.pmrj.2017.02.002
Evaluating the reliability of a novel neck-strength assessment protocol for healthy adults using self-generated resistance with a hand-held dynamometer Physiotherapy Canada Versteegh Theo Beaudet Danielle Greenbaum Marla Hellyer Leah Tritton Amanda Walton Dave 1 2015
67 1 58 64 0300-0508 10.3138/ptc.2013-66 10.3138/ptc.2013-66 25931654
Foundations of Clinical Research: Applications to Practice Portney L G Watkins M P Pearson/Prentice Hall 2015

Exploring the role of cervical spine endurance as a predictor of concussion risk and recovery following sports related concussion Musculoskeletal Science and Practice Baker Matthew Quesnele Jairus Baldisera Tara Kenrick-Rochon Shannon Laurence Michelle Grenier Sylvain 7 2019
42 193 197 2468-7812 10.1016/j.msksp.2019.04.002 10.1016/j.msksp.2019.04.002 31047873
Differential effects of acute and multiple concussions on gait initiation performance Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Buckley Thomas A. Munkasy Barry A. Krazeise David A. Oldham Jessie R. Evans Kelsey M. Clouse Brandy 8 2020
101 8 1347 1354 0003-9993 10.1016/j.apmr.2020.03.018 10.1016/j.apmr.2020.03.018 32343972
Gaze stability in young adults with previous concussion history Journal of Vestibular Research D’Silva Linda J. Siengsukon Catherine F. Devos Hannes 17 10 2020
30 4 259 266 0957-4271 10.3233/ves-200706 10.3233/ves-200706
Evidence of residual cognitive deficits in young adults with a concussion history from adolescence Brain Research Caffey Abigail L. Dalecki Marc 10 2021
1768 147570 0006-8993 10.1016/j.brainres.2021.147570 10.1016/j.brainres.2021.147570
Enduring cognitive and linguistic deficits in individuals with a history of concussion American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology Stockbridge Melissa D. Newman Rochelle American Speech Language Hearing Association 19 11 2019
28 4 1554 1570 1058-0360 10.1044/2019_ajslp-18-0196 10.1044/2019_ajslp-18-0196
The association of concussion history and symptom presentation in combat sport athletes Physical Therapy in Sport Brown Daniel A. Grant Gary Evans Kerrie Leung Felix T. Hides Julie A. 3 2021
48 101 108 1466-853X 10.1016/j.ptsp.2020.12.019 10.1016/j.ptsp.2020.12.019 33406456
The basics of electromyography J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Mills K R 2005
76 Suppl_2 ii32 ii35 15961866
Relationships between injury kinematics, neurological recovery, and pathology following concussion Brain Commun Wofford Kathryn L Grovola Michael R Adewole Dayo O Browne Kevin D Putt Mary E O’Donnell John C Cullen D Kacy 1 10 2021
3 4 fcab268 2632-1297 10.1093/braincomms/fcab268 10.1093/braincomms/fcab268 34934944
