
==== Front
Environ Sci Ecotechnol
Environ Sci Ecotechnol
Environmental Science and Ecotechnology
2096-9643
2666-4984
Elsevier

S2666-4984(24)00083-8
10.1016/j.ese.2024.100469
100469
Review
Applying molecular oxygen for organic pollutant degradation: Strategies, mechanisms, and perspectives
Fan Xiaohu ab
Fu Qiang ab
Liu Guorui c
Jia Hongliang d
Dong Xiaolong ab
Li Yi-Fan ab
Cui Song cuisong-bq@neau.edu.cn
ab⁎
a International Joint Research Center for Persistent Toxic Substances (IJRC-PTS), School of Water Conservancy and Civil Engineering, Northeast Agricultural University, Harbin, 150030, China
b Research Center for Eco-Environment Protection of Songhua River Basin, Northeast Agricultural University, Harbin, 150030, China
c State Key Laboratory of Environmental Chemistry and Ecotoxicology, Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100085, China
d IJRC-PTS, College of Environmental Science and Engineering, Dalian Maritime University, Dalian, 116026, China
⁎ Corresponding author. International Joint Research Center for Persistent Toxic Substances (IJRC-PTS), School of Water Conservancy and Civil Engineering, Northeast Agricultural University, Harbin, 150030, China. cuisong-bq@neau.edu.cn
02 8 2024
11 2024
02 8 2024
22 10046922 2 2024
26 7 2024
29 7 2024
© 2024 The Authors
2024
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Molecular oxygen (O2) is an environmentally friendly, cost-effective, and non-toxic oxidant. Activation of O2 generates various highly oxidative reactive oxygen species (ROS), which efficiently degrade pollutants with minimal environmental impact. Despite extensive research on the application of O2 activation in environmental remediation, a comprehensive review addressing this topic is currently lacking. This review provides an informative overview of recent advancements in O2 activation, focusing on three primary strategies: photocatalytic activation, chemical activation, and electrochemical activation of O2. We elucidate the respective mechanisms of these activation methods and discuss their advantages and disadvantages. Additionally, we thoroughly analyze the influence of oxygen supply, reactive temperature, and pH on the O2 activation process. From electron transfer and energy transfer perspectives, we explore the pathways for ROS generation during O2 activation. Finally, we address the challenges faced by researchers in this field and discuss future prospects for utilizing O2 activation in pollution control applications. This detailed analysis enhances our understanding and provides valuable insights for the practical implementation of organic pollutant degradation.

Graphical abstract

Image 1

Highlights

• The generation of 1O2 involves both energy transfer and electron transfer.

• Defect engineering plays an important role in O2 activation.

• Different activation strategies necessitate varying oxygen concentration levels.

• The electrochemical activation achieves wastewater purification and energy storage.

• O2 activation mainly occurs in both acidic and slightly alkaline environments.

Keywords

Reactive oxygen species
Activation strategies
Molecular oxygen
Organic pollutant degradation
==== Body
pmc1 Introduction

The rapid advancement of industrial civilization has led to the proliferation of various organic contaminants, including antibiotics [1], pesticides [2], personal care products [3], and surfactants [4]. These substances pose significant threats to ecological systems and human health due to their high toxicity and extensive production. Their inherent structural stability makes them resistant to natural degradation processes [5]. Advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) have gained widespread recognition for their efficacy in degrading organic pollutants [6,7]. AOPs facilitate the abundant generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by harnessing the potential of highly reactive oxidants within optimal catalytic environments. These potent agents play a pivotal role in decomposing a wide range of organic pollutants, encompassing organic compounds in industrial wastewater [8], agricultural pollutants [9], and pharmaceutical residues in medical wastewater [10]. The strategic implementation of AOPs is crucial for improving water quality, preserving the ecological environment, and promoting sustainable development principles.

At present, AOPs encompass a variety of methodologies, including Fenton and Fenton-like processes [11], photocatalytic methods [12], and electrocatalytic techniques [13]. The ROS generated by these modalities possess distinct attributes that influence their effectiveness in contaminant removal. These ROS are produced through redox reactions. Traditionally, the majority of ROS are produced through electron acquisition. However, the pathway's sources for electron donors are diverse, primarily including metals, oxidants, photonic energy, and electric currents. For example, the classical Fenton reaction represents a reduction pathway for generating hydroxyl radicals (•OH), where Fe2+ acts as an electron donor to produce hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), resulting in •OH and Fe3+. Photo-generated electrons can activate peroxymonosulfate (PMS), leading to the production of •OH and •SO4− [14]. Additionally, PMS can acquire electrons from low-valence metals to generate •OH [15]. On the other hand, oxidation reactions also play a crucial role in ROS generation. High-value metals can directly oxidize prevalent oxidants into various ROS [16]. For example, Mn3+ can directly oxidize PMS and H2O2 to yield superoxide radicals (•O2−) [17]. Mo6+ possesses the ability to transform •O2− into singlet oxygen (1O2) [18]. Within the photocatalytic process, the oxidation of •O2− by photoinduced holes represents one avenue for producing 1O2 [19]. Additionally, water oxidation is widely recognized as a precursor to ROS. Tungsten trioxide and zinc sulfide possess abundant valence band holes, facilitating the direct oxidation of hydroxide ions (OH−) or water molecules to generate •OH, which actively participates in the decomposition of tetracycline (TC) [20]. Various AOPs currently exist that can generate a significant amount of ROS, thereby aiding in eliminating pollutants. While these conventional methodologies have demonstrated their effectiveness, they often pose risks of causing secondary pollution. Therefore, there is an urgent need to explore novel technologies capable of efficiently degrading environmental contaminants.

Molecular oxygen (O2), acclaimed for its environmental friendliness and cost-efficiency, is ubiquitously accessible in the atmosphere. However, the direct oxidation of numerous organic contaminants by O2 is hindered due to spin-forbidden reactions [21]. In contrast, the activation of O2 can generate various ROS, including •O2−, 1O2, •OH, and H2O2. These ROS play a pivotal role as oxidizing agents in the decomposition processes of organic compounds.

Given the significance of activating O2, this review provides a comprehensive analysis of research advancements in the degradation of organic contaminants through the activation of O2. This paper extensively discusses primary strategies for activating O2 to degrade organic molecules, including photocatalytic, chemical, and electrochemical methods. Moreover, it intricately dissects factors influencing O2 activation and explores generative pathways of ROS considering electron transfer and energy transfer dimensions. This concludes with a discussion of prospects for novel degradation approaches through O2 activation. This article aims to enhance understanding of O2 activation methodologies and their role in environmentally removing organic pollutants.

2 Photocatalytic oxygen activation

The degradation of organic pollutants via the photochemical activation of O2 involves the conversion of dissolved O2 into various ROS. Based on the generation of ROS, this conversion mechanism can occur via two principal pathways: energy transfer or electron transfer [22]. The efficiency of ROS generation in this innovative oxidation process depends on several factors, including the performance characteristics of the semiconductor, the illumination mode, and the source of O2.

2.1 Metal-based photocatalysts

Recently, various metal oxides, including titanium dioxide (TiO2), zinc oxide (ZnO), copper(I) oxide (Cu2O), and iron oxide (Fe2O3), have been applied to activate oxygen for the degradation of organic pollutants under light irradiation. Notably, bismuth-containing photocatalysts have emerged as crucial semiconductors in this field.

Zhao et al. [23] employed a solvent-thermal modification technique to synthesize BiOCl, wherein the exposure to a 300 W xenon lamp activated O2, resulting in the prolific generation of •O2− and 1O2. With a modest quantity of H2O2, the rhodamine B (RhB), methyl orange (Mo), and phenol decomposition rates were amplified by 2.6, 3.1, and 2.4 times, respectively. 1O2 is generated as a result of the energy transfer or electron transfer. Wang et al. [24] ingeniously crafted an iodine-doped Bi2WO6 catalyst that created high-density oxygen vacancies (OVs) to enhance the photochemical activation of O2. Their findings indicated that •O2− and 1O2 were the principal ROS implicated in the disintegration of sodium pentachlorophenate (NaPCP) [24]. Nd-doped BiO2−x exhibited proficient near-infrared ray light-driven photocatalytic O2 activation, where the abundant production of •O2− accelerated doxycycline degradation with a reaction rate constant reaching up to 134.4 × 10−4 min−1 [25]. In the photochemical activation process, two-electron reduction of O2 is the main pathway for H2O2 formation, which is an important ROS in pollutant degradation [25]. Sheng et al. [26] investigated the photocatalytic prowess of Bi2WO6 under visible light irradiation using phenol as a prototypical pollutant. Their findings revealed that post-irradiation treatment resulted in the liberation of photo-induced electrons from Bi2WO6 capable of converting O2 into H2O2. In the presence of electrons, H2O2 undergoes decomposition to yield the highly oxidative •OH, thereby accelerating the efficient degradation of phenol. Liu et al. [27] engineered an iodine-doped Bi2MoO6 semiconductor and developed a light-stimulated H2O2 production system. This system demonstrated a 96.0% efficiency in the photodegradation of acetaminophen (APAP).

In addition to Bi-based photocatalysts, iron oxides have also been frequently mentioned for their effectiveness in the photocatalytic activation of O2. Yue et al. [28] reported synthesizing a Z-type heterojunction 0Dα-Fe2O3/TiO2. The Z-scheme charge transfer mechanism significantly accelerated the Fe3+/Fe2+ cycling rate, optimizing the utilization of H2O2 for •OH generation. This system demonstrated superior degradation efficacy against 2,4-dichlorophenol (2,4-DCP), achieving a degradation kinetic rate constant of 1.08 min−1. Another advanced photocatalyst, N-GQDs/Bi2Fe4O9, was designed to oxidize organic contaminants [29]. Upon light exposure, N-GQDs/Bi2Fe4O9 exhibited remarkable H2O2 production (1.6 μM min−1). Moreover, electrons congregating around N-GQDs enhanced the redox cycling of Fe3+/Fe2+ reactions, promoting •OH production and resulting in a 99.9% bisphenol A (BPA) elimination rate.

Metal sulfides, characterized by their narrow band gap, exhibit remarkable responsiveness to visible light and have thus been utilized in synthesizing photocatalysts for degrading organic pollutants by activating O2 [30]. In scenarios where the ROS generated through photocatalytic O2 activation is H2O2, this process is also called the photo-Fenton system [31]. Yang et al. [32] designed a CdS/Fe2+ photo-Fenton system to degrade sulfamethazine (SMT) under visible light, highlighting the capability of CdS nanorods in converting O2 to H2O2 via a direct two-electron reduction pathway. Similarly, Jiang et al. [33] developed a CdS/rGO/Fe2+ photo-Fenton system capable of degrading phenol through in situ H2O2 generation under visible light irradiation. Their findings suggested that the in situ production of H2O2 in this system may follow a two-electron, one-step reduction mechanism.

The photo-Fenton process, which involves the reduction of dissolved O2 under light irradiation, is regarded as an innovative strategy. Shi et al. [34] developed a CdS/reduced graphene (rGO)/ZnFe2O4 (ZFO) nanocomposite system that effectively degrades TC. This degradation occurs through the in situ generation of H2O2 via a single-electron, two-step reduction of O2 under visible light irradiation. Yang et al. [35] established a Sv-MoS2/BN heterojunction. Upon light exposure, the Sv-MoS2/BN-5 achieved an H2O2 production rate of 428.17 μmol h−1 g−1 and completed in situ disinfection for Escherichia coli (E. coli). Moreover, ternary metal sulfides exhibit superior catalytic activity and a broader range of properties than binary metal sulfides. Du et al. [36] synthesized Zn2In2S5 using a meticulous in situ hydrothermal approach. This system can generate abundant H2O2 under light irradiation and exhibits excellent performance in aromatic pollutant removal, with a phenol degradation efficiency of 97.6% and an impressive H2O2 yield of 1.3 mmol L−1. As shown in Table 1, the photocatalytic activation of O2 has demonstrated remarkable efficiency in degrading organic pollutants through the generation of ROS.Table 1 Representative studies on the degradation of organic pollutants by photocatalytic oxygen activation.

Table 1Catalysts	Mechanism	Contami-nants	Reaction conditions	O2 supply	ROS	Removal efficiency	TOC removal	Reference	
OV-BOC	Energy transfer	RhB	[RhB]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 3.5	Dissolved oxygen	1O2, •O2−	99.8% (30.0 min)	-	[23]	
BWO-0.18	Energy transfer	NaPCP	[NaPCP]0 = 30.0 × 10−6 mg L−1, 300 W Xenon lamp	Dissolved oxygen	1O2, •O2−	99.9% (1.0 h)	90.0%	[24]	
Nd-BiO2−x	Electron transfer	Doxycycline	[Doxycycline]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, 300 W xenon lamp	Dissolved oxygen	•O2−	94.2% (1.0 h)	72.0%	[25]	
BMO-3	Electron transfer	APAP	[APAP]0 = 20.0 μmol L−1, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 6.8	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2	96.0% (2.0 h)	61.0%	[27]	
FT-200	Electron transfer	2,4-DCP	[2,4-DCP]0 = 20.0 μmol L−1, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 3.0	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2, •OH	100.0% (6.0 min)	91.5%	[28]	
N-GQDs/Bi2Fe4O9	Electron transfer	BPA	[BPA]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 3.0	Dissolved oxygen	•OH	99.8% (90.0 min)	-	[29]	
Sv-MoS2/BN-5	Electron transfer	E. coli	[E. coli]0 = 6.0 × 107 CFU mL−1, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 3.0	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2	100.0% (60.0 min)	-	[35]	
CZS-5	Electron transfer	phenol	[phenol]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 7.0	O2 aeration	H2O2	97.6% (180.0 min)	87.0%	[36]	
Cv-PCNNS	Electron transfer	MTZ	[MTZ]0 = 10.0 mmol L−1, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 7.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	90.7% (100.0 min)	62.0%	[47]	
g-C3N4	Electron transfer	TC	[TC]0 = 50.0 ppm, 300 W Xenon lamp, pH = 7.0	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2, •OH	90.0% (300 min)	-	[48]	
FeOOH/UPCN	Electron transfer	OTC	[OTC]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, 300 W
Xenon lamp, pH = 7.0	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2, •OH	86.2% (120.0 min)	48.6%	[49]	
Note: “Dissolved oxygen” refers to the oxygen that comes from the dissolved oxygen in the aqueous solution without any aeration; “Air aeration” refers to the main source of oxygen in the system from the air; “O2 aeration” signifies that the primary source of oxygen in the system is pure oxygen. Abbreviations: OV-BOC, BiOCl with oxygen vacancy; BWO, Bi2WO6; Nd-BiO2−x, Nd doped BiO2−x; BMO-3, iodine-doped Bi2MoO6; FT-200, Fe2O3 loaded TiO2 nanoparticles; N-GQDs/Bi2Fe4O9, nitrogen-doped graphene quantum dots/Bi2Fe4O9; Sv-MoS2/BN-5, sulfur vacancy-rich MoS2/boron nitride; CZS-5, N-doped hollow carbon spheres/Zn2In2S5; Cv-PCNNS, porous g-C3N4 nanosheets with carbon vacancies; g-C3N4, graphitic carbon nitride; FeOOH/UPCN, iron-based oxyhydroxides/ultrathin porous g-C3N4; RhB, rhodamine B; NaPCP, sodium pentachlorophenate; APAP, acetaminophen; 2,4-DCP, 2,4-dichlorophenol; BPA, bisphenol A; E. coli, Escherichia coli; MTZ, metronidazole; TC, tetracycline; OTC, oxytetracycline.

2.2 Organic photocatalysts

The application of metal-based photocatalysts is typically hindered by their poor light responsiveness, biological toxicity, and instability [37]. In contrast, organic photocatalysts have demonstrated superior qualities such as ease of fabrication, appropriate visible light response band gap, high stability, and beneficial metal-free properties [38,39]. Currently recognized as the most prominent organic photocatalyst for activating O2 and removing contaminants [40], graphite carbon nitride (g-C3N4) faces challenges due to inefficient light utilization and rapid recombination of photogenerated charge carriers that significantly impair O2 activation [41]. To address these limitations in g-C3N4 photocatalytic efficiency under light irradiation, various strategies have been applied, including defect engineering [42], doping [43], the creation of ultrathin structures [44], and ion intercalation [45] (Fig. 1).Fig. 1 a, Proposed mechanism for the photocatalysis-self-Fenton system based on carbon defective Cv-PCNNS-550. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [47]. Copyright 2023, Elsevier. b, The photo-Fenton degradation mechanism proposed in the FeOOH/UPCN composite system with ultrathin material. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [49]. Copyright 2022, Elsevier. c, Mechanism for the photocatalysis-self-Fenton system of P doped g-C3N4. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [50]. Copyright 2020, Elsevier. d, The ionothermal synthesis of K+/I− intercalated g-C3N4 (CN-KCl/KI). Reproduced with permission from Ref. [52]. Copyright 2023, NAS.

Fig. 1

Defect engineering plays a crucial role in enhancing exciton dissociation, thereby influencing the activation of O2. Zhou et al. [46] employed a gas reduction technique to introduce nitrogen vacancies in layered g-C3N4. The vacancies at the interface create a significant energy disparity, enabling the dissociation of singlet excitons into free electron-hole pairs and effectively activating O2 to efficiently generate •OH for organic pollutant degradation. Moreover, defect engineering enhances charge separation and supports the reduction of O2 to H2O2 during photocatalysis, substantially contributing to the degradation of organic pollutants. Li et al. [47] developed porous g-C3N4 nanosheets with carbon vacancies (Cv-PCNNS) via a two-step heat treatment approach (Fig. 1a). Their findings showed that these nanosheets exhibited remarkable capability in generating a substantial amount of H2O2 through a one-step dual-electron reduction reaction of O2, achieving an impressive 984.8 μmol L−1 h−1. Activating O2 via photocatalysis-self-Fenton reaction achieved notable degradation efficiency for metronidazole (MTZ) (90.7%) within 100 min.

Owing to its extensive specific surface area, ultrathin material offers significant advantages in activating O2. Hu et al. [48] synthesized a series of catalysts consisting of ultrathin g-C3N4 nanosheets that demonstrated high-efficiency light-driven catalytic performance in the production of H2O2, achieving a rate of 170.0 μmol L−1 h−1. In the presence of this catalyst, the produced H2O2 can be further converted into •OH for TC degradation. Moreover, the ultrathin structure facilitates short migration distances for photo-generated carriers, enhancing O2 reduction and H2O2 generation under light irradiation. Shi et al. [49] fabricated ultrathin porous g-C3N4 (UPCN) integrated with amorphous FeOOH quantum dots (Fig. 1b). This configuration enabled the production of 23.9 μmol L−1 H2O2 within 120 min under visible light irradiation at natural pH levels. Notably, in the photo-Fenton system, this catalyst achieved effective degradation rates of oxytetracycline (OTC) (20.0 mg L−1) of 86.2% and total organic carbon (TOC) removal efficiency of 48.6% within 120.0 min.

Doping also plays a significant role in enhancing oxygen activation. Phosphorus-doped g-C3N4 (P-doped g-C3N4) has demonstrated remarkable photocatalytic reactivity in the degradation of 2,4-DCP [50] (Fig. 1c). Comparative studies have revealed that the degradation activity of 2,4-DCP can be increased by a factor of 20.5 using P-doped g-C3N4 compared to bulk g-C3N4 photocatalysis. This increase is primarily attributed to the generation of •OH from H2O2 produced via the oxygen reduction. Inefficient carrier separation negatively affects O2 activation, particularly during electron transfer processes. To address this issue, doping has emerged as an effective strategy for enhancing carrier separation and ensuring efficient O2 activation. An oxygen-doped g-C3N4 (OCN) variant has been synthesized, resulting in a 3.5-fold increase in H2O2 production under monochromatic light compared to bulk g-C3N4 [51]. The improved carrier transfer efficiency in OCN facilitates the two-electron reduction of O2 and consequently demonstrates superior degradation efficiencies for phenol and 2,4-DCP.

Intercalation engineering in carbon nitride significantly improves carrier separation and transfer, enhancing O2 activation for H2O2 production. In a recent study, Liu et al. [52] modified g-C3N4 by the intercalation of potassium ions (K+) and iodide ions (I−) into its layered structure, resulting in the achievement of a H2O2 production rate of 13.1 mM g−1 h−1 and an apparent quantum yield of 23.6% at 400 nm for this ion-intercalated crystalline g-C3N4. This suggests that interstitial doping engineering can facilitate the creation of rapid charge diffusion channels and promote efficient two-electron oxygen reduction (Fig. 1d).

In summary, the photocatalytic activation of O2 has been extensively investigated and applied in environmental purification. The protocol eliminates the need for additional oxidants during the process. Moreover, this procedure can generate various ROS, which are advantageous for the degrading and mineralizing organic pollutants. Photocatalytic reactions typically occur at room temperature, with simple operation and without requiring complex equipment or conditions. However, the efficiency of photocatalytic O2 activation is limited by factors such as charge carrier recombination, low carrier migration rate, and insufficient activated O2 adsorption sites. Although certain emerging catalysts can overcome these challenges, they often increase production costs. Additionally, prolonged usage leads to catalyst deactivation or breakdown, necessitating periodic replacement or regeneration, escalating costs and complicating operations. Current studies primarily employ artificial illumination for photocatalysis; however, this approach is energy-intensive. While the photocatalytic activation of O2 to generate ROS holds promise for pollutant eradication, further investigation is needed to overcome existing obstacles and enhance its practicability and efficacy.

3 Chemical oxygen activation

The activation of O2 through photochemistry requires strict conditions, including temperature, light radiation intensity, photoreactor design, and selection of photocatalytic materials [53,54]. These limitations may hinder the broader application of photocatalytic O2 activation. Conversely, certain zero-valent metals (ZVMs), low-valent transition metals (LVTMs), and defect materials can activate O2 without such demanding operating environments.

3.1 Zero valent metals

In recent years, the potential of ZVMs, such as Fe, Al, and Cu, to activate O2 has gained increasing recognition due to their ability to generate various ROS for pollutant removal. Notably, zero-valent iron (ZVI, Fe0) has garnered significant attention owing to its safety and widespread availability [55]. When introduced into a solution containing dissolved oxygen, Fe0 undergoes a thermodynamically spontaneous corrosion reaction. This process involves electron transfer from Fe0 to O2, leading to the oxidation of Fe0 into Fe2+. Concurrently, O2 is reduced to H2O2. In acidic or neutral environments, Fe2+ further catalyzes H2O2 formation into •OH (equations (1), (2)).(1) Fe0+O2+2H+→Fe2++H2O2

(2) Fe2++H2O2→Fe3++•OH+OH−

Numerous studies have established that ROS generated from the activation of O2 by Fe0 predominantly consists of H2O2, thus making this process analogous to a Fenton-like reaction. The Fe0/O2 system has been used for treating refined cottonseed oil (CTO) wastewater (Fig. 2a) [56]. Experimental findings have demonstrated the effective degradation of CTO in wastewater using the Fe0/O2 system with an observable enhancement in degradation efficiency due to increased oxygen concentration. To further enhance the degradation efficiency and prevent Fe0 aggregation within this system, researchers have developed composite materials by combining Fe0 with other substances. Carbon-coated nano ZVI (Fe@C), obtained by high-temperature calcination of complexes formed between Fe and organic compounds, exhibit small size, high content, and excellent dispersion properties, ensuring their heightened activity in Fenton-like reactions [57]. This catalyst activates O2 to generate H2O2 and forms the Fe@C-H2O2 Fenton system, effectively degrading SMT. Yang et al. [58] encapsulated nano ZVI within a three-dimensional graphene network material (3D-GN@nZVI), successfully activating dissolved oxygen and facilitating sulfadiazine (SDZ) degradation. In addition, introducing foreign metals can accelerate the corrosion of Fe0 and enhance the efficiency of O2 activation [59].Fig. 2 a, The degradation mechanisms of CTO by ZVI system. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [56]. Copyright 2022, Elsevier. b, The degradation mechanism of SMT in the Cu0/C-air system. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [62]. Copyright 2021, Elsevier. c, Mechanism for active species generation in the Zn0-CNTs-O2 system. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [66]. Copyright 2017, Elsevier. d, Ascorbic acid enhances the activation of oxygen by the Fe2+/air process. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [71]. Copyright 2016, Elsevier. e, Mechanisms of activating O2 by Cu(I) on Cu-Al/KIT-6. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [73]. Copyright 2020, Elsevier. f, Degradation mechanism of nitrobenzene (NB) in air/CuCoFe/Tar-LDH reaction systems. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [80]. Copyright 2022, ACS. g, The mechanism of ROS generation in the CoS2–1.5 h system. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [85]. Copyright 2021, Wiley. h, The oxygen molecule activation by carbon defects. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [86]. Copyright 2023, Elsevier.

Fig. 2

Similar to ZVI, zero valence copper (ZVC, Cu0) can also activate O2, leading to the production of H2O2 and the formation of a Fenton-like system. Meanwhile, during the oxidation process, Cu0 generates Cu+ and Cu2+ ions, which subsequently react with in situ generated H2O2 to produce •OH and •O2− radicals (equations (3), (4), (5)).(3) 2Cu0+O2+H2O2→2Cu++H2O2+2OH−

(4) Cu++H2O2→2Cu2++•OH+2OH−

(5) Cu2++O2+H2O2→Cu++•O2−+H+

The involvement of Cu+ and Cu2+ ions adds complexity to the process of Cu0 activating O2. In an nZVC/air system, nZVC can activate O2 to produce H2O2 while simultaneously releasing Cu + [60]. This activation further catalyzes the transformation of H2O2 into •OH and facilitates the destruction of -N=N- azo pollutants, forming carbon-centered radicals. Both radicals contribute to mineralizing low molecular weight organic acids under neutral conditions. Cu0 exhibits significant potential for activating O2 and removing organic pollutants. However, Cu0 tends to aggregate and release a large amount of copper ions after use during its preparation process, leading to contamination in water environments and reducing its catalytic activity [61]. Additionally, factors such as dissolved oxygen concentration and mass transfer efficiency also influence the catalytic performance of Cu0. To address these issues, Yang et al. [62] developed a novel mesoporous carbon-hybridized zero-valent copper (Cu0/C) through the calcination of copper-based metal-organic frameworks (Cu3(BTC)2) in a tubular furnace (Fig. 2b). The carbon-based matrix not only adsorbs pollutants but also effectively inhibits the leaching of copper ions. Under neutral pH conditions, the Cu0/C-air system achieved a high SMT mineralization rate (73.1%). Table 2 lists ZVMs/O2 systems for the degradation of contaminants.Table 2 The removal of pollutants based on ZVMs/O2 systems.

Table 2ZVMs	Contaminants	Reaction conditions	O2 supply	ROS	Removal efficiency	TOC removal	Reference	
ZVI	CTO	pH = 2.5–3.1	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	93.5% (3.0 h)	-	[56]	
Fe@C	SMT	[SMT]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, pH = 4.0	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2, •OH	97.6% (300.0 min)	93.8%	[57]	
3D-GN@nZVI	SDZ	[SDZ]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2, •OH	81.0% (120.0 min)	-	[58]	
BM Fe/Cu	4-CP	[4-CP]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0	Air aeration	•O2−, •OH	100.0% (120.0 min)	66.4%	[59]	
nZVC	MO	[MO]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, pH = 6.6	Air aeration	H2O2, •OH	100.0% (4.0 h)	56.1%	[60]	
ZVCMMT	ATZ	[ATZ]0 = 15.0 μM, pH = 3.0	Air aeration	•OH	90.0% (180.0 min)	-	[61]	
Cu0/C	SMT	[SMT]0 = 20.0 m L−1, pH = 4.0	Air aeration	H2O2, •OH	96.7% (90.0 min)	68.8%	[62]	
Zn0-CNTs-Fe3O4	OTC	[OTC]0 = 100.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	98.6% (60.0 min)	-	[67]	
Zn-Fe-CNTs	SMX	[SMX]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, pH = 1.50	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	100.0% (120.0 min)	51.3%	[68]	
ZVZ/Cu(II) system	MTZ	[MTZ]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 5.0	Dissolved oxygen	H2O2, •OH, •O2−	90.0% (10.0 min)	-	[69]	
Abbreviations: ZVI, zero-valent iron; Fe@C, carbon-coated nanoscale zero-valent iron; 3D-GN@nZVI, nanoscale zero-valent iron encapsulated in three-dimensional graphene network; BM Fe/Cu, ball milling Fe/Cu; nZVC, nanoscale zero-valent copper; ZVCMMT, montmorillonite templated zero-valent copper; Cu0/C, mesoporous carbon hybrid loaded zero-valent copper; Zn0-CNTs-Fe3O4, Zn0-carbon nanotubes-Fe3O4; Zn-Fe-CNTs, Zn-Fe-carbon nanotubes; ZVZ/Cu(II) system, zero-valent zinc/Cu(II) system; CTO, cottonseed oil; SMT, sulfamethazine; SDZ, sulfadiazine; 4-CP, 4-chlorophenol; MO, methyl orange; ATZ, atrazine; OTC, oxytetracycline; SMX, sulfamethoxazole; MTZ, metronidazole.

Additionally, zero-valent zinc (ZVZ, Zn0) can facilitate the in situ generation of H2O2 through the activation of O2. However, the concentration of H2O2 generated by the Zn0/air system is relatively low, necessitating further modifications to enhance its in situ generation [63]. According to electrochemical corrosion theory, Zn0 acts as an anode in a corrosion cell, releasing electrons that are transferred to the cathode. The received electrons on the cathode surface can react with O2 to produce H2O2. Simultaneously, Zn0 undergoes oxidation, leading to the formation of precipitates such as ZnO or Zn(OH)2, as depicted by equations (6), (7), (8), (9), (10).(6) 2Zn+3O2+4H+→H2O2+2ZnO+Zn(OH)2

(7) Anode:Zn+2e−→Zn2+

(8) Cathode:O2+2H++2e−→H2O2

(9) Zn+H2O2→ZnO+H2O

(10) Zn2++H2O2+2e−→Zn(OH)2

Therefore, selecting suitable cathode materials is crucial for improving the efficiency of O2 activation and increasing H2O2 production. Among various materials, carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have emerged as a standout choice due to their cost-effectiveness, high conductivity, and stability, making them widely utilized in electrochemical oxidation and fuel cell applications for in situ H2O2 generation [64,65]. Gong et al. [66] developed the Zn-CNTs-O2 system wherein Zn and CNTs form a corrosion cell that reduces O2 to H2O2 on CNTs’ surface (Fig. 2c). Simultaneously, dissolved Zn2+ precipitates as Zn(OH)2 onto the CNTs. The formation of this corrosion cell is primarily responsible for increasing the yield of H2O2. To further enhance the operational efficiency of the Zn/CNTs corrosion battery, some researchers have incorporated iron oxide and iron ions into Zn-CNTs. Liu et al. [67] synthesized a catalyst named Zn0-CNTs-Fe3O4, which achieved a degradation rate of 98.6% toward OTC. Furthermore, combining zinc with iron yields superior outcomes; a Zn-Fe-CNTs catalyst based on Zn0-CNTs and Fe0 eliminated sulfamethoxazole (SMX) within just 10.0 min [68].

3.2 Low valence transition metals

In contrast to ZVMs, certain LVTMs also function as electron donors for the activation of O2, resulting in the generation of ROS. Among these LVTMs, extensive research has been conducted on the activation of O2 by Fe2+. Fe2+ can activate dissolved oxygen under aerobic conditions, leading to the formation of •O2−, which subsequently accepts electrons and ultimately leads to the generation of H2O2. Moreover, Fe2+ plays a crucial role in the Fenton reaction with H2O2, facilitating the production of •OH [70]. This mechanism exhibits high efficacy in degrading organic pollutants, according to equations (11), (12), (13).(11) Fe2++O2→Fe2++•O2−

(12) Fe2++•O2−+2H+→Fe3++H2O2

(13) Fe2++H2O2+H+→Fe3++•OH+H2O

In a neutral environment, forming irreversible precipitates by Fe3+ impedes the activation of O2 and the generation of ROS. Additionally, reducing Fe3+ to Fe2+ is a slow process mediated by •O2−, resulting in low efficiency and limiting the removal of pollutants. Researchers have explored incorporating ligands into O2 activation systems to enhance pollutant removal efficiency to facilitate ROS production. Hou et al. [71] established an AA/Fe(II)/air system. They discovered that ascorbic acid (AA) enhances the activation process of O2 by Fe2+, unveiling an accelerated production rate of ROS through its pivotal role in promoting the Fe2+/Fe3+ cycle (Fig. 2d). Furthermore, Zong et al. [72] constructed a Fe(II)-tetrapolyphosphate (TPP)/air system, which demonstrated that TPP significantly enhances the activation of O2 by Fe2+ and accelerates the reduction of Fe3+.

In recent studies, the activation of O2 by Cu + has garnered significant attention. Wang et al. [73] synthesized Cu-Al/KIT-6 and utilized it for the activation of O2 (Fig. 2e). The experimental findings demonstrated that Cu + effectively activated O2 and generated ROS, thereby facilitating BPA removal, revealing its potential as an O2 activator. However, the environmental instability of Cu + poses a challenge to activating O2. Zheng et al. [74] synthesized a hydrothermal carbonaceous carbon material containing stable CuCl (CuCl-HTCC) to address this limitation. Their study revealed that CuCl-HTCC contained a substantial amount of stable Cu+, which exhibited significantly higher efficiency in activating O2 than unstable homogeneous reactions involving only Cu+. Table 3 provides examples showcasing pollutant degradation by LVTMs through the activation of O2.Table 3 The degradation of pollutants by LVTMs/O2 systems.

Table 3LVTMs	Contaminants	Reaction conditions	O2 supply	ROS	Removal efficiency	TOC removal	Reference	
AA/Fe(II)	RhB	[RhB]0 = 0.01 mmol L−1, pH = 6.0	Air aeration	H2O2, •OH	47.0% (6.0 h)	16.0%	[71]	
Fe(II)-TPP complex	SMX	[SMX]0 = 1.3 mg L−1, pH = 8.0	Air aeration	H2O2, •OH, •O2−	75.7% (20.0 min)	-	[72]	
Cu-Al/KIT-6	BPA	[BPA]0 = 25.0 mg L−1, pH = 5.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	99.0% (120.0 min)	46.0%	[73]	
CuCl-HTCC	IBU	[IBU]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 4.6	Magnetic stirring	•O2−, •OH	Almost 100.0% (120.0 min)	-	[74]	
P-Cu	IBU	[IBU]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 6.0	Air aeration	•OH	100.0% (120.0 min)	52.6%	[75]	
Mo/Cu2+ system	IBU	[IBU]0 = 5.0 ppm, pH = 3.0	Air aeration	1O2, •O2−	67.2%	-	[76]	
Fe3O4/O2/TPP system	PNP	[PNP]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0	Dissolved oxygen	•OH	80.0% (480.0 min)	-	[77]	
Abbreviations: AA/Fe(II), ascorbic acid/Fe(II); Fe(II)-TPP complex, Fe(II)-tetrapolyphosphate complex; Cu-Al/KIT-6, framework Cu doped Al2O3 dispersed on KIT-6; CuCl-HTCC, copper chloride loaded hydrothermal carbonaceous carbon; P-Cu, low valence copper on red P; Fe3O4/O2/TPP system, Fe3O4/O2/tripolyphosphate system; RhB, rhodamine B; SMX, sulfamethoxazole; BPA, bisphenol A; IBU, ibuprofen; PNP, p-nitrophenol.

3.3 Defect engineering

Defect engineering has become a prominent research focus due to its ability to directly activate O2, making it an attractive area for investigation in water treatment applications. Defect engineering involves deliberately manipulating a catalyst's performance by introducing, regulating, and repairing internal defects such as lattice, vacancies, and surface flaws. This approach does not rely on external energy or sacrificial reagents [78].

The presence of OVs plays a crucial role in the activation of O2, making them recognized for their exceptional capability and potential to revolutionize this field. Wu et al. [79] discovered that OVs are crucial in generating ROS by capturing electrons and forming •O2−. Additionally, OVs without electrons can extract electrons from organic pollutants, degrading them and maintaining electrostatic equilibrium, resulting in a 32.0% degradation rate of BPA without requiring an additional oxidant PMS.

However, the rapid reversion of •O2− back to O2 may explain the decreased degradation rates of pollutants. Addressing this phenomenon, Wang et al. [80] synthesized CuCoFe/Tar-LDH with OVs and provided an explanation for the process (Fig. 2f). They proposed that the process began with the adsorption of O2 onto the OVs in CuCoFe/Tar-LDH, which is then converted into •O2− and subsequently transformed into •OH. The study by Wang et al. underscores the effectiveness of oxygen vacancy-mediated catalysts in directly activating O2 to generate highly reactive oxidizing species. Based on these findings, it can be inferred that ROS production during the activation of O2 through OVs is directly influenced by the dissolved oxygen concentration. Research conducted by Wang et al. [81] investigated the regulatory mechanism and transformation pathway of ROS during the process of O2 activation. Their findings revealed that under low dissolved oxygen concentration conditions, O2 predominantly leads to forming 1O2 and •O2−. Conversely, as the concentration of dissolved oxygen increases, there is a more prominent conversion from O2 to •OH. This study demonstrates that the potential for selective ROS production can be controlled by adjusting dissolved oxygen levels. Their research holds significant value in advancing wastewater treatment.

Moreover, this process also exhibits significant antimicrobial properties. For instance, a form of magnesium oxide with surface OVs can directly generate 1O2 and •O2− through the reaction between OVs and O2, even in the absence of light. This catalyst has demonstrated outstanding antibacterial performance by effectively eliminating E. coli within 2 h [82]. Additionally, Prasanna et al. [83] found that zinc oxide enriched with OVs exhibited significant antibacterial properties due to the generation of ROS through the activation of surface OVs.

However, research on the activation of O2 by sulfur vacancies is less prevalent than that on OVs. Ultrasonic treatment of CoS2−x material led to numerous sulfur vacancies on its surface, which can reduce dissolved oxygen to •O2− (Fig. 2g) [85]. Consequently, continuous generation of 1O2 occurs, effectively degrading organic pollutants. OVs and sulfur vacancies are specific forms of anionic vacancies that arise due to the absence of oxygen or sulfur lattice sites in metal oxides and metal sulfides. These vacancies possess the ability to effectively promote O2 activation. However, they are prone to instability and metal leaching, limiting their practical applicability. Therefore, non-metal carbon materials featuring carbon vacancies have attracted considerable interest. Liu et al. [86] conducted a study wherein they synthesized a type of defective porous carbon (DPC) capable of adsorbing dissolved oxygen and activating it into •O2− and 1O2 (Fig. 2h). The experimental findings suggest that the primary active center for chemisorption and direct conversion of dissolved oxygen into •O2− may be the non-diagonal cyclic structure of carbon vacancies. The activation of O2 by defect engineering for degradation of organic contaminants is systematically summarized in Table 4.Table 4 The activation of O2 by defect engineering for degradation of organic contaminants.

Table 4Catalyst	Defect engineering	Contaminants	Reaction conditions	O2 supply	ROS	Removal efficiency	TOC removal	Refe-rence	
Fe-Co LDH	Oxygen Vacancy	BPA	[BPA]0 = 2.0 mg L−1, pH = 7.0	Dissolved oxygen	1O2, •O2−	32.0% (60.0 min)	49.0%	[79]	
CuCoFe/Tar-LDH	Oxygen Vacancy	NB	[NB]0 = 150.0 mg L−1, pH = 7.2	Air aeration	•OH, •O2−	78.3% (240.0 min)	45.5%	[80]	
CuCoFe-300	Oxygen Vacancy	CIP	[CIP]0 = 15.0 mg L−1, pH = 4.0	O2 aeration	•OH, •O2−	75.0% (240.0 min)	54.1%	[81]	
MgO	Oxygen Vacancy	E. coli	[E. coli]0 = 0.05 mol L−1, pH = 8.0	O2 aeration	•O2−, 1O2	100.0% (2.0 h)	-	[82]	
ZnO	Oxygen Vacancy	S. aureus	[S. aureus]0 = 3.0 × 1012 CFU mL−1, pH = 8.5	Dissolved oxygen	•OH, •O2−, H2O2	17.0% (120.0 min)	-	[83]	
DR-MoS2	Sulfur vacancy	Black T	[Black T]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0	Dissolved oxygen	•OH, H2O2	99.8% (25.0 min)	-	[84]	
CoS2-x	Sulfur vacancy	RhB	[RhB]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, pH = 4.5	Dissolved oxygen	1O2	91.9% (120.0 min)	70.7%	[85]	
DPC-800	Carbon vacancy	CIP	[CIP]0 = 20.0 mg L−1, pH = 6.6	Dissolved oxygen	1O2, •O2−	98.0% (60.0 min)	-	[86]	
Abbreviations: Fe-Co LDH, Fe-Co layered double hydroxide; CuCoFe/Tar-LDH, tartrate-modified CuCoFe-layered double hydroxide; CuCoFe-300, calcined CuCoFe-layered double hydroxide with 300 °C; DR-MoS2, defect-rich MoS2; DPC-800, calcined defected porous carbon with 800 °C; BPA, bisphenol A; NB, nitrobenzene; CIP, ciprofloxacin; E. coli, Escherichia coli; S. aureus, Staphylococcus aureus; Black T, Eriochrome Black T; RhB, rhodamine B.

Compared to the photocatalytic activation of O2, the chemical oxygen activation modality offers operational simplicity, reduced material preparation expenditures, and superior O2 activation effects, resulting in effective pollutant removal. However, ZVMs and LVTMs are fundamentally expendable materials characterized by single-use functionality and minimal reusability. Moreover, the instability of these materials may lead to the liberation of metal ions, posing a risk of secondary contamination. Additionally, in alkaline environments, the catalytic activity of ZVMs and LVTMs may be curtailed, impacting the efficiency of ROS production. In contrast to ZVMs and LVTMs, defect structures can reduce reaction barriers, promote O2 activation, and enhance pollutant degradation efficiency. The utilization of defect engineering for O2 activation represents an emerging and cutting-edge technological approach. Nonetheless, a lack of dedicated research reports is currently elucidating the process and mechanism underlying O2 activation via defect engineering. While defect engineering is indispensable for O2 activation, the accumulation of reaction intermediates, water, and other catalysts on the molecular surface may fill up defects, diminishing adsorption capacity toward O2 while hindering electron transfer. The design and synthesis of defect materials with proficient activation properties pose a significant challenge, requiring careful consideration of catalyst architecture, composition, and synthesis techniques, potentially extending the trajectory of research and development.

4 Electrochemical oxygen activation

The electrochemical activation of O2 is a pivotal pathway for the in situ synthesis of H2O2, playing a significant role in various processes. At the cathode, O2 undergoes a two-electron reduction reaction to produce H2O2. The presence of catalysts or electrons influences the catalytic decomposition of H2O2 into various ROS. Based on the mode of ROS formation, the electrochemical activation of oxygen can be further categorized into four processes: the electro-Fenton (EF) process, the photoelectro-Fenton (PEF) process, the photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) process, and the microbial fuel cell (MFC) process.

4.1 Electro-Fenton process

The EF process involves the introduction of O2 or air at the cathode, facilitating the continuous in situ generation of H2O2 through 2e− oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) (Fig. 3a). The incorporation of the Fe2+ catalyst within the Fenton reaction leads to the generation of •OH (equations (14), (15)). •OH indiscriminately degrades organic pollutants into smaller organic molecules, salts, and carbon dioxide via addition, substitution, and bond cleavage. Variations in reaction conditions, including pH, cathode material, and anode catalyst, can result in distinct mechanisms and efficiencies in the EF reaction.(14) O2+2H++2e−→H2O2

(15) O2+3H++3e−→•OH+H2O

(16) O2+4H++4e−→2H2O

Fig. 3 The ROS generation pathway based on the activation of O2 by electro-Fenton process (a), photoelectro-Fenton process (b), photoelectrocatalytic process (c), mcrobial fuel cell process (d).

Fig. 3

Zhao et al. [87] documented a FeCuC-embedded carbon aerogel with ORR activity, demonstrating high efficiency in removing organic pollutants through the EF reaction. By rapidly oxidizing surface Fe0 to Fe2+, this material facilitated the generation of •OH from H2O2, resulting in a significant removal rate of TOC for various organic pollutants (88–99%). Moreover, other metals, such as Co2+ and Fe2+, were found to catalyze H2O2 effectively in an R-FPE system used for degrading 2,4-DCP [88]. The synergistic effect between Co2+ and Fe2+ led to the abundant production of •OH by transforming electrochemically generated H2O2. However, several challenges currently hinder the EF process, including the limited availability of selective and active catalysts, suboptimal H2O2 synthesis via the two-electron ORR pathway, the reduced efficacy of H2O2 decomposition through the Haber–Weiss cycle, and sluggish activation of catalytic metal sites [89]. Fortuitously, the emergence of single-atom catalyst (SAC) membranes has been shown to augment two-electron ORR, thereby facilitating the conversion of H2O2 into •OH via one-electron ORR. This advancement improves degradation efficiency and the system's stability [90]. Jin et al. [91] successfully developed a p-block BiN3/MXene electrocatalytic membrane that proficiently executes a three-electron ORR to generate •OH from O2. Without additional chemical reagents, this novel approach achieves a maximum production rate of 26.7 μmol L−1 h−1 cm−2 for •OH and an observed rate constant (Kobs) for SMX degradation reaching 1.03 min−1.

The cathodic surface can generate H2O2 through a two-electron reduction pathway or water via a direct four-electron pathway (equation (16)), depending on the type and intrinsic properties of the cathode material and other operating conditions. The selectivity of the cathode material for the ORR is crucial in achieving the in situ generation of H2O2 at the cathodic interface, particularly when compared to metallic substrates. Carbon-based materials are considered more suitable for the in situ synthesis of H2O2 due to their distinct features, including enhanced stability, minimal toxicity, affordability, corrosion resistance, and pronounced selectivity for the two-electron pathway in O2 reduction. To activate O2 efficiently, a large-pore graphene aerogel (GA) cathode with a substantial surface area has been utilized [92]. Abundant large pores served as reactive sites facilitating the efficient generation of •OH through the electrochemical decomposition of Fe2+, producing H2O2 (107.6 mg L−1), resulting in a ciprofloxacin (CIP) TOC removal rate of 91.0%. Gu et al. [93] employed oxygen-doped CNTs (OCNT) as cathodes to catalyze O2 activation for the degradation of organic pollutants.

Within O2-activated EF systems, H2O2 and •OH are the primary ROS. However, •OH has a short lifespan and limited selectivity. In contrast, metastable 1O2, which possesses unoccupied π∗ orbitals, can selectively target electron-rich micropollutants through electrophilic addition. Therefore, investigating EF systems for generating 1O2 is of particular significance. Jin et al. [94] developed a fluidic single-atom electrode specifically designed for the selective electrocatalysis of O2 into 1O2. This system achieved an impressive selectivity of over 98.0% for 1O2 production and a removal rate of SMX of 91.9%. Yang et al. [95] engineered a conductive electrocatalytic membrane with Fe(II)-modulated FeCo-layered double hydroxide nanosheets (Fe(II)-FeCo LDHs). These nanosheets effectively catalyzed H2O2 into 1O2, exhibiting high kinetic activity with a rate constant of 0.04 min−1 and achieving a degradation efficiency of 93.2% for atrazine (ATZ). The selective production of 1O2 is crucial in precise chemical site targeting. Feng et al. [96] proposed a novel strategy to construct an oxidation–reduction interface on the electrode surface. They discovered that this strategy predominantly generated 1O2, effectively circumventing the competitive formation of other ROS. By leveraging a cutting-edge carbon-based electrocatalytic bilayer system, which takes advantage of the synergistic effect of dual active electrochemical membrane electrodes, they enhanced the production 1O2 [97]. The optimized production of 1O2 achieved a concentration of 2583.0 μmol L−1 without additional chemical reagents. This system accomplished a propranolol (PRO) removal efficiency of 97.5%. Table 5 lists the recent studies on the degradation of contaminants in water or wastewater by the EF process.Table 5 The pollutants degradation based on the activation of O2 by electro-Fenton process.

Table 5Cathodes	Anodes	Contaminants	Reaction conditions	O2 supply	ROS	Removal efficiency	TOC removal	Reference	
FeCuC	BDD	BPA	[BPA]0 = 2.0 mg L−1, Na2SO4 = 50.0 μM, I = 30.0 mA, pH = 3.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	-	97.0%	[87]	
GF-C	Pt	RhB	[RhB]0 = 60.0 mg L−1, Na2SO4 = 50.0 μM, j = 6.0 mA cm−2, pH = 3.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	99.0%	80.0%	[88]	
Ti sheet	BiN3/MXene membrane	SMX	[SMX]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, Na2SO4 = 20.0 mmol L−1, I = 10.0 mA, pH = 3.0–9.5	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	>95.0%	60.0%	[91]	
GA	Pt sheet	CIP	[CIP]0 = 50.0 mg L−1, Na2SO4 = 50.0 μM, j = 30.0 mA cm−2, pH = 3.0,	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	Almost 100.0%	91.0%	[92]	
CrN4/MXene	Ti sheet	SMX	[SMX]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 6.8	O2 aeration	1O2	95.0%	61.2%	[94]	
FE-ECM	Titanium plate	ATZ	[ATZ]0 = 20.0 μM, Na2SO4 = 100.0 mM, j = 2.0 mA cm−2, pH = 7.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH, 1O2	93.1%	73.04%	[95]	
Carbon aerogels	Pt foil	BPA	[BPA]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, Na2SO4 = 50.0 μM, pH = 3.0 and 9.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, 1O2, •O2−, •OH	98.0%	72.3%	[96]	
MOF-SnO2@CF	Fe@CF membranes	PRO	[PRO]0 = 5.0 mg L−1, Na2SO4 = 10.0 μM, pH = 3.0	O2 aeration	H2O2, 1O2, •O2−, •OH	97.5%	83.0%	[97]	
Abbreviations: FeCuC, iron-copper-embedded carbon aerogel; BDD, boron-doped diamond; GF-C, graphite felt-C; GA, graphene aerogel; FE-ECM, Fe(II)-modulated FeCo LDHs on a conductive OCNT-precoated membrane; MOF-SnO2@CF, metal organic frameworks-SnO2@ carbon fibers; Fe@CF, Fe@carbon fibers; BPA, bisphenol A; RhB, rhodamine B; SMX, sulfamethoxazole; CIP, ciprofloxacin; ATZ, atrazine; PRO, propranolol.

4.2 Photoelectro-Fenton process and photoelectrocatalytic process

The PEF process is an advanced oxidation method combining photocatalytic and electrochemical reactions. By integrating the properties of photocatalysis with electrochemical oxidation, the dual-functional PEF catalysts synergistically exploit photoelectric properties, effectively accelerating the recycling of Fe2+/Fe3+ in traditional electrochemical reactions, expanding the operational pH range, and simultaneously maintaining elevated degradation efficiencies (Fig. 3b). Bai et al. [98] developed a novel PEF-like system utilizing a bifunctional Z-scheme WO3/g-C3N4 catalyst, which significantly accelerated the degradation of CIP. The PEF system exhibited superior efficacy in removing CIP compared to singular photocatalytic and EF systems, achieving complete elimination within just 2 h under visible light irradiation.

In the PEF process, various ROS can be generated through light and electric reactions. Wang et al. [99] developed an integrated system based on zinc-air batteries that incorporate polyterthiophene (pTTh) as a photo-enhanced electrocatalyst, achieving a high H2O2 production rate (34.8 mg L−1 h−1) and effectively degrading co-generated pollutants through efficient catalysis of the 2e− ORR. Compared to the EF process, PEF generates •OH and H2O2 and produces active substances such as e−, h+, and •O2−, resulting in a broader spectrum of ROS that facilitates the effective breakdown of stubborn organic pollutants. Du et al. [100] synergized UV irradiation and heterogeneous electro-Fenton (Hetero-EF) treatment by employing FeCu@PC porous carbon, adeptly reducing O2 in the Hetero-PEF process with a TOC removal rate of 73.3% for SMT, which is 2.2 times higher than that achieved by the Hetero-EF process. Sunlight is the most cost-effective illumination compared to costly artificial light sources in PEF. Therefore, solar-powered PEF (SPEF) is a more viable alternative to conventional PEF. Ye et al. [101] discovered that SPEF outperformed electrooxidation (EO), EF, and UVA (ultraviolet with wavelength 320–400 nm) -assisted PEF in efficiently degrading bronopol under a consistent current density. After 360 min of operation, SPEF realized a mineralization rate of 94.0%. Pinheiro et al. [102] utilized Fe3O4 nanoparticles as heterogeneous catalysts to initiate SPEF, which exhibited a catalytic removal efficiency of 98.7% for fuel within just 90.0 min. Salmerón et al. [103] conducted an inaugural pilot-scale experiment of SPEF, meticulously engineering the experimental apparatus to optimize the electrocatalytic synthesis of H2O2. By fine-tuning the conditions, they achieved an H2O2 production rate of 64.9 mg min−1 with a current efficiency of 89.3%. The SPEF process facilitated rapid degradation of over 50.0% of pesticide residues within a mere 5.0 min.

The PEC process combines the principles of photocatalysis and electrochemical oxidation, synergistically enhancing charge carrier segregation and reducing recombination events upon illumination (Fig. 3c). In contrast to the PEF paradigm, an electrical bias is strategically applied in the PEC system to mobilize photoelectrons for oxygen reduction at the cathode [104]. Simultaneously, photogenerated holes migrate to the anode's surface, generating highly oxidative and indiscriminate •OH, while electrons catalyze additional oxidants. Apart from •OH and hole, other oxidizing entities such as •O2− and perhydroxyl radicals are also present in the PEC system, as described by equations (17), (18), (19), (20), (21) [105,106].(17) hv+semiconductor→h++e−

(18) h++H2O→•OH+H+

(19) e−+O2→•O2−

(20) •O2−+H+→•HO2

(21) 2•HO2→H2O2+O2

In the PEC-based WO3/FPC system, an anodic potential was applied to the WO3 photoanode, facilitating the segregation of photogenerated charges. Meanwhile, the F-doped porous carbon served as the cathode and was selectively designed to catalyze the reduction of O2 to H2O2 [107]. This system measured an H2O2 generation rate of 0.87 mmol L−1 h−1 with a Faradaic efficiency (FE) of 75.0%. The degradation rates of phenol, BPA, and ATZ exceeded 90.0% within 60.0 min, achieving a mineralization rate of 40.0%. Kaushik et al. [108] pioneered the development of a Fe3O4@NiCO2O4 (FNCO) photoanode, which was subsequently integrated into a PEC system. The designed PEC water treatment system achieved nearly 60.0% TOC removal efficiency. Furthermore, compared with electrochemical oxidation processes that require higher cell potentials for organic compound mineralization [109,110], one notable advantage of PEC systems is their lower bias potential requirement. Liang et al. [111] proposed a novel separated PEC system utilizing black TiO2 nanospheres (b-TiO2−x) as the photoanode. This innovative system demonstrated exceptional water purification efficacy (98.3%) and H2O2 synthesis (6.8 μmol h−1 cm−2), operating at an impressively low voltage of 0.5 V while maintaining minimal energy expenditure for wastewater treatment at only 0.03 kWh m−3. Zhang et al. [112] employed a magnetic Fe3O4@SiO2@mesoporous TiO2 (FST) photocatalyst-imbued electrode to implement a synergistic PEC/H2O2 process for the degradation of organic contaminants. In this FST PEC/H2O2 system, the removal rates of TOC within 8 min were found to be 77.9% (RhB), 80.2% (MO), and 65.5% (AMX). However, recent advancements in PEC technology have led to the development of a bias-free system capable of simultaneously synthesizing H2O2 and harvesting electrical energy [113]. Chen et al. [114] revealed that, upon visible light exposure, the WO3/W photoanode induced a negative bias on the Pt/PVC photoelectrode while concurrently bestowing a positive bias upon the WO3/W photoanode. The collaborative separation of hole-electron pairs across these dual photoelectrodes created an inherent bias. Jeon et al. [115] successfully synthesized pristine H2O2 solution through PEC by utilizing sunlight as the sole external energy input at zero external bias (0.0 V battery voltage) without any reduction in photocurrent. In PEC systems operating without external bias, water, oxygen, and sunlight alone are sufficient to achieve simultaneous wastewater purification and energy storage. This technology holds significant potential for advancements in both the environmental and energy sectors. Dong et al. [116] recently reported a groundbreaking study on a self-sustaining PEC system driven by solar energy without external biasing. The researchers successfully synthesized and utilized H2O2 in situ using synthetic leaf blades. Their findings indicated that by optimizing the coupling between the photoanode and cathode, they achieved an impressive unassisted production rate of H2O2 at 0.7 μmol min−1 cm−2. This achievement represents an efficient self-circulating light Fenton-like system that solely relies on oxygen, water, and sunlight to accomplish wastewater treatment and energy storage objectives. The activation of O2 by the PEF and PEC processes for organic pollutant degradation are summarized in Table 6.Table 6 The activation of O2 by photoelectro-Fenton process and photoelectrocatalytic process.

Table 6Cathodes	Anodes	Contaminants	Reaction conditions	O2 supply	ROS	Removal efficiency	TOC removal	Reference	
Carbon felt	Pt	CIP	[CIP]0 = 50.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0, Na2SO4 = 50.0 μM, 300 W xenon lamp	O2 aeration	H2O2, •O2−, •OH	100.0%	80.3%	[98]	
CP@pTTh	Zn foil	RhB	[RhB]0 = 16.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0, Na2SO4 = 50.0 μM, j = 195.0 mA cm−2, 300 W xenon lamp	O2 aeration	H2O2, •O2−, •OH	Almost
100.0%	-	[99]	
FeCu@PC	RuO2	SMT	[SMT]0 = 80.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0–7.0, Na2SO4 = 20.0 mmol L−1, I = 25.0 mA, 5 W UV lamp	O2 aeration	H2O2, •O2−, •OH	96.3%	73.3%	[100]	
Co-free MWCNTs	BDD	Bronopol	[Bronopol]0 = 0.28 mM, pH = 3.0, Na2SO = 50.0 μM, Sunlight, j = 40.0 mA cm−2	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	94.0%	88.0%	[101]	
GDE	Pt	SY dye	[SY dye]0 = 100.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0, Na2SO4 = 100.0 mM, pH = 3.0, Solar irradiation, I = 100.0 mA	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	100.0%	71.0%	[102]	
GDE	BDD thin film	MET	[MET]0 = 90.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0, Na2SO4 = 50.0 mM, j = 100.0 mA cm−2	Air aeration	H2O2, •OH, 1O2	70.0%	32.0%	[103]	
FPC	WO3	BPA	[BPA]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0, Na2SO4 = 50.0 μM, 500 W xenon lamp, j = 1.0 mA cm−2	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	90.0%	40.0%	[107]	
Carbon cloth	Fe3O4@NiCo2O4	RhB	[RhB]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, pH = 3.0, Na2SO4 = 0.1 M, j = 7.5 mA cm−2, 150 W SAIC visible light lamp	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	99.0%	60.0%	[108]	
Pt	FST	SMT	[SMT]0 = 10.0 mg L−1, Acidic condition, Na2SO4 = 0.1 M, j = 7.7 mA cm−2, LED light	Air aeration	H2O2, •O2−, •OH	96.3%	73.3%	[112]	
Mo-SACs/mrG	SnO2−x/BiVO4	MB	[MB]0 = 5.0 mg L−1, Acidic condition, Simulated solar light, j = 1.5 mA cm−2	O2 aeration	H2O2, •OH	99.5%	-	[116]	
Abbreviations: CP@pTTh, carbon paper@polyterthiophene; FeCu@PC, FeCu@porous carbon; MWCNTs, multiwalled carbon nanotubes; BDD, boron-doped diamond; GDE, gas diffusion electrode; FPC, F-doped porous carbon; Mo-SACs/mrG, Mo single-atom catalysts/mildly reduced graphene; FST, Fe3O4@SiO2@mesoporous TiO2; CIP, ciprofloxacin; RhB, rhodamine B; SMT, sulfamethazine; SY, sunset yellow; MET, methomyl; BPA, bisphenol A; MB, methylene blue.

4.3 Microbial fuel cell process

The MFC represents an innovative device that utilizes a microbial metabolic process to convert organic waste and various biomass into electrical energy [117,118]. In this metabolic process, microorganisms facilitate the conversion of organic substrates into electrical energy. Traditionally, an MFC consists of two electrodes (anode and cathode), separated by an electrolytic medium (Fig. 3d). Microorganisms thrive on the anode's surface and engage in respiration utilizing organic compounds, generating electrons and protons. Electrons flow through an external circuit toward the cathode, where O2 undergoes a two-electron reduction, leading to H2O2 formation. The anaerobic exoelectrogenic bacteria in the anodic chamber of the MFC are capable of extracellular electron transfer [119], commonly known as “exoelectrogens” or “electrogens,” including sulfate-reducing bacteria such as Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Shewanella oneidensis, and E. coli, among others [120]. These microorganisms significantly influence the oxygen reduction potential in an MFC.

An investigation focused on utilizing an MFC with graphite felt as an electrode and S. oneidensis MR-1 as the electroactive bacterium [121]. The MFC generated electricity in situ beneath the composite cathode, resulting in a peak H2O2 production of 135.9 mol L−1, which subsequently reacted with leached Fe2+ to produce H2O2. At the same time, the system demonstrated a degradation efficiency of 78.3% toward triphenyltin chloride (TPTC). The presence of abundant microorganisms in the activated sludge effectively facilitated O2 reduction. Soltani et al. [122] employed mixed active microorganisms collected from anaerobic digestion tanks in wastewater treatment plants as inoculum, using glucose as the carbon substrate. The findings revealed that after 8 h, the H2O2 concentration within the system reached 3.2 mg L−1.

The electrode serves as a crucial site for microbial growth and adherence. The choice of electrode material significantly impacts the reduction of O2 and the attenuation of pollutants. Wang et al. [123] developed an MFC utilizing acetylene black as the catalyst for H2O2 generation and Fe-Mn binary oxide as the catalyst for •OH generation. Compared to the EF process, the MFC exhibited a 38.0% increase in the CBZ elimination rate over 24 h. Rafaqat et al. [124] proposed a low-cost composite cathode composed of activated carbon/stainless steel (AC/SS) and graphite powder/stainless steel (GP/SS), where SS facilitated current distribution while AC/GP supported simultaneous H2O2 production. These dual-cathode variants achieved concurrent H2O2 generation at 1420.0 μM/2680.0 μM and an enhanced degradation rate for AR 114 of 96.0%/90.0%. Furthermore, the influence of factors such as proton exchange membranes, co-substrate diversity, MFC architecture, and hydraulic retention duration on in situ H2O2 synthesis within an MFC was uncovered. An MFC based on activated oxygen presents an economically viable and environmentally friendly technology for wastewater remediation and energy generation. However, the widespread implementation of MFCs faces challenges, including reduced current density, suboptimal conductivity, and inadequate H2O2 yield.

In summary, the newly developed methodologies for electrochemical oxygen activation exhibit significant advantages in pollutant remediation while also presenting technical and environmental challenges. The utilization of the Fenton reaction not only provides economic benefits but also reduces hazards associated with the handling, transportation, and containment of H2O2. Moreover, it effectively degrades pollutants by generating highly reactive •OH. However, practical implementation is hindered by high energy consumption and the requirement for supporting electrolytes. Additionally, the PEF process combines photocatalysis and electrocatalysis to enhance O2 activation, resulting in increased production of ROS and improved capacity for pollutant removal. Nevertheless, this method necessitates simultaneous consumption of light and electrical energy and strict criteria for selecting the photocathode. The PEC process initiates O2 activation through energy transfer and charge transfer processes. The efficiency of the entire process is determined by the choice of photoanode material, which presents a challenge in developing cost-effective and high-performing alternatives. MFC technology offers an economically and environmentally friendly approach by generating H2O2 within the cathode compartment, thereby reducing operational costs for wastewater treatment. MFCs utilize microorganisms to convert the chemical energy of organic compounds into electrical energy, representing a promising renewable energy technology. However, this technology faces limitations such as suboptimal H2O2 yield, diminished unit throughput, reduced current density, and inadequate conductivity. This investigation highlights that the efficacy of electrochemical activation processes heavily relies on acidic environments and access to pure oxygen (refer to Table 5, Table 6). Overcoming these challenges becomes crucial for advancing electrochemical oxygen activation.

5 Influencing factors of O2 activation

The efficacy of O2 activation methodologies relies on various factors, including the availability of O2, reaction temperature, and pH level. Therefore, it is crucial to systematically optimize these parameters to enhance the efficiency of O2 activation, improve pollutant removal capabilities, and establish a foundation for reducing operational expenditures.

5.1 Oxygen supply

Among the O2 activation methods discussed in this paper, three types of O2 supply are identified: air aeration, pure oxygen aeration, and dissolved oxygen in the solution itself. Based on the data presented in Tables 1 and it has been found that the primary source of O2 during photocatalytic oxygen activation is the dissolved oxygen in the solution. These findings suggest these systems have demonstrated effective O2 activation capabilities even under lower O2 concentrations. This enhanced efficiency can be attributed to various modification strategies, such as defect engineering, doping, surface engineering, and ultrathin structures, which enhance the adsorption capacity of O2.

Most studies in Table 2, Table 3 exhibit the use of air or pure oxygen aeration to activate O2, indicating potential limitations in the efficacy of ZVMs and LVTMs for oxygen utilization. This may require high concentrations to activate O2 and generate ROS, possibly due to the low adsorption capacity of ZVMs and LVTMs toward oxygen. The analysis in Table 4 reveals that dissolved oxygen is the primary source for activating O2 through defect engineering, highlighting the crucial role of defect sites with a strong adsorptive propensity for O2. Table 5, Table 6 further reveal that pure oxygen aeration is the principal method for the electrochemical activation of O2, where purity significantly impacts H2O2 generation. However, the practical implementation of pollution control measures favors alternative approaches over pure oxygen aeration due to suboptimal oxygen utilization and substantial energy consumption losses, posing challenges for large-scale adoption.

During the aeration process, bubbles’ size plays a crucial role in activating O2. Microbubbles (MBs) and nanobubbles (NBs), with their larger surface areas compared to large bubbles, facilitate faster diffusion rates of O2 and longer hydraulic retention times [125,126]. Consequently, MBs and NBs can effectively provide water with a sustained oxygen supply. It is worth noting that MBs and NBs release a substantial amount of energy upon collapse, generating ROS [127]. For instance, Ghadimkhani et al. [128] elucidated that when NBs burst into molecular gas, they liberate considerable surface energy capable of converting O2 into radicals.

In conclusion, air aeration, pure oxygen aeration, and dissolved oxygen within solutions are vital sources in activation systems that significantly contribute to the degradation of pollutants through ROS. Additionally, oxygenation efficiency and pollutant removal are profoundly influenced by the size of gas bubbles. Therefore, it is imperative to carefully select an appropriate method for supplying oxygen based on the specific requirements and specifications of the processing system.

5.2 Reaction temperature

As an important experimental parameter, reaction temperature significantly impacts O2 activation. Typically, oxygen activation processes occur in ambient room temperature conditions. The reaction temperature has a bidirectional effect on both O2 activation and the generation of ROS. Temperature increases can enhance pollutant mass transfer capacity and O2 diffusion [129]. However, excessively high temperatures decrease O2 solubility and accelerate the H2O2 self-decomposition rate [130].

5.3 pH

The pH level plays a crucial role in the activation of O2. As shown in Table 1, the photochemical activation of O2 is feasible under both acidic and marginally alkaline conditions. In contrast to acidic environments, alkaline settings can significantly reduce the oxidation efficiency of pollutants. Under strongly alkaline conditions, semiconductor material surfaces may become negatively charged, attracting holes and repelling electrons, thereby influencing their recombination at the surface. This phenomenon hinders the formation of ROS, ultimately resulting in a diminished capacity for pollutant degradation [131]. Table 1 demonstrates that mild alkaline conditions promote pollutant degradation, which may be attributed to the dissociation constant (pKa) of the pollutants. However, when the pH exceeds the pKa value of the pollutants, an excess of OH− can induce electrostatic repulsion between pollutant anions and the negatively charged catalyst surface, impeding pollutant degradation efficiency [132].

The chemical activation of O2 predominantly occurs in both acidic and marginally alkaline environments, providing informative background information (Table 2, Table 3, Table 4). It is well-known that acidic conditions are favorable for pollutant degradation due to the corrosion of zero-valent metals, which initiates the activation of O2. Under acidic conditions, a lower pH facilitates the release of low-valent metal ions from zero-valent metals and the dissolution of oxide layers on their surfaces. However, it should be noted that excessively high pH levels impede the efficacy of pollutant degradation as metal ions quickly bind with OH−, forming adverse metal hydroxide precipitates that hinder ROS generation [71]. Moreover, compared to alkaline milieus, acidic conditions significantly elevate the redox potential of O2/•O2−, thereby increasing its propensity for conversion into •O2− in the presence of acid [133]. The importance of pH is further highlighted by its facilitation of the in situ synthesis of H2O2 during reduction processes involving proton participation. Conversely, alkaline conditions favor H2O2 disintegration and mitigate catalyst deactivation phenomena. Nonetheless, an overly diminished pH level within the solution may lead to alternative reactions and concurrently impact catalyst stability.

An acidic environment is essential for the optimal efficacy of the electrochemical activation process of O2 (Table 5, Table 6). During this process, H2O2 serves as the main ROS generated. The production of H2O2 relies on the presence of •O2−, a pair of protons, and a single electron. In an alkaline milieu, an abundance of OH− persistently consumes protons, thereby hindering the formation of H2O2. However, excessively low pH levels impede the interaction between metal ions and H2O2, reducing diminished •OH production.

6 ROS generation path based on O2 activation

O2, known for its safety, environmental friendliness, and green properties, exists in the stable triplet oxygen (3O2) with two unpaired electrons in its highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO). The activation of O2 involves the acquisition of electrons and energy, which weakens the oxygen–oxygen bond and leads to the generation of ROS [134]. This study elucidates three fundamental approaches for activating O2: photocatalytic, chemical, and electrochemical methods. This article provides a comprehensive summary and analysis of each ROS production pathway, contributing to a better understanding of strategies for activating O2.

•O2− is an important ROS involved in the mineralization of organic molecules and serves as an intermediate in the generation of other ROS. The predominant source of •O2− production is through the single-electron reduction of O2, although the electron donor for this reduction varies depending on different activation strategies. In photochemical activation processes, O2 is activated by photo-excited electrons in a semiconductor; however, the reduction of O2 to •O2− via photo-generated electrons requires that the semiconductor's conduction band potential be lower than the standard redox potential of O2/•O2− (E = −0.05 eV vs. normal hydrogen electrode (NHE)) [135]. Additionally, valence band holes can oxidize H2O2 and generate •O2−. In chemical activation processes, electron donors such as ZVMs, LVTMs, and materials with defect engineering reduce O2. ZVMs and LVTMs possess good reducibility because they can easily donate one or multiple electrons. Moreover, defect engineering involving OVs provides an abundance of electrons capable of reducing O2, forming •O2−. Unlike ZVMs and LVTMs, OVs can induce the adsorption and interaction of O2 in their vicinity, influenced by localized charge effects, reduced surface energy, and other contributing factors. O2 is sequestered at these OVs, leading to elongation of the O–O bond within the oxygen molecule toward its theoretical length of •O2− (1.26 Å) [80]. This elongation occurs as electrons are transferred from the OVs to the π2py∗ orbital of O2, ultimately resulting in the formation of •O2−. During electrochemical activation, O2 can acquire electrons on the photoanode and cathode, thereby undergoing reduction to form •O2−.

The in situ production of H2O2 plays a crucial role in the degradation process of organic pollutants. This is primarily achieved through oxygen reduction by photo-generated electrons, metals, defects, and the cathode surface. In photochemical processes, semiconductors can generate photoelectrons that reduce O2 to produce H2O2. There are two distinct pathways for the reduction of O2 to H2O2: the first entails a direct two-electron reduction (equation (22)), while the second involves a one-electron, two-stage indirect reduction sequence (equations (23), (24)). O2 can directly gain two electrons and two protons to form H2O2. Additionally, O2 initially undergoes a reaction to yield •O2− by accepting a single electron before assimilating an additional electron and two protons to form H2O2.(22) O2+2H++2e−→H2O2

(23) O2+e−→•O2−

(24) •O2−+2H++e−→H2O2

The band structure is critical to distinguishing between the two activation pathways. Considering that the standard potential for the two-electron transfer process is 0.68 V vs. NHE [136], O2 activation can occur through a one-step two-electron transfer process if the catalyst's conduction band potential is below this threshold. Additionally, in the two-step single-electron transfer of O2, •O2− acts as an intermediate species; therefore, introducing an •O2− scavenger can inhibit the single-electron transfer sequence. If introducing a scavenger leads to no formation of H2O2, it indicates that H2O2 synthesis exclusively occurs via the single-electron transfer pathway of O2. However, ORRs do not always result in H2O2 formation. O2 undergoes a four-electron reduction process at excessively high voltages, producing H2O.

The •OH radical, known for its exceptional oxidative properties in eliminating organic pollutants, is formed through the reduction and hydrogenation of O2 to •O2−, followed by a subsequent conversion into H2O2 with a lower energy barrier. This electron reduction process facilitates a more favorable reaction pathway, leading to the subsequent reduction of H2O2 to •OH. Moreover, photo-induced holes in semiconductors can generate •OH through oxidation when the valence band position of the semiconductor aligns with the required standard potential (equation (25)).(25) H2O+h+→•OH+H+

O2 exists in three electron configurations: two low-lying singlet excited states (O2(1Δg) and O2(1Σg+)) and a ground state triplet (O2(3Σg−)) [137]. Since the energies of O2(1Δg) (95.0 kJ mol−1) and O2(1Σg+) (158.0 kJ mol−1) are higher than the ground state triplet, singlet excited states exhibit higher reactivity. When the spin restriction of 3O2 is overcome, electrons join one of the orbitals to form “singlet oxygen delta” O2(1Δg), a rare chemical species with high chemical reactivity [138]. The transition from the 1Δg state to the 3Σg− state is spin-forbidden, making O2(1Δg) a relatively long-lived species. O2(1Σg+), on the other hand, has a shorter lifespan due to the allowed spin transition to the O2(1Δg) state, so the term “singlet oxygen” mainly refers to O2(1Δg) [139].

Based on the activation of O2, the generation pathways of 1O2 can be broadly categorized into electron transfer and energy transfer (refer to Table 1, Table 6). In the electron transfer process, 1O2 can be produced through the redox reactions involving O2 or radicals. Although H2O2 is capable of generating 1O2 through self-decomposition, this sequence occurs at a relatively slow rate. •O2− plays a crucial role as an intermediate species generating of 1O2. Potent oxidants possess the ability to directly convert •O2− into 1O2. Photo-generated holcan to interact with •O2− leading to the formation 1O2. The oxidative processes involving radicals such as •OH and •OOH further facilitate the conversion of •O2− into 1O2. Additionally, high-valence metal ions have a propensity for oxidizing •O2−. These reactions can be observed in the photochemical, chemical, and electrochemical activation of O2 (equations (26), (27), (28), (29)).(26) O2+e−→•O2−

(27) •O2−+h+→O21

(28) •O2−+2•OH+2H+→O21+2OH−

(29) •O2−+Co4+/Co3+→O21+2Co2+

The transformation of O2 into 1O2 via energy transfer is currently limited to photochemical O2 activation. In its ground state, the oxygen molecule exists as 3O2, with the spins of its two unpaired electrons parallel [140]. When the spin states of these electrons change to become antiparallel, the oxygen molecule converts into 1O2. Under illumination, semiconductor photocatalysts generate excitons, electron-hole pairs induced by photon absorption. Before exciton–exciton annihilation (EEA), singlet excitons undergo intersystem crossing (ISC) and transition to energetically favorable triplet states [141]. This process involves a change in electron spin orientation, resulting in the formation of long-lived triplet excitons. The triplet excitons transfer energy to O2, inducing a spin state change (spin flip) that generates 1O2 (Fig. 4). 1O2 is a high-energy form of oxygen with strong oxidizing power, enabling its involvement in diverse chemical reactions, including the oxidation of organic compounds.Fig. 4 The production mechanism of 1O2 by O2 activation through energy transfer.

Fig. 4

7 Conclusions and outlook

O2, known for its environmentally friendly, non-toxic, and cost-effective properties, stands out as a superior oxidant in the sustainable degradation of contaminants. The activation of O2 leads to the generation of ROS, which are instrumental in efficiently degrading and mineralizing various organic pollutants. This study presents a comprehensive analysis of recent advancements in utilizing oxygen as an oxidant for environmental remediation. Several strategies have been developed to activate O2, including photochemical, chemical, and electrochemical methods. These approaches have shown remarkable outcomes in wastewater treatment. Notably, energy and electron transfer are the primary mechanisms underlying O2 activation. Given its paramount importance in environmental remediation, there is significant interest among researchers regarding the activation of O2. However, this field is still at an early stage, with numerous complexities and challenges that have yet to be addressed. Therefore, meticulous research is essential to provide valuable theoretical references for future investigations.

First, it is crucial to minimize energy consumption in applications to achieve energy-efficient and environmentally benign water purification technologies. The electrochemical activation process using pure oxygen aeration may have low oxygen utilization efficiency and high energy consumption. Therefore, exploring the use of ambient air or oxygen generated via water electrolysis as alternatives for the reaction becomes essential to address this research gap. Simultaneously, transitioning toward low-power light sources or solar energy should be considered wherever feasible for photochemical activation.

Second, intensifying research efforts on the selective generation of 1O2 is pivotal. 1O2 stands out due to its extended lifespan and selectivity as the sole ROS producible via both energy transfer and electron transfer mechanisms. Optimizing the activation process to enhance 1O2 yield is important while conducting comprehensive studies elucidating the underlying formation mechanisms during O2 activation.

Moreover, comprehensive investigations are warranted to unravel the intricate activation mechanism of O2 within complex aquatic ecosystems. Rigorous experimental studies are essential for unveiling the nuanced complexities of O2 activation, aiming to achieve targeted pollutant removal and efficient resource utilization.

Ultimately, a versatile wastewater treatment system can be structured by synergizing diverse activation methods and leveraging their strengths. For instance, by synergistically integrating photocatalytic and electrocatalytic technologies, solar energy can be harnessed while concurrently regulating reactions via electricity, thereby amplifying the efficiency of the treatment process.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Xiaohu Fan: Writing - Original Draft, Visualization, Software, Methodology, Investigation, Data Curation. Qiang Fu: Methodology, Investigation. Guorui Liu: Methodology, Investigation. Hongliang Jia: Methodology, Conceptualization. Xiaolong Dong: Visualization. Yi-Fan Li: Methodology, Formal Analysis. Song Cui: Writing - Review & Editing, Validation, Supervision, Resources, Methodology, Funding Acquisition, Conceptualization.

Declaration of competing interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Distinguished Youth Science Foundation of Heilongjiang Province, China (JQ2023E001 ) and Young Leading Talents of 10.13039/501100008534 Northeast Agricultural University , China (NEAU2023QNLJ-013 ).
==== Refs
References

1 Liu P. Dai J. Bie C. Li H. Zhang Z. Guo X. Zhu L. Bioaccessibility of microplastic-associated antibiotics in freshwater organisms: highlighting the impacts of biofilm colonization via an in vitro protocol Environ. Sci. Technol. 56 17 2022 12267 12277 10.1021/acs.est.2c02782 35952376
2 Khmaissa M. Zouari-Mechichi H. Sciara G. Record E. Mechichi T. Pollution from livestock farming antibiotics an emerging environmental and human health concern: a review J. Hazard Mater. 13 2024 100410 10.1016/j.hazadv.2024.100410
3 Harris K.J. Munoz G. Woo V. Sauve S. Rand A.A. Targeted and suspect screening of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances in cosmetics and personal care products Environ. Sci. Technol. 56 20 2022 14594 14604 10.1021/acs.est.2c02660 36178710
4 Mukherjee A. Mullick A. Vadthya P. Moulik S. Roy A. Surfactant degradation using hydrodynamic cavitation based hybrid advanced oxidation technology: a techno economic feasibility study Chem. Eng. J. 398 2020 125599 10.1016/j.cej.2020.125599
5 Xia T. Lin Y. Li W. Ju M. Photocatalytic degradation of organic pollutants by MOFs based materials: a review Chin. Chem. Lett. 32 10 2021 2975 2984 10.1016/j.cclet.2021.02.058
6 Xie Z.H. He C.S. Pei D.N. Dong Y. Yang S.R. Xiong Z. Zhou P. Pan Z.C. Yao G. Lai B. Review of characteristics, generation pathways and detection methods of singlet oxygen generated in advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) Chem. Eng. J. 468 2023 143778 10.1016/j.cej.2023.143778
7 Yan H. Lai C. Liu S. Wang D. Zhou X. Zhang M. Li L. Ma D. Xu F. Huo X. Tang L. Yan M. Nie J. Fan X. Insight into the selective oxidation behavior of organic pollutants via Ni-N4-C mediated electron transfer pathway Chem. Eng. J. 473 2023 145253 10.1016/j.cej.2023.145253
8 Giannakis S. Lin K.-Y.A. Ghanbari F. A review of the recent advances on the treatment of industrial wastewaters by Sulfate Radical-based Advanced Oxidation Processes (SR-AOPs) Chem. Eng. J. 406 2021 127083 10.1016/j.cej.2020.127083
9 Akbari S. Moussavi G. Decker J. Marin M.L. Bosca F. Giannakis S. Superior visible light-mediated catalytic activity of a novel N-doped, Fe3O4-incorporating MgO nanosheet in presence of PMS: imidacloprid degradation and implications on simultaneous bacterial inactivation Appl. Catal. B Environ. 317 2022 121732 10.1016/j.apcatb.2022.121732
10 Qin J. Liu Z. Xu W. Zhu X. Liang F. Yu Y. Zheng Y. Yao L. Zhang H. Lin K. Fang J. Fang Z. Heterogeneous photocatalysis coupled with Fenton-Like reaction for fluoroquinolone antibiotics degradation by poly (Triazine Imide): from mechanism to application in a continuous flow catalytic system Chem. Eng. J. 476 2023 146856 10.1016/j.cej.2023.146856
11 Fu B.G. Zhou X. Lu Y. Quan W.Z. Li C. Cheng L. Xiao X. Yu Y.Y. Interfacial OOH⁎ mediated Fe(II) regeneration on the single atom Co-N-C catalyst for efficient Fenton-like processes J. Hazard Mater. 2024 134214 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2024.134214
12 Feng W. Jiang Y. Ge F. Bai Q. Yang J. Shang L. Cao R. Niu G. Wang L. Zhu Z. Sui N. Interconversion of sp-hybridized chemical bonds induces piezoelectric enhanced photocatalysis Appl. Catal. B Environ. 349 2024 123868 10.1016/j.apcatb.2024.123868
13 Yang S. Feng Y. Gao D. Wang X. Suo N. Yu Y. Zhang S. Electrocatalysis degradation of tetracycline in a three-dimensional aeration electrocatalysis reactor (3D-AER) with a flotation-tailings particle electrode (FPE): physicochemical properties, influencing factors and the degradation mechanism J. Hazard Mater. 407 2021 124361 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.124361
14 Wang H. Long Z. Chen R. Zhang H. Shi H. Chen Y. Boosting PMS activation over BiVO4 piezo-photocatalyst to rapidly degrade tetracycline: intermediates and mechanism Sep. Purif. Technol. 331 2024 125598 10.1016/j.seppur.2023.125598
15 Dong Z.T. Niu C.G. Guo H. Niu H.Y. Liang S. Liang C. Liu H.Y. Yang Y.Y. Anchoring CuFe2O4 nanoparticles into N-doped carbon nanosheets for peroxymonosulfate activation: built-in electric field dominated radical and non-radical process Chem. Eng. J. 426 2021 130850 10.1016/j.cej.2021.130850
16 Lai C. Yan H. Wang D. Liu S. Zhou X. Li X. Zhang M. Li L. Fu Y. Xu F. Yang X. Huo X. Facile synthesis of Mn, Ce co-doped g-C3N4 composite for peroxymonosulfate activation towards organic contaminant degradation Chemosphere 293 2022 133472 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.133472
17 Zhou H. Yang J. Cao W. Chen C. Jiang C. Wang Y. Hollow Meso-crystalline Mn-doped Fe3O4 Fenton-like catalysis for ciprofloxacin degradation: applications in water purification on wide pH range Appl. Surf. Sci. 590 2022 153120 10.1016/j.apsusc.2022.153120
18 Yi Q. Ji J. Shen B. Dong C. Liu J. Zhang J. Xing M. Singlet Oxygen triggered by superoxide radicals in a molybdenum cocatalytic Fenton reaction with enhanced redox activity in the environment Environ. Sci. Technol. 53 16 2019 9725 9733 10.1021/acs.est.9b01676 31331171
19 Xu Y. Guo M. Ge C. Zhang P. Xu W. Zhang L. Zhou S. Liao J. Cu single atoms/O doping g-C3N4 mediated photocatalytic activation of peroxymonosulfate for ultrafast carbamazepine removal via high 1O2 yield Appl. Surf. Sci. 640 2023 158290 10.1016/j.apsusc.2023.158290
20 Sun H. Qin P. Guo J. Jiang Y. Liang Y. Gong X. Ma X. Wu Q. Zhang J. Luo L. Wu Z. Enhanced electron channel via the interfacial heterotropic electric field in dual S-scheme g-C3N4/WO3/ZnS photocatalyst for year-round antibiotic degradation under sunlight Chem. Eng. J. 470 2023 144217 10.1016/j.cej.2023.144217
21 Lyu P. Zhu J. Han C. Qiang L. Zhang L. Mei B. He J. Liu X. Bian Z. Li H. Self-driven reactive oxygen species generation via interfacial oxygen vacancies on carbon-coated TiO2-x with versatile applications ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 13 1 2021 2033 2043 10.1021/acsami.0c19414 33378149
22 Sun X. Luo X. Zhang X. Xie J. Jin S. Wang H. Zheng X. Wu X. Xie Y. Enhanced superoxide generation on defective surfaces for selective photooxidation J. Am. Chem. Soc. 141 9 2019 3797 3801 10.1021/jacs.8b13051 30784264
23 Zhao H. Liu X. Dong Y. Xia Y. Wang H. A special synthesis of BiOCl photocatalyst for efficient pollutants removal: new insight into the band structure regulation and molecular oxygen activation Appl. Catal. B Environ. 256 2019 117872 10.1016/j.apcatb.2019.117872
24 Wang S. Xiong Z. Yang N. Ding X. Chen H. Iodine-doping-assisted tunable introduction of oxygen vacancies on bismuth tungstate photocatalysts for highly efficient molecular oxygen activation and pentachlorophenol mineralization Chin. J. Catal. 41 10 2020 1544 1553 10.1016/S1872-2067(19)63506-0
25 Wang Q. Xu D. Dong Y. Pang S. Zhang L. Zhang G. Lv L. Liu X. Xia Y. Campos L.C. Ren Z. Wang P. Unsaturated Nd-Bi dual-metal sites enable efficient NIR light-driven O2 activation for water purification Appl. Catal. B Environ. 319 2022 121924 10.1016/j.apcatb.2022.121924
26 Sheng J. Li X. Xu Y. Generation of H2O2 and OH radicals on Bi2WO6 for phenol degradation under visible light ACS Catal. 4 3 2014 732 737 10.1021/cs400927w
27 Liu H. Wang C. Yang Y. Gao M. Xue A. Chen H. Ding X. Selective photocatalytic remediation of para-substituted phenol pollutants over iodine-doped Bi2MoO6 via in-situ generated H2O2 and iodine radicals activation Sep. Purif. Technol. 340 2024 126711 10.1016/j.seppur.2024.126711
28 Yue C. Sun N. Qiu Y. Zhu L. Du Z. Liu F. A direct Z-scheme 0D α-Fe2O3/TiO2 heterojunction for enhanced photo-Fenton activity with low H2O2 consumption Chin. Chem. Lett. 2024 109698 10.1016/j.cclet.2024.109698
29 Wei L.W. Zheng M.W. Liu S.H. Paul Wang H. Pu Y.C. Nguyen V.C. Visible-light photocatalytic O2-to-H2O2 via nitrogen-graphene quantum dots-modified Bi2Fe4O9 for synchronizing the reduction of Cr(VI) and oxidation of organic contaminants: kinetics, mechanism, and performance Chem. Eng. J. 487 2024 150712 10.1016/j.cej.2024.150712
30 Sun H. Qin P. Guo J. Jiang Y. Liang Y. Gong X. Ma X. Wu Q. Zhang J. Luo L. Wu Z. Enhanced electron channel via the interfacial heterotropic electric field in dual S-scheme g-C3N4/WO3/ZnS photocatalyst for year-round antibiotic degradation under sunlight Chem. Eng. J. 470 2023 144217 10.1016/j.cej.2023.144217
31 Liu W. Wang P. Chen J. Gao X. Che H. Su X. Liu B. Ao Y. In situ single iron atom doping on Bi2WO6 monolayers triggers efficient photo-fenton reaction Environ. Sci. Ecotechnol. 2024 100414 10.1016/j.ese.2024.100414
32 Yang Z. Wang J. Photo-Fenton degradation of sulfamethazine using self-assembled CdS nanorods with in-situ production of H2O2 at wide pH range Chem. Eng. J. 450 2022 138024 10.1016/j.cej.2022.138024
33 Jiang Z. Wang L. Lei J. Liu Y. Zhang J. Photo-Fenton degradation of phenol by CdS/rGO/Fe2+ at natural pH with in situ-generated H2O2 Appl. Catal. B Environ. 241 2019 367 374 10.1016/j.apcatb.2018.09.049
34 Shi W. Wang L. Wang J. Sun H. Shi Y. Guo F. Lu C. Magnetically retrievable CdS/reduced graphene oxide/ZnFe2O4 ternary nanocomposite for self-generated H2O2 towards photo-Fenton removal of tetracycline under visible light irradiation Sep. Purif. Technol. 292 2022 120987 10.1016/j.seppur.2022.120987
35 Yang Y.Y. Guo H. Huang D.W. Li L. Liu H.Y. Sui L. Wu Q. Zhu J.J. Zhang L. Niu C.G. Simultaneously tuning oxygen reduction pathway and charge transfer dynamics toward sacrificial agent-free photocatalytic H2O2 production for in-situ water disinfection Chem. Eng. J. 479 2024 147863 10.1016/j.cej.2023.147863
36 Du C. Feng W. Nie S. Su X. Liu H. Feng J. Sun J. Hu C. Dong S. π-π conjugation driving degradation of aromatic compounds with in-situ hydrogen peroxide generation over Zn2In2S5 grown on nitrogen-doped carbon spheres Appl. Catal. B Environ. 310 2022 121298 10.1016/j.apcatb.2022.121298
37 Mushtaq M.A. Kumar A. Yasin G. Arif M. Tabish M. Ibraheem S. Cai X. Ye W. Fang X. Saad A. Zhao J. Ji S. Yan D. 3D interconnected porous Mo-doped WO3@CdS hierarchical hollow heterostructures for efficient photoelectrochemical nitrogen reduction to ammonia Appl. Catal. B Environ. 317 2022 121711 10.1016/j.apcatb.2022.121711
38 Gaikwad R.P. Naikwadi D.R. Biradar A.V. Gawande M.B. Photocatalytic one-pot conversion of aldehydes to esters and degradation of rhodamine B dye using mesoporous graphitic carbon nitride ACS Appl. Nano Mater. 6 3 2023 1859 1869 10.1021/acsanm.2c04846
39 Chávez A.M. Torres-Pinto A. Álvarez P.M. Faria J.L. Silva C.G. Silva A.M.T. One-pot synthesis and immobilization of urea-derived graphitic carbon nitride onto ceramic foams for visible-light photocatalytic wet peroxide oxidation in water treatment Chem. Eng. J. 481 2024 10.1016/j.cej.2023.148141
40 Wu Y. Chen J. Che H. Gao X. Ao Y. Wang P. Boosting 2e− oxygen reduction reaction in garland carbon nitride with carbon defects for high-efficient photocatalysis-self-Fenton degradation of 2,4-dichlorophenol Appl. Catal. B Environ. 307 2022 121185 10.1016/j.apcatb.2022.121185
41 Ong W.J. Tan L.L. Ng Y.H. Yong S.T. Chai S.P. Graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4)-based photocatalysts for artificial photosynthesis and environmental remediation: are we a step closer to achieving sustainability? Chem. Rev. 116 12 2016 7159 7329 10.1021/acs.chemrev.6b00075 27199146
42 Deng H. Jia Y. Wang W. Zhong S. Hao R. Fan L. Liu X. Defect and crystallinity-mediated charge separation in carbon nitride for synergistically boosted solar-driven hydrogen evolution ACS Sustain. Chem. Eng. 11 37 2023 13736 13746 10.1021/acssuschemeng.3c03772
43 Aquino de Carvalho N. Wang Y. Morales-Soto N. Waldeck D. Bibby K. Doudrick K. Gilbertson L.M. Using C-doping to identify photocatalytic properties of graphitic carbon nitride that govern antibacterial efficacy ACS ES&T Water 1 2 2020 269 280 10.1021/acsestwater.0c00053
44 Aggarwal M. Basu S. Shetti N.P. Nadagouda M.N. Kwon E.E. Park Y.-K. Aminabhavi T.M. Photocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction: exploring the role of ultrathin 2D graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4) Chem. Eng. J. 425 2021 131402 10.1016/j.cej.2021.131402
45 Zhang Q. Wang B. Miao H. Fan J. Sun T. Liu E. Efficient photocatalytic H2O2 production over K+-intercalated crystalline g-C3N4 with regulated oxygen reduction pathway Chem. Eng. J. 482 2024 148844 10.1016/j.cej.2024.148844
46 Zhou Z. Li K. Deng W. Li J. Yan Y. Li Y. Quan X. Wang T. Nitrogen vacancy mediated exciton dissociation in carbon nitride nanosheets: enhanced hydroxyl radicals generation for efficient photocatalytic degradation of organic pollutants J. Hazard Mater. 387 2020 122023 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.122023
47 Li R. Zheng M. Zhou X. Zhang D. Shi Y. Li C. Yang M. Carbon vacancies in porous g-C3N4 nanosheets induced robust H2O2 production for highly efficient photocatalysis-self-Fenton system for metronidazole degradation Chem. Eng. J. 464 2023 142584 10.1016/j.cej.2023.142584
48 Hu J. Zhang P. Yang T. Cai Y. Qu J. Yang X. Screen superior ultra-thin g-C3N4 material for photocatalytic in-situ H2O2 production to remove tetracycline Appl. Surf. Sci. 576 2022 151841 10.1016/j.apsusc.2021.151841
49 Shi W. Sun W. Liu Y. Zhang K. Sun H. Lin X. Hong Y. Guo F. A self-sufficient photo-Fenton system with coupling in-situ production H2O2 of ultrathin porous g-C3N4 nanosheets and amorphous FeOOH quantum dots J. Hazard Mater. 436 2022 129141 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2022.129141
50 Ma J. Wang K. Wang C. Chen X. Zhu W. Zhu G. Yao W. Zhu Y. Photocatalysis-self-Fenton system with high-fluent degradation and high mineralization ability Appl. Catal. B Environ. 276 2020 119150 10.1016/j.apcatb.2020.119150
51 Wei Z. Liu M. Zhang Z. Yao W. Tan H. Zhu Y. Efficient visible-light-driven selective oxygen reduction to hydrogen peroxide by oxygen-enriched graphitic carbon nitride polymers Energy Environ. Sci. 11 9 2018 2581 2589 10.1039/C8EE01316K
52 Liu L.L. Chen F. Wu J.H. Chen J.J. Yu H.Q. Synergy of crystallinity modulation and intercalation engineering in carbon nitride for boosted H2O2 photosynthesis Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 120 6 2023 e2215305120 10.1073/pnas.2215305120
53 Du C. Feng W. Nie S. Zhang J. Liang Y. Han X. Wu Y. Feng J. Dong S. Liu H. Sun J. Harnessing efficient in-situ H2O2 production via a KPF6/BiOBr photocatalyst for the degradation of polyethylene Sep. Purif. Technol. 279 2021 119734 10.1016/j.seppur.2021.119734
54 Wang H. Jiang S. Chen S. Li D. Zhang X. Shao W. Sun X. Xie J. Zhao Z. Zhang Q. Tian Y. Xie Y. Enhanced singlet oxygen generation in oxidized graphitic carbon nitride for organic synthesis Adv. Mater. 28 32 2016 6940 6945 10.1002/adma.201601413 27271463
55 Yamaguchi R. Kurosu S. Suzuki M. Kawase Y. Hydroxyl radical generation by zero-valent iron/Cu (ZVI/Cu) bimetallic catalyst in wastewater treatment: heterogeneous Fenton/Fenton-like reactions by Fenton reagents formed in-situ under oxic conditions Chem. Eng. J. 334 2018 1537 1549 10.1016/j.cej.2017.10.154
56 Fan C. Wu S. Zheng X. Bei K. He S. Zhao M. Enhancement of cottonseed oil refining wastewater treatment by zero valent iron under sunlight irradiation and O2 bubbling J. Colloid Interface Sci. 615 2022 124 132 10.1016/j.jcis.2022.01.171 35124500
57 Lv H. Niu H. Zhao X. Cai Y. Wu F. Carbon zero-valent iron materials possessing high-content fine Fe0 nanoparticles with enhanced microelectrolysis-Fenton-like catalytic performance for water purification Appl. Catal. B Environ. 286 2021 119940 10.1016/j.apcatb.2021.119940
58 Yang Y. Xu L. Li W. Fan W. Song S. Yang J. Adsorption and degradation of sulfadiazine over nanoscale zero-valent iron encapsulated in three-dimensional graphene network through oxygen-driven heterogeneous Fenton-like reactions Appl. Catal. B Environ. 259 2019 118057 10.1016/j.apcatb.2019.118057
59 Fan J. Qin H. Zhang Y. Jiang S. Degradation of 4-chlorophenol by BM Fe/Cu-O2 system: the symbiosis of •O2- and •OH radicals Water Environ. Res. 91 8 2019 770 779 10.1002/wer.1107 30913327
60 Dong G. Ai Z. Zhang L. Total aerobic destruction of azo contaminants with nanoscale zero-valent copper at neutral pH: promotion effect of in-situ generated carbon center radicals Water Res. 66 2014 22 30 10.1016/j.watres.2014.08.011 25181614
61 Hong R. Guo Z. Gao J. Gu C. Rapid degradation of atrazine by hydroxyl radical induced from montmorillonite templated subnano-sized zero-valent copper Chemosphere 180 2017 335 342 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2017.04.025 28412491
62 Yang Z. Liu Y. Wang J. MOF-derived Cu0/C activation of molecular oxygen for efficient degradation of sulfamethazine Chem. Eng. J. 427 2022 131961 10.1016/j.cej.2021.131961
63 Zhang J. Wu Y. Liu L. Lan Y. Rapid removal of p-chloronitrobenzene from aqueous solution by a combination of ozone with zero-valent zinc Sep. Purif. Technol. 151 2015 318 323 10.1016/j.seppur.2015.07.060
64 Ghasemi M. Khataee A. Gholami P. Soltani R.D.C. Hassani A. Orooji Y. In-situ electro-generation and activation of hydrogen peroxide using a CuFeNLDH-CNTs modified graphite cathode for degradation of cefazolin J. Environ. Manag. 267 2020 110629 10.1016/j.jenvman.2020.110629
65 Zárate-Guzmán A.I. González-Gutiérrez L.V. Godínez L.A. Medel-Reyes A. Carrasco-Marín F. Romero-Cano L.A. Towards understanding of heterogeneous Fenton reaction using carbon-Fe catalysts coupled to in-situ H2O2 electro-generation as clean technology for wastewater treatment Chemosphere 224 2019 698 706 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.02.101 30851521
66 Gong X.-b. Yang Z. Peng L. Zhou A.-l. Liu Y.-l. Liu Y. In-situ synthesis of hydrogen peroxide in a novel Zn-CNTs-O2 system J. Power Sources 378 2018 190 197 10.1016/j.jpowsour.2017.12.040
67 Liu Y. Tan N. Wang B. Liu Y. Stepwise adsorption-oxidation removal of oxytetracycline by Zn0-CNTs-Fe3O4 from aqueous solution Chem. Eng. J. 375 2019 121963 10.1016/j.cej.2019.121963
68 Liu Y. Fan Q. Wang J. Zn-Fe-CNTs catalytic in situ generation of H2O2 for Fenton-like degradation of sulfamethoxazole J. Hazard Mater. 342 2018 166 176 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2017.08.016 28826059
69 Yang Z. Luo Y. Yue J. Wang X. Xu H. Ye Q. Zhang Y. Xing X. Wang Q. Zhang J. Activation of O2 by zero-valent zinc assisted with Cu(II) for organics removal: performance and mechanism J. Hazard Mater. 424 2022 127506 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2021.127506
70 Foroughi M. Peighambardoust S.J. Ramavandi B. Boffito D.C. Simultaneous anionic dyes degradation via H2O2 activation using Zeolite 4A/ZnO/Fe2(MoO4)3 nanoparticles in a sono-photocatalytic process Adv. Polym. Technol. 35 1 2024 10.1016/j.apt.2023.104320
71 Hou X. Shen W. Huang X. Ai Z. Zhang L. Ascorbic acid enhanced activation of oxygen by ferrous iron: a case of aerobic degradation of rhodamine B J. Hazard Mater. 308 2016 67 74 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2016.01.031 26808244
72 Zong Y. Mao Y. Xu L. Wu D. Non-selective degradation of organic pollutants via dioxygen activation induced by Fe(II)-tetrapolyphosphate complexes: identification of reactive oxidant and kinetic modeling Chem. Eng. J. 398 2020 125603 10.1016/j.cej.2020.125603
73 Wang H. Zhang L. Hu C. Wang X. Enhanced Fenton-like catalytic performance of Cu-Al/KIT-6 and the key role of O2 in triggering reaction Chem. Eng. J. 387 2020 124006 10.1016/j.cej.2019.124006
74 Zheng N. He X. Zhou Q. Wang R. Zhang X. Hu R. Hu Z. Generation of reactive chlorine species via molecular oxygen activation on a copper chloride loaded hydrothermal carbonaceous carbon for advanced oxidation process Appl. Catal. B Environ. 319 2022 121918 10.1016/j.apcatb.2022.121918
75 Zheng N. Li L. Tang X. Xie W. Zhu Q. Wang X. Lian Y. Yu J.C. Hu Z. Spontaneous formation of low valence copper on red phosphorus to effectively activate molecular oxygen for advanced oxidation process Environ. Sci. Technol. 57 12 2023 5024 5033 10.1021/acs.est.2c09645 36892275
76 Zheng N. Tang X. Lian Y. Ou Z. Zhou Q. Wang R. Hu Z. Low-valent copper on molybdenum triggers molecular oxygen activation to selectively generate singlet oxygen for advanced oxidation processes J. Hazard Mater. 452 2023 131210 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.131210
77 Zhang C. Kong C. Tratnyek P.G. Qin C. Zhao Y. Piao Y. Effect of interfacial action on the generation and transformation of reactive oxygen species in tripolyphosphate-enhanced heterogeneous Fe3O4/O2 systems Environ. Sci. Technol. 58 2024 1378 1389 10.1021/acs.est.3c07372 38179651
78 Hu Z. Wu Z. Han C. He J. Ni Z. Chen W. Two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenides: interface and defect engineering Chem. Soc. Rev. 47 9 2018 3100 3128 10.1039/C8CS00024G 29509206
79 Wu L. Sun Z. Zhen Y. Zhu S. Yang C. Lu J. Tian Y. Zhong D. Ma J. Oxygen vacancy-induced nonradical degradation of organics: critical trigger of oxygen (O2) in the Fe-Co LDH/Peroxymonosulfate system Environ. Sci. Technol. 55 22 2021 15400 15411 10.1021/acs.est.1c04600 34738465
80 Wang S. Zhu J. Li T. Ge F. Zhang Z. Zhu R. Xie H. Xu Y. Oxygen vacancy-mediated CuCoFe/Tartrate-LDH catalyst directly activates oxygen to produce superoxide radicals: transformation of active species and implication for nitrobenzene degradation Environ. Sci. Technol. 56 12 2022 7924 7934 10.1021/acs.est.2c00522 35587516
81 Wang S. Li T. Cheng X. Zhu R. Xu Y. Regulating the concentration of dissolved oxygen to achieve the directional transformation of reactive oxygen species: a controllable oxidation process for ciprofloxacin degradation by calcined CuCoFe-LDH Water Res. 233 2023 119744 10.1016/j.watres.2023.119744
82 Hao Y.J. Liu B. Tian L.G. Li F.T. Ren J. Liu S.J. Liu Y. Zhao J. Wang X.J. Synthesis of 111 Facet-exposed MgO with surface oxygen vacancies for reactive oxygen species generation in the dark ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 9 14 2017 12687 12693 10.1021/acsami.6b16856 28339179
83 Lakshmi Prasanna V. Vijayaraghavan R. Insight into the mechanism of antibacterial activity of ZnO: surface defects mediated reactive oxygen species even in the dark Langmuir 31 33 2015 9155 9162 10.1021/acs.langmuir.5b02266 26222950
84 Yein W.T. Wang Q. Liu Y. Li Y. Jian J. Wu X. Piezo-potential induced molecular oxygen activation of defect-rich MoS2 ultrathin nanosheets for organic dye degradation in dark J. Environ. Chem. Eng. 8 1 2020 103626 10.1016/j.jece.2019.103626
85 Ji J. Yan Q. Yin P. Mine S. Matsuoka M. Xing M. Defects on CoS2-x: tuning redox reactions for sustainable degradation of organic pollutants Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 60 6 2021 2903 2908 10.1002/ange.202013015 33098249
86 Liu J. Yao Z. Qiu G. Wan Y. Song W. Zeng H. Yang F. Zhao D. Yuan W. Ju P. Lin R. Zhou H. Shi L. Hu K. Generation of reactive oxygen species through dissolved oxygen activation on defected porous carbon for efficient degradation of antibiotics Chem. Eng. J. 455 2023 140602 10.1016/j.cej.2022.140602
87 Zhao H. Qian L. Chen Y. Wang Q. Zhao G. Selective catalytic two-electron O2 reduction for onsite efficient oxidation reaction in heterogeneous electro-Fenton process Chem. Eng. J. 332 2018 486 498 10.1016/j.cej.2017.09.093
88 Xu H. Guo H. Chai C. Li N. Lin X. Xu W. Anodized graphite felt as an efficient cathode for in-situ hydrogen peroxide production and electro-Fenton degradation of rhodamine B Chemosphere 286 2022 131936 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.131936
89 Xu Y. Mao Z. Qu R. Wang J. Yu J. Luo X. Shi M. Mao X. Ding J. Liu B. Electrochemical hydrogenation of oxidized contaminants for water purification without supporting electrolyte Nat. Water 1 1 2023 95 103 10.1038/s44221-022-00002-3
90 Shen X. Xiao F. Zhao H. Chen Y. Fang C. Xiao R. Chu W. Zhao G. In situ-formed PdFe nanoalloy and carbon defects in cathode for synergic reduction–oxidation of chlorinated pollutants in electro-Fenton process Environ. Sci. Technol. 54 7 2020 4564 4572 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.9b05896 31977202
91 Jin L. Liu M. You S. Zhao H. Liu Y. Electrocatalytic membrane with p-block bismuth atoms for selective oxygen activation to hydroxyl radicals for effective water decontamination Appl. Catal. B Environ. 352 2024 124044 10.1016/j.apcatb.2024.124044
92 Wang Y. Chen J. Gao J. Meng H. Chai S. Jian Y. Shi L. Wang Y. He C. Selective electrochemical H2O2 generation on the graphene aerogel for efficient electro-Fenton degradation of ciprofloxacin Sep. Purif. Technol. 272 2021 118884 10.1016/j.seppur.2021.118884
93 Gu J. Xie J. Li S. Song G. Zhou M. Highly efficient electro-peroxone enhanced by oxygen-doped carbon nanotubes with triple role of in-situ H2O2 generation, activation and catalytic ozonation Chem. Eng. J. 452 2023 139597 10.1016/j.cej.2022.139597
94 Jin L. Duan X. Sun M. Vecitis C.D. Yu H. Liu Y. A general strategy to synthesize fluidic single atom electrodes for selective reactive oxygen species production ACS Nano 17 13 2023 12875 12883 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acsnano.3c04521 37358416
95 Yang L. Xu D. Luo X. Zhu X. Zhao J. Song J. Han Y. Li G. Gao X. Liu L. Fe (II)-modulated microporous electrocatalytic membranes for organic microcontaminant oxidation and fouling control: mechanisms of regulating electron transport toward enhanced reactive oxygen species activation Environ. Sci. Technol. 57 47 2023 19000 19011 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.3c01792 37162466
96 Feng Z. Chen M. Yang Q. Wang Z. Li L. Zhao H. Zhao G. New insights into selective singlet oxygen production via the typical electroactivation of oxygen for water decontamination Environ. Sci. Technol. 57 44 2023 17123 17131 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.3c06336 37875432
97 Yan N. Ren T. Lu K. Gao Y. Sun M. Huang X. Zhang X. Carbon-based electrocatalytic dual-membrane system bolsters singlet oxygen production for ultrafast water decontamination J. Hazard Mater. 463 2024 132787 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.132787
98 Bai X. Li Y. Xie L. Liu X. Zhan S. Hu W. A novel Fe-free photo-electro-Fenton-like system for enhanced ciprofloxacin degradation: bifunctional Z-scheme WO3/gC3N4 Environ. Sci.: Nano 6 9 2019 2850 2862 10.1039/C9EN00528E
99 Wang K. Mo Z. Tang S. Li M. Yang H. Long B. Wang Y. Song S. Tong Y. Photo-enhanced Zn–air batteries with simultaneous highly efficient in situ H2O2 generation for wastewater treatment J. Mater. Chem. A 7 23 2019 14129 14135 10.1039/C9TA04253A
100 Du X. Su P. Fu W. Zhang Q. Zhou M. Heterogeneous photoelectro-Fenton catalyzed by FeCu@PC for efficient degradation of sulfamethazine Electrochim. Acta 412 2022 140122 10.1016/j.electacta.2022.140122
101 Ye Z. Guelfi D.R.V. Álvarez G. Alcaide F. Brillas E. Sirés I. Enhanced electrocatalytic production of H2O2 at Co-based air-diffusion cathodes for the photoelectro-Fenton treatment of bronopol Appl. Catal. B Environ. 247 2019 191 199 10.1016/j.apcatb.2019.01.029
102 Pinheiro A.C.N. Bernardino T.S. Junior F.E.B. Lanza M.R.V. Barros W.R.P. Enhanced electrodegradation of the Sunset Yellow dye in acid media by heterogeneous photoelectro-Fenton process using Fe3O4 nanoparticles as a catalyst J. Environ. Chem. Eng. 8 1 2020 103621 10.1016/j.jece.2019.103621
103 Salmerón I. Plakas K.V. Sirés I. Oller I. Maldonado M.I. Karabelas A.J. Malato S. Optimization of electrocatalytic H2O2 production at pilot plant scale for solar-assisted water treatment Appl. Catal. B Environ. 242 2019 327 336 ttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.apcatb.2018.09.045
104 Yusuf T.L. Orimolade B.O. Masekela D. Mamba B. Mabuba N. The application of photoelectrocatalysis in the degradation of rhodamine B in aqueous solutions: a review RSC Adv. 12 40 2022 26176 26191 10.1039/D2RA04236C 36275103
105 Yu H. Xue Y. Lu Y. Wang X. Zhu S. Qin W. Huo M. Novel application of a Z-scheme photocatalyst of Ag3PO4@g-C3N4 for photocatalytic fuel cells J. Environ. Manag. 254 2020 109738 10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.109738
106 Peleyeju M.G. Arotiba O.A. Recent trend in visible-light photoelectrocatalytic systems for degradation of organic contaminants in water/wastewater Environ Sci-Wat Res 4 10 2018 1389 1411 10.1039/C8EW00276B
107 Ye F. Wang T. Quan X. Yu H. Chen S. Constructing efficient WO3-FPC system for photoelectrochemical H2O2 production and organic pollutants degradation Chem. Eng. J. 389 2020 123427 10.1016/j.cej.2019.123427
108 Kaushik R. Sharma K. Felix Siril P. Halder A. Design and investigation of photoelectrochemical water treatment using self-standing Fe3O4/NiCO2O4 photoanode: in-situ H2O2 generation and fenton-like activation Chem. Eng. J. 479 2024 147575 10.1016/j.cej.2023.147575
109 Sun Y. Han L. Strasser P. A comparative perspective of electrochemical and photochemical approaches for catalytic H2O2 production Chem. Soc. Rev. 49 18 2020 6605 6631 10.1039/D0CS00458H 32760937
110 Singh A. Sarma S.K. Karmakar S. Basu S. Photocatalytic H2O2 generation assisted photoelectrochemical water oxidation for enhanced BiVO4 photoanode performance CEJ advances 8 2021 100142 10.1016/j.ceja.2021.100142
111 Liang R. Wu H. Hu Z. Sun J. Fu C. Li S. Zhang X. Zhou M. Novel photoelectrocatalytic system of oxygen vacancy-rich black TiO2-x nanocones photoanode and natural air diffusion cathode for efficient water purification and simultaneous H2O2 production Appl. Catal. B Environ. 352 2024 124042 10.1016/j.apcatb.2024.124042
112 Zhang B. Li X. Ma Y. Jiang T. Zhu Y. Ren H. Visible-light photoelectrocatalysis/H2O2 synergistic degradation of organic pollutants by a magnetic Fe3O4@SiO2@ mesoporous TiO2 catalyst-loaded photoelectrode RSC Adv. 12 47 2022 30577 30587 10.1039/D2RA05183D 36337955
113 Dang Q. Zhang W. Liu J. Wang L. Wu D. Wang D. Lei Z. Tang L. Bias-free driven ion assisted photoelectrochemical system for sustainable wastewater treatment Nat. Commun. 14 1 2023 8413 10.1038/s41467-023-44155-5 38110421
114 Chen Q. Li J. Li X. Huang K. Zhou B. Shangguan W. Self-biasing photoelectrochemical cell for spontaneous overall water splitting under visible-light illumination ChemSusChem 6 7 2013 1276 1281 10.1002/cssc.201200936 23775929
115 Jeon T.H. Kim B. Kim C. Xia C. Wang H. Alvarez P.J.J. Choi W. Solar photoelectrochemical synthesis of electrolyte-free H2O2 aqueous solution without needing electrical bias and H2 Energy Environ. Sci. 14 5 2021 3110 3119 10.1039/D0EE03567J
116 Dong C. Yang Y. Hu X. Cho Y. Jang G. Ao Y. Wang L. Shen J. Park J.H. Zhang K. Self-cycled photo-Fenton-like system based on an artificial leaf with a solar-to-H2O2 conversion efficiency of 1.46 Nat. Commun. 13 1 2022 4982 10.1038/s41467-022-32410-0 36008378
117 Sharma M. Jalalah M. Alsareii S.A. Harraz F.A. Xue W. Thakur N. Salama E.-S. Li X. Microalgal cycling in the cathode of microbial fuel cells (MFCs) induced oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and electricity: a biocatalytic process for clean energy Chem. Eng. J. 479 2024 147431 10.1016/j.cej.2023.147431
118 Wang D. Hu J. Liu B. Hou H. Yang J. Li Y. Zhu Y. liang S. Xiao K. Degradation of refractory organics in dual-cathode electro-Fenton using air-cathode for H2O2 electrogeneration and microbial fuel cell cathode for Fe2+ regeneration J. Hazard Mater. 412 2021 125269 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2021.125269
119 Bhaduri S. Behera M. From single-chamber to multi-anodic microbial fuel cells: a review J. Environ. Manag. 355 2024 120465 10.1016/j.jenvman.2024.120465
120 Logan B.E. Hamelers B. Rozendal R. Schröder U. Keller J. Freguia S. Aelterman P. Verstraete W. Rabaey K. Microbial fuel cells: methodology and technology Environ. Sci. Technol. 40 17 2006 5181 5192 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es0605016 16999087
121 Yong X.-Y. Gu D.-Y. Wu Y.-D. Yan Z.-Y. Zhou J. Wu X.-Y. Wei P. Jia H.-H. Zheng T. Yong Y.-C. Bio-electron-Fenton (BEF) process driven by microbial fuel cells for triphenyltin chloride (TPTC) degradation J. Hazard Mater. 324 2017 178 183 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2016.10.047 28340989
122 Soltani F. Navidjouy N. Khorsandi H. Rahimnejad M. Alizadeh S. A novel bio-electro-Fenton system with dual application for the catalytic degradation of tetracycline antibiotic in wastewater and bioelectricity generation RSC Adv. 11 44 2021 27160 27173 10.1039/d1ra04584a 35480664
123 Wang W. Lu Y. Luo H. Liu G. Zhang R. Jin S. A microbial electro-fenton cell for removing carbamazepine in wastewater with electricity output Water Res. 139 2018 58 65 10.1016/j.watres.2018.03.066 29626730
124 Rafaqat S. Arshad F. Shahid R. Ali N. Employing the cost-effective composite cathodes for bio-Fenton facilitated degradation of acid red 114 integrated into hydrogen peroxide synthesizing microbial fuel cell Electrochim. Acta 487 2024 144141 10.1016/j.electacta.2024.144141
125 Xue S. Zhang Y. Marhaba T. Zhang W. Aeration and dissolution behavior of oxygen nanobubbles in water J. Colloid Interface Sci. 609 2022 584 591 10.1016/j.jcis.2021.11.061 34815086
126 Wang L. Ali J. Wang Z. Oladoja N.A. Cheng R. Zhang C. Mailhot G. Pan G. Oxygen nanobubbles enhanced photodegradation of oxytetracycline under visible light: synergistic effect and mechanism Chem. Eng. J. 388 2020 124227 10.1016/j.cej.2020.124227
127 Wang B. Wang L. Cen W. Lyu T. Jarvis P. Zhang Y. Zhang Y. Han Y. Wang L. Pan G. Zhang K. Fan W. Exploring a chemical input free advanced oxidation process based on nanobubble technology to treat organic micropollutants Environ. Pollut. 340 Pt 1 2024 122877 10.1016/j.envpol.2023.122877
128 Ghadimkhani A. Zhang W. Marhaba T. Ceramic membrane defouling (cleaning) by air nano bubbles Chemosphere 146 2016 379 384 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2015.12.023 26741542
129 Panizza M. Oturan M.A. Degradation of Alizarin Red by electro-Fenton process using a graphite-felt cathode Electrochim. Acta 56 20 2011 7084 7087 10.1016/j.electacta.2011.05.105
130 Petrucci E. Da Pozzo A. Di Palma L. On the ability to electrogenerate hydrogen peroxide and to regenerate ferrous ions of three selected carbon-based cathodes for electro-Fenton processes Chem. Eng. J. 283 2016 750 758 10.1016/j.cej.2015.08.030
131 Liu M. Xing Z. Zhao H. Song S. Wang Y. Li Z. Zhou W. An efficient photo-Fenton system for in-situ evolution of H2O2 via defective iron-based metal organic framework@ZnIn2S4 core-shell Z-scheme heterojunction nanoreactor J. Hazard Mater. 437 2022 129436 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2022.129436
132 Yang W. Sun K. Wan J. Ma Y.-A. Liu J. Zhu B. Liu L. Fu F. Boosting holes generation and O2 activation by bifunctional NiCoP modified Bi4O5Br2 for efficient photocatalytic aerobic oxidation Appl. Catal. B Environ. 320 2023 121978 10.1016/j.apcatb.2022.121978
133 Nosaka Y. Nosaka A.Y. Generation and detection of reactive oxygen species in photocatalysis Chem. Rev. 117 17 2017 11302 11336 10.1021/acs.chemrev.7b00161 28777548
134 Li Q. Li F.T. Recent advances in molecular oxygen activation via photocatalysis and its application in oxidation reactions Chem. Eng. J. 421 2021 129915 10.1016/j.cej.2021.129915
135 Di J. Xia J. Ji M. Wang B. Li X. Zhang Q. Chen Z. Li H. Nitrogen-doped carbon quantum dots/BiOBr ultrathin nanosheets: in situ strong coupling and improved molecular oxygen activation ability under visible light irradiation ACS Sustainable Chem. Eng. 4 1 2016 136 146 https://doi/10.1021/acssuschemeng.5b00862
136 Liou Y.-F. Wei L.W. Chen C. Liu S.H. Pu Y.C. Wang H.P. Photocatalytic splitting of H2O-to-H2O2 by BiOI/g-C3N4/CoP S-scheme heterojunctions New J. Chem. 47 4 2023 1825 1831 10.1039/D2NJ04216A
137 Wang Y. Lin Y. He S. Wu S. Yang C. Singlet oxygen: properties, generation, detection, and environmental applications J. Hazard Mater. 461 2024 132538 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.132538
138 Rayaroth M.P. Aravind U.K. Boczkaj G. Aravindakumar C.T. Singlet oxygen in the removal of organic pollutants: an updated review on the degradation pathways based on mass spectrometry and DFT calculations Chemosphere 345 2023 140203 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2023.140203
139 DeRosa M.C. Crutchley R.J. Photosensitized singlet oxygen and its applications Coord. Chem. Rev. 233 2002 351 371 10.1016/S0010-8545(02)00034-6
140 Kearns D.R. Physical and chemical properties of singlet molecular oxygen Chem. Rev. 71 4 1971 395 427 10.1021/cr60272a004
141 Chakraborty J. Nath I. Verpoort F. A physicochemical introspection of porous organic polymer photocatalysts for wastewater treatment Chem. Soc. Rev. 51 3 2022 1124 1138 10.1039/D1CS00916H 35037675
