
==== Front
Heliyon
Heliyon
Heliyon
2405-8440
Elsevier

S2405-8440(24)12841-1
10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e36810
e36810
Review Article
A review on template-assisted approaches & self assembly of nanomaterials at liquid/liquid interface
Gangwar Nisha a
Gangwar Chinky ab
Sarkar Joy dr.joysarkar4@gmail.com
a⁎
a Department of Chemistry, University of Lucknow, Lucknow, 226007, U.P., India
b Department of Chemistry, B.S.N.V.P.G. College (KKV), Lucknow, 226001, U.P., India
⁎ Corresponding author. dr.joysarkar4@gmail.com
23 8 2024
15 9 2024
23 8 2024
10 17 e3681024 3 2024
9 8 2024
22 8 2024
© 2024 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd.
2024

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/).
In recent times, nanomaterials (NMs) have gained significant attention for their unique properties and wide-ranging applications. This increased interest has driven research aimed at developing more efficient synthetic approaches in the fields of material science. Moreover, today's increasing demand for materials underscores the need for innovative technologies that can effectively scale up production to meet these growing needs. Hence, this review is primarily delve deeply into the template-assisted method i.e., an advance bottom-up approach for NMs synthesis. Furthermore, this review emphasizes to explore the advancements in soft template-based synthetic strategies for nanostructured materials as it provides high control on morphology and size. Therefore, this review specifically organized around on providing an in-depth discussion of the liquid/liquid interface-assisted soft template method, applications, and the factors affecting liquid/liquid interface for NMs synthesis. These key points are instrumental in driving advancements, highlighting the ongoing need for further enhancement and refinement of smart technologies. Finally, we conclude the review by describing the challenges and future perspectives of the liquid/liquid-assisted approach for NMs designing.

Graphical abstract

Image 1

Highlights

• Synthesis of nanomaterials (NMs) with controlled morphology.

• Template-assisted synthesis i.e., hard and soft.

• NMs formation at liquid/liquid interface.

• Involvement in self-assembly and interfacial chemistry.

Keywords

Hard template
Soft template
Liquid/liquid interface
Nanomaterials designing
Self-assembly
==== Body
pmc1 Introduction

The growth of urbanization, industrialization, and population directly contributes to heightened pollution levels, significantly impacting both our environment and public health. Concerned about these issues and the applications of nanomaterials (NMs), researchers have frequently focussed on published research reports in the field of material science and nanotechnology as an efficient and sustainable solutions. In the past decade, advancements in nanoscience provided a promising solutions by representing NMs having distinguished quantum size, macroscopic tunnelling, dielectric confinement, surface and volume factors [1]. However, it is difficult to say that the synthesized NMs are ready to be used without processing the materials to make the specific property for applications useful for mankind. It is also well known that the applications of any NMs depend on the close relation between synthesized NMs, their structural features and properties. The synthesis of these cutting-edge materials or NMs have a plethora of applications in various fields (sensor, catalyst, drug delivery, device fabrication, environmental remediation such as wastewater treatment, etc.) [2,3]. NMs are materials that lie in the nanoscale range between 1 and 1000 nm. NMs beautifully show unique physiochemical properties controlled by different parameters like size, morphology, dimensionality, etc [4,5]. These remarkable characteristics of NMs make them unique over bulk materials. Consequently, researchers are not only concentrating on applications but they are also working on modifying the approaches for NMs synthesis to enhance the physiochemical properties for better results. In general, NMs are synthesized by two approaches i.e., top-down and bottom-up. The top-down approaches are focused on the macroscopic or large particles, reduced to nano-sized materials. It comprises physical processes like mechanical grinding, electron beam lithography, ball milling, vapor phase synthesis, spray pyrolysis, inert gas condensation, discharge method, etc [[6], [7], [8]]. The chief downsides of these methods are that they are expensive and comprise substantial setups. The approach is based on the grinding of materials. While bottom-up approaches emphasize the principle of molecular recognition (i.e., self-assembly) that involves the miniaturizing of materials components to the atomic level [9]. The self-assembly is defined by the spontaneous gathering of small particles changes into stable novel NMs with distinct morphology. The forces responsible for self-assembly are hydrogen bonding, hydrophilic/hydrophobic interactions, van der Waals, magnetic, electrostatic, and surface organic molecular forces [[10], [11], [12]]. Bottom-up approach involves chemical processes like a sol-gel, solvothermal, sonochemical, and biological methods (such as plant-based extract, microorganisms, enzymes, biomolecules) etc [7,13]. It is a cost-effective and readily controlled process for the high-yield targeting products as compared to top-down approaches. However, the drawback of this approach is that it needs multifaceted experimental steps that restrict its applications to simple NMs [14]. It further sub-classified into three categories i.e., template-based, solution-based, and vapor-based method [15]. As this review is primarily focused on the sequential key points of the current discussion, our objective is to delve deeply into the template-assisted method i.e., an advance bottom-up approach for NMs synthesis. Nowadays, template-assisted methods for NMs synthesis are an emerging field for researchers. It entails employing scaffolds or templates on the nanoscale level to direct the assembly or growth of NMs. These methods enable precise control over the morphology, dimensions, composition, and enhanced properties of NMs [[16], [17], [18], [19]]. Also, NMs with specific properties can be tailored by manipulating the template structure and deposition step. The tailored NMs are suitable for multipurpose applications in the field of biosensing, catalysis, electronics, and biomedicines. These methods for NMs synthesis are classified into hard and soft template approaches [15,20]. Hard template is a rigid material, whose stable structure directly dictates the size and morphology of sample particle. While, the soft template possess non-rigid structural features. For the fabrication of NMs, different types of templates are used but the removal of the template after the production of NMs is a complex process, and many times the structure of synthesized NMs is disturbed in this process. Dong et al. mentioned that several characteristics of hard template method pose a barrier to its efficient use include their considerably less controllable pore size, the irresistible nucleation that occurs outside the pore leads to a lower yield, and complex processes with high costs [21,22]. For better understanding, it is crucial to grasp the fundamentals of hard and soft template approaches and deeper discussion of them are mentioned in forthcoming sections. Poolakkandy et al. reported that soft-template-assisted synthesis provides high control on morphology and size of the synthesized NMs [15]. Therefore, considering the advantages of the soft template method, our focus is to review and explore its applications in the upcoming discussion. Various interfaces such as solid/liquid (S/L), gas/solid (G/S), liquid/liquid (L/L), and gas/liquid (G/L) are utilized as templates in NMs synthesis. However, it is important to consider the limitations associated with each interface when employing them as templates. Huhn et al. highlighted challenges such as limited control over morphology and difficulties in template removal when employing the solid/liquid interface as a template [23]. Nuruzzaman et al. reported that using the solid/gas interface as a template presents challenges such as limited control over morphology, along with specific conditions required for gas-phase interactions to maintain template stability and achieve desired NMs properties [24]. In 2007, Ariga et al. noted that the gas/liquid interface presents restrictions, as direct interaction between gas-phase species and template materials can hinder precise control over NMs assembly and properties. Additionally, achieving uniform and well-defined NMs structures can be challenging due to the limited templating influence [25]. To overcome these limitations, among different synthesis methods, L/L interface-assisted method as a soft template is the most leading, effective, and efficient in comparison with G/L, G/S, and S/L interfaces [26,27]. This method depends on the interface developed between the two immiscible solvents that's why it is known as the L/L interface-assisted method. The beauty of this method is that it provides the freedom to choose different solvents without any removal of the template with a simple synthesis procedure and is economically favoured. It is exciting to know that synthesized NMs by this method are present in technologies such as electrocatalysis, removal of heavy metal and dye degradation from wastewater, electrochromism, sensing & device fabrication, biological activities supercapacitor, etc., [28,29]. In this review, our objective is to explore the advancements in soft template-based synthetic strategies for nanostructured materials. Therefore, this review specifically organized around on providing an in-depth discussion of the liquid/liquid interface-assisted soft template method, applications, and the factors affecting L/L interface for NMs synthesis. To understand the fundamentals and advancements of the L/L interface-assisted method as a soft template, this review starts with a basic description of the templated-assisted approaches for nanomaterials synthesis (Section 2) which are subdivided into different classes i.e., hard and soft template methods. In the next section, we will understand the details of the L/L interface-assisted method through some reported examples and general mechanisms including basic knowledge of the G/L interface, G/S interface, and S/L interface. Hopefully, this review will help to gain more knowledge about the advanced bottom-up approach i.e., L/L interface-assisted method as a soft template for the fabrication of complicated nanomaterials without any complex process to inspire innovative progress and captivating area of research in nanoscience and nanotechnology for mankind.

2 Template-assisted approaches for nanomaterials synthesis

Over the last two decades, significant strides have been made in developing synthetic strategies for NMs with precise control over size, shape, composition, and spatial arrangement. “Template” is the main component in template-assisted synthesis. It is an entity having nanostructured characteristics and the properties of synthesized NMs depend on the size, morphology, and charge distribution of the template [[30], [31], [32]]. It follows the three steps i.e., template preparation, synthesis of NMs by utilizing a template, and removal of a template (if required), respectively [33]. In the realm of NMs synthesis, a template is fundamentally a material characterized by nanostructured features and hence there exists a wide array of materials that can be considered. These include naturally occurring substances as well as synthetic nanostructures derived from established synthesis methods. The physical and chemical properties of NMs can vary significantly depending on the type of template used in their synthesis [34]. The fabrication of the desired product can be done by chemical (organic reactions i.e., addition, substitution, elimination, etc.) or physical methods like channel replication and surface coating. Likewise, the removal of a template can be done by chemical or physical methods i.e., calcination and dissolution, respectively [35]. By this method, synthesized NMs are achieved with controlled morphology, shape, and dimension. Based on the template types, the template-assisted approaches can be classified as hard and soft template methods.

2.1 Hard template method

The hard template method is a nanocasting method in which solid porous materials are used as a solid mold. These solid molds have a suitable size, shape, and inside porosity in which liquid materials are allowed to be set for molded structure. These molds are filled with precursor molecules and removed after the formation of the desired nanomaterial without affecting the properties as shown in Fig. 1 [[36], [37], [38]]. It is mostly inorganic and silica-based materials which is widely used as a template. Other than silica, polymer microspheres like polystyrene-acrylate (PSA), etc., porous membranes, mesoporous carbon, porous anodic aluminium oxide (AAO), ion exchange resin, etc., is used as a hard template for NMs synthesis because of their restricted particle size and distinct structures [[39], [40], [41], [42]]. While synthesizing NMs via hard template method it is necessary to consider some important factors i.e., the precursor should be chemically unreactive with the template so judicious selection of precursor and the template is important. The strong interaction leads to the pore blocking of hard template and hence strong interaction between the precursor and hard template should be avoided. For easy diffusion of the precursor into the mesoporous hard template solvent selection is important. To avoid the collapsed structure of desired product after removal of the template a sufficient amount of precursor is necessary [43]. Although the hard template method for NMs synthesis is an outstanding approach for crystalline oxides. However, several characteristics that pose a barrier to its efficient use include their considerably less controllable pore size, the irresistible nucleation that occurs outside the pore and results in a lower yield, and complex processes with high costs [21,22]. The drawback of this method is that at the time of template removal, it may cause damage to NMs structure because of using harsh conditions like etching by HF, etc.Fig. 1 Pictorial representation of the synthesis of nanostructure using hard templates.

Fig. 1

2.2 Soft template method

In the soft template method, the flexible nanostructures are used as a soft template, formed by intermolecular interaction by weak non-covalent bonds (electrostatic interaction and hydrogen bonding) between the precursors and soft templates as shown in Fig. 2. Unlike the hard template, soft template approaches are generally based on organic materials i.e., soft materials, containing surfactants, flexible organic molecules, block copolymers, interfaces, and so forth are used as soft templates [[42], [43], [44], [45]]. Typically, for the synthesis of NMs co-precipitation, hydrothermal, and sol-gel processes are frequently used as a soft templating methodology but nowadays interface assisted synthesis is also a popular area of research. Similarly, for removing template calcination and solvent extraction are used frequently [2,46,47]. Since the liquid/liquid (L/L) interface-assisted approach as a soft template for the synthesis of NMs is the main theme of the present review. The template preparation is an initial step of NMs synthesis with a soft template which consists of surfactant self-assembly leading to the formation of micelle or liquid crystal. The second step leads to the formation of an inorganic-organic hybrid by adding an inorganic precursor to surfactant self-assembly. At last removal of organic template takes place [48,49].Fig. 2 Pictorial representation of the synthesis of nanostructure using Soft templates.

Fig. 2

In general soft template-assisted synthesis of nanomaterials follows three mechanisms i.e., cooperative self-assembly (CSA), true crystal liquid templating (TCLT), and evaporation-induced self-assembly (EISA), shown in Fig. 3 [15]. In the CSA mechanism, low concentrations of surfactant are used which leads to the formation of micelle by the assembly of precursors and templates that occur synchronously in various reactions. This step is known as “cooperative assembly”. In the end, desired nanomaterials are obtained by developing a liquid crystal phase that is precipitated by the solution [46]. TLCT mechanism depends on the high concentration of surfactant. In the absence of precursors, the liquid crystal phase is developed and then the precursor is combined with that liquid crystal phase [42,46]. The EISA mechanism follows three steps first is the preparation of a dilute solution of precursors, template, and volatile solvent with appropriate stoichiometry. The second one is a distribution of prepared solution in a huge area to achieve critical micelle concentration (CMC) by solvent evaporation and the last one is a condensation process of precursors near the liquid crystal phase which developed the final product [[50], [51], [52]].Fig. 3 General mechanistic steps for soft template-assisted synthesis of nanomaterials via Cooperative self-assembly (CSA), True crystal liquid templating (TCLT), and Evaporation-induced self-assembly (EISA) [15].

Fig. 3

After the synthesis of nanomaterials, the soft template removal takes place through different processes like combustion or depolymerization via thermal treatment or calcination, low-temperature chemical treatment, etc. without affecting the morphology and properties of nanomaterials [53]. In contrast to the hard template method, soft templates are gaining more popularity due to their inexpensive cost and ease of synthesis sometimes without the necessity for a time-consuming procedure to remove the template [54]. A comparison between hard and soft template method is shown in Table 1.Table 1 Comparative study of hard and soft template method for nanomaterial synthesis.

Table 1Hard Template Method	Soft Template Method	
Mainly inorganic-based materials like silica, polymer microspheres, porous membranes, mesoporous carbon, AAO, ion exchange resin, etc., are used as hard templates.	Mainly organic-based, surfactant, block copolymers, flexible organic molecules, and interfaces are used as soft templates.	
By nanocasting process and mesoporous template.	The mechanism follows cooperative self-assembly, True crystal liquid templating, and evaporation-induced self-assembly.	
Complex synthesis steps.	Synthesis is done in a few steps.	
Template removal by etching using HF, and high-temperature calcination may cause the damage of nanostructure morphology.	Template removal by low-temperature heat treatment, combustion, or depolymerization. Sometimes no need to remove the template so maintain the morphology of synthesized nanomaterials.	
Less controllable pore size, and fixed morphology because of the preformed structure of hard template.	Controllable morphology, tunable pore structure, and properties of synthesized nanomaterials.	
Expensive and time-consuming method.	Less expensive and less time-consuming procedure for template removal.	

The comparative study of hard and soft template approaches shows that the soft template method is a more promising approach for NMs synthesis. It generally avoids complex reaction procedures and is easy to handle. The main aim of this review is to focus on the synthesis of NMs by soft templates i.e., liquid/liquid interface assisted as a soft template. Also, review the fact that the liquid/liquid (L/L) interface-assisted approach for nanomaterials fabrication are more emerging and efficient approach than other interface-assisted synthesis pathways of soft template methods. But to know about the L/L interface-assisted approach it is necessary to gain a little bit of knowledge about other interface-assisted approaches as a soft template for the synthesis of NMs.

3 Synthesis of nanomaterials with interface assisted as soft template

To assemble NMs based on the interfacial assembly is an elegant approach. The interface is something related to the phase boundary between two substances or solvents and the thickness of this interphase ranges from some angstroms to nanometres and even micrometres scale. In material science, the interface is more dynamic at phase boundaries of multi-reactions than the bulk phase [26,55]. The interface forms a unique non-equilibrium atmosphere with improved surface energy for the self-assembly of starting material to start the nucleation, leading to the formation of intermediates at the interface of two phases for the generation of desired nanomaterials [26]. The interfaces as a soft template including in NMs synthesis are gas/liquid, liquid/liquid, gas/solid, and solid/liquid, as shown in Fig. 4 [56,57]. Some reported synthesized NMs by gas/liquid, gas/solid, and solid/liquid interface-assisted approaches are shown in Table 2.Fig. 4 Diagrammatic presentation of different interfaces for nanomaterial synthesis, comprising gas/liquid, liquid/liquid, gas/solid, and liquid/solid interfaces [26].

Fig. 4

Table 2 Synthesized nanomaterials via solid/liquid, gas/liquid, and gas/solid interface-assisted approach.

Table 2Interfaces Used	Nanostructures	Morphology	Application	Reference	
Solid/Liquid	CeO2/Cu2O	Nanocomposite	Catalytic activity for CO oxidation.	[76]	
Fe3O4/Fe(OH)3	Flower-like nanocomposite	Nanocatalyst for the cycloaddition reaction of CO2 and epoxides.	[77]	
CeO2	Nanotube	A catalyst for CO oxidation.	[78]	
CuO	Nanorod	Photocatalytic degradation of RhB.	[79]	
Co3O4	Mesoporous nanoparticle	Electrochemical capacitive behavior.	[80]	
Gas/Liquid	NiO	Flower like-hollow nanosphere	Proposing excellent supercapacitor potentials.	[81]	
Ag-MnOOH-GO	Nanocomposite	Electrochemical sensing has a good property to catalyze H2O2.	[82]	
Pt NWN	Nanowire network sheet	Used in electrocatalytic reactions i.e. ORR and HER, capable of developing next-generation electrocatalysts.	[83]	
Cu(OH)2/Au/SiO2	Ordered nanoarray composite	For detection of trace gaseous VOCs (Volatile organic compounds).	[84]	
Janus Nanographene Oxide	2D lamellar-like nanostructure	Enhancing foam stability in high-temperature reservoirs.	[85]	
Quasi 2D Polyaniline (PANI)	Thin Film (2.6–30 nm)	Good chemical vapor sensing ability.	[86]	
Ag/WO3/rGO	Nanocomposite	H2S gas sensor	[87]	
Fe3O4	Nanorod	For the photodegradation of phenol as a catalytic carrier.	[88]	
SnO2/rGO	Nanocomposite	Sensing of NO2.	[89]	
Gas/Solid	Fluorine-doped carbon nanosphere (FPHCs)	Hierarchical porous hollow nanosphere	Suitable for sustainable energy applications.	[90]	
Pt NWs	Nanowires	Active catalysts toward ORR.	[91]	
Cu2S	Tree-like nanostructure	Suggested potential for 1D functional nanosystems.	[92]	
AlN	Hollow nanosphere	Suggested applications as potential high-temperature structural materials.	[93]	

3.1 Solid/liquid (S/L) interface assisted synthesis of nanomaterials

The solid/liquid interface assisted synthesis is more suitable for the polymer nanomaterials or functional mesoporous materials with tuned morphology without any destruction in the morphology of the product. It is generally based on the evaporation-induced self-assembly mechanism (EISA). In this method, an ingredient is dissolved in the liquid phase, and the solid phase acts as a template as well as a precursor or reaction field [56,[58], [59], [60]]. In many research articles ice surfaces, solvent crystals, salts, graphene, metal templates, cellulose, paper, and glasses, etc. are reported as solid templates in S/L interface for nanomaterials fabrication (as shown in Table 2) [56,[61], [62], [63], [64], [65], [66], [67], [68]].

3.2 Gas/liquid (G/L) interface synthesis of nanomaterials

The gas/liquid interface synthesis follows the general mechanism of evaporation of the organic solvent in which the hydrophilic substrate is taken in an aqueous surface surrounded with a small amount of organic solution of a hydrophobic substrate. The G/L interface is formed after the evaporation of the organic solvent [69]. This method is broadly used in the synthesis of metal-organic framework (MOF) nanomaterials [70]. It provides room for the synthesis of thin nanostructures up to 0.6 nm because the precursor cannot be delivered from the gas side [71]. Although this method is suitable for nanomaterials consisting of hydrophilic and hydrophobic substrates the major drawback of this method is for large-yield production it needs a large G/L interface (as shown in Table 2) [27].

3.3 Gas/solid (G/S) interface synthesis of nanomaterials

The main methodology used in solid/gas-assisted method is a chemical vapor deposition (CVD), vapor phase transport (VPT), and physical vapor deposition (PVD) for the synthesis of nanomaterials [27,72,73]. The CVD is a very common method utilized, in which the gaseous component is diffused at the surface of the substrate by adsorption i.e. solid/gas interface. This interface results in the formation of nucleation, growth, and combination, and the desired nanoproduct is formed with the bi-product. Later, gaseous products and unreactive components are desorbed from the surface and removed (as shown in Table 2) [27,74,75].

Among all mentioned interface synthesis approaches the liquid/liquid interface as a soft template method for the miniaturization of materials is a piqued and emerging field for researchers nowadays. It is a flexible method of synthesis for tuned nanomaterials with modified morphologies. The detailed views about this method are discussed in section 4.

4 Synthesis of nanomaterials with liquid/liquid (L/L) interface as a soft template

The fundamentals of the L/L interface-assisted method are based on the self-assembly of solid NMs at the interface of the two immiscible liquids. Examples of two immiscible solvents used for chemical reactions include chloroform/water, DCE (dichloroethane)/water, DCM (dichloromethane)/water, toluene/water, n-hexane/water, etc., are more pronounced [29,94]. In this process, the precursor should be dissolved in one of the two solvents, coordinating and reducing agent in another solvent. It is a widely used method for the fabrication of metal-organic frameworks and polymer NMs [26,95]. The general mechanism for liquid/liquid interface-assisted synthesis is shown in Fig. 5. The liquid-liquid interface-assisted method offers opportunities for synthesizing NMs with controlled thickness, morphology, uniformity, and transparency under appropriate reaction conditions, using a straightforward and practical approaches [29].Fig. 5 Schematic diagram of the methodology for L/L interface-assisted synthesis of NMs.

Fig. 5

Before delving into specific examples, it's crucial to understand the fundamental principles of this approach. The question arises: why do solid particles assemble at the interface of solvents? This phenomenon is driven by interfacial energies and the minimization of interfacial area. Immiscible solvents exhibit distinct intermolecular forces and do not blend at a molecular level. At their interface, there exists notable interfacial tension owing to the disparity in cohesive energies between the two solvents. Solid particles can lower this tension by adsorbing at the interface, where they can partially shield the solvent-solvent interactions. Also, the accumulation of solid particles at the interface reduces the free energy of the system. This happens because the particles move to locations where they minimize the exposed surface area between the two immiscible phases, thereby lowering the associated free energy of the system. Hence, these solid particles tends to minimize the high energy of the L/L interface and decrease the interfacial area, thereby immigrate at the interface which is thermodynamically favoured [96,97]. Due to numerous parameters such as particle size, roughness factor, chemical and surface composition, shape, etc., which influence this process, achieving optimized reaction conditions is crucial in experiments [29,98,99]. The effective interaction between solid particles is dependent on factors such as the nature of the interface, size, shape, and chemical composition of the particles. Under favourable conditions, the accumulation and interaction of solid particles are stable. Moshrefi et al. described a copper nanoparticle-based flexible electrocatalytic composite electrode material at the micro interface between two immiscible electrolyte solutions (ITIES). This setup was used for the simultaneous electropolymerization of 2,2′:5′,2″-terthiophene (TT) and reduction of copper(II) ions, demonstrating a promising approach for generating electrocatalytic materials for carbon capture [100]. A facile method of using green solvents, low catalyst loading, high yields, short reaction times, and the ability to reuse the catalyst was reported by Hoseini in 2014. This study demonstrated the synthesis of palladium nanoparticles by reduction of an organopalladium(II) complex at the oil–water interface and it has been found that the product have high potential for catalysing the reaction of aryl chloride derivatives [101]. Yao reported a method for single-crystal silver nanosheets at room temperature via a chloroform-water interfacial reaction route with o-ethoxyaniline (OEA) in chloroform as reductant. A remarkable SERS (surface-enhanced Raman scattering) response and high reproducibility was observed [102]. A novel approach for molybdenum disulphide synthesis at the liquid–liquid interface was demonstrated by Higgins in 2019 for scaleup the 2D materials [103]. A gold-silver alloy preparation method with poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) in hexane/water interface was introduced by Puthiyottil in 2023 and this study proved a non-enzymatic electrochemical detection of histamine [104]. Liu prepared a cobalt based metal organic framework nanosheets using liquid/liquid interface as an electrode for high-performance asymmetric supercapacitor [105]. Table 3 provides detailed data on the synthesis at the liquid-liquid interface and their applications. This study demonstrates that nanomaterials produced by this method are sufficiently stable and potentially effective for diverse applications in the current scenario. These investigations also revealed good control on morphology and size of the NMs by adjusting the conditions at the interface. However, under unfavourable conditions, the particles may precipitate at the liquid-liquid interface or agglomerate [29,106]. There is no need for struggling with the removal of templates after synthesizing NMs using this method. It can produce nanomaterials in large quantities due to efficient nucleation and growth at the interface. Therefore, it is typically scalable and can be adapted for large-scale synthesis without major modifications, provided there is stability in the liquid-liquid interface. For bulky production, parallel laminar flow in a microflow reactor may be suitable due to their sufficiently small channels to ensure the solution is stable flow [107,108]. This method required environmentally friendly solvents and reduces the production of hazardous waste compared to other methods, thereby enhancing its sustainability for future applications. Also, the liquid/liquid interface provides a straightforward method for functionalizing and modifying nanomaterial surfaces, thereby improving their stability and functionality. From Table 3, it is clear that this method supports the synthesis of a wide range of NMs, including metals, metal oxides, and composites, which are suitable for multipurpose applications.Table 3 List of recently synthesized nanomaterials via liquid/liquid interface method with their applications.

Table 3Nanostructures	Interfaces used as soft-template	Morphology	Application	Reference	
PSS-free PEDOT	Chloroform/Water	Nanocomposite	Electrochromism
Applications.	[109]	
PPy/MnO2	Chloroform/Water	Nanosheet	Electrochemical sensor for nicotine.	[110]	
PEDOT/graphene	Chloroform/Water	Nanocomposite	Electrochromism
Applications.	[109]	
ZnO	Water/Air	Nanosheet	Sensing and device fabrication.	[111]	
Nickle Hydroxide	n-Butanol/Water	Nanoflakes	Non-enzymatic electrochemical sensor to detect glutamic acid.	[112]	
CuO	n-Octanol/Water	Hollow Nanosphere	Surface photovoltage properties and photocatalytic activity.	[113]	
Fe2O3	Benzene/Water	Durian-like hollow sphere	Removal of heavy metal ion Cr(VI).	[114]	
NiCo2O4	n-Butanol/Water	Nanoflake	Electrochemical detection of dopamine.	[115]	
MnO/MnO2	DMF/Water	Nanoparticle, Microbar, Nanoflake	Applications in lithium-ion batteries.	[116]	
PPy/Ag	Chloroform/Water	Nanosheet	H2O2 sensing and antibacterial activity.	[117]	
Fe2O3	Toluene/Water	Cauliflower-like	Organic dye degradation and heavy metal ions removal in water treatment, photocatalytic degradation in the presence of H2O2 for rhodamine B.	[118]	
MnO/MnO2	DCM/Water	Urchin-like	Catalytic degradation of methylene blue.	[119]	
Au nanoring arrays	Oil/Water	Nanoring	–	[120]	
PT/Au	n-Hexane/Water	Nanocomposite thin film	Electrochromic applications.	[121]	
Sulfonated Graphene/Polyaniline	Chloroform/Water	Nanocomposite	Electrochemical measurements for use in energy storage and conversion devices.	[122]	
Pure FeNPs	Toluene/Water	Spherical nanoparticle	Show superparamagnetic properties for biomedical and industrial applications.	[123]	
AgNBs	RAIL(redox-active ionic liquid) ([FcMDDA+]
[TFPB−])/Water	Chain like-Nanobelt	Substrate for plasmonic applications.	[124]	
PdNFAs	RAIL/Water	Vertically aligned nanofibre arrays	Electrocatalytic activity towards ethanol oxidation reaction.	[125]	
Bis(dipyrrinato) zinc(II) complex	dichloromethane/pyridine (100:1) solution/Water	Nanosheet	–	[126]	
MoO3
MoS2
MoSe2	Toluene/Water	Nanobelt	Illustrated for electrochemical applications.	[127]	
Nanosheets	
PT/Au-NPs/CNT	n-Hexane/Water	Nanocomposite	Electrochemical sensor for dopamine.	[128]	

4.1 Reaction occurred at liquid/liquid interface assisted method

The reaction occurring at the interface of two immiscible liquids have been extensively studied. These reactions exhibit behaviour distinct from those in the bulk phase, largely driven by the unique characteristics of this region. Reduction, precipitation, polymerization, and complexation reactions were typically observed to occur at the interface of two immiscible liquids. These can be easily understood by examining examples of nanomaterials fabrication in recent years. Johans et al. synthesized the polyphenylpyrrole-coated silver nanospheroids of 3–20 nm size via electrochemical reduction at the liquid-liquid interface. In this process, silver metal ions were transferred from the aqueous phase to the organic phase. Subsequently, a slow homogeneous electron transfer reaction occurred from N-phenylpyrrole to the silver ion, followed by polymerization and growth of the metal clusters [129]. A novel method involves using a liquid-liquid interfacial reaction to produce noble metal palladium nanoparticles at the interface between 1,2-dichloroethane and water was also introduced by Lee in 2009 for studying the growth kinetics of the formation. The study concluded that the reaction was initiated by the reduction of ammonium tetrachloropalladate salt, resulting in the formation of palladium nanoparticles with sizes ranging from 50 to 100 nm [130]. Likewise, oxidation at the liquid-liquid interface are employed for NMs fabrication. In this, oxidation of precursor molecules or ions present in one phase by oxidizing agents present in the other phase occurred. Kelgenbaeva et al. proposed a method for synthesizing superparamagnetic hematite nanoparticles of approx. 10 nm size using liquid/liquid interface method in which water and toluene were taken as a solvents [123]. Likewise, complexation at the liquid-liquid interface is also employed for the formation of metal organic frameworks (MOF) NMs. In this, a metal ion in an aqueous phase can complex with organic ligands dissolved in an organic phase at the liquid-liquid interface leads to the nucleation and growth of MOF NMs. For example, a bluish film with a dark color at the interphase was observed on spreading hexahydroxytriphenylene (HHTP) solution made in ethyl acetate onto an aqueous cuprous acetate solution, within a few minutes at room temperature [131]. Likewise, Yang et al. proposed a novel method for rapid synthesis of well-crystalline 2D MOF for nitro reduction via liquid/liquid interfacial approach. In this, Cu-CoPc (2D MOFs with Cu2+ coordinated to CoPc), where Pc is phthalocyanine, based structures prepared for the catalytic reduction of nitroaromatics [132].

4.2 Factors affecting the liquid/liquid interface assisted method for nanomaterials synthesis

Factors influencing the liquid/liquid interface assisted NMs synthesis include various parameters that affect the reaction dynamics and NMs characteristics. One of such factor is the choice of liquids. For example, Cheng et al. considered toluene water interface for iron oxide NMs preparation and a cauliflower like morphology was observed [118]. While, Cheng et al. prepared iron oxide durian-like hollow spherical NMs using benzene water as an interface [114]. Hence, the selection of immiscible liquid have tendency to affect the stability of interface as well as solubility of precursors, which in turn affect the growth kinetics and physicochemical properties of NMs. Likewise, one such factor is the use of surfactants. Polymeric micelles typically exhibit greater stability compared to low molecular weight surfactant micelles due to the increased interfacial free energy [133]. The surface chemistry of the liquid/liquid interface may also affect the physiochemical properties of NMs. The distribution of NMs depends on interfacial tension of the liquid/liquid interface. Likewise, pH is another factor plays an important role as it change the surface charge. Fernando et al. reported that the pH increased may leads to decreased particle size within a specific time frame. As a consequence, pH conditions preferred to reduced aggregation and enhanced particle stability [134]. Similarly, light may also affect the liquid/liquid interface which results in photoisomerization of the synthesized NMs [135]. Similarly, temperature is a factor that influences the liquid-liquid interface, thereby affecting the physicochemical properties of nanomaterials. Therefore, many approaches are devised to optimise the factors which led to the creation of smart liquid/liquid systems with vast potential for intricate and practical applications. However, despite considerable advancements, there is still a need for further enhancement and refinement of these technologies.

5 Conclusion and future perspectives

In recent times, nanomaterials have garnered increased attention due to their distinct properties and diverse applications. This heightened interest has spurred research into developing more effective synthetic approaches within the fields of nanoscience and nanotechnology. In today's era, there is a rising demand for materials that necessitates the development of new and intelligent technologies to scale up production. The soft template assisted liquid-liquid interface method as mentioned in this review can potentially serve as a solution to meet this demand. The L/L-assisted approach has several advantages compared with other interface-assisted synthesis pathways. In the L/L-assisted approach, to perform the reaction no sophisticated instruments are required, and can be easily done in any environmental conditions. The reaction doesn't follow complex synthesis steps and nanomaterials are synthesized with controlled morphology without any removal of the template. It is extremely reproducible. This review summarized several reported examples of the broadness of the liquid/liquid assisted approach for the fabrication of nanomaterials, covering organic, inorganic, and hybrid nanomaterials prepared by the different immiscible solvents. That means it provides room to play with solvents beautifully. The potentiality of novel liquid-liquid interfaces is another experimental frontier that is yet to be explored and a variety of fundamental questions are open to answer. Consequently, a lot of experimental investigations as well as theoretical efforts are necessary to explore all these objectives and enhance the applicability of the liquid/liquid interface-assisted method for nanomaterials designing. Additionally, the liquid-liquid interface method has high potential for producing two-dimensional metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), which have garnered significant attention due to their exceptional properties in diverse research fields such as catalysis, biomedicine, energy storage, and sensing applications etc. In the future, there is optimism about fabricating nanomaterials using the liquid-liquid interface method, where miscible green solvents could potentially replace the selection of immiscible liquids. This approach holds promise for advancing environmentally friendly and sustainable practices in nanomaterial synthesis. Therefore, this review benefits future studies of template-assisted approaches and nanomaterials at liquid/liquid interface. We believe these findings could provide novel synthesis pathways with controlled morphology and their multidisciplinary applications.

Funding

This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Nisha Gangwar: Resources, Methodology, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Chinky Gangwar: Writing – review & editing. Joy Sarkar: Supervision.

Declaration of competing interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

The authors are thankful to the Head, Department of Chemistry, 10.13039/501100021212 University of Lucknow , Lucknow (U.P.) India, for providing basic infrastructure. Mr. Ajeet Singh and Mr. Bharat Kaushik (Senior Research Fellow) 10.13039/100023445 BITS PILANI, Pilani main campus, Pilani, Rajasthan India for their support and help in accessing the recent articles.
==== Refs
References

1 Xie Y. Kocaefe D. Chen C. Kocaefe Y. Review of research on template methods in preparation of nanomaterials J. Nanomater. 2016 1 2016 2302595 10.1155/2016/2302595
2 Oni O.P. Hu Y. Tang S. Yan H. Zeng H. Wang H. Ma L. Yang C. Ran J. Syntheses and applications of mesoporous hydroxyapatite: a review Mater. Chem. Front. 7 2023 9
3 Wang F. Seo J.-H. Luo G. Starr M.B. Li Z. Geng D. Yin X. Wang S. Fraser D.G. Morgan D. Ma Z. Wang X. Nanometre-thick single-crystalline nanosheets grown at the water–air interface Nat. Commun. 7 1 2016 10444 10.1038/ncomms10444
4 Dardun V. Pinto T. Benaillon L. Veyre L. Galipaud J. Camp C. Meille V. Thieuleux C. Easy preparation of small crystalline Pd2Sn nanoparticles in solution at room temperature Dalton Trans. 52 7 2023 2157 10.1039/D2DT03476J 36723026
5 El-Khawaga A.M. Zidan A. El-Mageed A.I.A.A. Preparation methods of different nanomaterials for various potential applications: a review J. Mol. Struct. 1281 2023 135148 10.1016/j.molstruc.2023.135148
6 Zhao C. Zhang H. Si W. Wu H. Mass production of two-dimensional oxides by rapid heating of hydrous chlorides Nat. Commun. 7 1 2016 12543 10.1038/ncomms12543
7 Patil N. Bhaskar R. Vyavhare V. Dhadge R. Khaire V. Patil Y. Overview on methods of synthesis of nanoparticles Int. J. Curr. Pharmaceut. Res. 13 2 2021 11
8 Mailly D. Nanofabrication techniques EPJ ST 172 1 2009 333 10.1140/epjst/e2009-01058-x
9 Gangwar C. Yaseen B. Kumar I. Singh N.K. Naik R.M. Growth kinetic study of tannic acid mediated monodispersed silver nanoparticles synthesized by chemical reduction method and its characterization ACS Omega 6 34 2021 22344 10.1021/acsomega.1c03100
10 Shi Q. Dong D. Si K.J. Sikdar D. Yap L.W. Premaratne M. Cheng W. Shape transformation of constituent building blocks within self-assembled nanosheets and nano-origami ACS Nano 12 2 2018 1014 10.1021/acsnano.7b08334 29303252
11 Niehues M. Engel S. Ravoo B.J. Photo-responsive self-assembly of plasmonic magnetic janus nanoparticles Langmuir 37 37 2021 11123 10.1021/acs.langmuir.1c01979
12 Li X. Chen C. Niu Q. Li N.-W. Yu L. Wang B. Self-assembly of nanoparticles at solid–liquid interface for electrochemical capacitors Rare Met. 41 11 2022 3591
13 Rangarajan M. Vasanthakumari R. Vikram S. Superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles from coprecipitation: composition, size, and magnetization Nanosci. Nanotechnol. 14 2014 1
14 Mei J. Liao T. Kou L. Sun Z. Two‐dimensional metal oxide nanomaterials for next‐generation rechargeable batteries Adv. Mater. 29 48 2017 1700176
15 Poolakkandy R.R. Menamparambath M.M. Soft-template-assisted synthesis: a promising approach for the fabrication of transition metal oxides Nanoscale Adv. 2 11 2020 5015 36132034
16 Ghimbeu C.M. Le Meins J.-M. Zlotea C. Vidal L. Schrodj G. Latroche M. Vix-Guterl C. Controlled synthesis of NiCo nanoalloys embedded in ordered porous carbon by a novel soft-template strategy Carbon 67 2014 260
17 Rodríguez-San-Miguel D. Montoro C. Zamora F. Covalent organic framework nanosheets: preparation, properties and applications Chem. Soc. Rev. 49 8 2020 2291 32182308
18 Liu Z. Nie K. Qu X. Li X. Li B. Yuan Y. Chong S. Liu P. Li Y. Yin Z. Huang W. General bottom-up colloidal synthesis of nano-monolayer transition-metal dichalcogenides with high 1t′-phase purity JACS 144 11 2022 4863 10.1021/jacs.1c12379
19 Fujii Y. Zhou S. Shimada M. Kubo M. Synthesis of monodispersed hollow mesoporous organosilica and silica nanoparticles with controllable shell thickness using soft and hard templates Langmuir 39 13 2023 4571 10.1021/acs.langmuir.2c03121 36944197
20 Zhang W. Dai L. Mesoporous metal nanomaterials: developments and electrocatalytic applications Chem.--Eur. J. 30 25 2024 e202400402 10.1002/chem.202400402
21 Lu A.-H. Schüth F. Nanocasting pathways to create ordered mesoporous solids C R Chim. 8 3–4 2005 609
22 Lu A.H. Schüth F. Nanocasting: a versatile strategy for creating nanostructured porous materials Adv. Mater. 18 14 2006 1793
23 Hühn D. Kantner K. Geidel C. Brandholt S. De I. Cock Soenen S.J. Rivera Gil P. Montenegro J.M. Braeckmans K. Müllen K. Nienhaus G.U. Klapper M. Parak W.J. Polymer-coated nanoparticles interacting with proteins and cells: focusing on the sign of the net charge ACS Nano 7 4 2013 3253 10.1021/nn3059295 23566380
24 Nuruzzaman M. Rahman M.M. Liu Y. Naidu R. Nanoencapsulation, nano-guard for pesticides: a new window for safe application J. Agric. Food Chem. 64 7 2016 1447 10.1021/acs.jafc.5b05214 26730488
25 Ariga K. Hill J.P. Ji Q. Layer-by-layer assembly as a versatile bottom-up nanofabrication technique for exploratory research and realistic application Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 9 19 2007 2319 10.1039/B700410A 17492095
26 Dong R. Zhang T. Feng X. Interface-assisted synthesis of 2D materials: trend and challenges Chem. Rev. 118 13 2018 6189 29912554
27 Sasaki K. Uchida Y. Nishiyama N. Bottom‐up synthesis of nanosheets at various interfaces ChemPlusChem 2023 e202300255
28 Divya V. Sangaranarayanan M.V. Nanomaterials at liquid/liquid interfaces-A review J. Nanosci. Nanotechnol. 15 9 2015 6863 10.1166/jnn.2015.10727 26716259
29 Zarbin A.J.G. Liquid–liquid interfaces: a unique and advantageous environment to prepare and process thin films of complex materials Mater. Horiz. 8 5 2021 1409 34846449
30 Vázquez M. Magnetic Nano-And Microwires: Design, Synthesis, Properties and Applications 2015 Woodhead Publishing
31 Li H. Wang L. Wei Y. Yan W. Feng J. Preparation of templated materials and their application to typical pollutants in wastewater: a review Front. Chem. 10 2022 882876
32 Marrakchi F. Ahmed M.J. Khanday W.A. Asif M. Hameed B.H. Mesoporous-activated carbon prepared from chitosan flakes via single-step sodium hydroxide activation for the adsorption of methylene blue Int. J. Biol. Macromol. 98 2017 233 28147233
33 Scarpelli F. Mastropietro T.F. Poerio T. Godbert N. Mesoporous TiO2 thin films: state of the art, Mater. for Sus Environ. Times 508 1 2018 135
34 Liu Y. Goebl J. Yin Y. Templated synthesis of nanostructured materials Chem. Soc. Rev. 42 7 2013 2610 10.1039/C2CS35369E 23093173
35 Petkovich N.D. Stein A. Controlling material macrostructures and mesostructures through combined hard and soft templating Chem. Soc. Rev. 42 2013 3721 23072972
36 Bhosale S.R. Bhosale R.R. Jagadhane K.S. Gore A.H. Kolekar G.B. Kolekar S.S. Anbhule P.V. Recent trends in synthetic Top-down approach for Mesoporous Carbon: a seminal review J. mater. nanosci. 10 1 2023 601
37 Liu X.-Y. Wang K.-X. Chen J.-S. Template-directed metal oxides for electrochemical energy storage Energy Stor. Mater. 3 2016 1
38 Yang H. Zhao D. Synthesis of replica mesostructures by the nanocasting strategy J. Mater. Chem. 15 12 2005 1217
39 Xie Y. Kocaefe D. Chen C. Kocaefe Y. Review of research on template methods in preparation of nanomaterials J. Nanomater. 2016 2016 1
40 Platschek B. Keilbach A. Bein T. Mesoporous structures confined in anodic alumina membranes Adv. Mater. 23 21 2011 2395 21484885
41 Kawamura G. Muto H. Matsuda A. Hard template synthesis of metal nanowires Front. Chem. 2 2014 104 25453031
42 Nugraha R.E. Fauziyah N.A. Wira G.R. Templated growth formation of mesoporous silica materials: a soft-hard template approach Nusant. Sci. Technol. Proc. 2022 318
43 Savic S. Vojisavljevic K. uč a-Nešić M.P. Zivojevic K. Mladenovic M. Knezevic N. Hard template synthesis of nanomaterials based on mesoporous silica Metall. & Mater. Eng. 24 4 2018 225
44 Meng Y. Gu D. Zhang F. Shi Y. Yang H. Li Z. Yu C. Tu B. Zhao D. Ordered mesoporous polymers and homologous carbon frameworks: amphiphilic surfactant templating and direct transformation Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 44 43 2005 7053
45 Li W. Wu Z. Wang J. Elzatahry A.A. Zhao D. A perspective on mesoporous TiO2 materials Chem. Mater. 26 1 2014 287
46 Soler-Illia G.J.A.A. Azzaroni O. Multifunctional hybrids by combining ordered mesoporous materials and macromolecular building blocks Chem. Soc. Rev. 40 2 2011 1107 21221447
47 Fan J. Boettcher S.W. Tsung C.-K. Shi Q. Schierhorn M. Stucky G.D. Field-Directed and confined molecular assembly of mesostructured materials: basic principles and new opportunities Chem. Mater. 20 3 2008 909 10.1021/cm702328k
48 Pal N. Bhaumik A. Soft templating strategies for the synthesis of mesoporous materials: inorganic, organic–inorganic hybrid and purely organic solids Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 189 2013 21 23337774
49 Ajami D. Liu L. Rebek J. Jr. Soft templates in encapsulation complexes Chem. Soc. Rev. 44 2 2015 490 24705709
50 Wang W. Faulkner D. Moir J. Ozin G.A. The effect of solvent in evaporation-induced self-assembly: a case study of benzene periodic mesoporous organosilica Sci. China Chem. 54 2011 1920
51 Grosso D. Cagnol F. Aa Soler-Illia GJ.d. Crepaldi E.L. Amenitsch H. Brunet-Bruneau A. Bourgeois A. Sanchez C. Adv. Funct. Mater. 14 2004 309
52 Hu D. Wang E. Wang A. Li H. Duan A. Synthesis of wrinkle silica nanospheres by solvent evaporation-induced self-assembly method for hydrogenation reaction Mater. Today Chem. 27 2023 101280 10.1016/j.mtchem.2022.101280
53 Petkovich N.D. Stein A. Controlling macro-and mesostructures with hierarchical porosity through combined hard and soft templating Chem. Soc. Rev. 42 9 2013 3721 23072972
54 Zhang Y. Li L. Su H. Huang W. Dong X. Binary metal oxide: advanced energy storage materials in supercapacitors J. Mater. Chem. A 3 1 2015 43
55 Dallas P. Georgakilas V. Interfacial polymerization of conductive polymers: generation of polymeric nanostructures in a 2-D space Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 224 2015 46 26272721
56 Chondath S.K. Menamparambath M.M. Interface-assisted synthesis: a gateway to effective nanostructure tuning of conducting polymers Nanoscale Adv. 3 4 2021 918 36133281
57 Chen L. Zhang S. Liu X. Ge X. Recent advances in water-mediated multiphase catalysis Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 65 2023 101691 10.1016/j.cocis.2023.101691
58 Oaki Y. Sato K. Crystal-controlled polymerization: recent advances in morphology design and control of organic polymer materials J. Mater. Chem. A 6 46 2018 23197
59 Huang X. Li S. Huang Y. Wu S. Zhou X. Li S. Gan C.L. Boey F. Mirkin C.A. Zhang H. Synthesis of hexagonal close-packed gold nanostructures Nat. Commun. 2 1 2011 292 10.1038/ncomms1291 21522136
60 Duan L. Wang C. Zhang W. Ma B. Deng Y. Li W. Zhao D. Interfacial assembly and applications of functional mesoporous materials Chem. Rev. 121 23 2021 14349 10.1021/acs.chemrev.1c00236
61 Zhao G. Li J. Ren X. Hu J. Hu W. Wang X. Highly active MnO2 nanosheet synthesis from graphene oxide templates and their application in efficient oxidative degradation of methylene blue RSC Adv. 3 31 2013 12909 10.1039/C3RA40942B
62 Zhou J. Gao X. Liu R. Xie Z. Yang J. Zhang S. Zhang G. Liu H. Li Y. Zhang J. Synthesis of graphdiyne nanowalls using acetylenic coupling reaction JACS 137 24 2015 7596
63 Choi I.Y. Lee J. Ahn H. Lee J. Choi H.C. Park M.J. High‐conductivity two‐dimensional polyaniline nanosheets developed on ice surfaces Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 54 36 2015 10497
64 Patil K.R. Hwang Y.K. Kim M.-J. Chang J.-S. Park S.-E. Preparation of thin films comprising palladium nanoparticles by a solid–liquid interface reaction technique J. Colloid Interface Sci. 276 2 2004 333 10.1016/j.jcis.2004.04.001 15271560
65 Wang X. Liu Q. Wu S. Xu B. Xu H. Multilayer polypyrrole nanosheets with self‐organized surface structures for flexible and efficient solar–thermal energy conversion Adv. Mater. 31 19 2019 1807716
66 Guo X. Bai N. Tian Y. Gai L. Free-standing reduced graphene oxide/polypyrrole films with enhanced electrochemical performance for flexible supercapacitors J. Power Sources 408 2018 51
67 Barpuzary D. Kim K. Park M.J. Two-dimensional growth of large-area conjugated polymers on ice surfaces: high conductivity and photoelectrochemical applications ACS Nano 13 4 2019 3953 30938984
68 Dreyer, S D.R. Park C.W. R Bielawski Ruoff R.S. “The chemistry of graphene oxide Chem. Soc. Rev. 39 1 2010 228 20023850
69 Matsuoka R. Sakamoto R. Hoshiko K. Sasaki S. Masunaga H. Nagashio K. Nishihara H. Crystalline graphdiyne nanosheets produced at a gas/liquid or liquid/liquid interface JACS 139 8 2017 3145 10.1021/jacs.6b12776
70 Kambe T. Sakamoto R. Hoshiko K. Takada K. Miyachi M. Ryu J.-H. Sasaki S. Kim J. Nakazato K. Takata M. Nishihara H. π-Conjugated nickel bis(dithiolene) complex nanosheet JACS 135 7 2013 2462 10.1021/ja312380b
71 Sun X. Wu K.-H. Sakamoto R. Kusamoto T. Maeda H. Ni X. Jiang W. Liu F. Sasaki S. Masunaga H. Bis (aminothiolato) nickel nanosheet as a redox switch for conductivity and an electrocatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction Chem. Sci. 8 12 2017 8078 29568456
72 Fan H. Wang J. Li X. You H. Li X. Pei C. Huang X. Li H. Direct CVD growth of MoS2 on chemically and thermally reduced graphene oxide nanosheets for improved photoresponse Apl. Mater. 9 5 2021 051105 10.1063/5.0047015
73 Soni A. Kushavah D. Lu L.-S. Chang W.-H. Pal S.K. Ultrafast exciton trapping and exciton–exciton annihilation in large-area CVD-grown monolayer WS2 J. Phys. Chem. C 125 43 2021 23880 10.1021/acs.jpcc.1c06267
74 Chondath S.K. Menamparambath M.M. Interface-assisted synthesis: a gateway to effective nanostructure tuning of conducting polymers Nanoscale Adv. 3 4 2021 918 10.1039/d0na00940g 36133281
75 Shang N.G. Au F.C.K. Meng X.M. Lee C.S. Bello I. Lee S.T. Uniform carbon nanoflake films and their field emissions Chem. Phys. Lett. 358 3 2002 187 10.1016/S0009-2614(02)00430-X
76 Bao H. Zhang Z. Hua Q. Huang W. Compositions, structures, and catalytic activities of CeO2@Cu2O nanocomposites prepared by the template-assisted method Langmuir 30 22 2014 6427 10.1021/la501406w 24827164
77 Qu J. Cao C.-Y. Dou Z.-F. Liu H. Yu Y. Li P. Song W.-G. Synthesis of cyclic carbonates: catalysis by an iron-based composite and the role of hydrogen bonding at the solid/liquid interface ChemSusChem 5 4 2012 652 10.1002/cssc.201100839 22441879
78 Chen G. Xu C. Song X. Zhao W. Ding Y. Sun S. Interface reaction route to two different kinds of CeO2 nanotubes Inorg. Chem. 47 2 2008 723 10.1021/ic701867f 18078335
79 Lee K.-T. Chen Y.-A. Lu S.-Y. Solid-liquid interface based biphasic reaction for nanomaterial preparation: bundled CuO nanorods as an example and their outstanding photocatalytic efficiencies ChemistrySelect 2 11 2017 3276 10.1002/slct.201700568
80 Zheng M.-b. Cao J. Liao S.-t. Liu J.-s. Chen H.-q. Zhao Y. Dai W.-j. Ji G.-b. Cao J.-m. Tao J. Preparation of mesoporous Co3O4 nanoparticles via Solid−Liquid route and effects of calcination temperature and textural parameters on their electrochemical capacitive behaviors J. Phys. Chem. C 113 9 2009 3887 10.1021/jp810230d
81 Cao C.-Y. Guo W. Cui Z.-M. Song W.-G. Cai W. Microwave-assisted gas/liquid interfacial synthesis of flowerlike NiO hollow nanosphere precursors and their application as supercapacitor electrodes J. Mater. Chem. 21 9 2011 3204 10.1039/C0JM03749D
82 Bai W. Nie F. Zheng J. Sheng Q. Novel silver nanoparticle–manganese oxyhydroxide–graphene oxide nanocomposite prepared by modified silver mirror reaction and its application for electrochemical sensing ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 6 8 2014 5439 10.1021/am500641d 24660983
83 Zhu E. Liu Y. Huang J. Zhang A. Peng B. Liu Z. Liu H. Yu J. Li Y.-R. Yang L. Duan X. Huang Y. Bubble-Mediated large-scale hierarchical assembly of ultrathin Pt nanowire network monolayer at gas/liquid interfaces ACS Nano 17 14 2023 14152 10.1021/acsnano.3c04771
84 Lu Y. Yuan X. Jia C. Lei B. Zhang H. Zhao Z. Zhu S. Zhao Q. Cai W. Self-Assembled bifunctional copper hydroxide/gold-ordered nanoarray composites for fast, sensitive, and recyclable SERS detection of hazardous benzene vapors Nanomaterials 13 13 2023 2016 37446532
85 Sun N. Yao X. Xu Z. Li J. Yang N. Lyu D. Zhao G. Dai C. Janus nanographene oxide with aerophilic/hydrophilic characteristics for enhancing foam stability in high-temperature reservoirs J. Mol. Liq. 371 2023 121087 10.1016/j.molliq.2022.121087
86 Zhang T. Qi H. Liao Z. Horev Y.D. Panes-Ruiz L.A. Petkov P.S. Zhang Z. Shivhare R. Zhang P. Liu K. Bezugly V. Liu S. Zheng Z. Mannsfeld S. Heine T. Cuniberti G. Haick H. Zschech E. Kaiser U. Dong R. Feng X. Engineering crystalline quasi-two-dimensional polyaniline thin film with enhanced electrical and chemiresistive sensing performances Nat. Commun. 10 1 2019 4225 10.1038/s41467-019-11921-3 31548543
87 Gui Y. Wu J. Tian K. Guo H. Qin X. Qin X. Guo X. Fang C. Liu P. Ultraviolet-induced gas sensing performance of Ag/WO3/rGO nanocomposites for H2S gas sensors ACS Appl. Electron. Mater. 5 7 2023 3625 10.1021/acsaelm.3c00349
88 Zhang C. Mo Z. Guo R. Teng G. Zhao G. Magnetic-field-induced synthesis of Fe3O4 nanorods by a gas–liquid interfacial process: microstructure control, magnetic and photocatalytic properties Mater. Res. Bull. 53 2014 116 10.1016/j.materresbull.2014.02.014
89 Gui Y.-h. Wang H.-y. Tian K. Yang L.-l. Guo H.-s. Zhang H.-z. Fang S.-m. Wang Y. Enhanced gas sensing properties to NO2 of SnO2/rGO nanocomposites synthesized by microwave-assisted gas-liquid interfacial method Ceram. Int. 44 5 2018 4900 10.1016/j.ceramint.2017.12.080
90 Hu J. Zhang L. Achieving F-doped porous hollow carbon nanospheres with ultrahigh pore volume via a gas–solid interface reaction J. Mater. Chem. A 9 48 2021 27560 10.1039/D1TA07749J
91 Ma Y. Gao W. Shan H. Chen W. Shang W. Tao P. Song C. Addiego C. Deng T. Pan X. Wu J. Platinum-based nanowires as active catalysts toward oxygen reduction reaction: in situ observation of surface-diffusion-assisted, solid-state oriented attachment Adv. Mater. 29 46 2017 1703460 10.1002/adma.201703460
92 Lai C. Wu Q. Chen J. Wen L. Ren S. Large-area aligned branched Cu2S nanostructure arrays: room-temperature synthesis and growth mechanism Nanotechnology 21 21 2010 215602 10.1088/0957-4484/21/21/215602
93 Zheng J. Song X. Zhang Y. Li Y. Li X. Pu Y. Nanosized aluminum nitride hollow spheres formed through a self-templating solid–gas interface reaction J. Solid State Chem. 180 1 2007 276 10.1016/j.jssc.2006.10.011
94 Catalán-Toledo J. Djafari J. Mas-Torrent M. Crivillers N. Redox-Active Au nanoparticles self-assembled at liquid–liquid interface via C–Au functionalization for dye degradation electrocatalysis ACS Appl. Nano Mater. 7 5 2024 5242
95 Zhao M. Lu Q. Ma Q. Zhang H. Two‐dimensional metal–organic framework nanosheets Small Methods 1 1–2 2017 1600030
96 Hua X. Bevan M.A. Frechette J. Reversible partitioning of nanoparticles at an oil–water interface Langmuir 32 44 2016 11341 10.1021/acs.langmuir.6b02255
97 Biswas S. Drzal L.T. A novel approach to create a highly ordered monolayer film of graphene nanosheets at the Liquid−Liquid interface Nano Lett. 9 1 2009 167 10.1021/nl802724f 19113892
98 Davidovits P. Kolb C.E. Williams L.R. Jayne J.T. Worsnop D.R. Mass accommodation and chemical reactions at gas− liquid interfaces Chem. Rev. 106 4 2006 1323 16608183
99 Ariga K. Liquid interfacial nanoarchitectonics: molecular machines, organic semiconductors, nanocarbons, stem cells, and others Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 63 2023 101656 10.1016/j.cocis.2022.101656
100 Moshrefi R. Przybyła H. Stockmann T.J. Simultaneous electro-generation/polymerization of Cu nanocluster embedded conductive poly (2, 2′: 5′, 2′′-terthiophene) films at micro and macro liquid/liquid interfaces Sci. Rep. 13 1 2023 1201 36681717
101 Hoseini S.J. Bahrami M. Dehghani M. Formation of snowman-like Pt/Pd thin film and Pt/Pd/reduced-graphene oxide thin film at liquid–liquid interface by use of organometallic complexes, suitable for methanol fuel cells RSC Adv. 4 27 2014 13796 10.1039/C4RA01625D
102 Yao K.-S. Zhao H.-L. Wang N. Li T.-J. Zhao S. Lu W.-W. Facile synthesis of ultra-large, single-crystal Ag nanosheet-assembled films at chloroform-water interface J. Solid State Chem. 278 2019 120912 10.1016/j.jssc.2019.120912
103 Higgins E.P.C. McAdams S.G. Hopkinson D.G. Byrne C. Walton A.S. Lewis D.J. Dryfe R.A.W. Room-temperature production of nanocrystalline molybdenum disulfide (MoS2) at the Liquid−Liquid interface Chem. Mater. 31 15 2019 5384 10.1021/acs.chemmater.8b05232 32063674
104 Puthiyottil N. Kanakkayil S. Pillai N.P. Rajan A. Parambath S.K. Krishnamurthy R.G. Chatanathodi R. Menamparambath M.M. In situ engineering of Au–Ag alloy embedded PEDOT nanohybrids at a solvent/non-solvent interface for the electrochemical enzyme-free detection of histamine J. Mater. Chem. B 11 5 2023 1144 36645247
105 Liu Q. Guo Z. Wang C. Guo S. Xu Z. Hu C. Liu Y. Wang Y. He J. Wong W.Y. A cobalt‐based metal‐organic framework nanosheet as the electrode for high‐performance asymmetric supercapacitor Adv. Sci. 2023 2207545
106 Bowden N. Terfort A. Carbeck J. Whitesides G.M. Self-assembly of mesoscale objects into ordered two-dimensional arrays Science 276 5310 1997 233 9092466
107 He Y. Kim K.-J. Chang C.-h. Segmented microfluidic flow reactors for nanomaterial synthesis Nanomaterials 10 7 2020 1421 32708175
108 Neyt N.C. Riley D.L. Application of reactor engineering concepts in continuous flow chemistry: a review React. Chem. Eng. 6 8 2021 1295
109 Pinto C.S. Souza V.H.R. Schmidt A. Zarbin A.J.G. PSS-free PEDOT and PEDOT/graphene transparent films: synthesis, characterization and electrochromism Synth. Met. 293 2023 117259
110 Chondath S.K. Sreekala A.P.K. Farzeena C. Varanakkottu S.N. Menamparambath M.M. Interfacial tension driven adsorption of MnO 2 nanoparticles at the liquid/liquid interface to tailor ultra-thin polypyrrole sheets Nanoscale 14 31 2022 11197
111 Wang F. Seo J.-H. Luo G. Starr M.B. Li Z. Geng D. Yin X. Wang S. Fraser D.G. Morgan D. Nanometre-thick single-crystalline nanosheets grown at the water–air interface Nat. Commun. 7 1 2016 10444
112 Poolakkandy R.R. Ar N. Padmalayam K.A. Gk R. Menamparambath M.M. Nickel hydroxide nanoflake/carbon nanotube composites for the electrochemical detection of glutamic acid using in vitro stroke model ACS Appl. Nano Mater. 6 2 2023 1347
113 Zhu J. Qian X. From 2-D CuO nanosheets to 3-D hollow nanospheres: interface-assisted synthesis, surface photovoltage properties and photocatalytic activity J. Solid State Chem. 183 7 2010 1632
114 Cheng X.-L. Jiang J.-S. Hu M. Mao G.-Y. Liu Z.-W. Zeng Y. Zhang Q.-H. Liquid–liquid interface-assisted solvothermal synthesis of durian-like α-Fe2O3 hollow spheres constructed by nano-polyhedrons CrystEngComm 14 9 2012 3056
115 Poolakkandy R.R. Neelakandan A.R. Puthiyaparambath M.F. Krishnamurthy R.G. Chatanathodi R. Menamparambath M.M. Nickel cobaltite/multi-walled carbon nanotube flexible sensor for the electrochemical detection of dopamine released by human neural cells J. Mater. Chem. C 10 8 2022 3048
116 Chen Z. Wang C. Chen M. Ye C. Lin Z. Xing L. Liao Y. Xu M. Cao G. Li W. Highly effective fabrication of two dimensional metal oxides as high performance lithium storage anodes J. Mater. Chem. A 7 8 2019 3924
117 Chondath S.K. Poolakkandy R.R. Kottayintavida R. Thekkangil A. Gopalan N.K. Vasu S.T. Athiyanathil S. Menamparambath M.M. Water–chloroform interface assisted microstructure tuning of polypyrrole–silver sheets ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 11 1 2019 1723 10.1021/acsami.8b18943 30592208
118 Cheng X.-L. Jiang J.-S. Jin C.-Y. Lin C.-C. Zeng Y. Zhang Q.-H. Cauliflower-like α-Fe2O3 microstructures: toluene–water interface-assisted synthesis, characterization, and applications in wastewater treatment and visible-light photocatalysis Chem. Eng. J. 236 2014 139
119 Liu Y. Chen Z. Shek C.-H. Wu C.M.L. Lai J.K.L. Hierarchical mesoporous MnO2 superstructures synthesized by soft-interface method and their catalytic performances ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 6 12 2014 9776 10.1021/am502191k 24884227
120 Clarke T.B. Colón G.S. Dick J.E. Tunable gold nanoring arrays by electrodeposition Adv. Mater. Technol. 8 13 2023 2201946 10.1002/admt.202201946
121 Inagaki C.S. Oliveira M.M. Zarbin A.J.G. Direct and one-step synthesis of polythiophene/gold nanoparticles thin films through liquid/liquid interfacial polymerization J. Colloid Interface Sci. 516 2018 498 10.1016/j.jcis.2018.01.076 29408140
122 Hao Q. Wang H. Yang X. Lu L. Wang X. Morphology-controlled fabrication of sulfonated graphene/polyaniline nanocomposites by liquid/liquid interfacial polymerization and investigation of their electrochemical properties Nano Res. 4 4 2011 323 10.1007/s12274-010-0087-4
123 Kelgenbaeva Z. Omurzak E. Takebe S. Sulaimankulova S. Abdullaeva Z. Iwamoto C. Mashimo T. Synthesis of pure iron nanoparticles at liquid–liquid interface using pulsed plasma J Nanopart Res 16 9 2014 2603 10.1007/s11051-014-2603-z
124 Zhang Y. Nishi N. Sakka T. Interface-templated synthesis of single-crystalline silver chain-like nanobelts at the liquid-liquid interface between water and redox-active ionic liquid Colloids Surf. A Physicochem. Eng. Asp. 597 2020 124747 10.1016/j.colsurfa.2020.124747
125 Zhang Y. Nishi N. Sakka T. Template-free and spontaneous formation of vertically aligned Pd nanofiber arrays at the liquid–liquid interface between redox-active ionic liquid and water ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 11 26 2019 23731 10.1021/acsami.9b05255
126 Sakamoto R. Yagi T. Hoshiko K. Kusaka S. Matsuoka R. Maeda H. Liu Z. Liu Q. Wong W.Y. Nishihara H. Photofunctionality in porphyrin‐hybridized bis (dipyrrinato) zinc (II) complex micro‐and nanosheets Angew. Chem. 129 13 2017 3580
127 Prabhu R.B. Singh K.K. Alex C. John N.S. A general route to free-standing films of nanocrystalline molybdenum chalcogenides at a liquid/liquid interface under hydrothermal conditions Appl. Surf. Sci. 511 2020 145579 10.1016/j.apsusc.2020.145579
128 Inagaki C.S. Oliveira M.M. Bergamini M.F. Marcolino-Junior L.H. Zarbin A.J.G. Facile synthesis and dopamine sensing application of three component nanocomposite thin films based on polythiophene, gold nanoparticles and carbon nanotubes J. Electroanal. Chem. 840 2019 208 10.1016/j.jelechem.2019.03.066
129 Johans C. Clohessy J. Fantini S. Kontturi K. Cunnane V.J. Electrosynthesis of polyphenylpyrrole coated silver particles at a liquid–liquid interface Electrochem. Commun. 4 3 2002 227 10.1016/S1388-2481(02)00256-4
130 Lee W.P. Chen H. Dryfe R. Ding Y. Kinetics of nanoparticle synthesis by liquid–liquid interfacial reaction Colloids Surf. A Physicochem. Eng. Asp. 343 1 2009 3 10.1016/j.colsurfa.2009.01.040
131 Rubio‐Giménez V. Galbiati M. Castells‐Gil J. Almora‐Barrios N. Navarro‐Sánchez J. Escorcia‐Ariza G. Mattera M. Arnold T. Rawle J. Tatay S. Bottom‐up fabrication of semiconductive metal–organic framework ultrathin films Adv. Mater. 30 10 2018 1704291
132 Yang J. Kong L. Huang C. Wang C. Wei S. Zhou L. Liquid-Liquid interfacial approach for rapid synthesis of Well-Crystalline Two-Dimensional Metal-Organic frameworks for nitro reduction Chem. Eng. J. 485 2024 149969 10.1016/j.cej.2024.149969
133 Cabral H. Miyata K. Osada K. Kataoka K. Block copolymer micelles in nanomedicine applications Chem. Rev. 118 14 2018 6844 10.1021/acs.chemrev.8b00199 29957926
134 Fernando I. Zhou Y. Impact of pH on the stability, dissolution and aggregation kinetics of silver nanoparticles Chemosphere 216 2019 297 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2018.10.122 30384298
135 Fu Y. Zhao S. Chen W. Zhang Q. Chai Y. Self-assembly of nanoparticles with stimulated responses at liquid interfaces Nano Today 54 2024 102073 10.1016/j.nantod.2023.102073
