
==== Front
World J Clin Cases
WJCC
World Journal of Clinical Cases
2307-8960
Baishideng Publishing Group Inc

jWJCC.v12.i25.pg5636
10.12998/wjcc.v12.i25.5636
94107
Editorial
Enhanced recovery after surgery: Progress in adapted pathways for implementation in standard and emerging surgical settings
Wishahi M et al. Enhanced recovery after surgery
Wishahi Mohamed Department of Urology, Theodor Bilharz Research Institute, Cairo 12411, Egypt. moh.weshahy@gmail.com

Kamal Nabawya M Department of Anaesthesia and Surgical Intensive Care, Theodor Bilharz Research Institute, Cairo 12411, Egypt

Hedaya Mohamed Saied Department of Surgery, Theodore Bilharz Research Institute, Cairo 12411, Egypt

Author contributions: Wishahi M contributed to the data collection, analysis, manuscript writing, and revision; Kamal NM contributed to the manuscript writing, and revision; Hedaya MS contributed to the manuscript writing, and revision; and all the authors approved the final manuscript.

Corresponding author: Mohamed Wishahi, Doctor, Professor, Department of Urology, Theodor Bilharz Research Institute, Ministry of High Education and Scientific Research, Embaba, Giza, Cairo 12411, Egypt. moh.weshahy@gmail.com

6 9 2024
6 9 2024
12 25 56365641
12 3 2024
29 4 2024
21 5 2024
©The Author(s) 2024. Published by Baishideng Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.
2024
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This article is an open-access article that was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial.
The concept of enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) has been practiced for decades and has been implemented in numerous surgical specialties. ERAS is a global surgical quality improvement initiative, and it is an element in the field of perioperative care. ERAS had shown significant clinical outcomes, patient-reported satisfaction, and improvements in medical service cost. ERAS has been developed for specific surgical procedures, but with the fast progress of newly introduced surgical procedures, the original ERAS have been developed and modified. Recently appearing Topics and future research trends encompass ERAS protocols for other types of surgery and the enhancement of perioperative status, including but not limited to pediatric surgery, laparoscopic and robotic assisted surgery, bariatric surgery, thoracic surgery, and renal transplantation. The elements and pathways of ERAS have been developed with the introduction of up-to-date methodologies in the pre-operative, operative, and post-operative pathways. ERAS costs are higher than traditional care, but the patient’s clinical outcome and satisfaction are higher. ERAS is in progress in the fields of anesthetic tasks, pediatric surgery, and organ transplantation. Although ERAS has shown significant clinical outcomes, there are needs to modify the protocol for specific cases, hospital facilities, resources, and nurses training on elements of ERAS. Several challenges and limitations exist in the implementation of ERAS that deserve consideration, it includes: Frailty, maximizing nutrition, prehabilitation, treating preoperative anemia, and enhancing ERAS adoption globally are all included.

Enhanced recovery after surgery
Anesthesia
Nurses
Elderly
Bowel preparation
ERAS
Perioperative nutrition
Major & ambulatory surgery
==== Body
pmc Core Tip: Enhanced recovery after surgery protocols (ERAS) is implemented in different surgical settings. The major advantage of ERAS is the early mobilization of the patient, which diminishes the possible risk of postoperative complications, including ileus and thromboembolic events. ERAS protocols include reduction of the period of hunger, acceleration of carbohydrate load, early oral feeding, and early mobilization that accelerates the recovery of normal activities, and reduces recovery time, hospital stay and hospital costs. ERAS is implemented in standard surgical settings; recently, ERAS has been successfully implemented in pediatric surgery, laparoscopy and robotic assisted surgery, and organ transplantation.

INTRODUCTION

Recently, Nag et al[1], and Sun et al[2], published an elaborated article on enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) for total knee arthroplasty and in elderly patient who underwent video-assisted thoracic surgery for lung cancer. Both articles presented the experience and benefits of the implementation of ERAS.

The concept ERAS has been practiced for decades and is implemented in different settings. At present, it is an element in the field of perioperative care. ERAS had shown significant clinical outcomes, patient-reported outcomes, and improvements medical service costs. Several challenges and limitations exist in the implementation of ERAS that deserve consideration.

ERAS has been developed for specific surgical procedures. With the fast progress of newly introduced surgical procedures, the original ERAS had been developed and modified to suit and be applicable for a specified procedure

ERAS has achieved significant benefits for patients and the health systems[3-6]. More than 3242 articles and reviews from 1997 to 2022 were published on ERAS in 684 journals in 78 nations, with China and the United States leading the way. The majority of these publications deal with oncology and surgery. Future research trends and recently emerging subjects include enhancing perioperative status and ERAS protocols for various surgical procedures, including pediatric surgery, laparoscopic surgery, robotic assisted surgery, bariatric surgery, thoracic surgery, renal transplantation, hand surgery, gynecologic surgery, and rehabilitation[7-11].

ERAS is an established element in standard surgical settings for oncological and non-oncological surgery. The elements and pathways of ERAS have been developed with the introduction of up-to-date methodologies in the pre-operative, operative, and post-operative pathways. The main elements are adapted for specific surgical procedures.

ADAPTED PATHWAYS FOR ERAS IN NEWLY EMERGING SURGICAL SETTINGS

Enhanced recovery after surgery in pediatric age groups and children

Implementation of ERAS in pediatric urologic surgery was successful in a few series. The safety and efficacy of ERAS protocols in pediatrics have been reported recently; the items of ERAS protocols have been well studied, and items were selected to suit the pediatric age. These selected items of ERAS were applied in specific situations, namely, pediatric augmentation cystoplasty, exstrophy and epispadias complex, and cloacal extropy. Implementation of ERAS has added significant benefits for children without increasing the risk of complications[12,13]. In pediatric age, ERAS components have been modified, targeted by the care pathway, and customized for pediatric urology patients (Table 1)[13].

Table 1 Modified enhanced recovery after surgery pathway in pediatric surgical patients[13]

Preoperative	Intraoperative	Postoperative	
Counsel about ERAS, obtained from caregiver	Regional anesthesia with catheter-based block	Prevention of nausea and vomiting	
Clear-liquid carbohydrate load (10 mL/kg up to 350 mL)	Avoiding excess drains, intraperitoneal or subcutaneous	Early feeding, clear fluids in post-operative day zero, regular diet on post-operative day one	
Avoid prolonged fasting, eat regular diet, clears-only diet is given in the day prior to surgery	Ensure euvolaemia, parenteral fluids are crystalloid administered 4–7 mL/kg/h	Early mobilization, out-of-bed in the post-operative day one	
No bowel preparation	Normothermia (36 °C–38 °C during the surgical procedure. (skin-to-skin time/ endoscopy/ laparoscopy)	Adjunctive pain medication (acetaminophen and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs)	
Antibiotic prophylaxis	Minimizing opioids (< 0.15 mg/kg intravenous morphine equivalents)	Early stoppage of intravenous fluids (either discontinue or lower rate to keep vein open. Post-operative day two)	
Prophylaxis against deep vein thrombosis (age ≥ 14, or presence of risk factors)	Minimally invasive surgical procedures	Early removal of extra drains/catheters. Non-urinary drain is removal by post-operative day four	
ERAS: Enhanced recovery after surgery.

Enhanced recovery after surgery for elderly patients

Enhanced recovery in colorectal surgery entails multiple modes and a multidisciplinary approach aiming at reducing surgical stress, early recovery, and early mobilization through optimization in the pre-, intra-, and postoperative care of the patients. ERAS was implemented safely in elderly patients with multiple comorbidities who underwent colectomy[6]. ERAS was implemented in elderly patients with a high body mass index who had undergone laparoscopic cholecystectomy[14].

The two main components that have been emphasis in the elderly are the pre- and post-rehabilitation programs and the shortening of preoperative fasting time.

However, different studies showed that the patients who had the ERAS protocol had a significantly shorter preoperative fasting time and alleviated preoperative hunger sensations compared to the non-ERAS patients. When compared to patients in the non-ERAS protocol group, elderly patients in the ERAS protocol group showed better results in terms of length of hospital stay, postoperative pain scores, postoperative hunger scores, and satisfaction levels.

Enhanced recovery after surgery recommendations for renal transplantation

The evidence foundation for ERAS in kidney transplantation is still weak when compared to other surgical specialties. The use of ERAS was found to shorten hospital stays without changing readmission rates in six trials involving a total of 1225 individuals. Applying the already available evidence has resulted in significant improvements to patient outcomes. This has demonstrated that ERAS is a safe, practical procedure for kidney transplant surgery that offers better postoperative results[15].

Enhanced recovery after surgery for laparoscopic colorectal surgery

ERAS has been widely used in colorectal laparoscopic surgery. Nonetheless, a number of studies have discovered that not all patients benefit from ERAS treatments. 1463 participants from seven studies were examined. The majority of the time, a prolonged duration of stay following surgery was linked to the criterion of ERAS failure. Identified risk factors were more intraoperative blood loss, longer operative duration. However, these elements are not directly related to ERAS rather it was related to the surgical performance. These findings will direct the doctor to take different action in a timely manner[16].

ROLE OF ANESTHESIA IN ENHANCED RECOVERY AFTER SURGERY PROTOCOLS

Protocols for Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) and procedures for interventional loco-regional anesthesia (LRA) have been evolving continuously. In addition to introducing several novel techniques to supplement ERAS procedures, ultrasound-guided regional anesthesia has resulted in the improvement of conventional methods. LRA can be used in more and more ERAS indications because to its effectiveness and adaptability. One of the main therapies enhancing postoperative outcomes is the combination of multimodal analgesic strategies with regional anesthetic procedures[17,18] (Table 2).

Table 2 Anesthetic task in enhanced recovery after surgery

Preoperative	Intraoperative	Postoperative	
Preoperative counseling & patient evaluation with requires investigators including laboratory work	Shot acting anesthetics and analgesics. Multimodal opioid sparing and pain management plan should be used and implemented before the induction of anesthesia. Narcotic alternatives that decreases opioid needs are: acetaminophen, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, 2-agonists as clonidine and gabapentin, and IV Xylocaine infusion	Shifting of the patient to the surgical ICU. On arrival of the patient in the ICU, all laboratory tests should be done: Chest X-ray, arterial blood gases, checking hemodynamic stability, verification of the lines, body temperature, making sure that the patient is warm enough and pain-free, as well as baseline monitoring	
Patient education and information in collaboration with the surgeon, and nursing staff	Restricted sodium and fluid infusion. Goal directed fluid therapy. Prevent hyponatremia, and optimization of intravascular volume avoiding hypo or hypervolemia. The use of electrical cardiometry device could be a guide to goal-directed fluid therapy, noninvasive determination of stroke volume and cardiac output	No nasogastric tube	
Scheduling period of fasting or no fasting	Regional anesthesia (when indicated): (1) Epidural anesthesia (mid-thoracic, lumbar, epidural catheter should be inserted between T5 and T8 roots levels); (2) Lumbar nerve block; (3) regional nerve block; and (4) local anesthesia	Post-operative pain relief is either through an epidural catheter that should be removed 12 h before application of anticoagulant or the use of patient-controlled analgesia	
Preoperative carbohydrate drinks are recommended for patients without diabetes. In adults, clear fluid is given 5–6 h before the procedure, and in pediatrics, 2 h	Prevent hypothermia: Body& limbs warming. Maintaining intraoperative normothermia with either passive (surgical draping, sheets, and blanket), or active with electric heating blanket, space heater, or the burr hugger	Encourage early and progressive patient mobilization	
Nutritional status should be assessed using a systemic screening tool, and malnourished patients should be optimized with oral
Supplements, or parental nutrition	Prevention of PONV. Preemptive multimodal antiemetic prophylaxis should be used in all at-risk patients to reduce PONV. An intervention for patients determined to be high-risk for PONV is the administration of dexamethasone (8 mg) at the induction of anesthesia and ondansetron (Zofran) (4 mg) at emergence from anesthesia. The combination of ondansetron with dexamethasone is superior to single-agent therapy in the prevention of PONV in moderate- to high-risk patients undergoing abdominal surgery	Non-opioid analgesia	
Prophylactics for thromboembolic events	Patients at high risk, it is recommended to use low-molecular-weight heparin	Early removing of urinary catheter	
Antibiotic prophylactic		Evaluation of outcome	
PONV: Post-operative nausea and vomiting; ICU: Intensive care unit.

The ERAS pathway has a number of components that enhance hemodynamic and perioperative fluid treatment. Liberal fluid treatment has been replaced by more customized methods in modern perioperative fluid management. One critical component is ensuring appropriate mean arterial pressure and preventing intraoperative hypotension. Heart output monitoring is used in goal-directed hemodynamic treatment (GDHT) to direct the administration of fluid and vasopressors, reduces complications and is best suited to high-risk patients or in high-risk procedures. ERAS pathways aid in providing proper hemodynamic management regarding fluid and hemodynamic therapy approaches[19]

Economic, cost, and clinical benefits of enhanced recovery after surgery in major oncology surgery

Pancreaticoduodenectomy: ERAS accelerates recovery and improves clinical outcomes. However, the evidence on cost benefit of ERAS has not been well evaluated in terms of cost benefit, compliance, and clinical benefits. A study on pancreaticoduodenectomy comparing ERAS programs and traditional care on hospital cost, length of stay, complications, delayed gastric emptying, readmission, reoperation, mortality, and compliance. The study showed that hospital costs were significantly reduced in the ERAS group, and the length of stay was shortened by 3.15 d in the ERAS group. Fewer patients in the ERAS group had complications. Incidences of delayed gastric emptying had significantly decreased in the ERAS group. The number of deaths was fewer in the ERAS group. ERAS implementation did not change readmissions and reoperations rate compared to traditional techniques. ERAS delivers significant cost savings, better clinical outcomes, and a lower rate of complications[20].

Hepatectomy: Addressing the economics of ERAS compared to conventional treatment, multiple elements are considered: Cost-effectiveness analysis, cost-benefit analysis and cost-minimization analysis, and capital flow diagram analysis. ERAS considerably lowers the overall social cost ($5958.67 vs $6725.80) and the financial burden of disease on patients ($8935.02 vs $10470.02). The average daily cost per capita in the ERAS group increased ($669.51 vs $589.98), according to a capital flow diagram study, but the advantages were contingent on lower hospital stays and less productivity loss. ERAS reduces the average length of stay, consequently reducing the economic burden and promoting the hospital bed turnover rate[21].

The role of nurses within enhanced recovery after surgery

As the healthcare providers that interact with patients the most during the perioperative pathway, nurses are recognized for their critical role in implementing numerous ERAS components. To guarantee highly educated nurses and optimal ERAS implementation, ongoing ERAS training will be necessary.

Nurses may fulfill extended roles in the postoperative period in certain types of surgery, such as coordinating pain management, mobilization, and oral feeding, along with the collection and analysis of data. Nurses should have a significant role in the preoperative period, the early postoperative phase, and the follow-up period[22].

CONCLUSION

The concept of ERAS has been practiced for decades; it has been developed and modified for implementation in mostly all surgical specialties. Recently, ERAS has been implemented in pediatric surgery, elderly patients, laparoscopic and robotic surgery, and organ transplantation. Eras costs are higher than traditional care; on the other side, the benefit of ERAS for the patient’s clinical outcome and satisfaction is higher. ERAS is in progress in anesthetic tasks, pediatric surgery, and organ transplantation. Although ERAS has shown significant clinical outcomes, there are needs to modify the protocol to the specific case, hospital facilities, resources, and nurses training on elements of ERAS.

Conflict-of-interest statement: All authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose.

Provenance and peer review: Invited article; Externally peer reviewed.

Peer-review model: Single blind

Specialty type: Surgery

Country of origin: Egypt

Peer-review report’s classification

Scientific Quality: Grade B, Grade C, Grade D, Grade D, Grade D

Novelty: Grade B, Grade C, Grade C, Grade C, Grade D

Creativity or Innovation: Grade B, Grade B, Grade C, Grade C, Grade D

Scientific Significance: Grade B, Grade C, Grade C, Grade C, Grade C

P-Reviewer: Gupta A, India; Rasa HK, Türkiye; Sarac E, Türkiye S-Editor: Liu JH L-Editor: A P-Editor: Yu HG
==== Refs
1 Nag DS Swain A Sahu S Sahoo A Wadhwa G Multidisciplinary approach toward enhanced recovery after surgery for total knee arthroplasty improves outcomes World J Clin Cases 2024 12 1549 1554 38576736
2 Sun MH Wu LS Qiu YY Yan J Li XQ Enhanced recovery after surgery in elderly patients with non-small cell lung cancer who underwent video-assisted thoracic surgery World J Clin Cases 2024 12 2040 2049 38680260
3 Ljungqvist O de Boer HD Balfour A Fawcett WJ Lobo DN Nelson G Scott MJ Wainwright TW Demartines N Opportunities and Challenges for the Next Phase of Enhanced Recovery After Surgery: A Review JAMA Surg 2021 156 775 784 33881466
4 Ljungqvist O Gustafsson U de Boer HD 20 + Years of Enhanced Recovery After Surgery: What's Next World J Surg 2023 47 1087 1089 36820869
5 Rosa F Longo F Pozzo C Strippoli A Quero G Fiorillo C Mele MC Alfieri S Enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) vs standard recovery for gastric cancer patients: The evidences and the issues Surg Oncol 2022 41 101727 35189515
6 Schwenk W [Enhanced recovery after surgery-Does the ERAS concept keep its promises] Chirurg 2021 92 405 420 33481060
7 Dong J Lei Y Wan Y Dong P Wang Y Liu K Zhang X Enhanced recovery after surgery from 1997 to 2022: a bibliometric and visual analysis Updates Surg 2024
8 Pozo C Shariat SF D'Andrea D Fajkovic H Abufaraj M Enhanced Recovery after Radical Cystectomy Curr Opin Urol 2019 29 227 238 30950886
9 Schulz GB Volz Y Jokisch F Casuscelli J Eismann L Pfitzinger P Stief CG Schlenker B [Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS®) after radical cystectomy-current data] Urologe A 2021 60 162 168 33439288
10 Mendoza-Vélez MLÁ Cárdenas-Lailson LE Barlandas-Quintana E Zubillaga-Mares A Use of enhanced recovery after surgery protocol in laparoscopic cholecystectomy in patients with symptomatic cholelithiasis Cir Cir 2022 90 50 55
11 Changjun C Xin Z Yue L Liyile C Pengde K Key Elements of Enhanced Recovery after Total Joint Arthroplasty: A Reanalysis of the Enhanced Recovery after Surgery Guidelines Orthop Surg 2023 15 671 678 36597677
12 Haid B Lusuardi L Oswald J [Enhanced recovery after surgery-a concept, also in pediatrics] Urologe A 2020 59 294 299 31980855
13 Rove KO Strine AC Wilcox DT Vricella GJ Welch TP VanderBrink B Chu DI Chaudhry R Zee RS Brockel MA PURSUE Study group Design and development of the Pediatric Urology Recovery After Surgery Endeavor (PURSUE) multicentre pilot and exploratory study BMJ Open 2020 10 e039035
14 Gu YX Wang XY Chen Y Shao JX Ni SX Zhang XM Shao SY Zhang Y Hu WJ Ma YY Liu MY Yu H Optimizing surgical outcomes for elderly gallstone patients with a high body mass index using enhanced recovery after surgery protocol World J Gastrointest Surg 2023 15 2191 2200 37969721
15 Tan JHS Bhatia K Sharma V Swamy M van Dellen D Dhanda R Khambalia H Enhanced recovery after surgery recommendations for renal transplantation: guidelines Br J Surg 2022 110 57 59 36168725
16 Sun SD Wu PP Zhou JF Wang JX He QL Failure of enhanced recovery after surgery in laparoscopic colorectal surgery: a systematic review Int J Colorectal Dis 2020 35 1007 1014 32361938
17 Mancel L Van Loon K Lopez AM Role of regional anesthesia in Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) protocols Curr Opin Anaesthesiol 2021 34 616 625 34325463
18 de Boer HD Scott MJ Fawcett WJ Anaesthesia role in enhanced recovery after surgery: a revolution in care outcomes Curr Opin Anaesthesiol 2023 36 202 207 36745085
19 French WB Scott M Fluid and Hemodynamics Anesthesiol Clin 2022 40 59 71 35236583
20 Noba L Rodgers S Doi L Chandler C Hariharan D Yip V Costs and clinical benefits of enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) in pancreaticoduodenectomy: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis J Cancer Res Clin Oncol 2023 149 6639 6660 36629919
21 Dong Y Zhang Y Jin C Comprehensive economic evaluation of enhanced recovery after surgery in hepatectomy Int J Equity Health 2021 20 245 34774038
22 Wainwright TW Jakobsen DH Kehlet H The current and future role of nurses within enhanced recovery after surgery pathways Br J Nurs 2022 31 656 659 35736850
