
==== Front
Int J Sports Phys Ther
Int J Sports Phys Ther
2159
International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy
2159-2896
NASMI Website: International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy

37547837
84308
10.26603/001c.84308
Original Research
Two-Dimensional and Three-Dimensional Biomechanical Factors During 90° Change of Direction are Associated to Non-Contact ACL injury in Female Soccer Players
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1761-7352
Di Paolo Stefano 1
Grassi Alberto 2
Tosarelli Filippo 3
Crepaldi Matteo 3
Bragonzoni Laura 1
Zaffagnini Stefano 2
Della Villa Francesco 3
1 Life Quality Studies University of Bologna https://ror.org/01111rn36
2 2nd Orthopaedic and Traumatologic Clinic Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli https://ror.org/02ycyys66
3 Education and Research Department Isokinetic Medical Group
Corresponding author Stefano Di Paolo Department for Life Quality Studies QUVI Università di Bologna Via Giulio Cesare Pupilli, 1, 40136 Bologna (BO), Italy ORCID ID: 0000-0002-1761-7352
1 8 2023
2023
18 4 887897
20 4 2023
4 7 2023
© The Author(s)
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (4.0) which permits non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Background

The two-dimensional (2D) video-analysis of the change of direction (COD) technique has never been used to attempt to predict the risk of ACL injury in female football players.

Hypothesis/Purpose

The purpose of the present pilot study was to prospectively investigate the biomechanical predictors of ACL injury during a COD task in female football players using both gold standard 3D motion capture and a qualitative scoring system based on 2D video-analysis.

Study Design

Prospective cohort study

Methods

Sixteen competitive female football (soccer) players (age 21.4 ± 4.3) performed a series of pre-planned 90° COD tasks. 3D motion data was recorded through 10 stereophotogrammetric cameras and a force platform. 2D frontal and transverse plane joint kinematics were computed through video-analysis from three high-speed cameras. A scoring system based on five criteria was adopted: limb stability, pelvis stability, trunk stability, shock absorption, and movement strategy. The players were prospectively followed for the next two consecutive football seasons and the occurrence of severe knee injuries was registered.

Results

Four players (25%) experienced an ACL injury. In 3D analysis, ACL-injured players showed greater knee valgus, knee internal rotation, and lower knee flexion (p= 0.017 – 0.029). Lower hip flexion coupled with greater external rotation (p= 0.003 – 0.042), ankle eversion, and contralateral pelvic drop (p<0.001) were also noted. In 2D analysis, ACL-injured players showed greater internal foot rotation, contralateral pelvic drop, lower knee flexion, and contralateral trunk tilt (moderate-to-large effect size). Pelvis stability and trunk stability showed the highest predictive value towards ACL injury. Total score was significantly lower in ACL-injured players with a moderate effect size (d=0.45).

Conclusions

Both 3D and 2D methodologies depicted biomechanical risk factors and offered predictive insights towards the ACL injury risk. Awareness should rise in women’s football regarding the high risk of ACL injury and the strategies to assess and mitigate it.

Level of Evidence

3

ACL
female football
biomechanics
2D video-analysis
injury prevention
change of direction
None.
==== Body
pmcINTRODUCTION

The rapid growth of women’s football (soccer) participation is bringing about increasing rates and earlier occurrence of primary Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) injury.1,2 Several authors have demonstrated that female footballers are at overall higher risk of ACL injury than their male counterparts1,3,4 and are less responsive to targeted preventative interventions e.g., the FIFA 11+ program.1,5,6

Therefore, a deeper comprehension of modifiable risk factors, such as ACL injury biomechanics, has been advocated to mitigate the injury risk in female football academies.7,8 Standardized methodologies are crucial to obtain objective measurements of players’ movement quality and identify ACL injury predictors in a user- and athlete-friendly fashion.

The 3D motion capture is the gold standard for biomechanical assessment of high-demanding tasks and has been used in prospective investigations of ACL injury predictors.7,9 Recently, 2D video-analysis has been proposed as a cost-effective alternative to 3D motion capture for high-demand tasks. Promising results have reported regarding the association between 2D angles (frontal plane knee, pelvis, and trunk angle; limited knee and hip flexion) and scoring systems (Movement Analysis Test, Cutting Movement Assessment Score) based on video-analysis and well-known ACL risk factors such as the knee abduction moment (KAM) and high vertical and posterior ground reaction forces (GRF).10–13 Such 2D scoring systems allow for simpler movement analysis for the raters and quicker feedback to the athletes, making them an attractive solution to implement large screenings in young population.12–14

However, the efficacy of 2D video-analysis in determine the risk of the occurrence of ACL injury has never been assessed prospectively in male nor female football players. The efficacy of 2D video-analysis and its agreement with 3D motion capture would support the use of dedicated methodologies to test female football players in primary ACL injury prevention.

The purpose of the present pilot study was to prospectively investigate the biomechanical predictors of ACL injury during a COD task in female football players using both gold standard 3D motion capture and a qualitative scoring system based on 2D video-analysis. The hypothesis was that both the 3D motion capture and the 2D scoring system would detect clinically-relevant biomechanical differences between non-injured and ACL-injured players such as shallower lower limb flexion and dynamic valgus.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB approval ID number: 555/2018/Sper/IOR of 12/09/2018) of Area Vasta Emilia Romagna Centro (AVEC, Bologna, Italy) and registered on ClinicalTrials.gov (Identifier: NCT03840551). Signed informed consent were collected from all participants before enrollment.

Participants

This represents a secondary analysis of a larger cross-sectional study aimed to investigate the concurrent validity of different methodologies (wearable inertial sensors and 2D video-analysis) for examining high-demand motion tasks for ACL injury prevention and rehabilitation.10,15 The analysis was conducted in the Education and Research Department of the Isokinetic Medical Group during the regular football season (February 2019). Sixteen young competitive (first-to-third Italian Football division) female football (soccer) players (age 21.4 ± 4.3, range 18-31) were enrolled in the study. Exclusion criteria were: evidence of previous severe injury (> 28 days recovery time); previous surgery to the lower limbs; body mass index (BMI) > 35; and cardiopulmonary or cardiovascular disorders.

Data Collection

Each player performed a series of pre-planned 90° COD tasks at maximum speed possible in a specialized laboratory equipped with artificial turf. The players wore their own running shoes and clothes. The COD task consisted of a 6-meter frontal sprint followed by a 90° sidestep cut with foot strike on a force platform and a further 3-meter sprint. The complete acquisition setting was previously described.10 In brief, a 10-minute dynamic warm-up and few unrecorded repetitions of the movement were performed by each player to get confident with the setting. The players were instructed by a single sport & exercise medicine physician specialized in sports biomechanics (F.D.V.), who also verified the validity of each trial. Full foot contact on the force platform was required to consider a trial valid. Each player performed six valid trials with three right and three left strikes.

3D motion data and 2D video-analysis data were collected simultaneously. 3D Motion data were recorded through a set of 10 stereophotogrammetric cameras (VICON Nexus, Vicon Motion Systems Ltd, Oxford, UK) and a force platform embedded in the floor (AMTI 400*600, Watertown, MA USA), and three high-speed cameras placed frontally and bilaterally towards movement direction to capture 2D data. The systems were synchronized for direct data comparison. The sampling rate was 120 Hz for cameras and force platform, and 100 Hz for the high-speed cameras.

The system calibration was performed at the beginning of the acquisition and repeated periodically during the session. Forty-two retroreflective markers were placed on each participant by a single expert user according to the full-body Plug-in Gait protocol. Anthropometric data were collected for each participant and model calibration was performed before data acquisition.

Data Processing – 3D Motion Capture

Marker trajectories were collected through the stereophotogrammetric cameras and interpolated through a spline-based algorithm. The lower limb and pelvis kinematics were computed through VICON Nexus software using the Cardan angles. The frontal, transverse and sagittal plane kinematics waveforms were extracted for the stance phase of the foot on the force platform. The positively defined rotations (+) were: knee varus and internal rotation, hip adduction and internal rotation, ankle inversion and internal rotation, and pelvis contralateral drop and rotation.

Data Processing – 2D Video Analysis

The 2D frontal and transverse plane joint kinematics was computed through video-analysis. The evaluation was performed in a specific VICON software environment through the recordings of the three high-speed cameras. Joint kinematics was evaluated at the frame of maximal knee flexion angle after the foot contact on the force platform. For each trial, the following 2D angles were calculated: Foot Projection Angle (FPA), Frontal Plane Knee Projection Angle (FPKPA), Pelvis tilt Angle (PA), and Trunk tilt Angle (TA). Furthermore, a scoring system was adopted based on the 2D kinematics.10,16 Five scoring criteria were used to evaluate each COD trial: limb stability (LS), pelvis stability (PS), trunk stability (TS), shock absorption (SA), and movement strategy (MS). The detailed description of each criteria was reported in a previous study.10 In brief, a score from 0/2 to 2/2 (non-adequate to adequate) was attributed to the trial for each criterion based on objective 2D measurements by a single sports physician. The total score was computed as the sum of each criterion sub-score (maximum total score: 10/10).

Prospective Follow-up

The players were prospectively followed for the next two consecutive football seasons through regular phone calls. The occurrence of severe knee injuries (> 28 days recovery time) was registered. In case of an ACL injury, an MRI and a clinical examination were carried out to confirm the presence of the ACL tear. Additional information, e.g., the nature of the injury mechanism (non-contact, indirect contact, contact) and the context (training, match), were retrieved.

Statistical Analysis

Based on the occurrence of an ACL injury during the follow-up period, the players were divided into two groups: “No injury” and “ACL injury”. Kinematic data were retrieved for the injured and dominant leg for the latter and former group, respectively.17 The normal distribution of the data was verified through the Shapiro-Wilk test. The categorical variables were presented as a percentage over the total, while the continuous variables were presented as mean ± standard deviation (95% Confidence Interval – CI).

For the 3D kinematics waveforms, the two-tailed Student’s t-test with Statistical Parametric Mapping (SPM) was used to investigate the difference between the two groups.18

For the 2D analysis, the two-tailed Student’s t-test was used to compare continuous 2D kinematics variables, and Cohen’s d effect size was reported. Effect size was considered small, medium, and large for Cohen’s d value of 0.2, 0.5, and 0.8, respectively. Furthermore, the Chi-square test for 3x2 (3 scores x 2 groups) contingency tables was computed to investigate the differences in the 2D scoring system percentage between the two groups for each of the five criteria. The Mann-Whitney U test was used to investigate the differences in the total score and in non-normally distributed variables, and Rank Biserial Correlation was reported as effect size measure. Differences were considered statistically significant for p<0.05. The statistical analyses were conducted in Matlab (The MathWorks, Natick, MA, US) and SPSS (IBM, Armonk, NY, US).

Given the pilot nature of the present study, no a-priori power-analysis was performed. However, the present cohort of 16 participants is consistent with previous pilot studies with similar purpose and methodological accuracy showing a minimum power of 0.80 for the analysis of frontal and sagittal plane knee and hip kinematics.19,20

RESULTS

Overall, four players out of 16 (25% of the cohort) experienced an ACL injury during the two football seasons following the data collection. All injuries occurred during football matches with a non-contact mechanism. A complete ACL rupture in all injured athletes was confirmed through MRI examination. No other severe joint/muscle injuries were reported. Age at the time of data collection was significantly lower (p=0.009) in the ACL-injured group, while no differences (p<0.05) were found in demographics and approaching COD speed between ACL-injured and non-injured players (Table 1).

172577 Table 1. Demographic data of the subjects enrolled in the study according to the occurrence of ACL injury during the following two football seasons.

	All
(n=16)	No ACL injury
(n=12)	ACL injury
(n=4)	p-⁠value	
Age	21.4 ± 4.3 [19.3 – 23.5]	22.4 ± 4.5 [19.8 – 24.9]	18.3 ± 0.5 [17.8 – 18.8]	0.009	
Height (cm)	166.8 ± 6.7 [163.5 –⁠ 170.1]	167.7 ± 6.3 [157.4 –⁠ 164.6]	164.0 ± 8.1 [156.1 –⁠ 171.9]	n.s.	
Weight (kg)	58.1 ± 4.4 [55.9 – 60.3]	58.3 ± 4.7 [55.6 – 61.0]	57.5 ± 4.2 [53.4 – 61.6]	n.s.	
BMI	20.9 ± 1.7 [20.1 – 21.7]	20.8 ± 1.9 [19.7 – 21.9]	21.4 ± 1.3 [20.1 – 22.7]	n.s.	
Dominant limb (r/l)	14/2	11/1	3/1	n.s.	
COD Approaching speed (m/s)	2.7 ± 0.6 [2.4 – 3.0]	2.6 ± 0.6 [2.3 – 2.9]	2.8 ± 0.5 [2.3 –3.3]	n.s.	
Notes: Data were expressed as mean ± standard deviation [95% confidence intervals]. COD=Change of Direction; n.s.=non-statistically significant difference (p>0.05). Dominant limb is meant as the preferred one used to kick a ball.

3D Motion Capture

The ACL-injured players showed greater knee valgus (p=0.029) and internal rotation (p=0.017) during the early stance phase and lower knee flexion (p=0.023) during the late stance phase (Figure 1, first row). Less hip flexion (p=0.042) coupled with greater external rotation (p=0.003) were also noted in the ACL-injured group (Figure 1, second row). Furthermore, ACL-injured players showed greater ankle eversion tendency and contralateral pelvic drop (p<0.001, Figure 1, third and fourth row).

172578 Figure 1. Joint kinematics in frontal, transverse, and sagittal plane from 3D motion capture for knee (first row), hip (second row), ankle (third row), and pelvis (fourth row) joints.

Notes: Data were normalized over the last stance phase before the 90° change of direction and reported as mean (solid lines) and standard deviation (dashed bars) for non-injured (blue) and ACL-injured (red) players. Student’s t-test in SPM was reported with statistically significant differences represented by black lines (p<0.05). Positive rotations: varus (knee), adduction (hip), inversion (ankle), contralateral drop (pelvis); internal rotation (knee, hip, ankle), contralateral rotation (pelvis); flexion (knee, hip, pelvis), dorsiflexion (ankle).

2D Video Analysis

ACL-injured players showed greater internal foot rotation, pelvic contralateral drop, lower knee flexion (moderate effect size), and contralateral trunk tilt (large effect size, Table 2, Figure 2). Pelvis stability and trunk stability scores showed the highest predictive value towards ACL injury (significantly more 0/2 scores in ACL-injured players, Table 3, Figure 3). Total score was significantly lower in ACL-injured players (moderate effect size), that never scored greater than 7/10 (Table 3, Figure 4).

172579 Table 2. Joint kinematics (°) extracted from 2D video-analysis according to the occurrence of ACL injury during the following two football seasons.

2D angle	No ACL injury (n=12)	ACL injury (n=4)	p-⁠value	Cohen’s d	
Foot Progression Angle	-15.2 ± 19.4 [-26.2 – -4.2]	-25.2 ± 19.9 [-44.7 – -5.7]	0.041	0.51	
Frontal Plane Knee Projection Angle	36.8 ± 17.2 [27.1 – 46.5]	41.8 ± 8.1 [33.9 – 49.7]	n.s.	0.23	
Pelvic Drop Angle	-9.9 ± 7.7 [-14.3 – -5.5]	-12.9 ± 9.1 [-21.8 – -3.9]	0.022	0.38	
Trunk Tilt Angle	4.2 ± 7.4 [0.1 – 8.4]	-5.7 ± 11.7 [-17.2 – 5.8]	<0.001	1.11	
α (180°-Knee Flexion Angle)	118.7 ± 10.7 [112.6 –⁠ 124.8]	124.3 ± 10.5 [114.0 –⁠ 134.6]	0.026	0.53	
Notes: Data were expressed as mean ± standard deviation [95% confidence intervals]. n.s.=non-statistically significant difference (p>0.05). Positive rotations: foot external rotation, knee valgus, pelvic contralateral hike, trunk ipsilateral tilt.

172580 Figure 2. Joint kinematics from 2D video-analysis. Data are presented as mean and standard deviation for the non-injured (blue) and ACL-injured (red) players.

Notes: Asterisks represent statistically significant differences between the two groups (p<0.05). FPA (Foot Progression Angle), FPKPA (Frontal Plane Knee Projection Angle), PA (Pelvic Drop Angle), TA (Trunk Tilt Angle), α (180°-Knee Flexion Angle). Positive rotations: foot external rotation, knee valgus, pelvic contralateral hike, trunk ipsilateral tilt.

172581 Table 3. Frequencies (%) of single sub-scores for the qualitative scoring system from 2D video-analysis according to the occurrence of ACL injury during the following two football seasons.

Score	No ACL injury (n=12)	ACL injury (n=4)	p-value	Cohen’s d	
	0	1	2	0	1	2			
Limb Stability	87.0	7.4	5.6	95.8	4.2	0.0	n.s.	1.8	
Pelvis Stability	48.1	27.8	24.1	87.5	12.5	0.0	0.003	11.7	
Trunk Stability	18.5	46.3	35.2	58.3	20.8	20.8	0.002	12.5	
Shock Absorption	16.7	59.3	24.1	25.0	66.7	8.3	n.s.	2.9	
Motor Strategy	16.7	29.6	53.7	29.2	29.2	41.7	n.s.	1.8	
Total Score	4.6 ± 2.8 [3.0 – 6.2]	2.4 ± 1.8 [0.6 – 4.2]	0.001	0.45	
Notes: Total score data were as mean ± standard deviation [95% confidence intervals]. n.s.=non-statistically significant difference (p>0.05).

172582 Figure 3. 2D score assigned through video-analysis.

Notes: Frequency distribution (%) are presented for the non-injured (blue) and ACL-injured (red) players for each of the 5 sub-criteria. P-value and Chi-square for each contingency table is shown.

172583 Figure 4. 2D Total score frequency distribution (%) for the non-injured (blue) and ACL-injured (red) players.

Notes: The score ranges from 0/10 (worst) to 10/10 (best).

DISCUSSION

The main finding of the present study was that both the 3D motion capture and 2D analysis of the COD technique offered predictive insights towards the ACL injury risk in female football players. Significant differences between players experiencing an ACL injury in the two seasons after testing and non-injured players were consistent with the current literature on non-contact ACL injury biomechanics.21–24 Moreover, the 2D scoring system successfully identified the ACL-injured players, that showed a lower total score (Figure 4). Thus, such a scoring system has the potential to identify female footballers at high risk for ACL injury in a cost-effective fashion.

A video-analysis study by Lucarno et al. recently described the ACL situational patterns and injury mechanism of professional female footballers, highlighting the frequent occurrence of non-contact or indirect contact injuries with multiplanar biomechanics.23 Injury biomechanics included knee dynamic valgus, limited lower limb flexion, pelvis and trunk tilt and rotation, and ankle rotation, consistently with the one of male counterparts.25 In the present study, all the differences found between ACL-inured and non-injured players agreed with the typical biomechanical profile for non-contact ACL injury described by Lucarno et al. and Della Villa et al.23,25

The ACL-injured players exhibited greater knee valgus and internal rotation and hip external rotation (Figure 1). These patterns have been shown to increase the KAM and the load on knee ligaments.24,26,27 In LS score, none of the ACL-injured players’ tasks was rated as 2/2. However, no differences in FPKPA were found and the overall rating was shifted towards the 0/2 score (Figure 2). These findings suggest a good sensitivity but a lower specificity of the LS score and the FPKPA for the ACL injury risk, in line with previous literature on other functional tests.28,29

Lower hip and knee flexion angles were also observed in the ACL-injured players in both 3D and 2D joint angles. Though not happening in the early stance phase, these results suggest a stiffer kinematic strategy adopted by the ACL-injured players.23,30,31

Pelvic drop was detected during the whole stance phase in the players that sustained an ACL injury (Figure 1). Pelvic drop and trunk lean in the ACL-injured players were also detected through the PA and TA 2D angles with a moderate-to-large effect. The PS and TS criteria strongly were the best predictors of ACL injury in the 2D scoring system: the percentage of trials rated 0/2 in the ACL-injured players was double than the non-injured players in the PS, and triple in the TS. Moreover, ACL-injured players were never rated 2/2 in PS. The association between poor core stability and the risk of knee overloading has been proposed in literature.12,13 The video-analysis studies on professional athletes clearly identified that ACL injuries happen with pelvis and trunk in non-neutral position.23,25 Donelon et al. recently listed the maintenance of an upright pelvis and trunk position among the actions aimed to modify the COD technique and mitigate the ACL injury risk.22 The results of the present study suggest that the analysis of pelvis and trunk frontal plane kinematics in 2D could effectively detect core imbalance during the COD task and that the scoring system described could have a strong predictive power towards the risk of ACL injury.

Greater ankle eversion was noted in the players that sustained an ACL injury in the second half of the stance phase (Figure 1). The 2D analysis revealed a more internal foot progression angle at peak knee flexion. Both aspects of the foot position indicate that ACL-injured players landed on the force platform adopting a more anticipatory strategy than the non-injured players. An anticipatory strategy with a greater internal foot progression angle has been associated with faster cutting but in conflict with a safe mechanism.32 Foot eversion and rotation are also common in the professional football players that sustain an ACL injury.23,25 The analysis of foot progression angle could give valuable insights on the attitude of players COD technique and strongly influence joint loading propagation on the kinetic chain.

The 2D total score proposed in the present study distinguished the players that sustained an ACL injury from the non-injured ones. Average total score was lower in the ACL-injured players (4.6 vs 2.4, moderate effect, Table 3) and none of the ACL-injured players’ trials were rated more than 7/10 (Figure 4). The total score is an intuitive measure that can be used by the professionals to track a player’s overall movement quality during the COD task and her progression over a prevention (or rehabilitation) program. From the results of the present pilot study, a total score of 4/10 or lower could be indicative or higher risk for ACL injury, while a score higher than 7/10 could be indicative of a protective COD technique.

The multiplanar risk factors detected in the players that sustained an ACL after testing were extremely congruent with the injury mechanism proposed in video-analysis studies on professional female footballers (Figure 5).23 Both the 3D motion capture and 2D video-analysis detected and agreed on most of the clinically-relevant differences. In the 2D video-analysis, frontal plane was indicative of a higher injury risk, but both frontal and sagittal view would be required to obtain a comprehensive measure of COD movement quality. Knee abduction angle, frequently used in multiple 2D assessments for this and other tasks (e.g., drop vertical jump, squats, and single-leg landings), might be not sufficient to explain the movement complexity and the relation with the ACL injury risk.28,29,33 Furthermore, approaching and landing strategies such as penultimate foot contact deceleration, anticipatory cut, flatfoot or heel strike, should be taken into account to finetune the assessment.11,12,22,34

172584 Figure 5. ACL injury frame (left) of one of the players involved in the prospective cohort. The frontal (middle, up) and sagittal (right, up) view of the 90° change of direction test performed with the involved limb is reported.

Notes: The associated 2D total score was 2/10 (bottom).

In the present study, 25% of the cohort experienced an ACL injury. Previous larger prospective studies reported an injury rate of 7-11%.29,35,36 In the present study, the tests were performed in late February, thus close to one of the two peaks of injury occurrence identified in professional football players.23 All injuries occurred during matches and without a direct contact with an opponent. This is again in line with the predominance of non-contact/indirect contact mechanisms found in professional female footballers (88%23). The fact that ACL-injured players were younger (p=0.009) than the rest of the cohort is consistent with the data reporting earlier occurrence (younger age) of the first ACL injury in female football.37 All these aspects deserve awareness from the football medicine community and highlight the urgent need for dedicated tools to counteract such a high injury risk since more and more female players turn professional earlier.

The present study has some limitations. First, the present pilot investigation involved a small cohort; thus, inferences should be interpreted with caution and are far from being conclusive. Despite the sample size, the results of both the 2D and 3D analyses were consistent with current literature on ACL injury risk biomechanics.21–24 Prospective studies with larger cohorts are necessary to set a benchmark for objective measurements in ACL injury prevention in football. Second, the 90° COD task assessed in the present study was pre-planned. Recent studies suggest that unanticipated sidestepping tasks could offer important insights on ACL injury risk.38 Preventative testing should consider the use of both pre-planned and unplanned tasks to get a wider understanding of players’ injury risk. No muscular strength data were collected. Such data could have increased the level of detail of the players’ comparison. The data collection was performed in a single session and no post-operative investigation was performed on those who were injured. The longitudinal analysis of the ACL-injured players could be used to quantitatively inform the ACL rehabilitation programs.

The clinical relevance of the present work is that the adoption of a 2D video-analysis scoring system based on quantitative measurements has the potential to identify female football players at higher risk for ACL injury in a cost-effective fashion. The players could therefore benefit from additional preventative neuromuscular training. Given the rapid growth of female football and their greater predisposition to the ACL injury,4,39 dedicated methodologies assessing players’ movement quality and injury risk are fundamental to mitigate the injury rates in early football careers.

CONCLUSION

Significant kinematic differences during a planned COD task were identified between ACL injured and non-injured players with both the 3D and 2D methodologies. The biomechanical pattern of the ACL-injured players was strongly consistent with the video-analysis of ACL injured elite players.23 Both the 3D and 2D methodologies offered precious predictive insights to assess and mitigate the ACL injury risk in women’s football.

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)

Body Mass Index (BMI)

Body Weight (BW)

Change of Direction (COD)

Confidence intervals (CI)

Foot Projection Angle (FPA)

Frontal Plane Knee Projection Angle (FPKPA)

Ground Reaction Force (GRF)

Knee Abduction Moment (KAM)

Limb Stability (LS)

Movement strategy (MS)

Pelvis tilt angle (PA)

Pelvis stability (PS)

Shock absorption (SA)

Statistical Parametric Mapping (SPM)

Trunk tilt angle (TA)

Trunk stability (TS)

Conflict of interest

Each author certifies that he or she has no commercial associations (e.g., consultancies, stock ownership, equity interest, patent/licensing arrangements, etc) that might pose a conflict of interest in connection with the submitted article.

Acknowledgments

The authors want to thank GPEM s.r.l. for the support in data collection.
==== Refs
Injury prevention knowledge, beliefs and strategies in elite female footballers at the FIFA Women’s World Cup France 2019 British Journal of Sports Medicine Geertsema Celeste Geertsema Liesel Farooq Abdulaziz Harøy Joar Oester Chelsea Weber Alexis Bahr Roald 4 1 2021
55 14 801 806 0306-3674 10.1136/bjsports-2020-103131 10.1136/bjsports-2020-103131
A scoping review on developmental activities of girls' and women's sports Frontiers in Sports and Active Living Peters Carrie M. Hendry David T. Hodges Nicola J. 23 9 2022
4 903886 2624-9367 10.3389/fspor.2022.903886 10.3389/fspor.2022.903886 36213454
Are female soccer players at an increased risk of second anterior cruciate ligament injury compared with their athletic peers? The American Journal of Sports Medicine Allen Melissa M. Pareek Ayoosh Krych Aaron J. Hewett Timothy E. Levy Bruce A. Stuart Michael J. Dahm Diane L. 20 7 2016
44 10 2492 2498 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546516648439 10.1177/0363546516648439
Increased risk of ACL injury for female but not male soccer players on artificial turf versus natural grass: a systematic review and meta-analysis Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine Xiao Michelle Lemos Jacie L. Hwang Calvin E. Sherman Seth L. Safran Marc R. Abrams Geoffrey D. 1 8 2022
10 8 23259671221114350 2325-9671 10.1177/23259671221114353 10.1177/23259671221114353 35990873
Effect of the FIFA 11+ on landing patterns and baseline movement errors in elite male youth soccer players Journal of Sport Rehabilitation Akbari Hadi Sahebozamani Mansour Daneshjoo Ablolhamid Amiri-Khorasani Mohammadtaghi Shimokochi Yohei 1 8 2020
29 6 730 737 1056-6716 10.1123/jsr.2018-0374 10.1123/jsr.2018-0374
Does the FIFA 11+ injury prevention program reduce the incidence of ACL injury in male soccer players? Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research Silvers-Granelli Holly J. Bizzini Mario Arundale Amelia Mandelbaum Bert R. Snyder-Mackler Lynn 10 2017
475 10 2447 2455 0009-921X 10.1007/s11999-017-5342-5 10.1007/s11999-017-5342-5 28389864
Preventive biomechanics: a paradigm shift with a translational approach to injury prevention The American Journal of Sports Medicine Hewett Timothy E. Bates Nathaniel A. 15 2 2017
45 11 2654 2664 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546516686080 10.1177/0363546516686080 28199800
Technique determinants of knee abduction moments during pivoting in female soccer players Clinical Biomechanics Jones Paul A. Herrington Lee C. Graham-Smith Philip 1 2016
31 107 112 0268-0033 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2015.09.012 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2015.09.012
Prospective frontal plane angles used to predict ACL strain and identify those at high risk for sports-related ACL injury Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine Bates Nathaniel A. Myer Gregory D. Hale Rena F. Schilaty Nathan D. Hewett Timothy E. 1 10 2020
8 10 2325967120957646 2325-9671 10.1177/2325967120957646 10.1177/2325967120957646 33110927
A 2D video-analysis scoring system of 90° change of direction technique identifies football players with high knee abduction moment Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy Della Villa Francesco Di Paolo Stefano Santagati Dario Della Croce Edoardo Lopomo Nicola Francesco Grassi Alberto Zaffagnini Stefano 29 4 2021
30 11 3616 3625 0942-2056 10.1007/s00167-021-06571-2 10.1007/s00167-021-06571-2 33912979
A 2D qualitative movement assessment of a deceleration task detects football players with high knee joint loading Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy Di Paolo Stefano Zaffagnini Stefano Tosarelli Filippo Aggio Fabrizio Bragonzoni Laura Grassi Alberto Della Villa Francesco 4 9 2021
29 12 4032 4040 0942-2056 10.1007/s00167-021-06709-2 10.1007/s00167-021-06709-2 34480582
A qualitative screening tool to identify athletes with ‘high-risk’ movement mechanics during cutting: The cutting movement assessment score (CMAS) Physical Therapy in Sport Dos’Santos Thomas McBurnie Alistair Donelon Thomas Thomas Christopher Comfort Paul Jones Paul A. 7 2019
38 152 161 1466-853X 10.1016/j.ptsp.2019.05.004 10.1016/j.ptsp.2019.05.004 31153108
Utility of 2D video analysis for assessing frontal plane trunk and pelvis motion during stepping, landing, and change in direction tasks: a validity study International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy Straub Rachel K Powers Christopher M 1 2 2022
17 2 139 147 2159-2896 10.26603/001c.30994 10.26603/001c.30994 35136682
A reliable video-based ACL injury screening tool for female team sport athletes International Journal of Sports Medicine Weir Gillian Alderson Jacqueline Smailes Natalie Elliott Bruce Donnelly Cyril 10 1 2019
40 3 191 199 0172-4622 10.1055/a-0756-9659 10.1055/a-0756-9659
Rehabilitation and return to sport assessment after anterior cruciate ligament injury: quantifying joint kinematics during complex high-speed tasks through wearable sensors Sensors Di Paolo Stefano Lopomo Nicola Francesco Della Villa Francesco Paolini Gabriele Figari Giulio Bragonzoni Laura Grassi Alberto Zaffagnini Stefano 26 3 2021
21 7 2331 1424-8220 10.3390/s21072331 10.3390/s21072331 33810610
On-field rehabilitation part 1: 4 pillars of high-quality on-field rehabilitation are restoring movement quality, physical conditioning, restoring sport-specific skills, and progressively developing chronic training load Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy Buckthorpe Matthew Della Villa Francesco Della Villa Stefano Roi Giulio Sergio 8 2019
49 8 565 569 0190-6011 10.2519/jospt.2019.8954 10.2519/jospt.2019.8954 31291553
Biomechanical measures of neuromuscular control and valgus loading of the knee predict anterior cruciate ligament injury risk in female athletes: a prospective study The American Journal of Sports Medicine Hewett Timothy E. Myer Gregory D. Ford Kevin R. Heidt Robert S. Jr. Colosimo Angelo J. McLean Scott G. van den Bogert Antonie J. Paterno Mark V. Succop Paul 4 2005
33 4 492 501 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546504269591 10.1177/0363546504269591 15722287
Zero- vs. one-dimensional, parametric vs. non-parametric, and confidence interval vs. hypothesis testing procedures in one-dimensional biomechanical trajectory analysis Journal of Biomechanics Pataky Todd C. Vanrenterghem Jos Robinson Mark A. 5 2015
48 7 1277 1285 0021-9290 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2015.02.051 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2015.02.051 25817475
Relation between peak knee flexion angle and knee ankle kinetics in single-leg jump landing from running: a pilot study on male handball players to prevent ACL injury The Physician and Sportsmedicine Ameer Mariam A. Muaidi Qassim I. 28 6 2017
45 3 337 343 0091-3847 10.1080/00913847.2017.1344514 10.1080/00913847.2017.1344514
Longitudinal Changes in hip strength and range of motion in female youth soccer players: implications for ACL injury, a pilot study Journal of Sport Rehabilitation Nguyen Anh-Dung Zuk Emma F. Baellow Andrea L. Pfile Kate R. DiStefano Lindsay J. Boling Michelle C. 9 2017
26 5 358 364 1056-6716 10.1123/jsr.2015-0197 10.1123/jsr.2015-0197 27632866
Biomechanical changes during a 90o cut in collegiate female soccer players with participation in the 11 International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy Dix Celeste Arundale Amelia Silvers-Granelli Holly Marmon Adam Zarzycki Ryan Snyder-Mackler Lynn 2 6 2021
16 3 671 680 2159-2896 10.26603/001c.22146 10.26603/001c.22146 34123519
Biomechanical Determinants of knee joint loads associated with increased anterior cruciate ligament loading during cutting: a systematic review and technical framework Sports Medicine - Open Donelon Thomas A. Dos’Santos Thomas Pitchers Guy Brown Mathew Jones Paul A. 2 11 2020
6 1 53 2199-1170 10.1186/s40798-020-00276-5 10.1186/s40798-020-00276-5 33136207
Systematic Video analysis of anterior cruciate ligament injuries in professional female soccer players The American Journal of Sports Medicine Lucarno Simona Zago Matteo Buckthorpe Matthew Grassi Alberto Tosarelli Filippo Smith Rebecca Della Villa Francesco 14 5 2021
49 7 1794 1802 0363-5465 10.1177/03635465211008169 10.1177/03635465211008169
Kinematics observed during ACL injury are associated with large early peak knee abduction moments during a change of direction task in healthy adolescents Journal of Orthopaedic Research Sigurðsson Haraldur B. Karlsson Jón Snyder-Mackler Lynn Briem Kristín 16 12 2020
39 10 2281 2290 0736-0266 10.1002/jor.24942 10.1002/jor.24942 33280158
Systematic video analysis of ACL injuries in professional male football (soccer): injury mechanisms, situational patterns and biomechanics study on 134 consecutive cases British Journal of Sports Medicine Della Villa Francesco Buckthorpe Matthew Grassi Alberto Nabiuzzi Alberto Tosarelli Filippo Zaffagnini Stefano Della Villa Stefano 19 6 2020
54 23 1423 1432 0306-3674 10.1136/bjsports-2019-101247 10.1136/bjsports-2019-101247
Longitudinal Increases in knee abduction moments in females during adolescent growth Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise Hewett Timothy E. Myer Gregory D. Kiefer Adam W. Ford Kevin R. 12 2015
47 12 2579 2585 0195-9131 10.1249/mss.0000000000000700 10.1249/mss.0000000000000700 25970663
Knee Abduction and internal rotation moments increase ACL force during landing through the posterior slope of the tibia Journal of Orthopaedic Research Navacchia Alessandro Bates Nathaniel A Schilaty Nathan D Krych Aaron J Hewett Timothy E 6 5 2019
37 8 1730 1742 0736-0266 10.1002/jor.24313 10.1002/jor.24313 30977558
The Vertical drop jump is a poor screening test for ACL injuries in female elite soccer and handball players: a prospective cohort study of 710 athletes The American Journal of Sports Medicine Krosshaug Tron Steffen Kathrin Kristianslund Eirik Nilstad Agnethe Mok Kam-Ming Myklebust Grethe Andersen Thor Einar Holme Ingar Engebretsen Lars Bahr Roald 11 2 2016
44 4 874 883 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546515625048 10.1177/0363546515625048
Drop jump? Single-leg squat? Not if you aim to predict anterior cruciate ligament injury from real-time clinical assessment: a prospective cohort study involving 880 elite female athletes Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy Petushek Erich Nilstad Agnethe Bahr Roald Krosshaug Tron 7 2021
51 7 372 378 0190-6011 10.2519/jospt.2021.10170 10.2519/jospt.2021.10170 34192883
Stiff Landings are associated with increased ACL injury risk in young female basketball and floorball players The American Journal of Sports Medicine Leppänen Mari Pasanen Kati Kujala Urho M. Vasankari Tommi Kannus Pekka Äyrämö Sami Krosshaug Tron Bahr Roald Avela Janne Perttunen Jarmo Parkkari Jari 2017
45 2 386 393 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546516665810 10.1177/0363546516665810 27637264
Limited hip and knee flexion during landing is associated with increased frontal plane knee motion and moments Clinical Biomechanics Pollard Christine D. Sigward Susan M. Powers Christopher M. 2 2010
25 2 142 146 0268-0033 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2009.10.005 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2009.10.005 19913961
Biomechanical determinants of performance and injury risk during cutting: a performance-injury conflict? Sports Medicine Dos’Santos Thomas Thomas Christopher McBurnie Alistair Comfort Paul Jones Paul A. 3 4 2021
51 9 1983 1998 0112-1642 10.1007/s40279-021-01448-3 10.1007/s40279-021-01448-3 33811615
Can two-dimensional measured peak sagittal plane excursions during drop vertical jumps help identify three-dimensional measured joint moments? The Knee Dingenen Bart Malfait Bart Vanrenterghem Jos Robinson Mark A. Verschueren Sabine M.P. Staes Filip F. 3 2015
22 2 73 79 0968-0160 10.1016/j.knee.2014.12.006 10.1016/j.knee.2014.12.006 25575747
Do healthy athletes exhibit at-risk biomechanics for anterior cruciate ligament injury during pivoting movements? Sports Biomechanics Di Paolo Stefano Bragonzoni Laura Della Villa Francesco Grassi Alberto Zaffagnini Stefano 2 6 2022
1 14 1476-3141 10.1080/14763141.2022.2080105 10.1080/14763141.2022.2080105
Biomechanical measures during two sport-specific tasks differentiate between soccer players who go on to anterior cruciate ligament injury and those who do not: a prospective cohort analysis International journal of sports physical therapy Dix Celeste Arundale Amelia Silvers-Granelli Holly Marmon Adam Zarzycki Ryan Snyder-Mackler Lynn 12 2020
15 6 928 935 2159-2896 10.26603/ijspt20200928 10.26603/ijspt20200928 33344009
Poor validity of functional performance tests to predict knee injury in female soccer players with or without anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction The American Journal of Sports Medicine Fältström Anne Hägglund Martin Hedevik Henrik Kvist Joanna 12 4 2021
49 6 1441 1450 0363-5465 10.1177/03635465211002541 10.1177/03635465211002541
ACL Tears in school-aged children and adolescents over 20 years Pediatrics Beck Nicholas A. Lawrence J. Todd R. Nordin James D. DeFor Terese A. Tompkins Marc 1 3 2017
139 3 0031-4005 10.1542/peds.2016-1877 10.1542/peds.2016-1877
Coordination and variability during anticipated and unanticipated sidestepping Gait & Posture Weir Gillian van Emmerik Richard Jewell Carl Hamill Joseph 1 2019
67 1 8 0966-6362 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2018.09.007 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2018.09.007
Why do female athletes injure their ACLs more frequently? What can we do to mitigate their risk? International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy Silvers-Granelli Holly 1 8 2021
16 4 971 977 2159-2896 10.26603/001c.25467 10.26603/001c.25467 34386276
