
==== Front
Int J Sports Phys Ther
Int J Sports Phys Ther
2159
International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy
2159-2896
NASMI Website: International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy

37020449
71361
10.26603/001c.71361
Original Research
Spatiotemporal Parameters of Gait Among Adolescent Athletes with Concussion When Performing a Visuospatial Cognitive Task
Lowe Leah 1
Castillo Fernando 1
Allen Melissa 1
Israel Michael 2
Yates Charlotte 3
1 Physical Therapy University of Central Arkansas
2 Orthopedics, Pediatrics Arkansas Children’s Hospital, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences
3 Physical Therapy University of Central Arkansas, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences
Corresponding author: Dr. Leah Lowe, Department of Physical Therapy, University of Central Arkansas, Physical Therapy Center, Suite 319, 201 Donaghey Avenue, Conway, Arkansas 72035 Email: llowe@uca.edu Tel: 1-501-450-5545 Fax: 1-501-450-5822
1 4 2023
2023
18 2 338347
22 7 2022
15 1 2023
© The Author(s)
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (4.0) which permits non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Background

Adolescent athletes aged 10 to 19 years are at the highest risk of experiencing sport-related concussions (SRCs). Despite the known deficits and battery of assessments following concussion, postural stability during dual-task gait remains understudied in this population.

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the dual-task cost (DTC) in adolescents with an acute or chronic SRC compared to reference values from healthy athlete peers for spatiotemporal parameters of gait during walking with and without a concurrent visuospatial memory task presented on a hand-held tablet. Researchers hypothesized that adolescents during the acute phase of concussion would be likely to experience a greater DTC compared to healthy peers in at least one spatiotemporal parameter of gait when walking within the dual-task paradigm.

Study Design

Cross-sectional, observational cohort design

Methods

Adolescents with concussion were recruited to participate. Subjects were divided into acute and chronic categories based on significant differences in the neuropsychological function after a period of 28 days. They walked at a self-selected speed along the 5.186-meter GAITRite® Walkway System with and without a concurrent visuospatial cognitive task presented on a hand-held tablet. Outcomes included normalized velocity (m/s), step length (m), and double limb (DLS) and single limb support (SLS) (defined as the percent of a gait cycle [%GC]). The data were then compared to the previously published reference values established using the same methods in the healthy athlete participants for all spatiotemporal parameters of gait.

Results

Data was collected on 29 adolescent athletes with SRC. Among males (15.53+/-1.12 years) with SRC, 20% of acute and 10% of chronic cases experienced a greater DTC compared to healthy athlete reference values. A similarly increased DTC was experienced by 83% of acute and 29% of chronic SRC cases for females (15.58+/-1.16 years).

Conclusions

Adolescent athletes with concussion may continue demonstrating deficits in gait capabilities even in the chronic phase, and compensatory gait strategies were not the same between males and females. Dual-task cost assessment using the GAITRite® may be a valuable adjunct to comprehensive analysis of gait following SRC.

Level of Evidence

2

adolescent
concussion
dual-task
gait
Supported by NIGMS IDeA Program award P30 GM110702 through the Center for Translational Neuroscience at the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences.
==== Body
pmcINTRODUCTION

In a 2018 report to Congress, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) classified mild traumatic brain injuries (mTBI) among children aged 18 years and younger as a major public health burden.1 Sports are a leading source of concussion, a form of mTBI, with approximately 1.6 to 3.8 million sport-related concussions (SRC) occurring each year.2 Athletes in the adolescent age group of 10 to 19 years comprise the largest athletic cohort at nearly 44 million participants annually.3 Additionally, nearly 70% of all SRC cases in the United States were reported among adolescent athletes.4 As a response to the growing rate of emergency department visits secondary to concussion among adolescents,5 concussion management groups including the American Medical Society for Sports Medicine (AMSSM)2 and Concussion in Sport Group (CISG)6 have promulgated recommendations for improvements in the recognition, diagnosis, rehabilitation, treatment, and overall mitigation of SRC.

The most common symptoms following SRC in adolescent athletes include deficits in somatic, vestibular, oculomotor, and cognitive systems as well as abnormalities in emotional regulation and sleep.6,7 Postural instability has been identified as a hallmark of SRC8,9 and authors have established that prolonged dizziness, reported in approximately 65-75% of athletes with concussion, is most predictive of protracted recovery.10 For this reason, multimodal sideline assessment batteries assess a variety of symptom characteristics as well as neuromotor capabilities.2,6–8 Specifically, researchers have shown that SRCs commonly disrupt important neurological processes that allow for communication between the vestibular system, cerebellum, and motor cortex, which play critical concerted roles in controlling posture and balance during gait.9,11 Although previous authors have reported that neurocognitive impairments persist beyond subjective symptom resolution, dynamic motor tasks such as gait following concussion may not be adequately assessed clinically.11

Authors exploring deficits in gait among athletes with SRC have shown that no significant differences exist when compared to healthy controls while ambulating alone.12,13 In contrast, researchers have identified deficits in neuromotor capabilities athletes of varying ages with and without concussion during walking within a dual-task paradigm, which combines cognitive and motor demands.14–19 Additionally, a significant dual-task cost (DTC), or the relative change between single-task and dual-task performance,14 has been reported for specific spatiotemporal parameters of gait, including gait speed,13,16–20 cadence,12–14,16,17 stride length,12–14,16,17 step length,18,20 double limb support time (DLS),16,18–20 and single limb support time (SLS)18–20 in athletes with and without concussion using computerized technology. Howell et al21 previously reported good to excellent consistency for DTCs when assessing adolescents during single- and dual-task walking, concluding that healthy controls are effective comparators when assessing subjects with injury. Cognitive tasks incorporated into dual-task gait paradigms have challenged different constructs of cognition, memory, and coordination. The Mini-Mental Examination (MMSE), Auditory Stroop Test, and Brooks Visuospatial Memory Task, which incorporate constructs of memory, auditory perception, and recall, have been used to demonstrate that significant differences in gait parameters exist between adolescents with and without SRC in dual-task, but not always single-task, gait paradigms.12,13,21,22 Authors examining dual-task gait paradigms have also established normative reference values for adolescent athletes using varying methodologies and cognitive tasks, which have provided great insight into remaining deficits even after symptom resolution; however, many studies lack a closed environment mirroring aspects of athletic play wherein athletes’ attention is focused on a manipulatable hand-held object during gait.

Ambulation while manipulating a hand-held object, such as a phone or sports ball, is commonplace in daily activities (e.g., maneuvering through class or school spaces while texting) and athletic play (e.g., catching or focusing on a ball in football or soccer, among other sports, while running in a specific direction). In 2018, Howell et al23 revealed that collegiate athletes with a history of concussion demonstrated significantly decreased walking speed during dual-task gait with neurocognitive tests presented on a hand-held tablet compared to healthy controls. Furthermore, in 2019, Lowe et al20 established baseline data for healthy adolescent athletes during single-task gait without a cognitive component and dual-task gait using a hand-held tablet to perform a visuospatial memory task while walking along the GAITRite® Walkway System. In that study, authors found that both male and female healthy athletes experienced a significant DTC (p<0.0001) for gait velocity, step length, DLS, and SLS.20 However, data for concussed adolescents combining a motor and cognitive (visuospatial memory) task with altered visual attention has not been published. An altered, or larger than expected DTC during a combined motor and cognitive task post-concussion could pose a risk to adolescents returning to daily activity and especially athletic play.24 Studies have highlighted the complexity of concussion as a formal diagnosis given variability in symptomology and recovery timeframes.1,2 Despite the existence of widely adopted return to play (RTP) protocols based on symptomology, no consensus has been reached regarding the consistent assessment of postural stability during gait. Therefore, examining DTC may be a viable and insightful addition to comprehensive assessments of concussion.

Compensatory strategies may not be entirely consistent between individual athletes with SRC.25 Given that individuals with concussion often present with such a variety of compensatory mechanisms during movement, the authors of the current study believe it is essential to examine athletes individually while assessing multiple parameters. For the purpose of the current study, authors focused on normalized velocity (m/s), step length (m), and SLS and DLS as a percentage of a gait cycle (%GC), which may present quite differently from one injured athlete to the next. Consistent with common methodologies in physical therapy for assessing children with deficit,26 the chosen cutoff for considering a parameter to be of concern and warrant further attention is one standard deviation (SD). Specifically, the outcome measure of interest was the DTC experienced by adolescent athletes with SRC on each spatiotemporal parameter of gait.

Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the DTC in adolescents with an acute or chronic SRC compared to reference values from healthy athlete peers22 for spatiotemporal parameters of gait during walking with and without a concurrent visuospatial memory task presented on a hand-held tablet. Researchers hypothesized that adolescents during the acute phase of concussion and seeking a medical evaluation or follow-up would be likely to experience a DTC greater than one SD compared to healthy athlete peers in at least one spatiotemporal parameter of gait when walking within the dual-task paradigm. This study also aimed to explore any residual deficits compared to their healthy athlete peers that might present during the chronic phase of concussion that could aid in RTP decisions.

METHODS

Participants

A convenience sample of 29 athletes, between the ages of 14-18 years old, with documented SRC was recruited from a regional sports medicine concussion clinic. The Institutional Review Board at the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences approved the study. All participants and guardians provided written informed consent to participate in the study. Participants were included in the study if they were being treated at a regional sports medicine clinic for a sport related concussion, had participated in sport programs through their school, were between the ages of 14-18 years old, and had a completed informed consent from the parent/guardian. Participants were excluded if they had a recent lower extremity injury or were deemed medically unfit to participate in assessments by the clinic sports medicine physician. Using the protocol outlined below, participants were assessed at each clinic visit until discharge (minimum of one and maximum of three assessments). Therefore, an individual participant in the current study could contribute up to three assessments if that participant continued to be seen in the clinic for a protracted recovery. Data from these assessments were divided into acute and chronic categories based on significant differences in neuropsychological function after a period of 28 days.27

Protocol

Gait parameters were assessed by instructing the participants (n=29) to walk at a self-selected speed on the 5.186 meters long GAITRite® (CIR Systems, Inc.; Franklin, NJ) portable gait analysis walkway for three undivided attention trials in addition to three divided attention trials. During each divided attention trial, a visuospatial memory task was given to the subjects to complete on a tablet (Microsoft Surface Pro, 2016) while walking. Participants used a tablet rather than their own cell phones to achieve novelty and require attention to the device. The task (Pattern Memory by ProProfs.com, available at www.memory-improvement-tips.com), similar to the visuospatial memory tasks commonly included in the neurocognitive testing used in concussion management, consisted of a one-second period of time to view a pattern of shapes arranged spatially on the tablet screen. After this time period, the shapes disappeared. The participants then had to place the shapes in the original position relying upon visuospatial working memory. Participants who typically wear corrective eyewear (e.g., glasses or contact lens) wore them during the assessment. All participants performed this task in the same manner with three practice attempts to learn the task in static stance and data collection during gait beginning at level four of the task. Additionally, the participants initiated the task 2.5 meters prior to stepping onto the pathway to allow the task to continue throughout the entirety of the sensor pathway and to account for acceleration. Investigators monitored each trial to ensure that the participant was actively completing the task throughout the data recording time period. If the participant failed at the task, causing the game to discontinue during a trial, that trial was repeated to ensure that the participant was actively completing the task throughout.

The GAITRite® portable gait analysis walkway and the corresponding GAITRite® software were used to record temporal and spatial parameters. Prior to each participant’s trials, investigators entered data for leg length, which was measured as the distance from greater trochanter to floor for each leg. For the purposes of this study, parameters that were captured by the GAITRite® include: gait velocity (cm/s); step length (cm); DLS, defined as the percent of the gait cycle (%GC) when both feet are on the ground; and SLS, defined as the %GC weight bearing through a single limb. The walkway is 5.186 meters long and embedded with sensors recording footfall pressures at 80 Hz, which allows calculation of temporal and spatial markers of gait. The software averages the three gait trials under each walking condition providing means for each parameter. The GAITRite® system has been shown to be a reliable and valid measure of gait for healthy individuals.28

Statistical Methods

Normalized velocity is calculated by the GAITRite® system by dividing the gait velocity captured by the GAITRite® (cm/s) by the participant’s leg length (cm) and then converting the value to meters per second (m/s) for reporting. The data were then compared to the reference values established using the same methods in the healthy athlete participants for all spatiotemporal parameters of gait by Lowe et al.20 Comparisons were stratified based on the frequency of female and male acute and chronic cases that experienced a DTC for each of the parameters of interest that were either within or above one SD of values produced by healthy athletes. Additionally, as concussion management protocols are typically personalized to athletes’ specific capabilities, symptoms, and concussion severity, individual DTC values for each spatiotemporal parameter of gait were also recorded for male and female athletes with acute and chronic concussion during a preliminary and follow-up testing timeline.

RESULTS

Twenty-nine adolescent athletes with concussion (Table 1) contributed to data collection in several assessment periods during their time in a sport medicine concussion clinic. The 17 male participants with SRC contributed to 25 total assessments, 15 of which were acute and 10 of which were chronic. For the 12 females with concussion, 20 total assessments were recorded, 6 of which were acute and 14 of which were chronic. Table 2 provides means and standard deviations for healthy subjects with and without a concurrent visual cognitive task.20 Table 3 demonstrates the percentage of male and female acute and chronic cases that experienced a DTC greater than one SD compared to healthy subjects for at least one parameter.

148734 Table 1. Participant demographics by sex, race, and ethnicity.

Race	Males (n=17)	Females (n=12)	
Caucasian	17	11	
African American	0	1	
2 or More	0	0	
Ethnicity			
Hispanic	0	0	
Non-Hispanic	17	12	

148735 Table 2. Table 2 published by Lowe et al20 demonstrating “the means and standard deviations of the gait parameters when [healthy] subjects walked without a concurrent visual-cognitive task (Single-Task) and with a concurrent visual-cognitive task (Dual Task). The means and standard deviations for the dual-task cost for each parameter (DTC).”

	Single Task	Dual Task	DTC	
Parameter	Male	Female	Male	Female	Male	Female	
Velocity	1.236	1.449	1.030	1.232	-0.205*	-0.217*	
(m/s)	(0.163)	(0.199)	(0.185)	(0.196)	(0.140)	(0.113)	
Step Length	68.031	65.483	60.073	58.650	-7.958*	-6.833*	
(cm)	(6.779)	(6.021)	(7.858)	(5.885)	(5.046)	(3.777)	
% in DLS	29.077	26.922	31.92	29.542	+2.847%*	+2.620%*	
(2.631)	(2.648)	(3.461)	(3.085)	(2.753)	(1.783)	
% in SLS	35.390	36.522	34.05	35.112	-1.343%*	-1.410%*	
(1.504)	(1.352)	(1.901)	(1.549)	(1.665)	(1.129)	
*Statistically significant DTC at p<0.0001

148736 Table 3. Percentage of male (25 assessments) and female (20 assessments) acute and chronic cases that experienced a DTC at least one SD greater than those of healthy subjects from the study by Lowe et al20 in each of the spatiotemporal parameters of gait recorded using the GAITRite® Walkway System.

	Males	Females	
(n = 25 assessments)	(n = 20 assessments)	
Parameter	Acute %	Chronic %	Acute %	Chronic %	
Cases (n=15*)	Cases (n=10*)	Cases (n=6*)	Cases (n=14*)	
Normalized Velocity	20%	0%	17%	20%	
Step Length	13%	0%	17%	30%	
SLS (%GC)	7%	0%	83	30%	
DLS (%GC)	7%	10%	33%	10%	
Asterisk (*) denotes the percentage of the male and female acute (20% and 83%, respectively) and chronic (10%, and 29%, respectively) cases that experienced a DTC greater than one SD compared to healthy athlete reference values for at least one spatiotemporal parameter of gait.

Twenty percent of male and 83% of female acute assessments demonstrated such a DTC. The percentage of acute assessments that demonstrated a greater DTC compared to reference values from healthy counterparts was different between males and females for each of the spatiotemporal parameters of gait (Figure 1a and 2a, respectively). In general, most male participants in the acute phase experienced the higher DTC for normalized velocity while most females did so for SLS.

148737 Figure 1. Percentage of male acute (1a; three out of 15) and chronic (1b; one out of 10) cases that experienced a DTC at least one SD greater than those of healthy athletes from the study by Lowe et al20 in each of the spatiotemporal parameters of gait.

148738 Figure 2. Percentage of female acute (2a; five out of six) and chronic (2b; four out of 14) cases that experienced a DTC at least one SD greater than those of healthy athletes from the study by Lowe et al20 in each of the spatiotemporal parameters of gait.

Additionally, 10% of male and 29% of female chronic assessments demonstrated a DTC greater than one SD compared to healthy athletes. For the 10% of male participants assessed in the chronic phase, the increased DTC was experienced in DLS only (Figure 1b). For the female participants assessed in the chronic phase, the higher DTC was distributed across the four parameters (Figure 2b).

DISCUSSION

The present study adds important insight into the need for comprehensive clinical assessments of gait in adolescent athletes with SRC. Lingering deficits in dynamic balance during stance have been previously identified by the current authors utilizing clinical assessments of balance.29 Additionally, for the past decade, the literature has highlighted the importance of assessing dual-task gait among adolescent, collegiate, and adult athletes. Moreover, healthy reference values and DTCs have been frequently used to assess adolescent athletes with concussion when exploring the impact of dual-task paradigms on spatiotemporal parameters of gait. The current study contributes novel findings suggesting that varying compensatory mechanisms exist in male and female adolescent athletes with acute or chronic SRC when combining a cognitive and gait task, further promoting the use of the DTC as a viable adjunct assessment following SRC.

Results from the present study reveal that a considerable number of male and female cases with acute concussion, approximately three out of 15 male assessments and five out of six female assessments, experienced a DTC greater than one SD compared to peers without injury. This finding is similar to those of previous studies that have revealed significant differences between healthy adolescent athletes and those with concussion (typically tested within 10 days after injury) in several spatiotemporal parameters of gait.13,14,16,18 The current study also found that the increased DTC was not experienced for the same spatiotemporal parameters of gait or to the same degree by males and females with acute SRC, suggesting that different compensatory patterns to perform dual-task gait may be evident based on sex in similar samples. Recently, Kieffer et al30 found that even in collegiate athletes, who are presumed to function with more developed neuromuscular abilities, DTCs for several parameters of gait varied irrespective of sex but were overall higher for females. When assessing adolescent athletes within 14 days of concussion, Howell et al16 found that females typically experienced a significantly greater DTC for cadence (not measured in the current study), whereas a separate study reported inconsistent variability in several cognitive, neuromotor, and oculomotor functions according to sex.30 With respect to varying gait strategies, Table 4 provides valuable data for individual assessments by each participant during initial testing who experienced a DTC greater than one SD compared to healthy references in at least one parameter of gait. Male participant A and female participant B, both with acute SRC, experienced the DTC on at least three parameters, representing athletes with the most negative side effects of a concussion who may require personalized balance and gait training in addition to eventually progressing through a RTP protocol. Perhaps more alarming was the presence of participants who were already classified as having chronic SRC at initial testing, namely female participants E and H, and still experiencing a higher DTC than references on at least one parameter of gait. This finding suggests that a classification of chronicity and perhaps symptom resolution may not be sufficient alone in determining an athlete’s readiness to safely return to sport.

148739 Table 4. Subjects with a DTC greater than one SD compared to published values for at least one parameter at initial assessment for the current study.

Subject	Sex	Acuity	Normalized Velocity	Step Length	SLS (%GC)	DLS (%GC)	
Single	Dual	DTC	Single	Dual	DTC	Single	Dual	DTC	Single	Dual	DTC	
A	Male	Acute	0.9*	0.53*	0.37†	63.16	44.23*	18.94†	34.9	30.9*	4.0†	29.7	37.3	7.6†	
B	Male	Acute	1.2	0.78*	0.42†	68.03	54.48	13.55†	34.2	35.8	1.6	29.7	27.8*	1.9	
C	Male	Acute	1.16	0.8	0.36†	62.75	50.16*	12.59	34.6	33.5	1.1	30.0	32.7	2.7	
D	Female	Acute	1.22	0.89*	0.33	62.4	52.37*	10.03	33.5*	31.0*	5.1†	32.8	37.9	5.1†	
E	Female	Chronic	1.86	1.1	0.76	79.63	60.26	19.37†	40.7	37.0*	0.8	18.4*	17.6*	0.8	
F	Female	Acute	0.86*	0.64*	0.22	52.09*	40.63	11.46†	35.0	32.8*	5.1†	28.3	33.4	5.1†	
G	Female	Acute	1.19*	0.85*	0.34	60.69	52.05*	8.64	34.0*	32.8*	4.4†	31.2	35.6	4.4	
H	Female	Chronic	1.08*	0.75*	0.33	61.23	92.27*	31.04†	35.4	32.2*	6.6†	28.8	35.4*	6.6†	
I	Female	Acute	1.38	1.0	0.38†	63.29	54.46	8.83	36.7	35.5	3.0†	26.8	29.8	3.0	
J	Female	Acute	1.36	1.16	0.2	63.86	59.19	4.67	36.9	34.7	3.4†	25.9	29.3	3.4	
Values with * indicate either single- or dual-task trials that were at least one SD less compared to healthy athletes. Bolded values with † denote DTCs that were at least one SD greater than those of healthy athletes.

The current study also revealed further inconsistencies in the progression of biomechanical strategies for gait in a dual-task paradigm after participants still in the concussion clinic surpassed the threshold for chronicity (>28 days27) during follow-up testing. Table 5 provides information for male and female athletes with chronic SRC who continued to experience a DTC greater than one SD compared to healthy athlete controls. Female participants D and G experienced a DTC within one SD compared to healthy athletes in normalized velocity during the acute phase (Table 4), but then demonstrated a DTC higher than one SD for the same parameter after meeting the threshold for chronic classification. Given that slowed average gait speed has been highly correlated with concussion severity and prolonged recovery after SRC,14,17,24 special attention may be warranted for athletes with elevated DTCs in this parameter. Additionally, although male participant B improved the DTC of his average gait speed and step length, he may have shifted his compensatory strategy to DLS, as evidenced by an increased DTC during the chronic phase (Table 4 and 5). These scenarios of fluid compensatory strategies were not consistent for each participant and varied between males and females; however, athletes like participants B, D, and G, who continued to experience gait deficits 28 days after initial injury, may be at higher risk for reinjury even after progressing through a symptom based RTP protocol.

148740 Table 5. Subjects with a DTC greater than one SD compared to published values for at least one parameter during follow-up assessment.

Subject	Sex	Acuity	Normalized Velocity	Step Length	SLS (%GC)	DLS (%GC)	
Single	Dual	DTC	Single	Dual	DTC	Single	Dual	DTC	Single	Dual	DTC	
B	Male	Chronic	1.44	1.14	0.3	77.48*	65.9	11.58	35.8	34.3	1.5	20.8*	31	10.2†	
D	Female	Chronic	1.11*	0.76*	0.35†	61.91	50.38*	11.53†	32.7*	29.8*	2.9†				
G	Female	Chronic	1.25	0.89*	0.36†	59.01*	49.4*	9.61	38.1*	35.4	2.7†				
Values with * indicate either single- or dual-task trials that were at least one SD less compared to healthy athletes. Bolded values with † denote DTCs that were at least one SD greater than those of healthy athletes.

Modern protocols suggest that, on average, symptom resolution may occur as soon as seven to 10 days following SRC, and most graduated RTP programs progress student athletes back to physical activity mainly guided by subjective symptom resolution.2,6 However, other researchers have identified athletes who reported symptom resolution after 21 to >28 days of initial injury and continued to either walk with significantly slower average gait speeds, smaller cadences, and shorter stride lengths or experience significant DTCs compared to healthy controls. Furthermore, Howell and colleagues24 found that adolescent athletes who experienced reinjury after RTP had consistently demonstrated a significant gait speed DTC across time, similar to participants D and G from our study. Therefore, it is evident that more work needs to be done to adequately assess postural stability in gait for adolescent athletes after SRC in addition to symptoms based RTP protocols. Currently, there is no consensus on a viable tool for assessing spatiotemporal parameters of gait following concussion. Based on the findings of the current study, the GAITRite® Walkway System combined with DTC assessment may provide data valuable in identifying deficits in gait that may otherwise go undetected by multimodal assessments such as the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT-third or fifth edition), which assesses subjective aspects of ambulation and limited constructs of postural stability during a tandem gait test.2,6

LIMITATIONS

This study used a sample of convenience in a relatively small group of adolescents with a narrow age range. Ideally, all athletes would have been assessed first during the acute phase of SRC and again in a progressive manner throughout the chronic stage. Additionally, not all athletes were able to contribute to assessments beyond initial testing, either due to worsening symptoms or meeting criteria to initiate a RTP protocol. More robust studies with a longer duration and a sample population from more than one medical facility would contribute to improved generalizability of these findings. Furthermore, a more racially and ethnically diverse sample of adolescents with concussion would contribute to generalizability. Data collection was performed using an expensive piece of equipment, not readily available to most clinicians. Further research comparing data obtained using the same visuospatial memory task during gait with incorporation of more traditional and clinically feasible tools (e.g., 10 Meter Walk Test) could provide valuable and practical insight to more clinicians in a variety of settings. Additionally, the complexity of the visuospatial memory task was not customized to the subject’s individual cognitive or motor capacities. Therefore, given the broad potential impact of concussion on neurocognitive capabilities, the attention, detailed understanding, and processing of all testing requirements may have varied for each participant.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings of the current study support the continued need for comprehensive assessments of postural stability in gait for adolescent athletes with SRC. High variation in DTCs that were greater than one SD compared to healthy subjects for several spatiotemporal parameters of gait highlights the potential need for customized rehabilitation plans prior to eventual RTS. No two athletes in the limited sample of the current study demonstrated the same compensatory strategies, mitigation patterns, or potential deficits during single- and dual-task gait with a SRC classified as either acute or chronic in nature. DTC analysis using the GAITRite® Walkway System may be a valuable adjunct to current assessment strategies following concussion among adolescent athletes. However, given potential constraints regarding financial, set-up time, and training requirements for the GAITRite®, future work is warranted to explore viable clinical assessment tools and/or strategies with strong agreement with higher order technologies for evaluating spatiotemporal parameters of gait. Additionally, future studies may build upon the framework established by this preliminary study by incorporating longitudinal designs with assessment of all subjects at varying stages following concussion with inclusion of matched controls from similar schools.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors have no conflicts of interest.
==== Refs
Report to Congress: The management of traumatic brain injury in children, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control; Division of Unintentional Injury Prevention 22 1 2016
2023-2-8 https://www.cdc.gov/traumaticbraininjury/pubs/congress-childrentbi.html
American Medical Society for Sports Medicine position statement: concussion in sport British Journal of Sports Medicine Harmon Kimberly G Drezner Jonathan A Gammons Matthew Guskiewicz Kevin M Halstead Mark Herring Stanley A Kutcher Jeffrey S Pana Andrea Putukian Margot Roberts William O 2013
47 1 15 26 0306-3674 10.1136/bjsports-2012-091941 10.1136/bjsports-2012-091941 23243113
Sports- and recreation-related concussions in US youth Pediatrics Bryan Mersine A. Rowhani-Rahbar Ali Comstock R. Dawn Rivara Frederick 1 7 2016
138 1 1 8 0031-4005 10.1542/peds.2015-4635 10.1542/peds.2015-4635
Trends in sports- and recreation-related traumatic brain injuries treated in US emergency departments: the national electronic injury surveillance system-all injury program (NEISS-AIP) 2001-2012 Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation Coronado Victor G. Haileyesus Tadesse Cheng Tabitha A. Bell Jeneita M. Haarbauer-Krupa Juliet Lionbarger Michael R. Flores-Herrera Javier McGuire Lisa C. Gilchrist Julie 5 2015
30 3 185 197 0885-9701 10.1097/htr.0000000000000156 10.1097/htr.0000000000000156 25955705
Emergency department visits for sports- and recreation-related traumatic brain injuries among children – United States, 2010- 2016 MMWR. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report Sarmiento Kelly Thomas Karen E. Daugherty Jill Waltzman Dana Haarbauer-Krupa Juliet K. Peterson Alexis B. Haileyesus Tadesse Breiding Matthew J. 15 3 2019
68 10 237 242 0149-2195 10.15585/mmwr.mm6810a2 10.15585/mmwr.mm6810a2 30870404
Consensus statement on concussion in sport – the 5th international conference on concussion in sport held in Berlin, October 2016 Br J Sports Med McCrory P. Meeuwisse W. Dvorak J.. 2018
51 838 844
Sport-related concussion in children and adolescents Pediatrics Halstead Mark E. Walter Kevin D. Moffatt Kody LaBella Cynthia R. Brooks M. Alison Canty Greg Diamond Alex B. Hennrikus William Logan Kelsey Nemeth Blaise A. Pengel K. Brooke Peterson Andrew R. Stricker Paul R. COUNCIL ON SPORTS MEDICINE AND FITNESS 1 12 2018
142 6 1 24 0031-4005 10.1542/peds.2018-3074 10.1542/peds.2018-3074
Assessment of postural stability following sport-related concussion Current Sports Medicine Reports Guskiewicz Kevin M. 2 2003
2 1 24 30 1537-890X 10.1249/00149619-200302000-00006 10.1249/00149619-200302000-00006
Normative tandem gait in collegiate student-athletes: implications for clinical concussion assessment Sports Health: A Multidisciplinary Approach Oldham Jessie R. DiFabio Melissa S. Kaminski Thomas W. DeWolf Ryan M. Buckley Thomas A. 2017
9 4 305 311 1941-7381 10.1177/1941738116680999 10.1177/1941738116680999 27899680
Which on-field signs/symptoms predict protracted recovery from sport-related concussion among high school football players? The American Journal of Sports Medicine Lau Brian C. Kontos Anthony P. Collins Michael W. Mucha Anne Lovell Mark R. 28 6 2011
39 11 2311 2318 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546511410655 10.1177/0363546511410655
Balance control in youth hockey players with and without a history of concussions during a lower limb reaching task Clinical Biomechanics Mitchell Katelyn M. Cinelli Michael E. 7 2019
67 142 147 0268-0033 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2019.05.006 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2019.05.006 31103964
Single-task and dual-task gait among collegiate athletes of different sport classifications: implications for concussion management Journal of Applied Biomechanics Howell David R. Oldham Jessie R. DiFabio Melissa Vallabhajosula Srikant Hall Eric E. Ketcham Caroline J. Meehan William P. Buckley Thomas A. 2 2017
33 1 24 31 1065-8483 10.1123/jab.2015-0323 10.1123/jab.2015-0323
Gait and quiet-stance performance among adolescents after concussion-symptom resolution Journal of Athletic Training Berkner Justin Meehan William P., III Master Christina L. Howell David R. 1 12 2017
52 12 1089 1095 1062-6050 10.4085/1062-6050-52.11.23 10.4085/1062-6050-52.11.23 29154694
The association between dual-task gait after concussion and prolonged symptom duration Journal of Neurotrauma Howell David R. Brilliant Anna Berkstresser Brant Wang Francis Fraser Joana Meehan William P., III 12 2017
34 23 3288 3294 0897-7151 10.1089/neu.2017.5191 10.1089/neu.2017.5191
Dual-task gait recovery after concussion among female and male collegiate athletes Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise Howell DAVID R. Oldham JESSIE Lanois COREY KOERTE INGA LIN ALEXANDER P. BERKSTRESSER BRANT WANG FRANCIS MEEHAN WILLIAM P. 28 1 2020
52 5 1015 1021 1530-0315 10.1249/mss.0000000000002225 10.1249/mss.0000000000002225 31985574
Dual-task gait differences in female and male adolescents following sport-related concussion Gait & Posture Howell David R. Stracciolini Andrea Geminiani Ellen Meehan William P., III 5 2017
54 284 289 0966-6362 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2017.03.034 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2017.03.034 28384609
Identification of postconcussion dual-task gait abnormalities using normative reference values Journal of Applied Biomechanics Howell David R. Buckley Thomas A. Berkstresser Brant Wang Francis Meehan William P. 1 8 2019
35 4 290 296 1065-8483 10.1123/jab.2018-0454 10.1123/jab.2018-0454
Dual-task effect on gait balance control in adolescents with concussion Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Howell David R. Osternig Louis R. Chou Li-Shan 8 2013
94 8 1513 1520 0003-9993 10.1016/j.apmr.2013.04.015 10.1016/j.apmr.2013.04.015 23643687
The chronic effects of concussion on gait Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Martini Douglas N. Sabin Matthew J. DePesa Sarah A. Leal Elisa W. Negrete Tabitha N. Sosnoff Jacob J. Broglio Steven P. 4 2011
92 4 585 589 0003-9993 10.1016/j.apmr.2010.11.029 10.1016/j.apmr.2010.11.029 21440703
Spatiotemporal parameters of adolescent gait when performing a visuospatial memory task International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy Lowe Leah M. Gokun Yevgeniya Williams David K Yates Charlotte 9 2019
14 5 753 760 2159-2896 10.26603/ijspt20190753 10.26603/ijspt20190753 31598413
Consistency and cost of dual-task gait balance measure in healthy adolescents and young adults Gait & Posture Howell David R. Osternig Louis R. Chou Li-Shan 9 2016
49 176 180 0966-6362 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2016.07.008 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2016.07.008 27427835
The effects of attention capacity on dynamic balance control following concussion Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation Catena Robert D Donkelaar Paul V Chou Li-Shan 3 2 2011
8 1 1 8 1743-0003 10.1186/1743-0003-8-8 10.1186/1743-0003-8-8 21291548
The utility of instrumented dual-task gait and tablet-based neurocognitive measurements after concussion Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport Howell David R. Stillman Alexandra Buckley Thomas A. Berkstresser Brant Wang Francis Meehan William P., III 4 2018
21 4 358 362 1440-2440 10.1016/j.jsams.2017.08.004 10.1016/j.jsams.2017.08.004 28919121
Worsening dual-task gait costs after concussion and their association with subsequent sport-related injury Journal of Neurotrauma Howell David R. Buckley Thomas A. Lynall Robert C. Meehan William P., III 15 7 2018
35 14 1630 1636 0897-7151 10.1089/neu.2017.5570 10.1089/neu.2017.5570
Using accelerometers to record postural sway in adolescents with concussion: a cross-sectional study Journal of Athletic Training Alkathiry Abdulaziz A. Sparto Patrick J. Freund Brin Whitney Susan L. Mucha Anne Furman Joseph M. Collins Michael W. Kontos Anthony P. 1 12 2018
53 12 1166 1172 1062-6050 10.4085/1062-6050-518-17 10.4085/1062-6050-518-17 30605371
Physical therapists’ use and alteration of standardized assessments of motor function in children Pediatric Physical Therapy Fay Deanne Brock Elizabeth Peneton Samantha Simon Rebecca Splan Madison Sullivan Laura Weiler Alyce 10 2018
30 4 318 325 0898-5669 10.1097/pep.0000000000000532 10.1097/pep.0000000000000532
Recovery of cognitive and dynamic motor function following concussion British Journal of Sports Medicine Parker T. M Osternig L. R Donkelaar P. V. Chou L.-S. 21 5 2007
41 12 868 873 0306-3674 10.1136/bjsm.2006.033761 10.1136/bjsm.2006.033761 17517857
Validity of the GAITRite® walkway system for the measurement of averaged and individual step parameters of gait Gait & Posture Webster Kate E. Wittwer Joanne E. Feller Julian A. 12 2005
22 4 317 321 0966-6362 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2004.10.005 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2004.10.005
Static and dynamic balance assessment in health and concussed adolescent athletes Clin J Sport Med Lowe L. Castillo F. Gokun Y.. 2021
00 1 6
Dual-task gait performance following head impact exposure in male and female collegiate rugby players International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy Kieffer Emily E Brolinson Per Gunnar Rowson Steven 2 4 2022
17 3 355 365 2159-2896 10.26603/001c.32591 10.26603/001c.32591 35391870
