
==== Front
Int J Sports Phys Ther
Int J Sports Phys Ther
2159
International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy
2159-2896
NASMI Website: International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy

37020434
73035
10.26603/001c.73035
Clinical Commentary/Current Concept Review
Periodization in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rehabilitation: New Framework Versus Old Model? A Clinical Commentary
Kakavas Georgios 1
Forelli Florian 2
Malliaropoulos Nikolaos 3
Hewett Timothy E 4
Tsaklis Panagiotis 5
1 Fysiotek Spine & Sports Lab
2 Orthosport Rehab Center
3 Queen Mary University
4 Marshall University https://ror.org/02erqft81
5 University of Thessaly
Corresponding author: Florian FORELLI, 16 rue de Paris, 95330 Domont, France, +33769495275 fforelli@capio.fr
1 4 2023
2023
18 2 541546
21 11 2022
28 1 2023
© The Author(s)
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (4.0) which permits non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

The physiological and psychological changes after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) do not always allow a return to sport in the best condition and at the same level as before. Moreover, the number of significant re-injuries, especially in young athletes should be considered and physical therapists must develop rehabilitation strategies and increasingly specific and ecological test batteries to optimize safe return to play. The return to sport and return to play of athletes after ACLR must progress through the recovery of strength, neuromotor control, and include cardiovascular training while considering different psychological aspects. Because motor control seems to be the key to a safe return to sport, it should be associated with the progressive development of strength, and cognitive abilities should also be considered throughout rehabilitation.

Periodization, the planned manipulation of training variables (load, sets, and repetitions) to maximize training adaptations while minimizing fatigue and injury, is relevant to the optimization of muscle strengthening, athletic qualities, and neurocognitive qualities of athletes during rehabilitation after ACLR. Periodized programming utilizes the principle of overload, whereby the neuromuscular system is required to adapt to unaccustomed loads. While progressive loading is a well-established and widely used concept for strengthening, the variance of volume and intensity makes periodization effective for improving athletic skills and attributes, such as muscular strength, endurance, and power, when compared with non-periodized training. The purpose of this clinical commentary is to broadly apply concepts of periodization to rehabilitation after ACLR.

periodization
motor control
anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction
return to sport
cognitive phase/mesocycle
==== Body
pmcINTRODUCTION

Non-contact injury of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is a common sports-related injury typically warranting extensive rehabilitation time andreconstructive surgery followed by rehabilitation. After a sports injury, the first question asked by most athletes (and coaches) is: ‘When will I (the athlete) be able to compete again?’ The answer to this question is rarely straightforward and is influenced by many factors. However, in most cases the goals of the injured athlete and the treating clinician (plus other stakeholders in the decision-making team, such as coaches, parents, and managers) are the same—to facilitate a timely and safe return to sport.1

Athletes that return to play are at an elevated risk for re-injury or injury to the contralateral limb with an estimated 1 in 4 (25%) athletes suffering a second injury after returning to high-level sport.2 The high re-injury rate among injured athletes has been a focus for researchers attempting to identify modifiable risk factors and different rehab protocols according the graft choice, type of surgery, type of injury (meniscus or medial collateral ligament, involvement, etc.) for rehabilitation strategies to improve return-to-sport (RTS) outcomes.3 Periodization is probably one of the most important and fundamental concepts in training and it is important to consider the use of this concept in rehabilitation of injuries to the ACL and after ACL reconstruction (ALCR).4 Periodization consists of a ‘training cycle’ divided into different training or rehab phases with distinct physical and physiological objectives – to enable the best performance from athletes in competition (i.e. peak performance, injury prevention). Theoretically, using the periodization concept, peak performance is achieved in a controlled way, as a result of the summation of the particular adaptations provided by each training-rehab phase (mesocycle; Figure 1).5

151871 Figure 1. Periodization training cycles.

Various models of periodization exist. The two most common are linear and non-linear. Linear periodization adjusts exercise volume and load across a series of predictable phases or mesocycles. This stepwise progression from one training stage to another based on intended goals is similar to advancing a rehabilitation protocol from one stage of recovery to the next. Non-linear periodization, on the other hand, involves a more frequent change of volume and load within a mesocycle.

However, when examining the role of the use of the periodization concept in achieving the maximum specific performance in selected sports events (e.g. a season’s best result), an important drawback emerges: very low rates of effectiveness.6 The high frequency of competition, together with the increasing physical demands of competition over the season,7 has served to accentuate the physical and mental load incurred by elite athletes from different sports. As a consequence of these demands, the importance of recovery and rehabilitation strategies designed to alleviate player fatigue, minimize injury risk, and enhance performance is of paramount importance to clubs and national federations responsible for managing the elite player health.8 The use of periodization in long standing rehabilitation programs after ACLR needs more research and data to become accepted by health professionals. Therefore, the purpose of this clinical commentary is to broadly apply concepts of periodization to rehabilitation after ACLR.

CAN PERIODIZATION BE APPLIED IN LONG-TERM REHABILITATION, SUCH AS AFTER ACL INJURY?

Over the years, the pursuit of greater human performance through training has led to athletes, coaches, and physical therapists engaging in higher training volumes and often greater intensity. When coupled with ever increasing competition demands and fixture congestion the interest in exercise recovery strategies is extremely important to consider within the training and competition calendar.8,9 Rehabilitation programs have traditionally used a basic progressive overload approach primarily focusing on the injured area. Periodized training is a safe method of training for healthy athletes, as well as those in pain or following an injury.10 The ideas and concepts presented in this commentary have not been tested in randomized controlled trials, however they may stimulate further suitable studies investigating the application of periodization in rehab.

Periodization is the planned manipulation of training variables (load, sets, and repetitions) to maximize training adaptations while minimizing fatigue. Periodized programming utilizes the principle of overload, whereby the neuromuscular system adapts to unaccustomed loads. While progressive overload is a well-established and widely used concept for strengthening, the variance of volume and intensity makes periodization effective at improving athletic performance attributes, such as muscular strength, endurance, and power, compared with non-periodized training.10

The traditional periodization model assumes that a relatively prolonged period of basic training/rehab (general preparation / rehabilitation stages) is a prerequisite to a more specific phase (special preparation / cognitive phase). During general preparation, rehabilitation specialists aim to improve cardiorespiratory endurance and strength, even in athletes competing in power-speed sports disciplines.11

Another common belief related to strength-power development, is that the so-called ‘strength foundation phase’ will provide positive transfer of maximum strength to the ability to produce muscle power in the subsequent training phases or rehab stages. To date, there is no strong evidence supporting this belief, mostly held in traditional literature written on the basis of authors’ personal experiences and not supported by research. Conversely, there are studies showing that training using heavy-loads (i.e. maximum strength training) results in improvements only in the high-force/low-velocity portion of the force-velocity curve, without necessarily affecting the ability to produce higher amounts of force at high velocities (muscle power). It appears that the parametric relationship between force and velocity (i.e. the higher the load, the lower the velocity) plays a key role in modulating chronic neuromechanical adaptations and may be helpful in preventing re-injury.12

For instance, in endurance sports, athletes appear to benefit from performing high volumes of low-intensity training (i.e. below lactate thresholds) during their basic/specific periods of preparation.11 Furthermore, coaches and physiotherapists use prolonged periods of basic training on muscle-tendon tissues adaptation and injury prevention cannot be ignored. However, it is likely that these positive adaptations in muscle, tendons and ligaments may also be obtained by typical strength power exercises, which can be directly implemented during the course of a rehab period.

PERIODIZATION CONCEPTS DURING ACL REHABILITATION: PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

The initial post-operative phase of ACLR rehabilitation focuses on pain and swelling management, restoration of range of motion, quadriceps recruitment, and normalizing gait mechanics. Once an athlete meets these goals, they can begin a periodized resistance training program. To determine the appropriate load for an exercise prescription, clinicians must establish a one-repetition maximum (1RM) for each exercise. Injured or healing tissues pose a challenge to determining 1RMs when they require limited loading.13 Indeed, for most sports disciplines, make it extremely difficult for strength and conditioning coaches and physical therapists to adopt this classic and theoretical method used with healthy athletes to those recovering from injury or surgery.14,15

The injury-induced reduction in physical and mental function associated with sports training and competition infers that it is illogical that a single recovery strategy and/or a generic one-size-fits-all approach would address a player’s recovery requirements. Alternatively, a framework where strategies are sequenced systematically at independent time points to match the source of physiological stress, alongside consideration to favorable adaptation might be a preferred approach in sports.16

From a practical standpoint, monitoring athletes using a battery of tests (Y-Balance test, hop tests, etc.) which best correlate to actual sports performance and RTS after injury is much more important than following theoretical concepts, which subjectively state that form might be predictable and controlled.17 With this simple and applied thought, strength and conditioning coaches and rehabilitation specialists may select better ways to control fluctuations in the competitiveness of individuals and teams, in addition to the already well-established variations in traditional training components (i.e. volume and intensity). Monitoring will help physical therapists and coaches to detect unexpected adaptations in the athletes’ fitness traits and adjust rehab and training loads according to these measured responses.18 In this regard, the use of validated methods for daily assessment (like GPS) of the internal training loads might be a useful strategy to quantify/modulate training intensity and its respective dose-response relationship with the specific changes in physical and mental qualities and quantities (cognitive load and fatigue assessment).19

THE NEUROCOGNITIVE MESOCYCLE: THE MISSING LINK IN ACL PERIODIZATION

ACL rehabilitation is a complex and multifaceted process involving physiological and psychological parameters which need to be constantly evolving to optimize individual athlete recovery needs and physiological adaptation.20 The relative importance of recovery versus adaptation will vary according to the needs of the athlete within the context of the procedure. This raises the idea of using rehab strategies in a manner that is periodized to mirror the demands of the sport, and to adequately recover from the stress, but also consider the need for an adaptive response. Sports injury rehabilitation must move beyond the traditional emphasis on mechanics and muscle strength and consider the need to address nuanced sensorimotor control deficits to ensure complete recovery and readiness for RTS demands.21 ACL injuries during sport are predominantly non-contact, suggesting injury may be a product of sensorimotor errors that result in a neuromuscular control fault unable to accommodate deleterious joint loading.22 Further, the vast majority of non-contact injury events occur while athletes are cognitively distracted, attending to complex visual demands or environmental stimuli, suggesting that neural mechanisms may directly contribute to the athlete’s ability to safely interact with the dynamic sport environment.23 Neurocognitive tasks, such as those measuring reaction time, processing speed, visual memory, and verbal memory, are well established in the neuropsychology literature as indirect measures of cerebral performance.

Situational awareness, arousal, and attentional resources of the individual may influence several areas of neurocognitive function, affecting the complex integration of vestibular, visual, and somatosensory information needed for neuromuscular control.24 Neuroplasticity deficits following ACL injury and surgery may at least in part be caused by physiotherapy protocols that do not engage differential learning and dual-tasking during (engaging more demanding aspects of the cognitive arsenal) exercises.

Over the course of rehabilitation following ACLR, excitability of the motor cortex for quadriceps contractions decreases, at least partially from the lack of differential exercise approaches that do not force the motor cortex to reintegrate the memory trace for quadriceps motor control before each repetition and action.25,26 Neurophysiological data across the stages of rehabilitation are lacking. Neuroimaging has been used to quantify brain activation differences between subjects with ACL deficiency who did not return to previous levels of physical activity and a healthy control group.27 In this phase, patients will focus on sport-specific exercises that are intended to be extremely challenging both physically and cognitively while performed in a controlled environment. All of the previously mentioned multimodal tasks can be implemented with a major focus on motor learning, cognitive loading and sensory re-weighting that are real-to sport and require quick decision making from unanticipated events.28,29

CONCLUSION

Sports rehabilitation specialists especially physical therapists and sports medicine physicians should have a basic understanding of periodization theory. Such an understanding can help sport medicine teams to better interact with the competitive mindset of athletes, their coaches, and their goals. A basic understanding of periodization theories and models may help sports rehabilitation specialists to skillfully plan rehabilitation programs that then progress toward the realization of the patients’ treatment goals.

With recent evidence in support of neurological contributions to ACL injury and rate of recovery, rehabilitation protocols may benefit from incorporation of approaches that target the sensorimotor and cognitive system. Periodization can incorporate the integration of motor learning principles (external focus and differential learning, anticipation, and reaction) and/or new technologies may bolster current ACL rehabilitation protocols and improve patient recovery and timing. Research has traditionally focused on administering a single rehab intervention whereas, in the applied setting, athletes are more likely to administer multiple interventions in varying sequences. Future research using robust rehabilitation technique protocols and large-scale randomized control trials is needed to better understand the influence of various techniques and the application of periodization concepts on the stress-injury-adaptation continuum.

Conflicts of interest

The authors report no conflicts of interest.
==== Refs
Reconstruction, rehabilitation and return-to-sport continuum after anterior cruciate ligament injury (ACLR3-continuum): Call for optimized programs Annals of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine Rambaud Alexandre JM Neri Thomas Edouard Pascal 6 2022
65 4 101470 1877-0657 10.1016/j.rehab.2020.101470 10.1016/j.rehab.2020.101470 33333209
2016 Consensus statement on return to sport from the First World Congress in Sports Physical Therapy, Bern British Journal of Sports Medicine Ardern Clare L Glasgow Philip Schneiders Anthony Witvrouw Erik Clarsen Benjamin Cools Ann Gojanovic Boris Griffin Steffan Khan Karim M Moksnes Håvard Mutch Stephen A Phillips Nicola Reurink Gustaaf Sadler Robin Grävare Silbernagel Karin Thorborg Kristian Wangensteen Arnlaug Wilk Kevin E Bizzini Mario BMJ 25 5 2016
50 14 853 864 0306-3674 10.1136/bjsports-2016-096278 10.1136/bjsports-2016-096278 27226389
The modifying factors that help improve anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction rehabilitation: a narrative review Annals of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine Rambaud Alexandre JM Neri Thomas Dingenen Bart Parker David Servien Elvire Gokeler Alli Edouard Pascal 6 2022
65 4 101601 1877-0657 10.1016/j.rehab.2021.101601 10.1016/j.rehab.2021.101601 34757010
Periodization in anterior cruciate ligament rehabilitation: a novel framework Medical Principles and Practice Kakavas George Malliaropoulos Nikolaos Bikos Georgios Pruna Ricard Valle Xavier Tsaklis Panagiotis Maffulli Nicola 2021
30 2 101 108 1011-7571 10.1159/000511228 10.1159/000511228 33264774
Periodization training focused on technical-tactical ability in young soccer players positively affects biochemical markers and game performance Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research Aquino Rodrigo Cruz Gonçalves Luiz G. Palucci Vieira Luiz H. Oliveira Lucas P. Alves Guilherme F. Pereira Santiago Paulo R. Puggina Enrico F. 10 2016
30 10 2723 2732 1064-8011 10.1519/jsc.0000000000001381 10.1519/jsc.0000000000001381
The evolution of physical and technical performance parameters in the english premier league International Journal of Sports Medicine Barnes C. Archer D. Hogg B. Bush M. Bradley P. Georg Thieme Verlag KG 10 7 2014
35 13 1095 1100 0172-4622 10.1055/s-0034-1375695 10.1055/s-0034-1375695
Compression garments and recovery from exercise: a meta-analysis Sports Medicine Brown Freddy Gissane Conor Howatson Glyn van Someren Ken Pedlar Charles Hill Jessica Springer Science and Business Media LLC 22 4 2017
47 11 2245 2267 0112-1642 10.1007/s40279-017-0728-9 10.1007/s40279-017-0728-9
The use of recovery strategies by Spanish first division soccer teams: a cross-sectional survey The Physician and Sportsmedicine Altarriba-Bartes Albert Peña Javier Vicens-Bordas Jordi Casals Martí Peirau Xavier Calleja-González Julio 2021
49 3 297 307 0091-3847 10.1080/00913847.2020.1819150 10.1080/00913847.2020.1819150 32882156
Block periodization versus traditional training theory: a review J Sports Med Phys Fitness Issurin V. 2008
48 1 65 75 18212712
Non-linear periodization for general fitness & athletes Journal of Human Kinetics Fleck Steven 1 9 2011
29A Special-Issue 41 45 1899-7562 10.2478/v10078-011-0057-2 10.2478/v10078-011-0057-2 23486658
Integration of strength and conditioning principles into a rehabilitation program Int J Sports Phys Ther Reiman M.P. Lorenz D.S. 2011
6 3 241 253 21904701
Short-term training for explosive strength causes neural and mechanical adaptations: Neuromuscular adaptations with explosive strength training Experimental Physiology Tillin Neale A. Pain Matthew T. G. Folland Jonathan P. 4 4 2012
97 5 630 641 0958-0670 10.1113/expphysiol.2011.063040 10.1113/expphysiol.2011.063040 22308164
Upgraded hardware─what about the software? Brain updates for return to play following ACL reconstruction British Journal of Sports Medicine Grooms Dustin R Myer Gregory D 2017
51 5 418 419 0306-3674 10.1136/bjsports-2016-096658 10.1136/bjsports-2016-096658 27797732
The combined impact of a perceptual–cognitive task and neuromuscular fatigue on knee biomechanics during landing The Knee Mejane Jeremy Faubert Jocelyn Romeas Thomas Labbe David R. 1 2019
26 1 52 60 0968-0160 10.1016/j.knee.2018.10.017 10.1016/j.knee.2018.10.017
‘What’s my risk of sustaining an ACL injury while playing football (soccer)?’ A systematic review with meta-analysis British Journal of Sports Medicine Montalvo Alicia M Schneider Daniel K Silva Paula L Yut Laura Webster Kate E Riley Michael A Kiefer Adam W Doherty-Restrepo Jennifer L Myer Gregory D 2019
53 21 1333 1340 0306-3674 10.1136/bjsports-2016-097261 10.1136/bjsports-2016-097261 29599121
Applied periodization: a methodological approach Journal of Human Sport and Exercise Naclerio Ayllón Fernando Moody Jeremy Chapman Mark Journal of Human Sport and Exercise 2013
8 2 350 366 1988-5202 10.4100/jhse.2012.82.04 10.4100/jhse.2012.82.04
Neuroplasticity and Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Indian Journal of Orthopaedics Kakavas George Malliaropoulos Nikolaos Pruna Ricard Traster David Bikos Georgios Maffulli Nicola 31 1 2020
54 3 275 280 0019-5413 10.1007/s43465-020-00045-2 10.1007/s43465-020-00045-2 32399146
Ball heading and subclinical concussion in soccer as a risk factor for anterior cruciate ligament injury Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research Kakavas George Malliaropoulos Nikolaos Blach Wieslaw Bikos Georgios Migliorini Filippo Maffulli Nicola 19 9 2021
16 1 566 1749-799X 10.1186/s13018-021-02711-z 10.1186/s13018-021-02711-z 34538251
Changed cortical activity after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a joint position paradigm: an EEG study: acl and cortical activity Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports Baumeister J. Reinecke K. Weiss M. 7 12 2007
18 4 473 484 0905-7188 10.1111/j.1600-0838.2007.00702.x 10.1111/j.1600-0838.2007.00702.x
The influence of musculoskeletal injury on cognition: implications for concussion research The American Journal of Sports Medicine Hutchison Michael Comper Paul Mainwaring Lynda Richards Doug 18 7 2011
39 11 2331 2337 0363-5465 10.1177/0363546511413375 10.1177/0363546511413375
Concussion frequency associates with musculoskeletal injury in retired nfl players Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise Pietrosimone BRIAN Golightly YVONNE M. Mihalik JASON P. Guskiewicz KEVIN M. 11 2015
47 11 2366 2372 0195-9131 10.1249/mss.0000000000000684 10.1249/mss.0000000000000684
Mechanoreceptors in the human anterior cruciate ligament The Anatomical Record Zimny Marilyn L. Schutte Michael Dabezies Eugene Wiley 2 1986
214 2 204 209 0003-276X 10.1002/ar.1092140216 10.1002/ar.1092140216
Mechanoreceptors in human cruciate ligaments. A histological study. The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery Schultz R A Miller D C Kerr C S Micheli L 9 1984
66 7 1072 1076 0021-9355 10.2106/00004623-198466070-00014 10.2106/00004623-198466070-00014 6207177
Neural anatomy of the human anterior cruciate ligament. The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery Schutte M J Dabezies E J Zimny M L Happel L T 2 1987
69 2 243 247 0021-9355 10.2106/00004623-198769020-00011 10.2106/00004623-198769020-00011 3805085
Nerve supply of the human knee and its functional importance The American Journal of Sports Medicine Kennedy John C. Alexander Ian J. Hayes Keith C. SAGE Publications 11 1982
10 6 329 335 0363-5465 10.1177/036354658201000601 10.1177/036354658201000601
Proprioception and function after anterior cruciate reconstruction The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volume Barrett DS 9 1991
73-B 5 833 837 0301-620X 10.1302/0301-620x.73b5.1894677 10.1302/0301-620x.73b5.1894677
The effects of joint position and direction of joint motion on proprioceptive sensibility in anterior cruciate ligament-deficient athletes The American Journal of Sports Medicine Borsa Paul A. Lephart Scott M. Irrgang James J. Safran Marc R. Fu Freddie H. SAGE Publications 5 1997
25 3 336 340 0363-5465 10.1177/036354659702500311 10.1177/036354659702500311 9167813
The anterior cruciate ligament deficiency as a model of brain plasticity Medical Hypotheses Kapreli Eleni Athanasopoulos Spyridon 1 2006
67 3 645 650 0306-9877 10.1016/j.mehy.2006.01.063 10.1016/j.mehy.2006.01.063
Gamma loop dysfunction in quadriceps on the contralateral side in patients with ruptured acl Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise Konishi YU Konishi HIROYUKI Fukubayashi TORU 6 2003
35 6 897 900 0195-9131 10.1249/01.mss.0000069754.07541.d2 10.1249/01.mss.0000069754.07541.d2 12783035
