
==== Front
Int J Sports Phys Ther
Int J Sports Phys Ther
2159
International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy
2159-2896
NASMI Website: International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy

37547844
81598
10.26603/001c.81598
Original Research
Balance Error Scoring System Performance Differences in Figure Skaters Based on Discipline
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6443-2951
Mangum L. Colby 1
Skibski Andrew 1
Devorski Luk 1
Slater Lindsay 2 3
1 Kinesiology and Rehabilitation Sciences University of Central Florida https://ror.org/036nfer12
2 Physical Therapy University of Illinois at Chicago https://ror.org/02mpq6x41
3 Athlete High Performance United States Figure Skating
Corresponding Author: L. Colby Mangum, PhD, ATC 4364 Scorpius Street, HS II Room 235 Orlando, FL, 32816 407-823-2795 l.colby.mangum@ucf.edu
1 8 2023
2023
18 4 898904
3 2 2023
7 5 2023
© The Author(s)
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (4.0) which permits non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Background

Balance and postural stability are required of figure skaters throughout on-ice performance. Spinning, jumping, and landing each rely on this skill set to maintain control while skaters manage changing demands for each skating discipline.

Hypothesis/Purpose

The aim of this study was to compare balance error scoring system (BESS) performance in figure skaters between disciplines and determine if age was related to BESS performance.

Study Design

Cross-sectional study.

Methods

Three hundred and fifty-eight figure skaters (age: 15.4±3.3 years, 213 females, 145 males) of multiple disciplines completed the BESS during the United States Figure Skating’s Standardized Testing of Athleticism to Recognize Skaters (S.T.A.R.S.) combine. Errors during each condition of the BESS were recorded by trained evaluators. A 3x6 ANOVA was used to determine BESS differences based on skating discipline. Spearman’s rho (ρ) correlation coefficients were calculated for relationships between BESS errors and age.

Results

Ice dancers had more errors than singles and pairs for bipedal foam (p<0.001) but had fewer errors than single skaters for single leg foam (p=0.002). Tandem on a firm surface also showed an increase in errors for ice dancers and pairs skaters compared to singles (p<0.001). There were significant weak negative relationships noted between age and bipedal foam and single leg firm conditions (ρ=-0.14, -0.23, p<0.05).

Conclusion

Figure skaters of different disciplines have varying levels of static postural stability. Assessing postural stability in figure skaters can provide insight to improve performance and may identify skaters at risk of injury.

Level of Evidence

3

sports performance
balance
screening
youth sports
The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
==== Body
pmcINTRODUCTION

Postural stability and balance are important to figure skaters of all ages as they influence flexibility and control. As figure skaters develop their on-ice skills from an early age, training may focus on specific jumps or spins, however the balance required to improve upon those initial skills can be measured independently from skating performance.1 Jumping and landing on a single leg requires power, strength, balance, and stability.2 Investigators have identified greater hamstring strength and hamstrings to quadriceps strength ratios in female figure skaters compared to female soccer players.3 Trunk flexion and extension forces while standing and were higher in an athlete sample, including figure skaters, that was evaluated against a non-athlete group.4 In junior elite figure skaters, knee extension strength was positively correlated to single axel and double axel height.5 Strength investigations in the figure skating population are more prevalent, revealing a gap in the balance and stability literature for this group of athletes. Clinicians can easily implement functional balance assessments to measure these characteristics.

The Balance Error Scoring System (BESS) is a clinical assessment originally developed for measuring postural control characteristics in healthy athletes without expensive equipment.6 Although the BESS is often utilized in concussion testing, this tool can be used to establish normative values for static postural stability that can be compared to values after musculoskeletal injury.7 The BESS involves testing balance in three different stance conditions: bipedal, single leg, and tandem. As an assessment tool for postural imbalances, both firm and foam surfaces are commonly used. An athletic setting may increase the amount of external attentional demands experienced by the test taker which may influence their BESS score. Ideally the test should be administered in a controlled environment.8

Tests of postural stability such as the BESS can provide insight into athletic capabilities, but also can be influenced by factors such as age,9 ankle instability,10 or head injury.6 Although the BESS may not have a relationship with the occurrence of acute lower extremity injuries, the test is advantageous to understand how balance differs between levels of sport.11 In figure skaters, dynamic postural stability has been assessed with the Y-Balance test to compare between sexes,12 but static postural stability has only been tested in a limited manner with the stork pose, which tests only single leg balance.12 Static postural stability is influenced during figure skating as positions are held isometrically for extended periods of time, whether in bipedal, single leg or tandem positions. In adolescents and young adults, older age improves BESS performance, likely due to cognitive and physical development.13 Therefore, it is important to use broader assessments such as the BESS to more fully understand variations in static postural stability in figure skaters across disciplines and ages.

The purpose of this study was to compare balance error scoring system (BESS) performance in figure skaters between disciplines and determine if age was related to BESS performance. A secondary purpose was to compare BESS errors between males and females, regardless of discipline. It was expected that skaters would display fewer errors during the bipedal and firm surface conditions across all disciplines. It was hypothesized that singles skaters would perform better on the BESS. For the secondary aim, females were expected to exhibit fewer errors than males. Age was expected to have a negative relationship indicating that as skater age increased, their errors decreased in each BESS condition.

METHODS

Study Design

A cross-sectional study evaluated the balance of participants in the United States Figure Skating’s Standardized Testing of Athleticism to Recognize Skaters (S.T.A.R.S.) combine. Deidentification of all data was performed before analysis and therefore this study was deemed exempt by the University Institutional Review Board.

Participants

The 358 participants did not have any current injury that limited their ability to complete the BESS test during the S.T.A.R.S. combine. The BESS was administered as part of combine testing by United States Figure Skating trained evaluators, which has sufficient interrater reliability for stance condition scores.14

Testing Procedures

Prior to balance testing, individuals self-reported age, sex, landing leg, and skating discipline. Landing leg length was measured from the greater trochanter to the lateral malleolus in centimeters using a tape measure and recorded.15 All skaters completed balance testing in the same order of conditions, starting with a firm then foam surface. The participants were barefoot when completing conditions as follows: bipedal firm, bipedal foam, single leg firm, single leg foam, tandem firm, and finally tandem foam. The single leg tasks were completed on their non-dominant or non-landing leg, and this leg was also placed behind the landing leg in the tandem stance conditions.16 Skaters were asked to balance with their eyes closed for 20-seconds for each trial.7 Errors were counted real-time by evaluators according to standardized BESS scoring with a maximum of 10 errors for each condition.

Statistical Analyses

Participant characteristics (age, sex, leg length, skating discipline) were used to calculate descriptive statistics. Errors observed were averaged for each BESS condition grouped by skating discipline and sex. A 3x6 ANOVA with Bonferroni post-hoc tests was performed to examine differences between discipline and condition. Mean differences (MD), standard error (SE), and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated for significant effects identified from ANOVA. Independent t-tests were used to evaluate sex differences. For non-normally distributed data, assessed by Shapiro-Wilk tests, Spearman’s rho correlation coefficients were utilized to calculate relationships between age and BESS performance in each condition. Alpha was set a priori to p≤.05. All SPSS v.28.0.1.0 (SPSS, Chicago, IL) was used for all statistical analyses.

RESULTS

There were 358 participants included in this study including singles, pairs, and dancers (age: 15.4±3.3 years, leg length: 84.7±7.3 cm, 213 females, 145 males). Mean and standard deviation for errors completed in each BESS condition by discipline are summarized in Table 1. The ANOVA revealed between group differences based on discipline for the bipedal foam (F: 16.42, p<0.001), single leg foam (F: 6.56, p=0.002), and tandem firm (F: 23.90, p<0.001). There were no significant interactions between discipline and BESS condition. In the bipedal foam stance, ice dancers had more errors than both pairs (MD: 1.24, SE: 0.28, 95% CI: 0.57, 1.91) and singles skaters (MD: 0.89, SE: 0.18, 95% CI: 0.47, 1.32). Singles skaters had more errors than ice dancers in the single leg foam stance (MD: -1.34, SE: 0.39, 95% CI: -2.26, -0.41). In the tandem firm position, ice dancers had more errors than singles skaters (MD: 2.13, SE: 0.32, 95% CI: 1.35, 2.91), and pairs had more errors than singles skaters (MD: 1.85, SE: 0.49, 95% CI: 0.67, 3.03). There were no differences between males and females in any BESS conditions (Table 2), although males were significantly older (Males: 16.7±3.5 years, Females: 14.5±2.9years, p<0.001) and had a longer leg length (Males: 88.8±7.4 cm, Females: 81.9±5.8 cm, p<0.001). Age had a weak, negative relationship with bipedal foam (ρ=-.14, p=.001) and with single leg firm (ρ=-.23, p<0.001).

167783 Table 1. Errors on Balance Error Scoring System by Skating Discipline

BESS Condition	Singles	Pairs	Ice Dance	
Bipedal Firm	0.01±0.07	0.00±0.00	0.02±0.18	
Bipedal Foam**, ***	0.35±1.00	0.00±0.00	1.24±2.89	
Single Leg Firm	2.26±2.48	1.75±1.68	1.89±2.11	
Single Leg Foam**	5.13±3.28	5.20±1.73	3.80±3.82	
Tandem Firm*, **	1.68±2.23	3.53±2.24	3.81±3.68	
Tandem Foam	3.66±2.44	3.13±2.19	3.84±2.80	
*p<0.05, difference between singles and pairs

**p<0.05, difference between singles and ice dancers

***p<0.05, difference between pairs and ice dancers

BESS, balance error scoring system.

167784 Table 2. Errors on Balance Error Scoring System by Sex

BESS Condition	Females (n=213)	Males (n=145)	All (n=358)	
Bipedal Firm	0.00±0.00	0.02±0.18	0.01±0.12	
Bipedal Foam	0.63±1.61	0.60±1.60	0.62±1.60	
Single Leg Firm	2.14±2.40	1.98±2.11	2.08±2.28	
Single Leg Foam	4.56±3.46	4.86±3.32	4.68±3.40	
Tandem Firm	2.51±2.92	2.78±3.11	2.62±2.99	
Tandem Foam	3.68±2.62	3.64±2.45	3.66±2.55	
BESS, balance error scoring system.

DISCUSSION

The results of this study support that BESS performance varies based on skating discipline. There were differences between disciplines for the bipedal foam, single leg foam, and tandem firm stances. The BESS effectively identifies static postural instability, especially in stances performed on foam surfaces.6 Singles skaters perform higher difficulty jumps and more technical elements during their routines, so they require a greater degree of postural stability.17 Ice dancers do not perform jumps, so they may not require the same level of postural stability needed for take-off and landing by singles skaters, as demonstrated by the poorer BESS performance in the bipedal foam and tandem firm stances (Table 1).

Past research has found varying performance on other measures of athleticism across skating discipline, specifically testing agility, strength, and flexibility.1 For example, the Y-Balance test is a dynamic test that has been used to measure the posterolateral reach in figure skaters, which corresponds with the landing position.15 A shorter reach distance during the posterolateral reach within the Y-Balance test has been correlated with skating speed. The Star Excursion Balance Test, from which the Y-Balance test was derived, has been incorporated into a previous study evaluating a proprioceptive training protocol in 10–18-year-old figure skaters.18 All participants in their sample showed improvement in the Star Excursion Balance Test following the strength and proprioception training.18 It has been reported that females have a greater Y-Balance composite score than males,15 but skating discipline has not previously been assessed. Comparing Y-Balance and BESS performance can provide insight into both dynamic and static stability.

Noting differences in postural stability allows for a discipline-specific understanding of the sport’s requirements. It has also been reported that dancers have decreased lumbar and hamstring flexibility compared to singles and pairs skaters, which may impact stability.1 The same decrease in postural stability and balance manifested in our present study with a greater number of errors in the bipedal foam and tandem firm stances (Table 1). This discipline-specific approach to balance can impact training and performance, injury prevention and rehabilitation strategies, and establishment of reference values for the BESS.

There were no discipline-specific differences in BESS performance for the bipedal firm, single leg firm, or tandem foam stances. These findings suggest that the easier, initial position, the bipedal firm stance, may not provide an adequate challenge to postural stability. Single leg firm can be a more challenging position, which is supported by the current findings when noting that single leg firm had more errors than the other firm stances in this sample, regardless of lack of difference between disciplines. However, single leg balance on a firm surface has been assessed in a figure skating population using the stork pose, which found greater hold times in ice dancers than singles and pairs skaters.1 Therefore, measuring stability with an endurance component may provide an additional challenge to compare between these athletes. Very few errors were recorded across groups for the bipedal firm and single leg firm positions (Table 1). The small number of errors agrees with previous findings which reported few BESS errors and minimal sway measured with a force platform in these positions.16 Conversely, the tandem foam stance may have been similarly challenging due to sway for all disciplines, as that condition averaged approximately three errors for all disciplines. Three errors during tandem foam is comparable to other studies investigating the BESS in healthy collegiate baseball players8 (2.9 errors), and a mixed sample of youth (3.8 errors), high school (3.5 errors), and college athletes (2.9 errors).13 These similarities in errors for tandem foam reinforce the notion that the highest degree of postural instability was in this stance as quantified by a force platform measuring sway.16 Together, these non-significant findings indicate that the least and most difficult conditions were not able to distinguish between skating disciplines in this sample. The overall body of evidence surrounding the BESS promotes its use to assess postural stability for baseline testing, musculoskeletal injury, and head injury purposes.6,13,19 Comparable findings have been reported when examining head injuries, where the bipedal firm and single leg firm stances do not differ between concussed and non-concussed athletes.6

There were weak negative correlations between age and bipedal foam and single leg firm conditions, implying that as age increased, errors decreased. Previous findings suggest a stronger relationship between age and BESS performance in adolescents and young adults, where college athletes scored significantly better than both high school and youth athletes.13 However, in this sample of elite young athletes, these relationships were less extreme. Youth athletes can increase balance and postural stability through sports and resistance training,20 and these participants’ athletic development and postural stability likely is greater than comparable non-athletes of the same age. Similarly, there has been an increase in agility and strength reported in more advanced skaters (junior and senior level) compared to novices.1 These findings suggest early sport specialization and a focus on strength and balance training throughout the stages of development in young athletes can improve athletic capabilities and performance.21

Although not the primary aim of the study, sex differences in BESS performance were assessed due to the frequency of this comparison in the current figure skating testing literature.12,15 There was no statistically significant difference between males and females on BESS performance in any condition. This conflicts with a study of normative scores on the BESS which reported fewer errors by females than males in a similar age range of young athletes.13 However, they found no differences in BESS errors between collegiate-level males and females.13 Comparing to college athletes may be more representative of our sample, as the figure skaters compete at a national level, and for the elite, an international level. They may be more athletically mature and specialized in their discipline despite the average age of the current participants (15.4±3.3 years) matching more closely to the high school cohort.

There were some limitations to the present study. Participants’ injury history, and previous musculoskeletal or head injuries were not available and may have been confounding variables which altered BESS performance. The performance of the BESS barefoot or shod, does not consider how skaters balance while in their skating boot and on the ice, and limits the authors’ ability to understand their balance on-ice. Also, access to the skaters’ level (e.g., novice, junior, senior) was not provided, which could have provided further understanding of the role of experience or skill level in postural stability. Age was relied upon for this comparison, but age does not necessarily relate to skill level. Future research should compare static postural stability such as the BESS across levels in figure skating. This could provide athletes, clinicians, and coaches information to use for training programs, injury rehabilitation, and talent identification.

CONCLUSION

The results of this study support the hypothesis that BESS performance in some stances varies based on skating discipline in elite figure skaters. Singles skaters tended to display the least errors, specifically on the bipedal foam and tandem firm stances, but ice dancers had fewer errors than singles in a more challenging stance, the single leg foam. These findings support the idea that static postural stability can vary across skating discipline, and therefore using the BESS to test postural stability off-ice in figure skaters may provide insight on performance improvement and injury risk. Additional factors such as age and sex do not tend to display a strong association with BESS performance in this population.

Declaration of Conflicting Interests

The authors have no conflicts of interest to report.
==== Refs
Difference in agility, strength, and flexibility in competitive figure skaters based on level of expertise and skating discipline Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research Slater Lindsay V. Vriner Melissa Zapalo Peter Arbour Kat Hart Joseph M. 12 2016
30 12 3321 3328 1064-8011 10.1519/jsc.0000000000001452 10.1519/jsc.0000000000001452
A comparison of pairs figure skaters in repeated jumps Journal of Sports Science & Medicine Sands William A. Kimmel Wendy L. McNeal Jeni R. Murray Steven Ross Stone Michael H. 1 3 2012
11 1 102 108 1303-2968 PMID: 24149126 PMCID: PMC3737852
Effect of sports and growth on hamstrings and quadriceps development in young female athletes: cross-sectional study Sports Sugimoto Dai Borg Dennis R. Brilliant Anna N. Meehan William P., III Micheli Lyle J. Geminiani Ellen T. 28 6 2019
7 7 158 2075-4663 10.3390/sports7070158 10.3390/sports7070158 31261679
Back extensor and psoas muscle cross-sectional area, prior physical training, and trunk muscle strength: a longitudinal study in adolescent girls European Journal of Applied Physiology Peltonen Juha E. Taimela Simo Erkintalo Minna Salminen Jouko J. Oksanen Airi Kujala Urho M. 1 12 1997
77 1-2 66 71 1439-6319 10.1007/s004210050301 10.1007/s004210050301
The relationship of strength and jump height in figure skaters The American Journal of Sports Medicine Podolsky Anatol Kaufman Kenton R. Cahalan Thomas D. Aleshinsky Sergei Y. Chao Edmund Y.S. 7 1990
18 4 400 405 0363-5465 10.1177/036354659001800412 10.1177/036354659001800412 2403190
Effects of mild head injury on postural stability as measured through clinical balance testing Journal of Athletic Training Riemann Bryan L. Guskiewicz Kevin M. 2000
35 1 19 25 1062-6050 PMID: 16558603 PMCID: PMC1323433 16558603
Systematic review of the balance error scoring system Sports Health: A Multidisciplinary Approach Bell David R. Guskiewicz Kevin M. Clark Micheal A. Padua Darin A. 8 4 2011
3 3 287 295 1941-7381 10.1177/1941738111403122 10.1177/1941738111403122 23016020
On-field testing environment and balance error scoring system performance during preseason screening of healthy collegiate baseball players Journal of Athletic Training Onate James A Beck Brian C Van Lunen Bonnie L 2007
42 4 446 451 1062-6050 PMID: 18174931 PMCID: PMC2140068 18174931
A normative dataset of the balance error scoring system in children aged between 5 and 14 Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine Hansen Colby Cushman Dan Anderson Nicholas Chen Wei Cheng Christine Hon Shirley D. Hung Man 11 2016
26 6 497 501 1050-642X 10.1097/jsm.0000000000000285 10.1097/jsm.0000000000000285
Postural control deficits in participants with functional ankle instability as measured by the balance error scoring system Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine Docherty Carrie L. Valovich McLeod Tamara C. Shultz Sandra J. 5 2006
16 3 203 208 1050-642X 10.1097/00042752-200605000-00003 10.1097/00042752-200605000-00003 16778539
Can neurocognitive function predict lower extremity injuries in male collegiate athletes? International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health Ha Sunghe Jeong Hee Seong Park Sang-Kyoon Lee Sae Yong 4 12 2020
17 23 9061 1660-4601 10.3390/ijerph17239061 10.3390/ijerph17239061 33291771
The lumbopelvic-hip complex contribution during lower extremity screening tests in elite figure skaters Journal of Athletic Training Webb Brittney Kenning Jessica Harris Guzman Aracelis Slater Lindsay Mangum L. Colby 1 6 2022
57 6 581 585 1938-162X 10.4085/1062-6050-0373.21 10.4085/1062-6050-0373.21 35969665
Normative performance on the balance error scoring system by youth, high school, and collegiate athletes Journal of Athletic Training Ozinga Sarah J. Linder Susan M. Koop Mandy Miller Dey Tanujit Figler Richard Russman Andrew N. So Richard Rosenthal Alan H. Cruickshank Jason Alberts Jay L. 1 7 2018
53 7 636 645 1062-6050 10.4085/1062-6050-129-17 10.4085/1062-6050-129-17 30109948
Intrarater and interrater reliability of the balance error scoring system (BESS) PM Finnoff Jonathan T. Peterson Valerie J. Hollman John H. Smith Jay 2009
1 1 50 54 1934-1482 10.1016/j.pmrj.2008.06.002 10.1016/j.pmrj.2008.06.002
Sex differences in y-balance performance in elite figure skaters Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research Slater Lindsay V. Vriner Melissa Schuyten Kristen Zapalo Peter Hart Joseph M. 5 2020
34 5 1416 1421 1064-8011 10.1519/jsc.0000000000002542 10.1519/jsc.0000000000002542 29489718
Relationship between clinical and forceplate measures of postural stability Journal of Sport Rehabilitation Riemann Bryan L. Guskiewicz Kevin M. Shields Edgar W. 5 1999
8 2 71 82 1056-6716 10.1123/jsr.8.2.71 10.1123/jsr.8.2.71
Common injuries and medical problems in singles figure skaters Current Sports Medicine Reports Porter Emily B. 2013
12 5 318 320 1537-890X 10.1249/jsr.0b013e3182a4b94e 10.1249/jsr.0b013e3182a4b94e 24030306
Influence of strength and proprioception training on functional ankle stability among young skaters Indian Journal of Health Sciences and Biomedical Research (KLEU) Mudaliar Priyanka Dharmayat Snehal 2017
10 3 317 2542-6214 10.4103/kleuhsj.kleuhsj_42_17 10.4103/kleuhsj.kleuhsj_42_17
Performance on the balance error scoring system decreases after fatigue Journal of Athletic Training Wilkins Joseph C. Valovich McLeod Tamara C. Perrin David H. Gansneder Bruce M. 2004
39 2 156 161 1062-6050 PMID: 15173867 PMCID: PMC419510 15173867
Effects of resistance training in youth athletes on muscular fitness and athletic performance: a conceptual model for long-term athlete development Frontiers in Physiology Granacher Urs Lesinski Melanie Büsch Dirk Muehlbauer Thomas Prieske Olaf Puta Christian Gollhofer Albert Behm David G. 9 5 2016
7 164 1664-042X 10.3389/fphys.2016.00164 10.3389/fphys.2016.00164 27242538
Longitudinal changes in athletic performance in competitive figure skaters Journal of Science in Sport and Exercise Cruz Jacquelyn P. Vriner Melissa Mangum L. Colby Slater Lindsay 7 6 2021
3 4 332 339 2096-6709 10.1007/s42978-021-00124-2 10.1007/s42978-021-00124-2
