
==== Front
BMJ Paediatr Open
BMJ Paediatr Open
bmjpo
bmjpo
BMJ Paediatrics Open
2399-9772
BMJ Publishing Group BMA House, Tavistock Square, London, WC1H 9JR

39209441
10.1136/bmjpo-2024-002863
bmjpo-2024-002863
Viewpoint
1506
Forgotten, invisible and neglected, children in prison from the first few months of life: an act against humanity
Siani Paolo 1siani.paolo@gmail.com

https://twitter.com/https://twitter.com/mumchild_irfmn
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-3997-3726
Bonati Maurizio 2maurizio.bonati@ricercaepratica.it

1 Pediatric Clinic, Santobono Pausilipon Azienda Ospedaliera Pediatrica, Napoli, Italy
2 Mario Negri Institute for Pharmacological Research, Milano, Italy
DrMaurizioBonati; maurizio.bonati@ricercaepratica.it
No, there are no competing interests.

2024
28 8 2024
8 1 e002863Copyright © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2024. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.
2024
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.

Health Policy
Child Health
Ethics
==== Body
pmc With wide variation between and within continents, 11 million people are held in penal institutions throughout the world.1 Since the beginning of the millennium, the total world prison population has grown by 27%, which is slightly less than the estimated increase in the world’s general population over the same period (31%). El Salvador is the country with the highest prison population rate in the world (1086 per 1 000 000 of the national population), while for Europe, it is Turkey (366 per 100 000). The estimated world prison population rate is 140 per 100 000.

Prisoners have significant health needs and experience a disproportionate burden of ill health (including high levels of long-term physical and mental illness) during their stay in prison, and this is very often an aggravation of disorders that were already present before detention. Prisoners generally receive worse healthcare than that delivered in the community.2 Prisoners are a vulnerable population at great risk of stigma, discrimination and inequality in the community, but they are even more so in prison. Women and children are part of this vulnerable population. Women are a minority of the prison population (approximately 740 000 women), and the number of children born or living in prison with their mothers is unreliable.3 In Italy, in June 2024, there were 61 460 inmates in the 189 penal institutions even though the places actually available were 47 067. A total of 44 inmates have committed suicide in prison since the beginning of the year. Dilapidated prisons, overcrowding and poor living conditions for inmates and staff are the norm in Italy. These are also the living conditions for 2480 women (4.4% of the prison population), with 17 mothers detained with 19 children in tow.4 The situation is worse in other countries, but that is not an excuse everywhere.

All children of imprisoned parents, whether or not the children are also in prison or not, are at high risk of inadequate parenting and require special attention. Studies on the children of imprisoned parents are more extensive than studies on imprisoned children themselves.5 Children born in prison or who spend their first months or years of life in prison enter a world that is very different from the one experienced by most newborns. Psychological implications for these children, which are complex and multifaceted, are influenced by a range of factors including maternal attachment, environmental conditions and subsequent caregiving arrangements.6 7

It has been estimated that 19 000 children live with a parent (mainly the mother) or a caregiver in prison, although the rate relative to the prison population by gender, age and restriction stay for children varies considerably between nations. No global consensus on the age to release children from prison exists, despiteUnited Nations (UN) recommendations or the Convention on the Rights of the Child statements,8 9 perhaps because these are not specific enough. The age limit allowed for a child to remain in prison with his or her caregiver ranges from 3 months to 9 years. In Europe, only in Northern Ireland, Norway, Scotland and Slovakia are children not allowed to live with their imprisoned parents in penal institutions.3 10 Although the evidence is scarce, the lifelong effects of incarceration on a child’s early stay in prison can be significant, as an editorial on the topic underlined a few years ago.11 To support the parenting role and reduce the conditions and effects of early child imprisonment, mother and child units have been set up in a few countries and have been systematically implemented or routinely evaluated even if not evidence based.3 12 The Netherlands provides mother and baby units in prisons until children turn 6–9 months, England and Wales until they turn 18 months of age, Germany until they are 3 years old. After these ages, the children move into specialised, prison-based housing for children until the age of 4 years (The Netherlands), 5 years (Germany) and 6 years (Italy). These are different approaches, but they do not guarantee that children who reside in custodial settings have access to the same level of education, healthcare and socialisation as children living in the community.13 A bill (SIani Law) to prevent boys and girls from living behind bars was approved by the Italian Parliament in 2022, but the Senate did not give the final green light. Everything must, therefore, start again.14

Despite the improvements that have occurred, states and the international community still have to make a lot more effort to ensure the full protection of children deprived of liberty.8 Recent moves to try and minimise the imprisonment of mothers, according to Bangkok Rules,15 that urge courts to suspend prison sentences for mothers wherever possible, or to use community rulings, go in this direction. Allowing children to stay with their caregiver in prison has an impact on child development. The UN Convention (art. 9)7 affirms the right of every minor, where this is not in conflict with his or her best interests, to maintain and develop regular relationships with both parents and family members, with a view to a healthy and functional consolidation of affections and a balanced emotional and identity development. This is impossible to guarantee in prison in the early years of life and, perhaps, is so in part only later in institutions with attenuated custody for imprisoned mothers. The best interests of the minor are clearly to live outside of prison, so the postponement of the prison sentence should be mandatory in the case of a pregnant woman or mother of a child in the first few years of life. Judicial measures that ignore the health consequences on children and women in prison are repressive, security based and dehumanising. These are measures that deny socio health, educational and human rights to children who are innocent.

Ensuring equal rights, freedom and opportunities is crucial. It is not easy to decide what choice to make from a legislative and executive point of view, but the interest of the child is to be born and to grow up outside of a prison or a closed institution that denies his or her rights. Regardless of the crimes committed by the parents, children are innocent. Any form of imprisonment, even semifree, is, therefore, a denial of human rights and damages the growth of the victims and the communities.

A call to action to protect children and their health against the imprisonment of children in compliance with the convention on the rights of the child everywhere in the world is necessary. The adverse effects of even earlier detention on child health must be prevented and monitored, trying to remedy it promptly also with appropriate legislative interventions.

Review Process File
28 08 2024

Funding: The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.

Patient consent for publication: Not applicable.

Provenance and peer review: Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
==== Refs
References

1 Fair H Walmsley R World prison population list 14th edn 2024 Available https://www.prisonstudies.org/sites/default/files/resources/downloads/world_prison_population_list_14th_edition.pdf
2 McLintock K Foy R Canvin K et al The quality of prison primary care: cross-sectional cluster-level analyses of prison healthcare data in the North of England EClinMed 2023 63 102171 10.1016/j.eclinm.2023.102171
3 Van Hout MC Klankwarth U-B Fleißner S et al Children living in prison with a primary caregiver: a global mapping of age restrictions and duration of stay Lancet Child Adolesc Health 2023 7 809 14 10.1016/S2352-4642(23)00190-6 37640034
4 Antonelli S Bambini in carcere. Primo Rapporto sulle donne detenute in Italia Antigone 2023 Available https://www.rapportoantigone.it/primo-rapporto-sulle-donne-detenute-in-italia/bambini/
5 Austin MK White II Kim AW Parental incarceration and child physical health outcomes from infancy to adulthood: a critical review and multilevel model of potential pathways Am J Hum Biol 2022 34 e23691 10.1002/ajhb.23691 34665892
6 Alejos M Babies and small children residing in prisons Geneva Quaker United Nations Office 2015 Available https://quno.org/sites/default/files/resources/Babies%20and%20small%20children%20residing%20in%20prisons.pdf
7 Nowak M United nations global study on children deprived of liberty Geneva: United Nations Project report 2019 Available https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/38497/1/UN-GLOBAL-STUDY-ON-CHILDREN-DEPRIVED-OF-LIBERTY-%282019%29.pdf
8 UN Committee on the Rights of the Child Report and recommendations of the day of general discussion on 'children of incarcerated parents' 2011 Available www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/HRBodies/CRC/Discussions/2011/DGD2011ReportAndRecommendations.pdf
9 Convention on the rights of the child. Treaty no. 27531 United Nations treaty series 1577 1989 3 178 Available https://treaties.un.org/doc/Treaties/1990/09/19900902%2003-14%20AM/Ch_IV_11p.pdf
10 Taylor J Majeed T Remond M et al A rapid review of the evidence on models of service delivery for correctional centre-based mothers and children’s units: does our approach need to change? BMJ Glob Health 2024 9 e012979 10.1136/bmjgh-2023-012979
11 Beresford S Loucks N Raikes B The health impact on children affected by parental imprisonment BMJ Paediatr Open 2020 4 e000275 10.1136/bmjpo-2018-000275
12 Aebi MF Cocco E Molnar L et al SPACE i – 2021 – council of Europe annual penal statistics: prison populations Strasbourg: Council of Europe 2022 Available https://childrenofprisoners.eu/facts_and_figures/age-limits-for-children-living-in-prisons/
13 Taylor J Majeed T Remond M et al Are custodial-based mothers and children’s units evaluated, effective and aligned with a human rights-based approach? - A systematic review of the evidence EClinMed 2024 69 102496 10.1016/j.eclinm.2024.102496
14 Proposta di legge: siani e altri: "Modifiche al codice penale, al codice di procedura penale e alla legge 21 aprile 2011, n. 62, in materia di tutela del rapporto tra detenute madri e figli minori (2298) 2022 Available https://www.camera.it/leg18/126?leg=18&idDocumento=2298
15 United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNDOC) United nations rules for the treatment of women prisoners and non-custodial measures for women offenders(the bangkok rules) 2011 Available https://www.unodc.org/documents/justice-and-prison-reform/Bangkok_Rules_ENG_22032015.pdf
