
==== Front
Heliyon
Heliyon
Heliyon
2405-8440
Elsevier

S2405-8440(24)13606-7
10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e37575
e37575
Research Article
A circularly polarized graphene based wideband 1 × 2 array antenna for terahertz spectrum applications
El Ansari Abdelaaziz abdelaaziz.elansari1@usmba.ac.ma
a
Das Sudipta sudipta.das1985@gmail.com
b⁎
Islam Tanvir tislam7@cougarnet.uh.edu
c
Samudrala Varakumari varakumari3@gmail.com
d
Soliman Naglaa F. nfsoliman@pnu.edu.sa
e
Algarni Abeer D. adalqarni@pnu.edu.sa
e⁎⁎
Amrani El Idrissi Najiba El najiba.elamrani@usmba.ac.ma
a
a Signal, System and Component Laboratory, Sidi Mohamed Ben Abdellah University – FST, Fez, 30000, Morocco
b Department of Electronics & Communication Engineering, IMPS College of Engineering and Technology, Malda, 732103, WB, India
c Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Houston, Houston, 77204, TX, USA
d Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, NRI Institute of Technology, Agiripalli, Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh, 521212, India
e Department of Information Technology, College of Computer and Information Sciences, Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University, P.O. Box 84428, Riyadh 11671, Saudi Arabia
⁎ Corresponding author. sudipta.das1985@gmail.com
⁎⁎ Corresponding author. adalqarni@pnu.edu.sa
07 9 2024
30 9 2024
07 9 2024
10 18 e375758 6 2024
11 8 2024
5 9 2024
© 2024 The Authors
2024
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
A graphene-based 1 × 2 array antenna with circular polarization for terahertz applications is prescribed in this article. Initially, a novel concept of a folded quarter wave impedance transformer is utilized in the design process of a single element for minimizing the overall antenna size. The opposite corners of the patches have been truncated and structural modifications are performed with the insertion of four flower-shaped slots along with an additional circular slot for achieving a much-improved reflection coefficient and better impedance bandwidth. It also shows a much wider 3 dB axial ratio bandwidth, confirming circular polarization due to the suggested modifications in its geometry. Then, an array antenna has been formed to provide better gain. The configured patches are fed by a magic-T power divider to attain the required impedance matching. The results of the CP antenna array have been analyzed using the HFSS and CST simulators. The propounded 1 × 2 array antenna shows circular polarization with a 3 dB AR bandwidth of 205 GHz (2.345–2.55 THz) and wide spectral coverage of 210 GHz (2.345 − 2.555 THz) along with a maximum gain of 8.65 dB and 99.8 % radiation efficiency with a total size of 53.5 × 102 × 1.56 μm3. It could be utilized for high-speed data transmission, material characterization, terahertz spectroscopy, terahertz imaging, etc. applications.

Keywords

Array antenna
Circular polarization
Flower slots
Patch antenna
THz band
Terahertz antenna
==== Body
pmc1 Introduction

The terahertz (THz) band has tremendous potential applications for numerous fields including both outdoor and indoor communications within the spectrum of 0.1–10 THz. Moreover, it promises significant applications in many areas specifically in Manufacturing, agriculture, materials characterization, spectroscopic imaging, and security [1]. Due to the availability of unallocated enormous bandwidth, the terahertz band supports significant high-speed communication by implementing effective terahertz antennas [2,3], which is impossible to reach in the microwave band that is allocated and congested with specified applications. However, there are several factors including high atmospheric attenuation and path loss which meanwhile limit the use of the entire THz spectrum effectively. In this context, high gain and highly directive antennas are supremely required to overcome these problems and to permit efficient transmission of data over long distances.

Over the last few decades, the dominance of printed circuit technology has been evident and as a result of this, microstrip patch antennas (MPAs) are highly preferred for the successful establishment of wireless communication systems from Radio Frequency (RF) to THz frequency bands. Further, microstrip patch antenna (MPA) has various advantages and also suffers from several drawbacks. Therefore, many scientists and researchers have reported several techniques to overcome the deficiencies (limited bandwidth, linear polarization, low directivity and gain, etc.) of the MPA, such as modified patch and ground structures [[4], [5], [6]], multilayer substrate [7], Substrate integrated waveguide structures [8], metamaterials [9,10], electromagnetic band gap (EBG) [11,12], and Micro-Electro-Mechanical Systems (MEMS)-based antenna structures [13], etc. The photoconductive antennas are a pivotal part in the generation and reception of terahertz (THz) radiations; however, due to critical impedance matching issues, they are associated with drawbacks of low output power. To resolve this issue, microstrip patch antennas are alternatively preferred to support applications in different spectrums of terahertz frequency regimes. In the literature, researchers have adopted and explored many new design methodologies for designing various geometries of printed terahertz antennas which include array antenna configurations [14,15], graphene-based simple patch [16], tree-shaped patch [17] photonic crystal antenna [[18], [19], [20]], proximity coupled monopole antenna [21], square ribbon patch with the defected ground and Photonic band-gap (PBG) substrate [22], modified patch with slotted ground [23], Metasurface inspired antenna [24], curved slit loaded patch with CPW feeding [25], metamaterial antenna [26], antenna with PBG structure over SiO2 substrate [27], octagonal patch on SiO2 substrate [28], 2 × 2 Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) [29], semi-circular moon shaped radiator [30], fractal antenna [31], antenna with semi-circular slot [32], fractal MIMO antenna [33], rhombus-shaped patch radiator [34], novel coronavirus shaped patch [35].

Although these techniques have successfully managed to design terahertz antennas with acceptable characteristics and parameters, these structures are restricted against polarization i.e., the antennas are arbitrarily orientated and linearly polarized. Nowadays, the most demandable antennas are the antennas having a circular polarization (CP) due to their ability to transmit electromagnetic waves in any direction [[36], [37], [38], [39], [40], [41], [42], [43]]. The referred [[36], [37], [38], [39], [40], [41], [42], [43]] design methodologies are suggested to achieve circular polarization for microwave and mm-wave application bands. In a likewise manner, there are high demands for circularly polarized THz antennas for supporting numerous applications at different terahertz frequency spectrums as recommended and reported in Refs. [[44], [45], [46], [47], [48]]. It includes an S-shaped and Z-shaped slots-loaded CP antenna structure [44], a rectangular dielectric resonator CP antenna (DRA) [45], an E-shaped transparent antenna [46], an optical transparent antenna perturbed with E and I-shaped slots [47], modified circular antenna with plexiglass superstrate material [48], leaf-shaped graphene antenna [49], dielectric resonator antenna with crossed slot [50], etc.

Based on the literature studies, there is a necessity to propose a circularly polarized terahertz antenna with superior performance parameters. In this context, the authors of this current article aimed to design an array antenna to offer wide bandwidth, circular polarization (CP) characteristics, high gain, and radiation efficiency by maintaining its compact size. The proposed array configuration has been adopted to achieve CP characteristics using a single feed technique. The corner truncated optimized patches are modified by adding flower slots and a circular slot to get an ideal circular polarization with enhanced performance. Finally, these two patch elements are fed together by a T magic power divider which increases the impedance bandwidth, 3 dB axial ratio bandwidth, radiation efficiency, and gain. The prescribed array antenna is dedicated to function for wireless communications in the Terahertz (THz) band, especially at around 2.45 THz. Consequently, it can be utilized for high-speed data transmission, material characterization, terahertz spectroscopy, and terahertz medical imaging applications.

The major highlights of the presented terahertz array antenna are summarized:i. Miniaturized size: The designed single feed 1 × 2 array antenna holds a tiny area of only 53.5× 102 μm2.

ii. Design Methodology: Folded feed line, corner truncation, loading of flower and circular shaped slots, array antenna formation, and use of magic-T power divider.

iii. Wideband operation: It is characterized by a wide operating bandwidth of 210 GHz, spanning from 2.345 THz to 2.555 THz at a reference of 10 dB return loss level.

iv. Wide Axial Ratio bandwidth: It shows a wide 3 dB ARBW of 205 GHz [2.345 − 2.55 THz].

v. Circular Polarization: The designed array shows circular polarization characteristics covering a large terahertz frequency spectrum.

vi. High Radiation Performance parameters: It offers a high gain of 8.65 dB and radiation efficiency reaches a maximum of 99.8 % at 2.45 THz.

vii. Applications: The suggested antenna could be utilized for high-speed data transmission, material characterization, terahertz spectroscopy, terahertz imaging, etc. applications.

After this introduction part, the discussion on graphene material is carried out in section 2. The design methodology for the proposed single radiating element is discussed in section 3. Section 4 demonstrates the design and simulation results of the single-fed circularly polarized array antenna. After that, the validation of the design and results with Computer Simulation Technology (CST) software is presented in section 5. Next, in section 6, an extensive performance comparison analysis with state-of-the-art is analyzed. Finally, section 7 concludes the article concisely.

2 Discussion on graphene material

Graphite is the most well-known allotropes of carbon due to its excellent conductivity. In graphite, the graphene sheets are organized as flat hexagonal layers, which consist of an arrangement of carbon atoms (Fig. 1). These layers are clutched with the help of the Van Der Waals forces when they pile on top of one another. Graphene is a widely popular 2D material due to its remarkable mechanical and electrical qualities. Scientists have been paying prime focus to graphene to unlock its excellent potential for the modeling of next-generation devices, to be utilized in the terahertz spectrum. It is a highly versatile material with outstanding conductivity, mechanical strength, and flexibility, and is suitable for numerous technological advancements. Its critical parameters (conductivity, chemical potential, relaxation time, thickness, mechanical strength, flexibility, and optical properties) make it promising for a wide variety of applications, which include photonics, electronics, etc. [16]. The graphene-based antennas are useful for many applications in the THz frequency spectrum. Graphene is preferred as a conductive material for high-frequency (THz) applications with low energy consumption. Due to its unique structure, it offers high charge mobilities, allowing fast-moving electricity compared to other metals. This distinctive property creates a special form of EM radiation in the THz frequency band. The essential parameters used in describing the properties of graphene material are summarized as follows:i. Thickness: The thickness of graphene is indicated by the single-layer thickness of carbon atoms. The thickness approximately equals to 0.34 nm (nm).

ii. Relaxation time: It is the average time between scattering events that an electron experiences as it moves through the graphene lattice. its value can range from picoseconds (ps) to nanoseconds (ns).

iii. Chemical Potential: Its chemical potential refers to the Fermi level relative to the Dirac point, which can be adjusted by doping or applying a gate voltage. It can range from −1 eV to 1 eV, but it is often controlled within a smaller range around the Dirac point (0 eV) for many applications.

iv. Electrical Conductivity: It is featured with high electrical conductivity and electron mobility. It can conduct electricity better than many other materials due to its unique electronic structure, which allows electrons to move through it with minimal scattering.

v. Thermal Conductivity: Graphene has excellent thermal conductivity, which can exceed 3000 Wm−1K−1. This makes it highly efficient for heat dissipation in electronic devices.

vi. Mechanical Strength: Graphene is extremely strong. Despite being only one atom thick, it is incredibly robust and can withstand significant mechanical stress.

vii. Flexibility: Graphene is highly flexible and can be bent, twisted, and stretched without breaking. These qualities make it suitable for applications that require both flexibility and strength.

viii. Optical Properties: It is nearly transparent and can absorb up to 2.3 % of visible light. This property, combined with its electrical conductivity, registered it as a dream fit for use in conductive films with transparency and other optoelectronic applications.

ix. Surface Area: Graphene has a high surface area (2630 m2/g), which makes it advantageous for applications in sensors, energy storage, and catalysis.

Fig. 1 Graphite and graphene carbon structure.

Fig. 1

3 Basic radiating element design methodology

The initial radiating element is a rectangular-shaped patch antenna (RSPA). Its dimensions can be determined through equations that exist in Refs. [[51], [52], [53], [54]]. The methodology used to obtain the proposed circularly polarized basic antenna is presented in the form of a design flowchart [55], shown in Fig. 2. The initiated basic element is fed by a folded impedance matching transformer to get a minimized antenna size. The intended shape of the single-element antenna has been reached after following seven optimization steps through the incorporation of truncated corners, flower-shaped slots, and a circular slot. Seven design steps are used to obtain a resonating frequency at 2.45 THz with an improved return loss and axial ratio. This proposed design is conducted on Rogers' substrate (RT/duroid 5880) with a total dimension of 50 × 51× 1.56 μm3. The Rogers’ substrate is highly reliable and it has low electrical losses, low moisture absorption, and stable dielectric constant over a wide range of frequencies. Graphene is employed as a conducting material for designing both the ground plane and the radiating element due to its magnificent electrical, thermal, and mechanical properties. The intended design stages to obtain the propounded antenna structure are demonstrated in the succeeding sections.Fig. 2 Antenna design methodology flowchart.

Fig. 2

3.1 Effect of truncated corners

Initially, the basic radiating element is depicted in Fig. 3 (a), and its geometrical dimensions are included in Table 1. First of all, in Case 1, the proper impedance matching has been assured by a quarter wave impedance transformer in a folded shape to achieve minimum antenna size as displayed in Fig. 3(a). Its reflection coefficient is displayed in Fig. 4 (a) which signifies a resonance peak at 2.62 THz with an S11 of about − 5.5 dB. Moreover, its axial ratio variations are depicted in Fig. 4 (b), according to the curve, it has values tending to the maximum limit (much above 3 dB) which confirms that the design in Case 1 has a linear polarization. To make the basic element a circularly polarized, 90° phase differed two orthogonal resonant modes of equal magnitudes should be generated. In the next steps, some modifications are introduced in design steps that can help to generate these orthogonal modes.Fig. 3 (a) The basic element fed by a folded quarter wave impedance transformer. (b) The basic element with two truncated corners.

Fig. 3

Table 1 Optimal geometrical parameters of the basic antenna.

Table 1Parameters	LS	WS	LP	WP	FL1	FL2	FL3	WF1	WF2	D	d	
Value (μm)	50	51	38.42	38.22	10	21.43	5	1.35	4.84	10.4	4.5	

Fig. 4 Simulation results of case 1 versus case 2. (a): S11 (b): The axial ratio.

Fig. 4

The first stage for improving the performance of the structure presented in Case 1 is to truncate two corners at two opposite sides as shown in Case 2 of Fig. 3 (b). These two truncated corners perturb the patch along its diagonal axes and make an asymmetric structure. Consequently, it leads the basic element near the circular polarization and offers significant impedance matching and shifting of resonance to a lower value. Fig. 4(a and b) shows its reflection coefficient S11 versus frequency as well as its axial ratio versus frequency for Case 2. The reflection coefficient is improved to − 11 dB at 2.52 THz and also, the axial ratio is down to 9 dB at 2.54 THz.

3.2 Effect of flower slots

In Case 2, the values in terms of S11 (=− 11 dB) and AR (=9 dB) aren't enough to obtain a wideband antenna with good circularly polarized waves. In the third step (Case 3), the objective is to resonate the basic element at the desired frequency (2.45 THz) with improved performance. The first flower-shaped slot is introduced within the patch as observed in Case 3 [Fig. 5]. As seen, the resonant frequency is further moved to a lower value, but the minimum value of the AR is not reached to 3 dB at the desired frequency of 2.45 THz [see Fig. 6(b)]. To achieve it, the next step is executed in which a second flower slot is added in the opposite quarter (see Fig. 5, Case 4). As shown in Case 4 of Fig. 6, the resonance is further lowered and decreased to 3 dB value as per the AR vs frequency plot. After that, a 3rd flower slot is added in the 3rd quarter as depicted in Case 5 of Fig. 5. Now, concerning both S11 and AR, the resonant frequency is achieved at the same value but not at the desired value of 2.45 THz as shown in Fig. 6 [Case 5]. In this context, the 4th flower slot is added (see Fig. 5, Case 6). In this case, the resonant frequency at 2.45 THz is obtained for both AR and S11 plots. The antenna shows S11 = − 19 dB, and AR = 1.3 dB at 2.45 THz with an improved − 10 dB IBW and 3 dB ARBW as compared to the preceding design cases.Fig. 5 Flower-shaped slots loaded design cases (a) one flower slot (b) two (c) three (d) four flower slots.

Fig. 5

Fig. 6 Simulation results of Case 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. (a): S11 (b): Axial ratio.

Fig. 6

3.3 Effect of circular slot

In addition to the previous six improvement steps, in this section, we present the last improvement step designated as Case 7. A circular slot is introduced in this design stage, as shown in Fig. 7. The optimal radius of this circular slot is obtained after the parametric sweep. This slot is used for the enhancement of bandwidth as per both reflection coefficient S11 and axial ratio, as well as for decreasing their minimum values. Also, the gain and the radiation efficiency in this case are slightly enhanced due to the presence of an optimized circular slot. The geometrical attributes of the optimized basic antenna are summarized in Table 1.Fig. 7 Proposed flower-shaped and circular slots-based CP antenna views (a) 2D (b) 3D.

Fig. 7

The results of the simulation study for the basic element (comparison of Case 7 against Case 6) are exhibited in Fig. 8. As shown, the performance parameters achieved in Case 7 are improved compared to Case 6. The reflection coefficient is improved to − 24 dB with a little bit of increment in impedance bandwidth at − 10 dB reference level. However, prominently, the 3 dB ARBW is enhanced from 35 GHz to 165 GHz along with a little bit of improvements in the peak gain and radiation efficiency as well.Fig. 8 Simulation results of the proposed single-fed circular polarized basic element (a): reflection coefficient bandwidth. (b): Axial ratio bandwidth. (c): Gain versus frequency. (d): Radiation efficiency versus frequency.

Fig. 8

The surface current distribution of the optimized basic element with phases 0°, 90°, 180° and 270° at 2.45 THz are shown in Fig. 9. The current vector tip direction changes clockwise which means that the basic element reveals a right-hand circular polarization (RHCP) characteristic. These flower slots and the circular slot helped to perturb the distribution of surface current in the patch. Therefore, two orthogonal degenerate modes of resonance frequency with equal amplitudes are excited.Fig. 9 Surface current distribution 2.45 THz with the phase (a) 0° (b) 90° (c) 270° (d) 180°.

Fig. 9

3.4 Parametric variations analysis

The outcome of variations in the radius of the incorporated circular slot has been examined through a simulation tool. It can be visualized that the addition of a circular slot within the patch structure is a very crucial design step. The variations in its radius (r) control the bandwidth of the antenna very significantly. The variations in S11 (dB) and Axial Ratio (dB) as a result of changes in ‘r’ are demonstrated in Fig. 10(a and b), respectively. It is noticeable that maximum IBW and 3-dB ARBW are achieved for the proposed dimension of r = 2.75 μm as indicated by the black solid line. The bandwidth performance is getting worse with further increases or decreases in its dimensions. Hence, r = 2.75 μm is considered to be the optimal circular slot radius during the design process.Fig. 10 Variations in operating bandwidth as a function of circular slot radius ‘r’ (a) S11 (dB) (b) Axial Ratio (dB).

Fig. 10

4 Proposed 1 × 2 array antenna

The design and simulation outcomes of the proposed graphene-based single-fed circularly polarized 1 × 2 array antenna is discussed in this section. For the excitation of the array, a simple T-power divider is employed for feeding the patch elements to get a well-adopted impedance matching [Fig. 11]. The performance of this array is analyzed to justify improvements in performance parameters (gain, impedance bandwidth, radiation efficiency, and axial ratio bandwidth). The intended array design is executed on the Rogers’ substrate (RT/duroid 5880) with an overall size of 53.5 × 102× 1.56 μm3.Fig. 11 Proposed single fed circular polarized 1 × 2 array antenna views (a) 2D (b) 3D.

Fig. 11

The simulation studies have been performed by HFSS EM solver. Fig. 12 (a) shows the reflection coefficient characteristics which shows the bandwidth of the array antenna is well improved and equals 210 GHz (from 2.345 THz to 2.555 THz). The axial ratio plot is shown in Fig. 12 (b). The 3 dB ARBW is also significantly enhanced and it equals 205 GHz (2.345 − 2.55 THz). The gain versus frequency is illustrated in Fig. 12 (c), according to this figure, it is noticed that the peak gain is increased to 8.65 dB at 2.45 THz. Fig. 12 (d) presents the radiation efficiency; it is increased to 99.97 % at 2.45 THz. The radiation patterns are presented indicating both co and cross-pol components. The patterns are projected in Fig. 13(a and b). The patterns are obtained in the desired shape and the cross-pol levels are adequately down in comparison to co-pol in both planes.Fig. 12 Simulation results of the single-fed circularly polarized 1 × 2 array antenna versus CP single element. (a) S11 (b) Axial ratio bandwidth (c) Gain, and (d) Radiation efficiency.

Fig. 12

Fig. 13 Radiation patterns representing Co-pol and Cross-pol at 2.45 THz in (a) E plane (b) H-plane.

Fig. 13

In addition, the circular polarization (CP) is evaluated by demonstrating surface current distribution at 2.45 THz as shown in Fig. 14. The CP is obtained by the excitation of two orthogonal modes having a phase shift of 90°. This is accomplished by the single feed, corners truncated, flower slots, and circular slots inserted on the patch element. In surface current distributions, figures with 0°, 90°, 180°, and 270° phases are plotted. Thus, it is clear that the direction of the vector current tips rotates in a clockwise direction, which proves the RHCP (Right Hand Circular Polarization) in the boresight direction.Fig. 14 Distributed surface currents at 2.45 THz with (a) 0° (b) 90° (c) 270° (d) 180° phases.

Fig. 14

5 Validation of design and results with computer simulation technology (CST) software

As per the current scenario, fabrication and measurement of THz antennas are challenging because of tiny dimensions and non-available practical resources. The various processes like PCB etching [56], nano-lithography [57], and micro-machining [58] can be implied to execute the practical prototyping of the THz antenna. The PCB etching process needs a high-precision etching module to execute the design with maximum accuracy. The nano-lithography and micro-machining techniques are employed to design or etch the microscopic level structures.

Due to the unavailability of resources for prototype testing and validation, we have carried out the design and analysis using two different 3D EM simulators (HFSS and CST). Both 3D simulators are used for electromagnetic problems. These tools are widely used for designing antennas, microwave circuits, RF components, and other high-frequency devices. The design and simulation analysis of the array antenna is executed by utilizing an HFSS-EM solver. The results obtained from HFSS software are validated by analyzing the results of the prescribed array antenna using the CST tool. Fig. 15 clarifies good agreement between the outcomes obtained from both EM solvers, which confirms the validity of the designed array antenna for terahertz applications.Fig. 15 Comparison of HFSS and CST Simulation results for 1 × 2 array antenna. (a) S11 (b) Axial ratio bandwidth (c) Gain (d) Radiation efficiency, (e) E plane, and (f) H-plane radiation patterns.

Fig. 15

6 Performance analysis with reported terahertz antennas and discussion

The performance of the suggested circularly polarized high gain, highly efficient terahertz array antenna is compared with a few previously referred terahertz antennas [[14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24], [25], [26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33], [34], [35],[44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49]] in terms of antenna dimensions, operating band, impedance bandwidth, ARBW, gain, and polarization. The summary of performance comparison analysis is presented in Table 2. As compared with other existing linearly polarized (LP) THz antenna designs [[14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24], [25], [26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33], [34], [35]], the proposed array antenna is considerably miniaturized. The proposed array antenna provides the highest gain as compared to all other references except ref. [30,32]. However, it offers a much wider impedance bandwidth with a compact size compared to Ref. [[30], [32]]. Furthermore, the terahertz antennas reported in Refs. [[14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24], [25], [26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33], [34], [35]] do not possess the capability to radiate with circular polarization. In this regard, a few terahertz antenna designs with CP characteristics are listed in Refs. [[44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49]]. In comparison to the referred THz CP antennas, the proposed design holds the most miniaturized size (0.83 λ0× 0.43λ0) and also shows the highest gain value of 8.65 dB along with the broadest 3 dB axial ratio bandwidth (ARBW). The broad ARBW confirms better circular polarization performance over the maximum range of frequencies.Table 2 Summary of comparative analysis with previously reported references.

Table 2Ref.	Antenna Size
λ0×λ0	Operating Band (THz)	− 10 dB Bandwidth (THz)	3 dB ARBW (%)	Maximum Gain (dB)	Circular
Polarization	
[14]: 2022	2.57 × 1.85	0.52–0.78	0.26	NA	–	No	
[15]: 2022	2.71 × 1.89	0.43–0.84	0.41	NA	–	No	
[16]:2024	0.39 × 0.17	0.84–1.12	0.28	NA	7.41	No	
[17]: 2022	0.98 × 0.49	0.276–0.711	0.435	NA	–	No	
[18]: 2024	3.59 × 1.30	0.60–0.70	0.1	NA	–	No	
[19]: 2022	3.28 × 2.10	0.5–0.8	0.3	NA	–	No	
[20]: 2021	0.518 × 0.44	0.73–0.75	0.02	NA	6.395	No	
[21]: 2023	0.96 × 0.67	3.572–3.6818	0.1098	NA	4.3	No	
[22]: 2023	0.46 × 0.46	0.6–0.8	0.2	NA	7.62	No	
[23]: 2023	0.34 × 0.26	0.57–1.02	0.45	NA	–		
[24]: 2023	0.61 × 0.61	0.445–0.470	0.025	NA	4.6	No	
[25]: 2024	–	0.761–0.853
1.117–1.413	0.092
0.296	NA	7.31	No	
[26]: 2022	–	1.281–1.354	0.073	NA	7.72		
[27]: 2023	–	1.267/1.502	–	NA	5.232	No	
[28]: 2023	1.38 × 1.38	0.257–0.370	0.113	NA	2.45	No	
[29]: 2021	0.5 × 0.5	0.095–0.205	0.11	NA	4.4	No	
[30]: 2021	1.58 × 1.4	0.616–0.64	0.024	NA	9.45	No	
[31]: 2023	0.27 × 0.18	1.41–3.0	1.59	NA	4.60	No	
[32]: 2022	0.33 × 0.5	1.0	–	NA	8.87	No	
[33]: 2022	0.71 × 0.35	0.35–0.75	0.4	NA	5.49	No	
[34]: 2021	0.55 × 0.55	0.445–0.714	0.269	NA	5.7	No	
[35]: 2023	0.44 ×0.44	0.3627–0.5918	0.2291	NA	4.0	No	
[44]: 2020	1.2 ×0. 46	0.258–0.355	0.097	9.3 %	5.6	Yes	
[45]: 2022	–	3.3688–3.7232	0.3544	2 %	8.0	Yes	
[46]: 2020	1.1 × 0.55	0.98–1.225	0.245	8.8 %	2.59	Yes	
[47]: 2021	1.1 × 0.55	0.98–1.23	0.25	8.7 %	2.61	Yes	
[48]: 2022	–	0.5–0.7	0.2	–	5	Yes	
[49]: 2024	–	2.31–2.41
3.11–3.51	0.1
0.4	–	6.11	Yes	
Proposed	0.83 × 0.43	2.345–2.555	0.21	9.4 %	8.65	Yes (RHCP)	
NA= Not Applicable.

In summary, the proposed array configuration is advantageous in terms of balanced performance by offering a smaller size, high gain, broad operating bandwidth, and right-hand circular polarization (RHCP) with a wider 3 dB AR bandwidth. Hence, the suggested array antenna could be promising for high-speed data transmission, material characterization, spectroscopy, and medical imaging applications in the terahertz regime due to its attractive size and superior performance.

7 Conclusion

In this article, an effort has been made to design a new 1 × 2 array antenna with a circular polarization using a single feed technique. The proposed graphene array antenna is intended for terahertz band applications. The intended geometry of the single antenna element has been obtained through the execution of six development stages. The design methodology includes the connection of a folded feed line, corner truncation at the patch, and the insertion of tiny flower-shaped slots placed in each quadrant of the patch along with the presence of a circular-shaped slot. The modified single-element patch antenna shows transformed polarization from linear to circular with enhanced 3 dB AR bandwidth performance. Finally, a 1× 2 array is configured comprising of two single-element patches, which are fed together by a magic-T power divider. Furthermore, the prescribed array antenna demonstrates an upgraded performance in terms of gain, impedance bandwidth, efficiency as well as the bandwidth for the axial ratio (3 dB) and the reflection coefficient. The suggested circularly polarized terahertz array antenna measures a compact geometry with an overall size of 102 × 53.5× 1.56 on a micrometer scale. Furthermore, it offers IBW of 210 GHz (2.345–2.555 THz), 3 dB ARBW of 205 GHz (2.345–2.55 THz), maximum gain, of 8.65 dB, and radiation efficiency of 99.8 %, respectively. This suggested circularly polarized microstrip 1 × 2 array antenna configuration is dedicated to work for wireless communications in the Terahertz (THz) spectral band precisely at around 2.45 THz. Therefore, it can be utilized for high-speed data transmission, material characterization, spectroscopy, and medical imaging applications in the terahertz domain.

Funding

This research was funded by 10.13039/501100004242 Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University Researchers Supporting Project number (PNURSP2024R51 ), Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

Data availability statement

The datasets are available within the manuscript.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Abdelaaziz El Ansari: Writing – original draft, Software, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation, Conceptualization. Sudipta Das: Writing – original draft, Validation, Supervision, Software, Investigation, Conceptualization. Tanvir Islam: Writing – review & editing, Visualization, Software, Formal analysis, Conceptualization. Varakumari Samudrala: Writing – review & editing, Visualization, Validation, Data curation, Conceptualization. Naglaa F. Soliman: Writing – review & editing, Methodology, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Data curation. Abeer D. Algarni: Writing – review & editing, Project administration, Methodology, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis. Najiba El Amrani El Idrissi: Writing – review & editing, Validation, Supervision, Resources, Methodology.

Declaration of competing interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgments

The authors extend their appreciation to 10.13039/501100004242 Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University Researchers Supporting Project number (PNURSP2024R51 ), Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
==== Refs
References

1 Shamim S.M. Das S. Hossain M.A. Investigations on graphene-based ultra-wideband (UWB) microstrip patch antennas for terahertz (THz) applications Plasmonics 16 2021 1623 1631
2 Lamri I.E. Ahmad S. Nakmouche M.F. Ghaffar A. Fawzy D.E. Allam A.M.M.A. Ali E.M. Dalarsson M. Alibakhshikenari M. Design and development of a graphene-based reconfigurable patch antenna array for THz applications Frequenz 77 3–4 2023 219 228
3 Sharma A. Tiwari P. Vishwakarma D.K. Frequency re-configurable metal-graphene hybrid MIMO patch antenna for terahertz communication Frequenz 76 7–8 2022 381 389
4 Devana V.N.K.R. Radha N. Sunitha P. Alsunaydih F.N. Alsaleem F. Alhassoon K. Compact MIMO UWB antenna integration with Ku band for advanced wireless communication applications Heliyon 10 5 2024 e27393
5 Bouchachi I. Reddaf A. Boudjerda M. Alhassoon K. Babes B. Alsunaydih F.N. Ali E. Alsharef M. Alsaleem F. Design and performances improvement of an UWB antenna with DGS structure using a grey wolf optimization algorithm Heliyon 10 5 2024 e26337
6 Kiani S. Rezaei P. Fakhr M. A CPW-fed wearable antenna at ISM band for biomedical and WBAN applications Wireless Network 27 2021 735 745
7 Yu X. Liang M. Shemelya C. 3-D printed parts for a multilayer phased array antenna system IEEE antennas Wirel Propag Lett. 17 11 2018 2150 2154
8 Sohrabi P. Rezaei P. Kiani S. A symmetrical SIW-based leaky-wave antenna with continuous beam scanning from backward-to-forward through broadside Wireless Network 27 2021 5417 5424
9 Raghavendra C. Ammal M.N. Madhav B.T.P. Metamaterial inspired square gap defected ground structured wideband dielectric resonator antenna for microwave applications Heliyon 9 2 2023 e13564
10 EL Houda Nasri N. EL Ghzaoui M. Das S. A square split ring resonator-based metamaterial integrated high gain 4 × 4 MIMO antenna with circular polarization for wideband 5G millimeter-wave applications Opt. Quant. Electron. 56 2024 971
11 Dellaoui S. Kaabal A. El Halaoui M. Asselman A. Ahyoud S. Rmili L. High gain array antenna using electromagnetic band gap structures for 5G applications Prog. Electromagn. Res. C. 118 2022 83 97
12 Kumar G. Singh D. Kumar R. A planar CPW fed UWB antenna with dual rectangular notch band characteristics incorporating U-slot SRRs, and EBGs Int J RF Microw Comput Eng 31 7 2021 10.1002/mmce.22676
13 Saha R. Maity S. Bhunia C.T. Design and characterization of a tunable patch antenna loaded with capacitive MEMS switch using CSRRs structure on the patch Alexandria Eng. J. 55 3 2016 2621 2630
14 Benlakehal M.E. Hocini A. Khedrouche D. Design and analysis of novel microstrip patch antenna array based on photonic crystal in THz Opt. Quant. Electron. 54 2022 297
15 Benlakehal M.E. Hocini A. Khedrouche D. Design and analysis of a 1 × 2 microstrip patch antenna array based on photonic crystals with a graphene load in THz J. Opt. 52 2022 483 493
16 El Ansari A. Islam T. Das S. El Idrissi N.E.A. Yakkou H. Khandare S.K. Design of a broadband (0.84–1.2 THz) microstrip patch antenna utilizing graphene material and polyimide substrate for terahertz 6G applications El Ghzaoui M. Das S. Samudrala V. Medikondu N.R. Next Generation Wireless Communication. Signals and Communication Technology 2024 Springer Cham 10.1007/978-3-031-56144-3_17
17 Vasu Babu K. A micro-scaled graphene-based tree-shaped wideband printed MIMO antenna for terahertz applications J. Comput. Electron. 21 1 2022 289 303
18 Babu K.V. Sree G.N.J. Islam T. Das S. Anuradha B. Spatially efficient MIMO antenna design using photonic crystal and polyimide substrate El Ghzaoui M. Das S. Samudrala V. Medikondu N.R. Next Generation Wireless Communication. Signals and Communication Technology 2024 Springer Cham 10.1007/978-3-031-56144-3_25
19 Benlakehal M.E. Hocini A. Khedrouche D. Design and analysis of a 1 × 2 microstrip patch antenna array based on periodic and aperiodic photonic crystals in terahertz Opt. Quant. Electron. 54 2022 672
20 Kushwaha R.K. Karuppanan P. Investigation and design of microstrip patch antenna employed on PCs substrates in THz regime Australian J. Electr. Electron. Eng. 18 2 2021 118 125
21 Babu K.V. Shifali P.C. Manisha J. Design and implementation of MIMO graphene patch antenna to improve isolation for THz applications Microsyst. Technol. 29 2023 1443 1453
22 Bendaoudi A. Berka M. Debab M. Mahdjoub Z. Effects of ground plane on a square graphene ribbon patch antenna designed on a high-permittivity substrate with PBG structures Frequenz 77 2023 385 394
23 krishna C.M. Islam T. Suguna N. Kumari S.V. Devi R.D.H. Das S. A micro-scaled graphene-based wideband (0.57–1.02 THz) patch antenna for terahertz applications Results in Optics 12 2023 100501
24 Alibakhshikenari M. Virdee B.S. Rajaguru R.K. High performance antenna-on-chip inspired by SIW and metasurface technologies for THz band operation Sci. Rep. 13 2023 56 36593353
25 Naik K.K. Asymmetric CPW-fed patch antenna with slits at terahertz applications for 6G wireless communications Wireless Network 30 2024 2343 2351
26 Aggarwal I. Pandey S. Sripathy M.R. A compact high gain metamaterial-based antenna for terahertz applications J. Electron. Mater. 51 2022 4589 4600
27 Bai Y. Li J. Dual-band terahertz antenna based on a novel photonic band gap structure Optoelectron. Lett. 19 2023 666 672
28 Pandey G.K. Thipparaju R.R. Mondal S. Graphene based quad port terahertz MIMO antenna for wireless indoor communications Opt. Quant. Electron. 55 2023 746
29 Okan T. High efficiency unslotted ultra-wideband microstrip antenna for sub-terahertz short range wireless communication systems Optik 242 2021 166859
30 Inzamam A. Ullah S. Ullah S. Habib U. Ahmad S. Ghaffar A. shikenari M.A. Khan S. Limiti E. Design and analysis of a photonic crystal based planar antenna for THz applications Electronics 10 16 2021 1941
31 Babu K.V. Sree G.N.J. Islam T. Performance analysis of a photonic crystals embedded wideband (1.41–3.0 THz) fractal MIMO antenna over SiO2 substrate for terahertz band applications Silicon 15 2023 7823 7836
32 Aathmanesan T. Gain improvement of THz antenna using semicircular slot and modified ground plane Int. J. Commun. Syst. 35 7 2022 e5103
33 Babu K.V. Das S. Sree G.N.J. Madhav B.T.P. Patel S.K.K. Parmar J. Design and optimization of micro-sized wideband fractal MIMO antenna based on characteristic analysis of graphene for terahertz applications Opt. Quant. Electron. 54 5 2022 281
34 Krishna C.M. Das S. Nella A. A micro-sized rhombus-shaped THz antenna for high-speed short-range wireless communication Applications Plasmonics 16 2021 2167 2177
35 Kiani S. Rezaei P. Fakhr M. On-chip coronavirus shape antenna for wide band applications in terahertz band J. Opt. 52 2023 860 867
36 Heidari H.R. Rezaei P. Kiani S. Taherinezhad M. A monopulse array antenna based on SIW with circular polarization for using in tracking systems AEU - International Journal of Electronics and Communications 162 2023 154563
37 Wen L. Gao S. Luo Q. Hu W. Izquierdo S.B. Design of a wideband dual-feed circularly polarized antenna for different axial ratio requirements IEEE Antenn. Wireless Propag. Lett. 20 1 2021 88 92
38 Ahmad N. Aslam J. Nawaz H. Shahid H. Shoaib N. Dual circularly polarized series-fed patch antenna array integrated with beam switching network Int J Numer Model Electron Networks Devices Fields 34 5 2021 1 19
39 Tran H.H. Trong N.N. Park H.C. A compact dual circularly polarized antenna with wideband operation and high isolation IEEE Access 8 2020 182959 182965
40 Almorabeti S. Rifi M. Terchoune H. Tizyi H. Afyf A. Latrach M. 2×2 circular polarized antenna array for RF energy harvesting system to a UAV Int J Microw Opt Technol 13 6 2018 508 516
41 Tran H.H. Hussain N. Le T.T. Low-profile wideband circularly polarized MIMO antenna with polarization diversity for WLAN applications AEU - Int. J. Electron. Commun. 108 2019 172 180
42 Bhaskar S. Singh A.K. Meandered cross-shaped slot circularly polarised antenna for handheld UHF RFID reader AEU Int. J. Electron. Commun. 100 2019 106 113
43 Nasimuddin Chen Z.N. Qing X. Slotted microstrip antennas for circular polarization with compact size IEEE Antennas Propag Mag 55 2 2013 124 137
44 Ullah S. Ruan C. Sadiq M.S. Haq T.U. He W. Microstrip system on-chip circular polarized (CP) slotted antenna for THz communication application J. Electromagn. Waves Appl. 34 8 2020 1029 1038
45 Vishwanath G. Varshney Sahana B.C. Tunable Terahertz Circularly Polarized Dielectric Resonator Antenna with the Higher Order Modes Silicon vol. 14 2022 6279 6289
46 Chowdhury M.S.U. Rahman M.A. Hossain M.A. Mobashsher A.T. A transparent conductive material based circularly polarized nano-antenna for THz applications 2020 IEEE Region 10 Symposium (TENSYMP) 2020 754 757 10.1109/TENSYMP50017.2020.9230696
47 Rahman M.A. Chowdhury Md S.U. Hossain Md A. Toaha M.A. Numerical analysis of a ITO based circularly polarized optically transparent THz antenna employing characteristic mode analysis Prog. Electromagn. Res. C 117 2021 1 16
48 Kiani N. Hamedani F.T. Rezaei P. Realization of polarization adjusting in reconfigurable graphene-based microstrip antenna by adding leaf-shaped patch Micro and Nanostruct 168 2022 p207322
49 Vishwanath Varshney G. Sahana B.C. Design of tunable THz dielectric resonator antenna with cross-slot for circular polarization Opt. Quant. Electron. 56 2024 922
50 Ansari A.E. Das S. Arrouch T.E. Idrissi N.E.A.E. A hybrid coupler integrated 1×4 printed array antenna with broadband and high performance for beamforming RFID reader Proc - 2022 9th Int Conf Wirel Networks Mob Commun WINCOM 2022 4 9 10.1109/WINCOM55661.2022.9966467
51 Ansari A.E. Das S. Idrissi N.E.A.E. Arrouch T.E. Bendali A. Slot incorporated high gain Printed RFID Reader Array antenna for 2.4 GHz ISM band applications E3S Web Conf. 351 2022 01056
52 Ansari A.E. Das S. Tabakh I. Madhav B.T.P. Bendali A. Idrissi N.E.A.E. Design and realization of a broadband multi-beam 1×2 array antenna based on 2×2 butler matrix for 2.45 GHz RFID reader applications J circuits Syst Comput 31 17 2022 1 20
53 Arrouch T.E. Idrissi N.E.A.E. Ansari A.E. Microstrip patch antenna using a parasitic mushroom for 5GApplication at 28GHz 2022 9th International Conference on Wireless Networks and Mobile Communications (WINCOM) 2022 IEEE 1 6
54 Ansari A. Islam T. Rao S.V.R. Saravanan A. Das S. Idrissi N.A. A broadband microstrip 1 x 8 magic-T power divider for ISM band array antenna applications J. Nano- Electron. Phys 15 3 2023 03003
55 Varcheh H.N. Rezaei P. Kiani S. A modified Jerusalem microstrip filter and its complementary for low phase noise X-band oscillator International Journal of Microwave and Wireless Technologies 15 10 2023 1707 1716 10.1017/S1759078723000703
56 Rabbani M.S. Ghafouri S.H. Improvement of microstrip antenna's gain, bandwidth and fabrication tolerance at terahertz frequency bands Wideband and Multi-Band Antennas and Arrays for Civil, Security & Military Applications London 2015 1 3 10.1049/ic.2015.0146
57 Wang L. Sreemanth M.U. Jin X.E. Xu X. Nanolithography using high transmission nanoscale bowtie apertures Nano Lett. 6 3 2006 361 364 16522023
58 Jamshed M.A. Nauman A. Abbasi M.A.B. Kim S.W. Antenna selection and designing for THz applications: suitability and performance evaluation A Survey IEEE Access 8 2020 113246 113261
