
==== Front
Spartan Med Res J
Spartan Med Res J
1364
Spartan Medical Research Journal
2474-7629
MSU College of Osteopathic Medicine Statewide Campus System Website: Spartan Medical Research Journal

123410
10.51894/001c.123410
Original Contribution
Influence of Porosities of 3D Printed Titanium Implants on the Tensile Properties in a Rat Tendon Repair Model
Fry Michael MD 1
Ren Weiping MD, PhD 2
Bou-Akl Therese MD, PhD 1
Wu Bin MD 1
Paula Pawlitz MS 1
Markel David C. MD 1 3
1 Section of Orthopaedic Surgery Ascension Providence Hospital, Southfield, MI, USA
2 Virotech Co., Inc., Troy, MI, USA
3 The CORE Institute, Novi, MI, USA
Corresponding Author: Therese Bou-Akl, MD, PhD. 16001 West Nine Mile Road, Southfield, MI 48075 t: 248-849-2564 f: 248-849-5366 Therese.bou-akl@ascension.org tbouakl@gmail.com
9 9 2024
2024
9 3 123410https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

BACKGROUND

There is a desire in orthopaedics to have soft tissue, particularly tendon, grow into metallic implants. With the introduction of three-dimensional (3D) printed porous metal implants, we hypothesized that tendons could directly attach to the implants. However, the effects of the porous metal structure on tissue growth and penetration into the pores are unknown. Using a rat model, we investigated the effect of pore size on tendon repair fixation using 3D printed titanium implants.

METHODS

There were three experimental groups of eight Sprague Dawley rats (n = 24) plus control (n = 3). Implants had defined pore sizes of 400µm (n = 8), 700µm (n = 8), and 1000µm (n = 8). A defect was created in the Achilles tendon and the implant positioned between cut ends and secured with suture. Specimens were harvested at twelve weeks. Half the specimens underwent mechanical testing to assess tensile load to failure. The remaining specimens were fixed and processed for hard tissue histological analysis.

RESULTS

The average load to failure was 72.6N for controls (SD 10.04), 29.95N for 400µm (SD 17.95), 55.08N for 700µm (SD 13.47), and 63.08N for 1000µm (SD 1.87). The load to failure was generally better in the larger pore sizes. The 700µm and 1000µm specimens performed similarly, while the 400µm showed significant differences vs control (p = 0.039), vs 1000µm (p = 0.010), and approached significance vs 700µm (p = 0.066). There was increasing ingrowth as pore size increased. Histology showed fibrous tendon tissue within and around the implants, with collagen fibers organized in bundles.

CONCLUSIONS

Tendon repair utilizing implants with 700µm and 1000µm pores exhibited similar load to failure as controls. Using a defined pore structure at the attachment points of tendons to implants may allow predictable tendon ingrowth onto/into an implant at the time of revision arthroplasty.

titanium
porosity
tendon healing
None
==== Body
pmcINTRODUCTION

Extensor mechanism and abductor reconstructions in total joint arthroplasty are problematic. Several methods exist for repair, ranging from simple suturing, augmentation with autograft or allograft, to complete replacement of the entire mechanism.1–3 The goal of repair is to achieve strong, stable reattachment and restore function. However, outcomes of these procedures are variable, and all treatment options are associated with substantial complications and failure rates.1–7

When tendons are injured, they do not fully regain their initial properties. Fibrosis and scar formation occurs, which decreases the mechanical strength of the tendon and can lead to re-injury and chronic complications.8–10 In order to improve outcomes after tendon injury, a better understanding of the optimal conditions to promote tendon healing and prevent fibrosis is needed.

The ability to grow tendon directly into a metal implant would have great reconstructive advantages. With the introduction of three dimensional (3D) printed porous metal implants, it was hypothesized that tendons could be grown onto or into the porous implant and thus directly attached. Several studies have demonstrated successful tendon healing and ingrowth of tissue into a porous metal implant,11–14 and use of a porous metal implant has been shown to improve tendon healing compared to direct repair.15–17 However, the effects of the porous metal structure on tissue growth and penetration into the pores are not fully understood, and there is no consensus regarding optimal pore size and structure to promote tendon healing.

We previously evaluated printed porous titanium (Ti) cylinder constructs with three pore sizes (400µm, 700µm, and 1000µm) on the viability and function of fibroblasts and tenocytes in-vitro using a bioreactor. Our results indicated that these cells penetrated and survived inside the material within an optimal pore size of 700µm.18

In this study, we sought to build upon the in-vitro work to better understand the impact of implant design in terms of tendon healing and strength. Using a rat model, we investigated the effect of pore size on tendon repair fixation using printed Ti implants with defined and differing pore sizes. We hypothesized that tendon repair with larger pore sizes would result in better tissue migration into the implants and thus improved mechanical strength.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ti Cylinders

Custom 3D printed porous Ti cylinders 4mm in diameter and 2mm in height with three defined pore sizes (400µm, 700µm, and 1000µm) were provided by Stryker Orthopaedics (Mahwah, NJ). Implants were printed using additive manufacturing technique according to Stryker’s specifications to ensure standardized and defined pore structure. A 1mm diameter hole was drilled through the center of the 400µm and 700µm cylinders to facilitate their fixation between the cut ends of the tendon (Figure 1). Pore sizes were selected based on a range that was manufacturable while also encompassing the ranges used for ingrowth devices.

244842 Figure 1. Custom 3D printed porous titanium cylinders (4x2mm). (A) shows the original cylinders and (B) shows the 400μm and 700μm cylinders with the central 1mm hole.

Animals and Surgical Technique

This animal study was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of Ascension Providence Hospital (Southfield, MI), IACUC # 102-19. Twenty-seven adult male Sprague Dawley rats (body weight of 500-700g) were randomized into three experimental groups based on the implant pore size (n = 8 per group) plus control (n = 3). The rat Achilles tendon injury model has been used frequently to model rupture repair or other tendon pathologies.19 The model was established by other investigators to evaluate tendon healing using different suture fixation methods.20–22 Animals were anesthetized using isoflurane, and fur was clipped from the right hind leg. The animals were positioned prone, and the surgical site scrubbed with povidone iodine followed by a rinse of alcohol. A 10mm longitudinal incision was made to expose the tendon complex, and an Achilles tendon defect was created by making a transverse cut 3mm above the tendon insertion into the calcaneus. A 2mm full-thickness segment was then removed. The implant was positioned between the two cut ends and sutured in place with 4-0 polypropylene monofilament using a modified Kessler technique (Figure 2). For the control group, a similar 2mm segment was resected and direct repair was performed using the same suture technique. Skin was then closed with a continuous subcuticular 5-0 monocryl suture.

244843 Figure 2. Fixation of Ti implant into Achilles tendon defect using a modified Kessler suture technique.

After the surgery, the animals were housed individually, allowed to move freely, and were fed a normal diet. The rats were sacrificed at twelve weeks. The tissue was harvested en bloc for analysis, which included the calcaneus, the tendon with implant in place, and the gastrocnemius muscle. Half of the specimens underwent mechanical testing to assess tensile load to failure. The remaining specimens were fixed in 10% neutral buffered formalin (NBF) and processed for hard tissue histological analysis.

Mechanical Testing

Tensile load to failure testing was performed at Wayne State University (Detroit, MI) using an electromechanical material testing system and custom fixtures (MTS QTest/100 tensile tester by MTS, MN, USA). Excess soft tissue was trimmed, the calcaneal and gastrocnemial ends of the tendon were coated with cyanoacrylate adhesive to allow for secure fixation. Specimens were fixed onto a tensile testing machine by clamping the gastrocnemius muscle into the upper clamp and the calcaneal end of the tendon to the lower clamp (Figure 3). Care was taken to ensure that the direction of the loading force was in-line with the direction of tendon fibers. Quasi-static tensile loading Testing was performed using a tension to failure of 0.1%/s and stopped once the implant was completely separated from the tendon, and the peak tensile force and the load to failure were recorded.

244844 Figure 3. Tensile testing setup. (A and B), the specimen with the implant in place before and after harvesting. Black arrows pointing at the implant (C) the specimen clamped to the tensile testing machine. (D) an enlarged view of the clamped sample.

Histology

Collected samples with the implant in place were fixed in 10% BNF for 48 hours followed by a rinse in distilled water and then stored in 70% ethanol till processing. Samples processed and embedded in Methyl methacrylate(MMA). Thick longitudinal sections showing the tendon-implant intersection from both ends were obtained (200-300µm) and were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E). All sections were evaluated independently by two pathologists.

Statistical Analysis

All data were expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD). The statistical analysis was performed by the first author ( Mike Fry) using the Microsoft Excel data analysis tool pack (Microsoft Office 365, Version 1705), single factor analysis of variance and paired T-tests were used to compare load to failure for all pore sizes. P values less than 0.05 were considered significant.

RESULTS

All animals tolerated the procedure well. No rats were removed from the study due to surgical or animal care complications.

The tensile testing results are shown in Figure 4, all failures occurred at the site of grafting. The average load to failure was 72.6N for controls (SD 10.04), 29.95N for 400µm (SD 17.95), 55.08N for 700µm (SD 13.47), and 63.08N for 1000µm (SD 1.87). The load to failure was generally better in the larger pore sizes.

No significant differences in the load to failure were noted between control vs 700µm (p = 0.186), control vs 1000µm (p = 0.105), or 700µm vs 1000µm (p = 0.284). The 400µm performed less well and demonstrated significant differences in load to failure vs control (p = 0.039), vs 1000µm (p = 0.010), and approached significance vs 700µm (p = 0.066).

244845 Figure 4. Tensile testing results (load to failure) and statistical analysis.

Histological evaluation showed fibrous tendon tissue grown within and around the implant material. The collagen appeared to be organized in bundles (Figure 5). Minimal or no tissue infiltration into the pores of the 400µm samples ( figure 5A and E), with the most infiltration seen within the 1000µm samples ( figure 5C and G). It was not possible technologically to identify the specific cell types and depth of tendon ingrowth into the scaffolds.

244846 Figure 5. Images of H&E hard tissue sections (200-300µm thick). Left panel show the whole section and the right panel shows higher magnification images of the tissue close to the implant. Yellow circles show the place of the implants within the sections. (A and E) show implants with pore size of 400µm, (B and F) pore size 700µm and (C and G) pore size 1000µm. (D and H) show the whole section and a higher magnification image of the control tendon without implant.

DISCUSSION

The ability to attach tendons directly to metallic implants is needed and desired in orthopaedic surgery. Printed porous titanium implants have the potential to specifically define the pore size in any area, which may allow better promotion of soft-tissue ingrowth into an implant. The structural and biologic mechanisms to achieve this goal remain poorly understood due to the complexity of tendon biology and previously due to the difficulty of creating defined pore structures. In this study, we showed that tendon repair using implants with larger pore sizes (700µm and 1000µm) had improved strength and tissue ingrowth compared to a smaller (400µm) pore size. These findings are consistent with the results of our in-vitro study.18

Other studies have investigated the effect of pore size on soft tissue healing in vivo. Zheng et al used four sizes (657.65µm, 527.15µm, 348.68µm, and 169.20µm) of a porous Ti implant to evaluate supraspinatus tendon healing and strength in rabbits.23 They found pore size of 527.15µm to have the greatest tissue ingrowth and tensile strength at both 6 weeks (56.67N) and 12 weeks (90.33N) (Zheng Y). Their histology results also note that implants with pore size of 527.15µm demonstrated the greatest depth of tendon ingrowth (833.33µm), as well as the thickest and most organized muscle fibers, which we were unable to appreciate in our study despite using similar slice thickness in our sections. Guo et al compared Ti implants with three pore sizes (300µm, 500µm, and 700 µm) in a rabbit patellar tendon model, finding pore size of 500µm to have the greatest tissue ingrowth and pull-out strength at 12 weeks.24 This study showed that tissue infiltration within the pores increased as the pore diameter increased, and that is in agreement with the findings by Chimutengwende-Gordon et al who implanted porous Ti implants with three pore sizes (500µm, 700µm, and 1000µm) and three strut sizes (200µm, 300µm, and 400µm) into the paraspinal muscles of sheep and evaluated histological soft tissue ingrowth at four weeks.25 They noted larger pore sizes exhibited more extensive tissue infiltration and determined that the combination of pore size of 700µm with strut size of 300µm supported revascularization to the greatest degree.25

Due to the significant complication rates and failures associated with extensor mechanism and abductor reconstructions,1–6 the utility of attaching tendon to implant in total joint arthroplasty is clear. However, soft tissue attachment to a metallic prosthesis has broad use in many areas of orthopaedic surgery. In orthopaedic oncology, custom porous implants have been used during endoprosthetic limb salvage procedures to reattach tendons and ligaments to their insertion points.26,27 Also, numerous studies have investigated the use of porous metal implants during rotator cuff repair.13–16 Tucker et al found that, compared to standard repair, supraspinatus repair with a porous Ti-coated implant resulted in improved tendon healing and superior mechanical properties in rats.15 In a canine model, Higuera et al demonstrated the benefit of allogenic bone plates saturated with recombinant human osteogenic protein-1 (rhOP-1) when reattaching the supraspinatus tendon to a porous Ti anchor.14 The potential benefit in sports medicine was further demonstrated in a pig model by Ryu et al, who showed enhancement of tendon-bone interface healing and graft maturation with the use of a cylindrical “titanium-web” during ACL reconstruction.17

There were some limitations to the study. First, while we were able to demonstrate statistically significant differences between pore sizes, the size of our study population was relatively small. Second, as previously mentioned we were unable to identify specific cell types or depth of tendon growth into the scaffold. Third, while the implants used were defined in size and shape, they were not “optimized” for any cell type, which has been shown to affect cell affinity and spread.28 Optimal pore size and tissue integration into an implant may be different with another structure. However, our results showed an effect of pore size on fixation strength and healing of soft tissues and may provide insight into future research. Additional studies are needed to further define the optimal conditions (structure, growth factors, etc.) that promote tendon healing to an implant. Additional mechanical testing will also be required to define pore sizes that will allow tolerance of clinical conditions.

CONCLUSION

Printing titanium implants allows for precise determination of pore size and structure. Our results showed that tendon repair utilizing implants with 700µm and 1000µm pores exhibited similar load to failure as controls. Increasing pore size also promoted better ingrowth/ongrowth. Using a defined pore structure at the attachment points of tendons to implants may allow predictable tendon to implant reconstruction at the time of revision arthroplasty.

Acknowledgments

Stryker Orthopaedics (Mahwah, NJ) kindly provided the custom 3D printed porous Ti cylinders used in this study. The authors would also like to thank Dr. Paul Begeman (Department of Biomedical Engineering, Wayne State University) for his assistance with the mechanical testing.

Conflict of Interest

The senior author, David Markel, is a paid consultant for Stryker and Smith & Nephew. Dr. Markel serves on the editorial board of the Journal of Arthroplasty and Arthroplasty Today, and he is a board member for MARCQI and the Michigan Orthopedic Society. The rest of the authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
==== Refs
Extensor tendon ruptures after total knee arthroplasty Orthop Traumatol Surg Res Bonnin M. Lustig S. Huten D. 2016
102 1 Suppl S21 31 10.1016/j.otsr.2015.06.025 10.1016/j.otsr.2015.06.025 26797000
Extensor mechanism disruption after total knee arthroplasty J Am Acad Orthop Surg Bates M. D. Springer B. D. 2015
23 2 95 106 10.5435/jaaos-d-13-00205 10.5435/jaaos-d-13-00205 25624362
Extensor mechanism failure associated with total knee arthroplasty: prevention and management J Am Acad Orthop Surg Parker D. A. Dunbar M. J. Rorabeck C. H. 2003
11 4 238 47 10.5435/00124635-200307000-00003 10.5435/00124635-200307000-00003 12889862
Is There Any Role for Direct Repair of Extensor Mechanism Disruption Following Total Knee Arthroplasty? J Arthroplasty Courtney P. M. Edmiston T. A. Pflederer C. T. Levine B. R. Gerlinger T. L. 2018
33 7S S244 S248 10.1016/j.arth.2017.11.045 29248484
Abductor avulsion after primary total hip arthroplasty. Results of repair J Arthroplasty Weber M. Berry D. J. 1997
12 2 202 6 10.1016/s0883-5403(97)90067-x 10.1016/s0883-5403(97)90067-x 9139103
Results of surgical repair of abductor avulsion after primary total hip arthroplasty J Arthroplasty Lübbeke A. Kampfen S. Stern R. Hoffmeyer P. 2008
23 5 694 8 10.1016/j.arth.2007.08.018 10.1016/j.arth.2007.08.018 18534495
The Management of Extensor Mechanism Disruption After Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review Sports Med Arthrosc Rev Maffulli N. Spiezia F. La Verde L. Rosa M. A. Franceschi F. 2017
25 1 41 50 10.1097/jsa.0000000000000139 10.1097/jsa.0000000000000139 28045873
The cellular basis of fibrotic tendon healing: challenges and opportunities Transl Res Nichols A. E. C. Best K. T. Loiselle A. E. 2019
209 156 168 10.1016/j.trsl.2019.02.002 10.1016/j.trsl.2019.02.002 30776336
New perspectives in rotator cuff tendon regeneration: review of tissue engineered therapies Chir Organi Mov Rotini R. Fini M. Giavaresi G. Marinelli A. Guerra E. Antonioli D. Castagna A. Giardino R. 2008
91 2 87 92 10.1007/s12306-007-0015-2 10.1007/s12306-007-0015-2 18320380
Mechanical, histological, and functional properties remain inferior in conservatively treated Achilles tendons in rodents: Long term evaluation J Biomech Freedman B. R. Fryhofer G. W. Salka N. S. Raja H. A. Hillin C. D. Nuss C. A. Farber D. C. Soslowsky L. J. 2017
56 55 60 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2017.02.030 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2017.02.030 28366437
Fibrous tissue ingrowth and attachment to porous tantalum J Biomed Mater Res Hacking S. A. Bobyn J. D. Toh K. Tanzer M. Krygier J. J. 2000
52 4 631 8 10.1002/1097-4636(20001215)52:4<631::AID-JBM7>3.0.CO;2-6 10.1002/1097-4636(20001215)52:4<631::AID-JBM7>3.0.CO;2-6 11033545
Successful canine patellar tendon reattachment to porous tantalum Clin Orthop Relat Res Itälä A. Heijink A. Leerapun T. Reach J. S. An K. N. Lewallen D. G. 2007
463 202 7 10.1097/BLO.0b013e318142b3f0 17987673
Direct tendon attachment and healing to porous tantalum: an experimental animal study J Bone Joint Surg Am Reach J. S., Jr. Dickey I. D. Zobitz M. E. Adams J. E. Scully S. P. Lewallen D. G. 2007
89 5 1000 9 10.2106/JBJS.E.00886 10.2106/JBJS.E.00886 17473137
Tendon reattachment to a metallic implant using an allogenic bone plate augmented with rhOP-1 vs.autogenous cancellous bone and marrow in a canine model J Orthop Res Higuera C. A. Inoue N. Lim J. S. Zhang R. Dimaano N. Frassica F. J. Chao E. Y. 2005
23 5 1091 9 10.1016/j.orthres.2005.01.017 10.1016/j.orthres.2005.01.017 16140192
P2 porous titanium implants improve tendon healing in an acute rat supraspinatus repair model J Shoulder Elbow Surg Tucker J. J. Gordon J. A. Zanes R. C. Zuskov A. Vinciguerra J. D. Bloebaum R. D. Soslowsky L. J. 2017
26 3 529 535 10.1016/j.jse.2016.09.006 10.1016/j.jse.2016.09.006 27751717
Biologic tendon fixation to metallic implant augmented with autogenous cancellous bone graft and bone marrow in a canine model J Orthop Res Inoue N. Ikeda K. Aro H. T. Frassica F. J. Sim F. H. Chao E. Y. 2002
20 5 957 66 10.1016/s0736-0266(02)00037-2 10.1016/s0736-0266(02)00037-2 12382960
Enhancement of tendon-bone interface healing and graft maturation with cylindrical titanium-web (TW) in a miniature swine anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction model: histological and collagen-based analysis BMC Musculoskelet Disord Ryu K. Saito M. Kurosaka D. Kitasato S. Omori T. Hayashi H. Kayama T. Marumo K. 2020
21 1 198 10.1186/s12891-020-03199-0 10.1186/s12891-020-03199-0 32234036
Attachment and Growth of Fibroblasts and Tenocytes Within a Porous Titanium Scaffold: A Bioreactor Approach Arthroplast Today Markel D.C. Dietz P. Provenzano G. Bou-Akl T. Ren W.P. 2022
14 231 236 10.1016/j.artd.2021.12.003 10.1016/j.artd.2021.12.003 35510067
The role of animal models in tendon research Bone Joint Res Hast M. W. Zuskov A. Soslowsky L. J. 2014
3 6 193 202 10.1302/2046-3758.36.2000281 10.1302/2046-3758.36.2000281 24958818
Comparison of different suture techniques for Achilles tendon repair in rat model using collagen scaffolds Acta Bioeng Biomech Gabler C. Gierschner S. Tischer T. Bader R. 2018
20 2 73 77 10.1155/2018/6432742 30220720
A new model for repair of the Achilles tendon in the rat J Invest Surg Black D. A. Lindley S. Tucci M. Lawyer T. Benghuzzi H. 2011
24 5 217 21 10.3109/08941939.2011.575915 10.3109/08941939.2011.575915 21867391
Comparison of Roll Stitch Technique and Core Suture Technique for Extensor Tendon Repair at the Metacarpophalangeal Joint level Trauma Mon Namazi H. Mozaffarian K. Golmakani M. R. 2016
21 1 e24563 10.5812/traumamon.24563 10.5812/traumamon.24563 27218053
Promotion of tendon growth into implant through pore-size design of a Ti-6Al-4 V porous scaffold prepared by 3D printing Mater Des Zheng Y. Han Q. Li D. Sheng F. Song Z. Wang J. 2021
197 109219 10.1016/j.matdes.2020.109219 10.1016/j.matdes.2020.109219
Effect of Pore Size of Porous-Structured Titanium Implants on Tendon Ingrowth Appl Bionics Biomech Guo Y. Liu F. Bian X. Lu K. Huang P. Ye X. Tang C. Li X. Wang H. Tang K. 2022
2801229 10.1155/2022/2801229 10.1155/2022/2801229 35510044
Determining the porous structure for optimal soft-tissue ingrowth: An in vivo histological study PLoS One Chimutengwende-Gordon M. Dowling R. Pendegrass C. Blunn G. 2018
13 10 e0206228 10.1371/journal.pone.0206228 10.1371/journal.pone.0206228 30372471
Limb salvage and abductor reattachment using a custom prosthesis with porous tantalum components J Arthroplasty Chalkin B. Minter J. 2005
20 1 127 130 10.1016/j.arth.2004.09.029 10.1016/j.arth.2004.09.029 15660072
Trabecular metal endoprosthetic limb salvage reconstruction of the lower limb J Arthroplasty Holt G. E. Christie M. J. Schwartz H. S. 2009
1079 85 10.1016/j.arth.2008.08.010 10.1016/j.arth.2008.08.010 18834697
Effect of pore geometry on the fatigue properties and cell affinity of porous titanium scaffolds fabricated by selective laser melting J Mech Behav Biomed Mater Zhao D. Huang Y. Ao Y. Han C. Wang Q. Li Y. Liu J. Wei Q. Zhang Z. 2018
88 478 487 10.1016/j.jmbbm.2018.08.048 10.1016/j.jmbbm.2018.08.048 30223211
