
==== Front
J Health Econ Outcomes Res
J Health Econ Outcomes Res
1694
Journal of Health Economics and Outcomes Research
2326-697X
2327-2236
Columbia Data Analytics, LLC Website: Journal of Health Economics and Outcomes Research

37641715
82159
10.36469/001c.82159
Brief Report
Health Economic Analysis of Two-Layer Bandage System for Treatment of Chronic Venous Insufficiency
Mallow Peter J. Conceptualization Formal Analysis Writing – original draft 1
1 Xavier University, Cincinnati, OH, USA
Corresponding author: Email: mallowp@xavier.edu
25 8 2023
2023
10 2 3943
21 5 2023
26 6 2023
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Background: Compression therapy is the gold standard for the treatment of chronic venous insufficiency (CVI). Two-layer bandage (2LB) systems have been shown to be a safe and effective treatment option.

Objective: To estimate the total cost per response (CPR) for the resolution of edema and wounds in patients with CVI treated with a 2LB system as part of their overall wound healing regimen.

Methods: A probabilistic decision tree model was developed to estimate the incremental CPR for a 2LB system. The model simulated 10 000 patients to estimate the CPR for the resolution of edema and wound healing. The analysis was performed using clinical data from a published single-arm, multicenter prospective study of CVI indicated for compression therapy. The response outcomes of interest were resolution of edema and rate of wound healing. The follow-up time was a maximum of 6 weeks, and the perspective of the study was a US outpatient treatment center. Economic data for compression therapy were based on the public prices of a 2LB system. Dressing changes occurred per manufacturer instructions for use.

Results: The study comprised 702 patients (56% female), with a total of 414 wounds. The median duration of the wounds was 42 days, and the median size at the initial visit was 3.5 cm2. The average pain reduction fell by 67% using a visual analog score. Bandages were typically changed once or twice a week (51.7%). Wound healing occurred in 128 of the 414 wounds (30.9%). The expected incremental CPR of a 2LB system for the resolution of edema was 65.67(range,16.67-124.32).TheexpectedincrementalCPRofa2LBsystemforthehealingofawoundwas138.71 (range, 35.71−273.53).

Conclusion: This economic evaluation complements previous clinical effectiveness and safety studies of 2LB systems for the treatment of CVI. The results demonstrate that the costs of incorporating 2LB into standard wound-healing protocols are negligible compared with overall treatment costs. Two-layer bandages may be considered a cost-effective first-line system for the treatment of wounds caused by CVI.

chronic venous insufficiency
compression therapy
health economics
two-layer bandage system
Financial support for this research was provided in part by Urgo Medical North America (UMNA). UNMA had no input on the study design, analysis, results, or manuscript.
==== Body
pmcBACKGROUND

Chronic venous insufficiency (CVI) is common in the United States and occurs in up to 40% of the population.1–3 CVI affects the venous system and manifests as lower-extremity edema, pain, and, in severe cases, ulcers.4 Untreated or poor management of CVI leads to a decrease in the patient’s quality of life and interferes with activities of daily living.5 The healthcare costs of a conservative treatment regimen, including ulcers and edema, on average exceed $2400 per month, or more than $5500 per episode.6–8 Collectively, US healthcare costs for CVI exceed $4.9 billion annually.9

The use of compression therapy is part of the standard treatment protocol for CVI.10–12 A novel 2-layer bandage system (2LB) has been shown to be safe, efficacious, and well-tolerated by patients for the treatment of CVI.13–18 However, there is limited economic evidence regarding the use of a 2LB system. The objective of the study was to estimate the total cost per response (CPR) for edema resolution and wound healing of patients with CVI treated with a 2LB system as part of their overall treatment regimen.

METHODS

Clinical Data

The clinical data were obtained from a recently published, prospective, multicenter study.19 This study recruited all CVI patients presenting with a venous leg ulcer or edema in which the physician made the clinical judgment to treat with a compression system. A 2LB system was used per the manufacturer’s instructions for use, and all treatment decisions were made by the patient’s physician. Patients were followed in an outpatient setting for a maximum of 6 weeks (average, 27 days). All patients were treated with a 2LB system for the duration of the study. The 2LB system components were a padded inelastic bandage with short elongation and an elastic bandage with lengthy elongation. The system provides a visual indicator to facilitate the proper application and achieve the desired pressure. The system can be worn 24 hours a day for up to 7 days per the instructions for use.13

The study comprised a total of 702 patients (56% female) and included 491 cases of edema and 414 wounds. Bandages were typically changed 1 or 2 times a week (51.7%). For those with wounds, the median duration of the wounds was 42 days, and the median size at the initial visit was 3.5 cm2. Wound healing occurred in 128 of the 414 wounds (30.9%) within the 6-week study period. The proportion of patients with edema that resolved at the end of the study period was 67.1%. All data were publicly available, and the study was deemed exempt from institutional review board review.

Cost and Utilization Data

The cost and utilization data were obtained from a pragmatic literature review. A search of English-language articles from January 2019 to January 2023 was performed in PubMed and Google Scholar for the model parameters. The articles were reviewed based on applicability, recency, and quality by a single reviewer. In the event of more than one study meeting the criteria, a pooled analysis was applied to identify the midpoint value used for the analysis. The cost and utilization data consisted of US national average patient-level data to allow for the results to be applied to a typical health system.

Modeling Strategy

A patient-level probabilistic decision tree model was developed to estimate the incremental CPR for the 2LB system (Figure 1). The perspective of the model was an outpatient treatment center in the United States. The cost parameters included the cost of the 2LB system and the medical technician’s time to apply the 2LB. The outcome measures were the percentage of edema resolved and the percentage of wounds healed at the conclusion of the follow-up period. The CPR was calculated with the following formula for edema resolved and wound healed:

CPR=∑C2LB/Outcome2LB

where C2LB is the summation of the costs of the 2LB system, and Outcome2LB is either the percentage of edema resolved or wound healed. Each model was performed separately, with the only difference being the outcome variable. A total of 10 000 patients were simulated. The base case model values were varied based on the reported ranges shown in Table 1. The models were developed using Treeage Software (Williamstown, Massachusetts). All data used in the model were publicly available in the literature.

170671 Figure 1. Model Diagram

The model framework was for an individual patient over a 6-week period. The model perspective was an outpatient treatment center in the United States. Discounting was not applied due to the short time horizon. A total of 10 000 patients were simulated to generate the results.

Abbreviation: 2LB, two-layer bandage.

170672 Table 1. Model Parameters

Parameter	Base Case	Sensitivity Analysis	Distribution	Reference	
		Low	High			
Cost of 2LB system ($)	12.00	9.00	15.00	Uniform	Urgo Medical20	
No. of dressing changes, over study period	4	1	6	Uniform	Chakravarthy et al21	
Time to change 2LB (sec)a	65	59	71	Uniform	Chakravarthy et al21	
Hourly medical technician wage ($)	26.00	26.00	26.00	Fixed	Chakravarthy et al21	
Resolved edema (%)	67	60	74	Triangle	Stucker et al19	
Wound healed (%)	31	28	34	Triangle	Stucker et al19	
aTime to change 2LB system did not include wound dressings.

Abbreviation: 2LB, two-layer bandage.

RESULTS

Figure 2 (top panel) and Table 2 show the probabilistic model results to resolve edema using the 2LB system. The mean expected incremental CPR was $65.67. Based on 10 000 simulated patients, the cost to resolve edema ranged from $16.67 to $124.32. The associated cost of the 2LB system over the study period ranged from $10.00 to $92.00, and the probability of resolving the edema ranged from 60% to 74%.

170673 Figure 2. Cost per Response for Edema Resolved and Wound Healed

170674 Table 2. Probabilistic Model Results: Edema Resolved

	Cost ($)	Probability of Edema Resolved (%)	Cost per Wound Healed ($)	
Mean	44.00	67	65.67	
Minimum	10.00	60	16.67	
10th percentile	18.00	63	28.57	
50th percentile	43.00	67	64.18	
90th percentile	70.00	71	98.59	
Maximum	92.00	74	124.32	

Figure 2 (lower panel) and Table 3 show the probabilistic model results in healing one wound. After 10 000 simulated patient trials, the mean expected incremental CPR was $138.71 and ranged from $35.71 to $273.53. The associated cost of the 2LB system over the study period ranged from $10.00 to $92.00, and the probability of healing the wound ranged from 28% to 34%.

170675 Table 3. Probabilistic Model Results: Wound Healed

	Cost ($)	Probability of Wound Healed (%)	Cost per Wound Healed ($)	
Mean	43.00	31	138.71	
Minimum	10.00	28	35.71	
10th percentile	18.00	29	62.07	
50th percentile	42.00	31	135.48	
90th percentile	70.00	33	212.12	
Maximum	93.00	34	273.53	

DISCUSSION

This study found the CPR for edema resolved or wound healed was expected to be approximately $66 or $139, respectively. The CPR approach is an effective means to evaluate an intervention because it combines the additional costs of the intervention, 2LB, with the benefit provided by the intervention. The result is more indicative of the overall costs after adjusting for patients who do not benefit from the intervention.

The overall costs to treat CVI run in excess of $5500.6–8 Thus, after adjusting for treatment failures, the use of a 2LB system was expected to account for 1% of the total cost to resolve edema or 3% of healing a wound. This cost is negligible in the overall treatment costs of patients with CVI.

The insignificant cost of the 2LB system should emphasize the safety, efficacy, and patient satisfaction of the 2LB system. A randomized controlled trial of a 2LB system and 4-layer bandage (4LB) system found that 2LB was safe and as effective as the 4LB and easier to apply.13–15 Appropriate pressure has been shown to be maintained with the 2LB system.16,22–24 Patient satisfaction with the 2LB system was 70% compared with 12% with the 4LB system, which led to increased compliance with the 2LB system.22 Finally, the average pain reduction fell by 67% using a visual analog score.19

Limitations

The results of this study were based on clinical data from a noncomparative observational study. Therefore, comparisons to other bandage systems were not possible. However, this study was a large prospective, multicenter study, which provided a real-world setting to conduct an economic evaluation. Second, this study examined the incremental costs of adding a 2LB system into the standard CVI treatment protocol. It was not intended to provide a total cost to treat a patient with CVI. Finally, this study was conducted from an outpatient clinic perspective and may not be generalizable to other sites of care.

CONCLUSION

This study provides economic evidence for using a 2LB system for the treatment of CVI in the outpatient setting. This study complements previous studies demonstrating the efficacy, safety, and increased patient satisfaction of a 2LB system. The use of a 2LB system should be considered an added economic value to the management of CVI.

Disclosures

The author has a consulting relationship with Urgo Medical North America (UMNA).

Ethics Approval and Data Availability

This research used publicly available secondary data.
==== Refs
The epidemiology of chronic venous insufficiency and varicose veins Annals of Epidemiology Beebe-Dimmer Jennifer L. Pfeifer John R. Engle Jennifer S. Schottenfeld David 3 2005
15 3 175 184 1047-2797 10.1016/j.annepidem.2004.05.015 10.1016/j.annepidem.2004.05.015 15723761
Prevalence of varicose veins and chronic venous insufficiency in men and women in the general population: Edinburgh Vein Study Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health Evans C. J. Fowkes F. G. Ruckley C. V. Lee A. J. 1 3 1999
53 3 149 153 0143-005X 10.1136/jech.53.3.149 10.1136/jech.53.3.149 10396491
Defining the human and health care costs of chronic venous insufficiency Seminars in Vascular Surgery Kim Young Maximilian Png C.Y. Sumpio Brandon J. DeCarlo Charles S. Dua Anahita 3 2021
34 1 59 64 0895-7967 10.1053/j.semvascsurg.2021.02.007 10.1053/j.semvascsurg.2021.02.007 33757637
Reporting standards in venous disease: an update. International Consensus Committee on Chronic Venous Disease Journal of Vascular Surgery Porter John M. Moneta Gregory L. 4 1995
21 4 635 645 0741-5214 10.1016/s0741-5214(95)70195-8 10.1016/s0741-5214(95)70195-8 7707568
Health-related quality of life after catheter-directed thrombolysis for deep vein thrombosis: secondary outcomes of the randomised, non-blinded, parallel-group CaVenT study BMJ Open Enden Tone Wik Hilde Skuterud Kvam Ann Kristin Haig Ylva Kløw Nils Einar Sandset Per Morten 8 2013
3 8 e002984 2044-6055 10.1136/bmjopen-2013-002984 10.1136/bmjopen-2013-002984 23988361
Why venous leg ulcers have difficulty healing: overview on pathophysiology, clinical consequences, and treatment Journal of Clinical Medicine Raffetto Joseph D. Ligi Daniela Maniscalco Rosanna Khalil Raouf A. Mannello Ferdinando 2021
10 1 29 2077-0383 10.3390/jcm10010029 10.3390/jcm10010029 33374372
The economic impact of infection requiring hospitalization on venous leg ulcers Journal of Vascular Surgery: Venous and Lymphatic Disorders Melikian Raffi O'Donnell Thomas F., Jr. Iafrati Mark 1 2022
10 1 96 101 2213-333X 10.1016/j.jvsv.2021.06.012 10.1016/j.jvsv.2021.06.012
Medical costs of treating venous stasis ulcers: evidence from a retrospective cohort study Vascular Medicine Olin Jeffrey W Beusterien Kathleen M Childs Mary Beth Seavey Caroline McHugh Linda Griffiths Robert I 2 1999
4 1 1 7 1358-863X 10.1177/1358836x9900400101 10.1177/1358836x9900400101
An estimate of the economic burden of venous leg ulcers associated with deep venous disease Vascular Medicine Kolluri Raghu Lugli Marzia Villalba Laurencia Varcoe Ramon Maleti Oscar Gallardo Fernando Black Stephen Forgues Fannie Lichtenberg Michael Hinahara Jordan Ramakrishnan Saranya Beckman Joshua A. 2022
27 1 63 72 1358-863X 10.1177/1358863x211028298 10.1177/1358863x211028298 34392750
The Association for the Advancement of Wound Care (AAWC) venous and pressure ulcer guidelines Ostomy Wound Manage Bolton L.L. Girolami S. Corbett L. van Rijswijk L. 2014
60 11 24 66
Management of patients with venous leg ulcers: challenges and current best practice Journal of Wound Care Franks Peter J Barker Judith Collier Mark Gethin Georgina Haesler Emily Jawien Arkadiusz Laeuchli Severin Mosti Giovanni Probst Sebastian Weller Carolina 1 6 2016
25 suppl 6 S1 S67 0969-0700 10.12968/jowc.2016.25.sup6.s1 10.12968/jowc.2016.25.sup6.s1
Management of venous leg ulcers: clinical practice guidelines of the Society for Vascular Surgery and the American Venous Forum Journal of Vascular Surgery O’Donnell Thomas F., Jr. Passman Marc A. Marston William A. Ennis William J. Dalsing Michael Kistner Robert L. Lurie Fedor Henke Peter K. Gloviczki Monika L. Eklöf Bo G. Stoughton Julianne Raju Sesadri Shortell Cynthia K. Raffetto Joseph D. Partsch Hugo Pounds Lori C. Cummings Mary E. Gillespie David L. McLafferty Robert B. Murad Mohammad Hassan Wakefield Thomas W. Gloviczki Peter 8 2014
60 2 3S 59S 0741-5214 10.1016/j.jvs.2014.04.049 10.1016/j.jvs.2014.04.049 24974070
Efficacy of two compression systems in the management of VLUs: results of a European RCT Journal of Wound Care Lazareth I. Moffatt C. Dissemond J. Padieu A.S. Lesne Truchetet F. Beissert S. Wicks G. Tilbe H. Sauvadet A. Bohbot S. Meaume S. 11 2012
21 11 553 565 0969-0700 10.12968/jowc.2012.21.11.553 10.12968/jowc.2012.21.11.553
Comparison of interface pressures of three compression bandaging systems used on healthy volunteers Journal of Wound Care Jünger M. Ladwig A. Bohbot S. Haase H. 11 2009
18 11 474 480 0969-0700 10.12968/jowc.2009.18.11.45000 10.12968/jowc.2009.18.11.45000
A comparison of interface pressures of three compression bandage systems British Journal of Nursing Hanna Richard Bohbot Serge Connolly Nicki 13 11 2008
17 20 S16 S24 0966-0461 10.12968/bjon.2008.17.sup9.31661 10.12968/bjon.2008.17.sup9.31661
Efficacy, safety and acceptability of a new two-layer bandage system for venous leg ulcers Journal of Wound Care Benigni J.P Lazareth I Parpex P. Gerard J.L Alves M Vin F Meaume S Senet P Allaert F.A Sauvadet A Bohbot S 9 2007
16 9 385 390 0969-0700 10.12968/jowc.2007.16.9.27866 10.12968/jowc.2007.16.9.27866 17987751
A dual pressure indicator, two-layer compression system for the treatment of venous leg ulcers: a review Journal of Wound Care Tai Hong Qian Chaen Lester Chong Rhan Boey Johnson Kime Sally Rial Rodrigo Montero Elena Conde Atkin Leanne Stansal Audrey Isabelle Lazareth Tickner Anthony Vlad Lucian G Lantis John Hester Colboc Galea Emilio 1 12 2021
30 Sup12 S6 S12 0969-0700 10.12968/jowc.2021.30.sup12.s6 10.12968/jowc.2021.30.sup12.s6
Clinical and economic impact of two-layer compression system for the treatment of venous leg ulcers: a systematic review Wounds Goka E.A. Poku E. Thokala P. Sutton A. 2020
32 1 11 21 32155127
Multicomponent compression system use in patients with chronic venous insufficiency: a real-life prospective study Journal of Wound Care Stucker Markus Munter Karl-Christian Erfurt-Berge Cornelia Lützkendorf Steffen Eder Stephan Möller Udo Dissemond Joachim 2 5 2021
30 5 400 412 0969-0700 10.12968/jowc.2021.30.5.400 10.12968/jowc.2021.30.5.400
International guidelines recognize the superior efficacy of multi-component bandages Medical Urgo https://www.urgomedical.us/products/urgok2 Accessed January 20, 2023.
The health economic implications of a comparative time and motion study done on two bandage systems, one traditional four layer system, the other a novel two layer dual compression system (DCS) Chakravarthy D. Mallow P. Pilati L. Symposium on Advanced Wound Care (SAWC) Fall Conference, November 3-6, 2022
Comparing 2-layer with traditional 4-layer compression therapy Wound Manag Prev Pilati L. Houserman D. 2020
66 4 8 9
Addressing compression continuity, consistency, and comfort using a dual compression system Wound Manag Prev Greenstein E. Tickner A. 2020
66 6 4 7
A dual compression system: preliminary clinical insights from the US Journal of Wound Care Lantis John C., II Barrett Christopher Couch Kara S Ehmann Suzie Greenstein Emily Ostler Marta Tickner Anthony 1 9 2020
29 suppl 9 S29 S37 0969-0700 10.12968/jowc.2020.29.sup9.s29 10.12968/jowc.2020.29.sup9.s29
