
==== Front
Trop Life Sci Res
Trop Life Sci Res
Tropical Life Sciences Research
Tropical Life Sciences Research
1985-3718
2180-4249
Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia

10.21315/tlsr2024.35.2.15
tlsr-35-2-309
Short Communication
Concerning Predation on Small Vertebrates by Alien Gold Morph Midas cichlid, Amphilophus citrinellus (Cichlidae)
Aqmal-Naser Mohamad Conceptualization Formal analysis Methodology Investigation Writing - original draft 1
Ahmad Amirrudin B. Conceptualization Methodology Writing - original draft 12*
1 Terrestrial Ecology, Biodiversity and Aquatic Research (TEBAR), Institute of Tropical Biodiversity and Sustainable Development, Universiti Malaysia Terengganu, 21030 Kuala Nerus, Terengganu, Malaysia
2 Biodiversity and Ecology Research (BERes), Faculty of Science and Marine Environment, Universiti Malaysia Terengganu, 21030 Kuala Nerus, Terengganu, Malaysia
* Corresponding author: amirrudin@umt.edu.my
7 2024
31 7 2024
35 2 309317
21 6 2023
30 1 2024
© Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia, 2024
2024
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This work is licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Neotropical cichlid possesses territorial aggression which explains their success as alien species that pose threats to local fauna. The feeding ecology of Midas cichlid, Amphilophus citrinellus species outside its native range had never been fully understood. We aim to determine the stomach content, length-weight relationship and condition factor of this non-native species in one of the agroecosystems in Malaysia. The fish was collected using a cast net, and the guts were dissected. The stomach content (n = 35) revealed Midas cichlids feed on a wide array of preys including fish, amphibian and gastropod. The b-value is 2.60 (negative allometric growth) and the relative condition factor, Kn is 1.04. This result represents an initial study on the feeding aspect of this cichlid. Subsequent and continued researches are needed to evaluate the feeding behaviour and prey preferences of this species in its introduced range.

Abstrak

Cichlid neotropika mempunyai pencerobohan wilayah yang menjelaskan kejayaan mereka sebagai spesies asing yang menimbulkan ancaman kepada fauna tempatan. Ekologi pemakanan Midas cichlid, spesies Amphilophus citrinellus di luar julat asalnya tidak pernah difahami sepenuhnya. Kami berhasrat untuk menentukan kandungan perut, hubungan panjang-berat dan faktor keadaan spesies bukan asli ini dalam salah satu agroekosistem di Malaysia. Ikan dikumpul menggunakan jaring tuang dan ususnya dibedah. Kandungan perut (n = 35) mendedahkan Midas cichlids memakan pelbagai jenis mangsa termasuk ikan, amfibia dan gastropod. Nilai b ialah 2.60 (pertumbuhan alometrik negatif) dan faktor keadaan relatif, Kn ialah 1.04. Keputusan ini mewakili kajian awal tentang aspek pemakanan cichlid ini. Penyelidikan seterusnya dan berterusan diperlukan untuk menilai tingkah laku pemakanan dan keutamaan mangsa spesies ini dalam julat yang diperkenalkan.

Biodiversity
Introduced Species
Invasiveness
Peninsular Malaysia
Rice Agro-Ecosystem
Kata kunci

Biodiversiti
Spesies Pengenalan
Invasif
Semenanjung Malaysia
Agro-Ekosistem Beras
==== Body
pmcHighlights

Midas cichlid feed on a wide array of preys including fish, amphibian and gastropod.

Midas cichlid in the rice agroecosystem have negative allometric growth(b = 2.60) and the relative condition factor, Kn is 1.04.

New information on the feeding ecology of Midas cichlid in their introduced range.

INTRODUCTION

Midas cichlid, Amphilopus citrinellus exhibits polychromatism, with two general colour morphs throughout its growth induced by breeding mode, location and water depth (Barlow 1976). The gold morphs A. citrinellus were typically aggressive, possibly as a response to predation (Barlow & Wallach 1976), and also owing competition over limited resources in their niche (Oldfield 2011), allowing them to survive outside the native range. This morph also showing the domination against the normal morph in term of predation and growth (Barlow et al. 1975). We believe such territorial aggression may be demonstrated constantly by A. citrinellus gold morph fish and it is persisting even when found outside their native environment.

A.citrinellus has been reported from outside its native ranges including Australia (Kroon et al. 2015), Indonesia (Tampubolon et al. 2015), Malaysia (Aqmal-Naser & Ahmad 2018a; 2020), Philippines (Poniente et al. 2019) and Singapore (Tan et al. 2020). Established feral populations of A. citrinellus have been reported from several countries including Singapore (Kwik et al. 2013) and Indonesia (Tampubolon et al. 2015), which suggest that this species soon could be another cichlid species invading natural waterbodies after tilapias (Oreochromis spp.). However, the feeding ecology of A. citrinellus outside its native range, especially in Peninsular Malaysia, is relatively unknown.

In this study, we examined the stomach contents of A. citrinellus populations thriving in agro ecosystem to investigate the potential impacts of this alien fish species to native biota. Since food is one of the keys in determine fish condition, population, level and growth rate (Begum et al. 2008), the information gathered on the diet of fish is crucial to understand their behaviour, biology and physiology (Shalloof et al. 2020). The study on feeding habit also can help to explain the biology of single species (Graham et al. 2007), and the trophic flow of the ecosystem (Cox et al. 2023). Our study is important for establishing the fundamental criteria of the potential invasiveness of the aggressive A. citrinellus in Peninsular Malaysia and the findings could be applicable to other places outside its native distribution range.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The occurrence of A. citrinellus at this study sites has been previously reported by Aqmal-Naser and Ahmad (2020). The samples of A. citrinellus were collected opportunistically from the rice field. Samples were collected using cast net with a dimension of 2.4 m height × 10 m circumference × 2 cm mesh size. All collected specimens were measured for standard length (SL; tip of the upper jaw to the base of caudal fin to the nearest mm). The gut was removed and dissected for visual examination of the stomach contents and the occurrence of the eggs in the abdominal cavity was recorded to indicate their ability to reproduce and to establish feral population at the study area. Any larger native fauna found in the stomach were identified using visible characters to the lowest possible taxon. The identification of fish species was based on Zakaria-Ismail et al. (2019), while the identification for frog and toad species were based on Grismer (2011). The fish stomach content analysis was done using Occurrence Method (Frequency of occurrence; %) as suggested by Hyslop (1980). The number of stomachs contain one or more individuals for each category of food and expressed as percentage (Kennedy & Fitzmaurice 1972). All specimens were preserved in 10% formalin solution and transferred to 75% ethanol after two weeks and deposited in Universiti Malaysia Terengganu Zoological Collection (UMTZC). The growth condition (b-value) of the fish were determined following the formula W = aLb (Ricker 1973) where W = weight of fish in gram; L = Length of fish in cm; a = describe the rate of change of weight with length (intercept); and b = weight at unit length (slope), while relative condition factor (Kn) following Le Cren (1951).

RESULTS

From the survey, we collected 35 specimens of gold morphs A. citrinellus (total length; 3.00 cm–18.50 cm, and weight 1.30 g–254.22 g). The growth condition (b-value) for the cichlid is 2.60, while the relative condition factor (Kn) is 1.04 (Fig. 1). The stomach content from two individuals contained native fauna; frog (Family Dicroglossidae), and a native fighting fish species (Betta imbellis). One individual is a gravid female and the stomach contain the remain of unidentified gastropod (Fig. 2). Stomach content of 20 individuals contain unidentified fish scales while the other 12 individuals’ fish had empty stomachs.

DISCUSSION

Documented evidence of such predation by alien fishes in Peninsular Malaysia is scarce, with the exception of Clarias gariepinus (Aqmal-Naser & Ahmad 2019). Several small-bodied native fish species had been previously reported at the study site (Aqmal-Naser & Ahmad 2018b), where some of these native species hold commercial potential for small-scale ornamental trade [(e.g., Rasbora trilineata, Oryzias javanicus, Lepidochepalichthys hasselti and Betta imbellis (Aqmal-Naser & Ahmad 2018b)], but may be threatened by the predation pressure from A.citrinellus. Given the aggressive behaviour demonstrated by this speciescomplex, the gold morph of A. citrinellus has been known to attack and eat small fishes (Barlow et al. 1975). Aggression behaviour demonstrated by this Midascichlid may be extended to the feeding needs of the fish. The fish not only respond aggressively towards their own morph as previously reported (Lehtonen 2014)but may aggressively prey upon the native species. Our study presents the first evidence on the predation of native frog and fish species, and also confirming the predation on snail species by A. citrinellus in Peninsular Malaysia. Since A.citrinellus has now occurred regularly in human-modified habitats (Kwik et al. 2013; Tampubolon et al. 2015), impacts on native fish community may be amplified in the near future if precautionary steps are not taken.

Several other predatory fish species can be found in the rice field (see Aqmal-Naser & Ahmad 2018a; 2018b). Many of these fishes feed on invertebrates, small fishes, and a few species such and the snakehead, Channa striata, the top predator in this agro ecosystem, feed on vertebrates including frogs. Dicroglossid frogs are common and widespread in the rice fields in Peninsular Malaysia (Shahriza & Ibrahim 2017) and are preyed by many species including snakes. With that being said, predation of a native frog by an alien fish has not been previously reported. The unexpected finding of A. citrinellus feeding on a native dicroglossid frog is recorded for the first time in Peninsular Malaysia. Elsewhere, predation of native frogs by the alien fish species, Clarias gariepinus has been previously documented in Cuba (Rodríguez-Machado & Rodríguez-Cabrera 2015), even on the critically endangered spiny-chest frog (Alsodes pehuenche) by introduced rainbow trout, Onchorhynchus milkyss (Zarco et al. 2020).

Our finding of A. citrinellus feeding on the native frog not only represents a threat to native fauna, but also may also imply competition with native predators for the same food resources. Without appropriate control measures, this may contribute to the loss of native biodiversity. Eventually, long term effects of alien fish species in the natural and man-made habitats are proliferated. Thus, a systematic and urgent plan is required for eradicating the invasive species plus further study and continued monitoring of this event must be executed immediately. Both A. citrinellus (in this study) and Clarias gariepinus (of the previous study) were recorded feeding on the native species within the same study area. Upon reaching a certain size, both of these alien species have no native predators (with the possible exception of the water monitor lizard, Varanus salvator). Given that this man-made ecosystem contains many small-bodied fish species, predation on native species likely occurs more frequently. Since both alien fish species feed on the same resources, competition for food between A. citrinellus, C. gariepinus and the native Channa striata may finally intensify.

While there is currently limited evidence of breeding populations (e.g., lack of juveniles), their feeding preferences posed a potential threat to the native biota. The initial discovery on a pair of A. citrinellus which the female is gravid (Fig. 2) could affirmed the possibility of establishing the breeding population soon. In the man-made habitat in Singapore, the species was known to have established population based on the size range from small to large and the presence of breeding pit (Kwik et al. 2013). Furthermore, Purnamaningtyas and Tjahjo (2017) reported that A. citrinellus has high fecundity in the reservoir and can breed throughout the year given that the water temperature ranging from 24°C–28°C.

Purnamaningtyas and Tjahjo (2017) also reported larger Midas cichlid has higher fecundity, where each female has about 1,000–3,000 eggs. They usually lay their eggs on the ceiling of natural caves or hard substrates (Lavery 1991), which in this study, the pair was collected from the concrete canals. However, the reproductive aspect of Midas cichlid is complex. The species is monogamous and spawning selection is complex (Rogers 1987). The female tends to choose normal and primitive colour male, the largest and the most aggressive male to spawn (Barlow 1992). Increasing number of male or crowding effect will have influence on the mating of Midas cichlid (Rogers 1987). The male is not choosy, but female will usually have individual selection, where it will choose male with high tendency to be a good father to the fry (Barlow 1992).

Midas cichlid population in this study shows negative allometric growth (b < 3.0) where the length increases but the weight did not increase proportionally. The relative condition factor of 1.04 also shows that the Midas cichlid population having the borderline growth condition between poor and good. The fish become slimmer or thinner, as one of the reasons, is the lack of food resources (Jisr et al. 2018). The empty stomach of 34.29% indicated the scarcity of food availability, hence Midas cichlid could devour any organism available including the frog. Plus, this agroecosystem is a highly disturbed environment, both temporally and spatially (Aqmal-Naser et al. 2023). Such factors as habitat and environments, are among the major factor contributing to the poor growth of fish (Morato et al. 2001). Compared to the related study, Midas cichlid in Indonesia has isometric growth (b = 3.5), as they consumed diverse food including insect larvae, insect and plant matters (Purnamaningtyas & Tjahjo 2017).

We were aware that the sample size of this cichlid in this study can be considered small (n = 35 individuals). Nevertheless, the veracious feeding behaviour shown through this observation is a clear indication that once the population of this alien species established, similar feeding behaviour will be observed and become more prominent, especially when the competition for food is escalating. Our finding provides an impetus for further studies on the potential impacts by A. citrinellus in other human-modified habitats, particularly in the urban areas of the central west coast (i.e., Selangor) and southern Peninsular Malaysia (e.g., Johor and Negeri Sembilan), which man-made habitats such as retention ponds, reservoirs and ex-mining pools are abundant that A. citrinellus was thriving well. Additional sampling on the other states in Peninsular Malaysia may provide ancillary data for better understanding on the impacts of this fish to the native biota. This data then can be used to suggest and provide crucial information on the potential “hotspots” of alien fish species in Peninsular Malaysia, which is important for informing potential control and/or extermination measures. Another future studies should explore on the possibility of A. citrinellus demonstrate bias aggression towards their own morph as this might explain the less numerous individuals collected during the sampling.

The occurrence of alien fish species with potential to become invasive in man-made and natural water bodies urgently requires monitoring and control. Owing to the limited information on their feeding ecology and biology, alien fish species were not previously regarded as a threat to native fauna and have hitherto of less interest from the researchers in Peninsular Malaysia. The concrete eradication measures are urgently needed as the negative ecological impacts of alien species start to escalate.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

We thank Universiti Malaysia Terengganu for the facilities and equipment used in the study. We thank Baizul Hafsyam for the identification of the frog. We thank Dr. Kenny WJ Chua for comments and suggestions to improve the manuscript. Amirul, Amirah, Aisha and Azira are gratefully acknowledged.

Figure 1 Length-weight relationship of Midas cichlid in the study site (n = 35).

Figure 2 The stomach contents of Amphilophus citrinellus containing: (A) partially digested native frog (Dicroglossidae); (B) native fish, Betta imbellis; (C) the operculum size of the gastropod; and (D) the remnant of gastropod along with egg cluster.

Table 1 The stomach content analysis for Amphilophus citrinellus (n = 35) with the percentage of occurrence (%FO) of three groups of fauna.

Class	Family	(% FO)	Remarks	
Actinopterygii	Opshronemidae	2.86	Betta imbellis (n = 1)	
Unidentified species	57.14	Unidentified fish scales (n = 20)	
Amphibia	Dicroglossidae	2.86	Partially digested frog (n = 1)	
Gastropoda	Ampullariidae	2.86	Unidentified mollusc (n = 1)	
Empty stomach	-	34.29	n = 12	

AUTHORS’ CONTRIBUTIONS: Mohamad Aqmal-Naser: Study conception, idea and design; carried out the sample collection; analyse the result; wrote and approved the final version of the manuscript.

Amirrudin B. Ahmad: Study conception, idea and design; wrote and approved the final version of the manuscript.
==== Refs
REFERENCES

Aqmal-Naser M Ahmad B 2018a Ichthyofauna in rice agroecosystem at Seberang Perai Tengah, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia with notes on the introduced species Journal of Agrobiotechnology 9 1 27 40
Aqmal-Naser M Ahmad AB 2018b Checklist of fishes in rice a groecosystem in Seberang Prai Tengah, Pulau Pinang, Peninsular Malaysia with notes on the emergence of the introduced species Malayan Nature Journal 70 4 477 488
Aqmal-Naser M Ahmad AB 2019 Introduction of alien fishes in the rice agroecosystem: A conflict between economical and ecological importance Fishmail 26 2 7
Aqmal-Naser M Ahmad AB 2020 First report of the hybrid blood parrot cichlid from a rice agroecosystem in Seberang Perai Tengah, Penang, Peninsular Malaysia, with notes on syntopic Midas cichlid, Amphilophus citrinellus Bioinvasions Records 9 3 588 598 10.3391/bir.2020.9.3.15
Aqmal-Naser M Iguchi KI Ahmad AB 2023 Spatial-temporal effects on fish diversity and assemblages in a highly modified environment Urban Ecosystems 26 1367 1379 10.1007/s11252-023-01387-z
Barlow GW 1976 The Midas cichlid in Nicaragua Thorson TB Investigations of the ichthyofauna of Nicaraguan Lakes United States University of Nebraska-Lincon 332 358
Barlow GW 1992 Is mating different in monogamous species? The Midas cichlid fish as a case study American Zoologist 32 1 91 99 10.1093/icb/32.1.91
Barlow GW Wallach SJ 1976 Colour and levels of aggression in the Midas cichlid Animal Behaviour 24 4 814 817 10.1016/s0003-3472(76)80011-5
Barlow GW Bauer DH McKaye KR 1975 A comparison of feeding, spacing, and aggression in color morphs of the Midas cichlid. I. food continuously present Behaviour 54 72 96 10.1163/156853975x00344
Begum M Alam MJ Islam MA Pal HK 2008 On the food and feeding habit of an estuarine catfish (Mystus gulio Hamilton) in the south-west coast of Bangladesh University Journal of Zoology, Rajshahi University 27 91 94 10.3329/ujzru.v27i0.1962
Cox TL Lance MJ Albertson LK Briggs MA Dutton AJ Zale AV 2023 Diet composition and resource overlap of sympatric native and introduced salmonids across neighboring streams during a peak discharge event PLoS One 18 1 e0280833 10.1371/journal.pone.0280833 36693054
Graham BS Grubbs D Holland K Popp BN 2007 A rapid ontogenetic shift in the diet of juvenile yellowfin tuna from Hawaii Marine Biology 150 647 658 10.1007/s00227-006-0360-y
Grismer LL 2011 Amphibians and reptiles of the Seribuat Archipelago (Peninsular Malaysia): A field guide Frankfurt, Germany Edition Chimaira
Hyslop EJ 1980 Stomach contents analysis: A review of methods and their application Journal of Fish Biology 17 4 411 429 10.1111/j.1095-8649.1980.tb02775.x
Jisr N Younes G Sukhn C El-Dakdouki MH 2018 Length-weight relationships and relative condition factor of fish inhabiting the marine area of the Eastern Mediterranean city, Tripoli-Lebanon The Egyptian Journal of Aquatic Research 44 4 299 305 10.1016/j.ejar.2018.11.004
Kennedy M Fitzmaurice P 1972 Some aspects of the biology of the gudgeon Gobio gobio (L.) in Irish waters Journal of Fish Biology 4 4 425 440 10.1111/j.1095-8649.1972.tb05690.x
Kroon F Phillips S Burrows D Hogan A 2015 Presence and absence of non-native fish species in the Wet Tropics region, Australia Journal of Fish Biology 86 3 1177 1185 10.1111/jfb.12614 25649431
Kwik JT Kho ZY Quek BS Tan HH Yeo DCJ 2013 Urban stormwater ponds in Singapore: Potential pathways for spread of alien freshwater fishes Bioinvasions Records 2 3 239 245 10.3391/bir.2013.2.3.11
Lavery RJ 1991 Physical factors determining spawning site selection in a Central American hole nester, Cichlasoma nigrofasciatum Environmental Biology of Fishes 31 203 206 10.1111/j.1095-8649.1972.tb05690.x
Lehtonen TK 2014 Colour biases in territorial aggression in a Neotropical cichlid fish Oecologia 175 1 85 93 10.1007/s00442-013-2879-1 24414236
Le Cren ED 1951 The length-weight relationship and seasonal cycle in gonad weight and condition in the perch (Perca fluviatilis) The Journal of Animal Ecology 20 201 219 10.2307/1540
Morato T Afonso P Lourinho P Barreiros JP Santos RS Nash RDM 2001 Length-weight relationships for 21 coastal fish species of the Azores, northeastern Atlantic Fisheries Research 50 3 297 302 10.1016/S0165-7836(00)00215-0
Oldfield RG 2011 Aggression and welfare in a common aquarium fish, the Midas cichlid Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science 14 4 340 360 10.1080/10888705.2011.600664 21932947
Poniente AJ Peña JTD Pol RM Zapanta LH Mudjekeewis DS 2019 First report of the non-native Midas cichlid, Amphilophus citrinellus (Gunther, 1864), in Laguna de Bay, Philippines The Philippine Journal of Fisheries 26 2 55 60 10.31398/tpjf/26.2.2019a0007
Purnamaningtyas SE Tjahjo DW 2017 Beberapa aspek biologi ikan oskar (Amphilophus citrinellus) di waduk IR. H. Djuanda, Jatiluhur, Jawa Barat BAWAL Widya Riset Perikanan Tangkap 3 1 9 16 10.15578/bawal.3.1.2010.9-16
Ricker WE 1973 Two mechanisms that make it impossible to maintain peak-period yields from stocks of Pacific salmon and other fishes Journal of the Fisheries Board of Canada 30 9 1275 1286 10.1139/f73-207
Rodríguez-Machado S Rodríguez-Cabrera TM 2015 First record of native amphibian predation by the invasive alien African catfish Clarias gariepinus (Siluriformes, Clariidae) in Cuba Pan-American Journal of Aquatic Science 10 3 254 258 10.5007/2175-7925.2018v31n2p53
Rogers W 1987 Sex ratio, monogamy and breeding success in the Midas cichlid (Cichlasoma citrinellum) Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 21 47 51 10.1007/BF00324434
Shahriza S Ibrahim J 2017 A survey of the amphibian species of Sungai Bubu, Anak Kurau, Perak, Peninsular Malaysia Russian Journal of Herpetology 24 1 54 62 10.30906/1026-2296-2019-24-1-54-62
Shalloof KAS Alaa M Aly W 2020 Feeding habits and trophic levels of cichlid species in tropical reservoir, Lake Nasser, Egypt The Egyptian Journal of Aquatic Research 46 2 159 165 10.1016/j.ejar.2020.04.001
Tampubolon PA Pradana IH Warsa A 2015 Determining monofilament gillnet optimum mesh size to mitigate Amphilophus citrinellus population outbreaks in Ir. H. Djuanda Reservoir Indonesian Fisheries Research Journal 21 2 67 74 10.15578/ifrj.21.2.2015.67-74
Tan HH Kelvin LKP Liew JH Low BW Lim RBH Kwik JTB Yeo DCJ 2020 The non-native freshwater fishes of Singapore: An annotated compilation Raffles Bulletin of Zoology 68 150 195
Zakaria-Ismail M Fatimah A Khaironizam MZ 2019 Fishes of the freshwater ecosystems of Peninsular Malaysia Mauritius LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing 356
Zarco A Corbalán V Debandi G 2020 Predation by invasive rainbow trout on the critically endangered Pehuenche spiny-chest frog Journal of Fish Biology 98 3 878 880 10.1111/jfb.14609 33161585
