
==== Front
JMIR Res Protoc
JMIR Res Protoc
ResProt
JMIR Research Protocols
1929-0748
JMIR Publications Toronto, Canada

v13i1e56436
39158944
10.2196/56436
Protocol
Protocol
Socioemotional Skills in the Teaching-Learning Process Mediated by Medium- and High-Fidelity Clinical Simulation in Nursing Students: Protocol for a Scoping Review
Mavragani Amaryllis
Ma Simone
Rodriguez Zuly
Al Mukhtar Salwa
Güngör Songül
Mahmood Hanady
Contreras-Ramos Luz Mery MSc https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1858-6789
1Faculty of Nursing Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia Carrera 33 # 30A -05 Bucaramanga, 680001 Colombia 57 607 685 45 00 ext 7060 luz.contrerasr@campusucc.edu.co

Laguado Jaimes Elveny MSc 1https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7169-6912

Jaimes Carvajal Nelly Esperanza MSc 1https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3167-5687

Pico Ferreira Marleny MSc 1https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2270-9902

Villamizar-Osorio Magda Liliana PhD 1https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4774-8545

1 Faculty of Nursing Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia Bucaramanga Colombia
Corresponding Author: Luz Mery Contreras-Ramos luz.contrerasr@campusucc.edu.co
2024
19 8 2024
13 e5643631 1 2024
22 3 2024
6 4 2024
15 4 2024
©Luz Mery Contreras-Ramos, Elveny Laguado Jaimes, Nelly Esperanza Jaimes Carvajal, Marleny Pico Ferreira, Magda Liliana Villamizar-Osorio. Originally published in JMIR Research Protocols (https://www.researchprotocols.org), 19.08.2024.
2024
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Research Protocols, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://www.researchprotocols.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.

Background

In nursing education, contact with real scenarios implies the design of favorable experiences to develop prioritization, reasoning, critical thinking, and management skills that support future practice. In the context of the teaching-learning process, simulation emerges as a support strategy, but its use and management require the knowledge and appropriation of teachers. Clinical simulation during education promotes growth in technical skills and aptitudes such as critical thinking, emotional management, organization, delegation, and teamwork. The culmination positively impacts the student, reflecting on their confidence, security, and adaptability to unexpected or unknown situations and risks.

Objective

The aim of this scoping review is to determine the socioemotional skills described during the teaching-learning process mediated by medium- and high-fidelity clinical simulation in nursing students.

Methods

The main concepts and limits of the research area will be determined according to the 5 phases of a scoping review proposed by Arksey and O’Malley. Research articles and postgraduate theses published between 2010 and 2023 in English and Spanish will be considered. Dissertation-type documents, book chapters, editorials, abstracts, and articles focused on clinical simulation among nursing professionals will be excluded. The articles will be retrieved from databases available at the Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia, along with CINAHL, Scielo, and PubMed. The search strategy will be based on the Population-Concept-Context framework. Article selection will be carried out by 2 independent evaluators who will review titles and abstracts in stage 1 and the full text in stage 2. A database of retrieved articles will be built with the variables of interest. A qualitative thematic analysis will be conducted by 5 independent reviewers to provide an overview of the literature, focusing on identifying similarities and contrasts between studies and contributions related to the aspects of social skills described in nursing students.

Results

The investigation has not yet started. The findings aim to focus on variables within the academic environment that, when correlated with the clinical simulation experience, may determine student learning. The working hypothesis is that students who experience greater satisfaction or possess better communication skills also demonstrate superior performance during high-fidelity simulation activities. The most relevant results will be contrasted considering the stated objective and knowledge gaps. Key aspects will also be compared with other reviews addressing related topics such as communication, self-efficacy, and self-confidence. Skills described by other authors that were not considered in the initial literature review will also be mentioned.

Conclusions

Educational institutions are responsible for including learning experiences in controlled environments such as medium- and high-fidelity simulation to ensure the acquisition of technical capabilities and additional socioemotional skills. Recognizing and managing emotions is necessary to provide adequate care for users of health care services and for the increased effectiveness of professionals.

Trial Registration

Open Science Framework p4ays; https://osf.io/p4ays

International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID)

PRR1-10.2196/56436

social skills
nursing students
high-fidelity simulation training
==== Body
pmcIntroduction

In the context of the teaching-learning process, simulation emerges as a support strategy; however, the use and management of simulators require the knowledge and appropriation of teachers [1]. Simulation is how a trained teacher creates scenarios to promote autonomous, collaborative learning along with critical and reflective thinking [2]. In turn, the mediator can formulate professional skills that respond to the needs of the context [3]. A requirement for this type of simulation is that teachers are trained in a pedagogical strategy for practice in the development of a model of enhancing competencies and clinical judgment in nursing [4].

Medium- and high-fidelity simulation has been used in nursing education. These scenarios reflect environments such as a hospital room, surgery room, or intensive care unit. Typically, a life-sized mannequin is used, which is connected to a computer system that simulates physiological variables such as vital signs, heart sounds, and respiratory sounds. The proposed cases can vary in complexity and aim for students to experience a situation similar to reality and acquire appropriate technical skills [5].

The implementation of this methodology among nursing students is supported by the use of technology for the training of facts and concepts, critical thinking, decision-making, and reasoning skills, which is then used to assess the progress of skills competencies and care interventions [6]. In this way, safe environments are generated that enable caring for a patient in a real situation, thus developing autonomous learning. Therefore, the main purpose of clinical simulation is to learn from significant experiences that allow building knowledge, representing a teaching-learning strategy that reflects the clinical practice environment, and finally offers the opportunity for evaluation of the training [7].

In nursing education, contact with real scenarios necessitates the design of favorable experiences to develop prioritization, reasoning, critical thinking, and management skills that support future practice [8]. Clinical simulation during education promotes technical skills and aptitudes, critical thinking, emotional management, organization, delegation, and teamwork, which has a positive impact on the student, reflecting on confidence, security, reaction to unexpected or unknown situations, and risk [9,10].

Barra and Calisto-Alegría [11] mentioned that simulation favors procedural skills through practice and repetition. They identified anxiety and shortcomings in the inputs, recommending methodological and didactic aspects in curricular proposals [11]. In addition, establishing socioemotional competencies of future nursing professionals will influence the quality of care, along with academic and effective performance via training, and improvement through clinical simulation is a favorable methodology for learning and evaluating socioemotional skills [12].

Understanding the patterns of communication in simulated situations in education is relevant as it generates trust in the clinical environment, which can in turn increase the efficiency of education in the processes of interaction with peers and patients [13].

Similarly, it is important to highlight the empathy that is required in nursing care, which is an art and the ethical center of the act of caring. The nurse is not exclusively limited to operational tasks, as nursing requires the establishment of interpersonal relationships with patients; therefore, communication and empathy are complementary to the knowledge and procedural skills necessary for an optimal condition of care. Through deliberate practice in simulation, one can effectively promote and improve the effectiveness of communication skills as well as the empathy and self-efficacy of students [14-16].

The aim of this study is to help identify the response patterns of teaching and learning methods or strategies. These patterns are manifested as emotional effects of students in a clinical simulation environment, which can cause tension, anxiety, and stress in students when facing nursing practices [17]. Toward this end, we will perform a scoping review to determine the socioemotional skills described during the teaching-learning process mediated by medium- and high-fidelity clinical simulation among nursing students.

Methods

Study Design and Registration

A scoping review will be carried out, which involves establishing the main concepts and their limits of a given area of research interest [18]. This study considers publications on the teaching-learning process for nursing in clinical simulation, high- and medium-fidelity simulation guides, and drug administration processes. The 5 phases proposed by Arksey and O’Malley [19] will be followed to carry out the review: (1) identifying the research question; (2) identifying relevant studies; (3) study selection; (4) charting the data; and (5) collating, summarizing, and reporting results.

This study represents the largest such investigation conducted as of January 2023 when the protocol was registered on the Open Science Framework under the identifier p4ays.

Eligibility Criteria

Full-text articles published on the central theme of the study, including postgraduate theses, studies using different quantitative methodologies, mixed methods studies, and systematic reviews, will be eligible for inclusion in the review. Articles published from 2010 to 2024 involving nursing student populations will be considered eligible. In addition, articles written in English and Spanish are considered. Dissertation-type documents, book chapters, editorials, abstracts, and articles focused on clinical simulation in nursing professionals will be excluded.

Information Sources

The databases available at the Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia (OVID Medicina y Enfermería, Science Direct, Sage Journals, Proquest Psychology Database, Proquest Social Science Database, Proquest UK & Ireland Database, Psycarticles, Redalyc, and Dialnet) and databases such as CINAHL, Scielo, and PubMed will be searched for relevant articles.

Search Strategy

The Population (or Participants)-Concept-Context framework recommended by the Joanna Briggs Institute [19] will be followed to identify the main concepts to orient the search strategy, which are summarized in Textbox 1.

Population-Concept-Context framework of the study.

Population

Nursing students

Concept

The personal set of abilities required to successfully interact and communicate with others, both verbally and nonverbally through gestures, body language, and personal appearance

Context

The teaching-learning process mediated by medium- and high-fidelity clinical simulation

To achieve standardization of search terms, the article’s keywords will be selected from the Descritores em Ciências da Saúde (DeCS) website for the descriptors in Spanish [20] and from Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) for the descriptors in English [21], which are presented in Table 1.

Table 1 Standardized search terms.

Spanish terms	English terms	Definition	
Enseñanza mediante simulación de alta fidelidad	High-fidelity simulation training	A controlled learning environment that closely represents reality	
Estudiantes de enfermería (synonyms: alumnos de enfermería, estudiante de enfermería)	Nursing students (synonyms: pupil nurses, pupil nurse)	Individuals enrolled in a school of nursing or a formal educational program leading to a degree in nursing	
Entrenamiento simulado	Simulation training (synonym: interactive learning)	A highly customized interactive medium or program that allows individuals to learn and practice real-world activities in an accurate, realistic, safe, and secure environment	
Modelos educacionales comunicación en salud	Educational model (synonyms: instructional models, instructional model, educational model)	Theoretical models that propose methods of learning or teaching as a basis or adjunct to changes in attitude or behavior. These educational interventions are usually applied in the fields of health and patient education but are not restricted to patient care	
Comunicación en salud (synonyms: información y comunicación en salud, información y comunicación en la salud)	Health communication (synonym: health communications)	The transfer of information from experts in the medical and public health fields to patients and the public; the study and use of communication strategies to inform and influence individual and community decisions that enhance health	
Habilidades sociales (synonym: habilidades socioemocionales)	Social skill (synonyms: social skills, social abilities, social ability, interpersonal skills, interpersonal skill, social competence)	The personal set of abilities required to successfully interact and communicate with others, both verbally and nonverbally through gestures, body language, and personal appearance	

Selection of Sources of Evidence

The search will begin in the databases available in the university library and then the literature review will be expanded to other open access databases. The compilation will be carried out in two stages.

The first stage involves title and abstract selection, which will be carried out by 2 reviewers independently considering the inclusion exclusion criteria. In this first stage, the selected keywords will be put to the test to verify that the articles that respond to the proposed theme are adequately recovered with these terms.

In the second stage, the full text of the articles selected in the first phase will be read by 2 reviewers independently and then the results obtained will be contrasted. Any disagreement between the 2 reviewers will be resolved by a third reviewer.

Data Charting Process

The extracted data will be organized in a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet, including the following aspects: title, bibliographic source, objective of the study, country of origin, type of study, design, evaluated social skills, simulation scenario, and level of the students.

Subsequently, a qualitative thematic analysis will be performed by 5 independent reviewers to offer an overview of the literature with the aim of identifying similarities, contrasts among authors, and contributions in the aspects of social skills described in nursing students. Because this is a scoping review, it will encompass many types of evidence and therefore it is not considered pertinent to apply bias control to the sources of information or the results of individual studies [22].

Synthesis of Results

The characteristics of the selected articles related to socioemotional skills mediated by clinical simulation as part of the teaching-learning process for nursing education will be described in detail. The data will be presented using summary tables and grouped figures.

Ethical Considerations

In accordance with current international regulations [23,24], this project does not require approval from an ethics committee, as the research does not involve the collection of new data from humans, does not present any risks to participants, and is based on the analysis of secondary data from previously published research.

Results

Selection of Sources of Evidence

The article selection process will be summarized using a PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) flowchart [22], as shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1 Example PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) flowchart for study inclusion.

Characteristics of Sources of Evidence

A table will be developed to summarize the main characteristics of the selected articles for the research objective, including the country where the study was conducted, design, and identified communication skills. The findings of this scoping review aim to focus on variables within the academic environment that, when related with the clinical simulation experience, may determine the outcomes of student learning. The working hypothesis posited is that students who experience greater satisfaction or possess better communication skills will also demonstrate superior performance during high-fidelity simulation activities.

Synthesis of Results

We will use a narrative approach for data extraction, including descriptions of author characteristics, year of publication, study design, objective, sample size, country, level of education, type of clinical simulation, and categorization by themes. The purpose is to consolidate knowledge about the study phenomenon. Toward this end, the 5 reviewers will apply criteria for critical reading to evaluate the evidence [25]. In case of any disagreement regarding theme categorization, resolution will be achieved through consensus among the reviewers.

Discussion

Summary of Evidence

Medium- and high-fidelity clinical simulation is a learning tool for technical capabilities and generates response patterns in students that can influence the acquisition of the socioemotional skills necessary for the adequate performance of nursing students in the real environment [26]. Social skills influence the academic and clinical performance of the student in training, complementing preparation for real-world scenarios.

We predict identifying a relationship between exposure to clinical simulation and the improvement of skills such as communication, self-confidence, and problem-solving, along with an increase in satisfaction perception.

The most relevant results will be contrasted considering the stated objective and knowledge gaps. Key aspects will also be compared with other reviews addressing related topics such as communication, self-efficacy, and self-confidence. Skills described by other authors that were not considered in the initial literature review will also be mentioned.

Limitations

Limitations related to the omission of gray literature or documents written in languages other than Spanish and English will be discussed, and recommendations for conducting future research will be proposed.

The main limitation is the lack of evaluation of the quality of the articles that will be selected; however, Arskey and O’Malley [18] specify that a scoping review does not aim to assess the quality of the evidence but rather to answer the research question. Additionally, there are limited studies on medium- and high-fidelity clinical simulation in nursing students available to date.

Conclusions

In accordance with the findings, the most significant results will be outlined. Providing adequate nursing care involves knowledge of equipment, advanced health care practices, and advanced technical capabilities. Educational institutions are responsible for including learning experiences in controlled environments such as medium- and high-fidelity simulation to ensure the acquisition of technical capabilities as well as socioemotional skills. Recognizing and managing emotions is necessary to provide adequate care for users of health care services and for the increased effectiveness of professionals.

This document is part of the project “Validity and reliability of the medication administration procedure guide for the development of high-fidelity simulation in nursing,” which was approved for financing in the Internal Call for Medium Amounts of the Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia (internal code INV3185).

Abbreviations

DeCS Descriptores en Ciencias de la Salud

MeSH Medical Subject Headings

PRISMA-ScR Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews

Authors' Contributions: All authors participated in the initial idea of the project, protocol design, and search strategy. MLVO, ELJ, and LMCR drafted the protocol. All authors contributed to the review, correction, and approval of the final version of the manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest: None declared.
==== Refs
1 Üzen Cura Ş Kocatepe V Yıldırım D Küçükakgün H Atay S Ünver V Examining knowledge, skill, stress, satisfaction, and self-confidence levels of nursing students in three different simulation modalities Asian Nurs Res 2020 08 14 3 158 164 10.1016/j.anr.2020.07.001 32653666 S1976-1317(20)30046-3
2 Ozdemir NG Kaya H The effectiveness of high-fidelity simulation methods to gain Foley catheterization knowledge, skills, satisfaction and self-confidence among novice nursing students: a randomized controlled trial Nurse Educ Today 2023 11 130 105952 10.1016/j.nedt.2023.105952 37639878 S0260-6917(23)00246-0 37639878
3 INACSL Standards Committee INACSL standards of best practice: SimulationSM simulation design Clin Simul Nurs 2016 12 12 S5 S12 10.1016/j.ecns.2016.09.005
4 Carrero-Planells A Pol-Castañeda S Alamillos-Guardiola MC Prieto-Alomar A Tomás-Sánchez M Moreno-Mulet C Students and teachers' satisfaction and perspectives on high-fidelity simulation for learning fundamental nursing procedures: a mixed-method study Nurse Educ Today 2021 09 104 104981 10.1016/j.nedt.2021.104981 34062333 S0260-6917(21)00238-0 34062333
5 Cengiz Z Gürdap Z Oltuluoğlu H Aslan H Aktura SÇ Developing nursing students' self-efficacy and problem solving skills via high-fidelity simulation Teach Learn Nurs 2023 10 18 4 e167 e173 10.1016/j.teln.2023.05.010
6 Cowperthwait A NLN/Jeffries simulation framework for simulated participant methodology Clini Simul Nurs 2020 05 42 12 21 10.1016/j.ecns.2019.12.009
7 Gómez-Pérez V Escrivá Peiró D Sancho-Cantus D Casaña Mohedo J In situ simulation: a strategy to restore patient safety in intensive care units after the COVID-19 pandemic? Systematic review Healthcare 2023 01 14 11 2 263 10.3390/healthcare11020263 36673631 healthcare11020263 36673631
8 Wagner EA Engaging nursing students in quality improvement: teaching safe medication administration J Nurs Educ 2022 05 61 5 268 271 10.3928/01484834-20220303-01 35522765 35522765
9 Yusef Contreras VA Sanhueza Ríos GA Seguel Palma FA Importancia de la simulación clinica en el desarrollo personal y desempeño del estudiante de enfermería Cienc Enferm 2021 12 27 39 1 13 10.29393/ce27-39isvf30039
10 Cabrera TAA Kempfer SS Clinical simulation in nursing teaching student experience in Chile Texto Contexto Enferm 2020 29 spe e20190295 10.1590/1980-265x-tce-2019-0295
11 Barra MJ Calisto-Alegría C Factores facilitadores y obstaculizadores del aprendizaje a través de la simulación Cienc Enferm 2023 02 08 29 1 1 11 10.29393/ce29-1ffmc20001
12 Sánchez EJ Impacto de las competencias socio-emocionales de los alumnos del grado en enfermería en prácticas clínicas reales y simuladas Universidad Católica San Antonio de Murcia 2019 2024-01-30 https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/tesis?codigo=285371
13 Lee U Choi H Jeon Y Nursing students' experiences with computer simulation-based communication education Int J Environ Res Public Health 2021 03 17 18 6 3108 10.3390/ijerph18063108 33803034 ijerph18063108 33803034
14 Foronda C MacWilliams B McArthur E Interprofessional communication in healthcare: an integrative review Nurse Educ Pract 2016 07 19 36 40 10.1016/j.nepr.2016.04.005 27428690 S1471-5953(16)30020-8 27428690
15 Wei H Watson J Healthcare interprofessional team members' perspectives on human caring: a directed content analysis study Int J Nurs Sci 2019 01 10 6 1 17 23 10.1016/j.ijnss.2018.12.001 31406864 S2352-0132(18)30521-0 31406864
16 Li J Li X Gu L Zhang R Zhao R Cai Q Lu Y Wang H Meng Q Wei H Effects of simulation-based deliberate practice on nursing students' communication, empathy, and self-efficacy J Nurs Educ 2019 12 01 58 12 681 689 10.3928/01484834-20191120-02 31794034 31794034
17 Gu M Sok SR Effects of simulation practicum using flipped learning for Korean nursing students Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020 09 18 17 18 6829 10.3390/ijerph17186829 32962057 ijerph17186829 32962057
18 Arksey H O'Malley L Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework Int J Soc Res Method 2005 02 8 1 19 32 10.1080/1364557032000119616
19 Levac D Colquhoun H O'Brien KK Scoping studies: advancing the methodology Implement Sci 2010 09 20 5 69 10.1186/1748-5908-5-69 20854677 1748-5908-5-69 20854677
20 DeCS/MeSH: Descritores em Ciências da Saúde 2024-01-30 https://decs.bvsalud.org/es/
21 MeSH (Medical Subject Headings) National Library of Medicine 2024-01-30 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/
22 Tricco AC Lillie E Zarin W O'Brien KK Colquhoun H Levac D Moher D Peters MD Horsley T Weeks L Hempel S Akl EA Chang C McGowan J Stewart L Hartling L Aldcroft A Wilson MG Garritty C Lewin S Godfrey CM Macdonald MT Langlois EV Soares-Weiser K Moriarty J Clifford T Tunçalp Özge Straus SE PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanation Ann Intern Med 2018 10 02 169 7 467 473 10.7326/M18-0850 30178033 2700389 30178033
23 Standards and operational guidance for ethics review of health-related research with human participants World Health Organization 2011 09 2024-08-12 https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241502948
24 WMA Declaration of Helsinki – Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects World Medical Association 2024-08-12 https://www.wma.net/policies-post/wma-declaration-of-helsinki-ethical-principles-for-medical-research-involving-human-subjects/
25 LoBiondo-Wood G Haber J Nursing research: methods and critical appraisal for evidence-based practice J Nurs Regul 2014 04 5 1 60 10.1016/s2155-8256(15)30102-2
26 Sánchez Expósito J Leal Costa C Díaz Agea JL Carrillo Izquierdo MD Jiménez Rodríguez D Socio-emotional competencies as predictors of performance of nursing students in simulated clinical practice Nurse Educ Pract 2018 09 32 122 128 10.1016/j.nepr.2018.07.009 30049574 S1471-5953(17)30764-3 30049574
