
==== Front
Nature
Nature
Nature
0028-0836
1476-4687
Nature Publishing Group UK London

36922613
5757
10.1038/s41586-023-05757-7
Matters Arising
Reply to: Common orthopaedic trauma may explain 31,000-year-old remains
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-5259-3819
Vlok Melandri Melandri.vlok@sydney.edu.au

1
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1167-4743
Maloney Tim t.maloney@griffith.edu.au

234
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6487-0043
Dilkes-Hall India Ella 5
Oktaviana Adhi Agus 67
Setiawan Pindi 8
Priyatno Andika Arief Drajat 9
Ririmasse Marlon 7
Geria I. Made 7
Effendy Muslimin A. R. 9
Istiawan Budy 9
Atmoko Falentinus Triwijaya 9
Adhityatama Shinatria 6
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2171-7145
Moffat Ian 10
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-0452-486X
Joannes-Boyau Renaud 1112
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2276-3258
Brumm Adam 3
Aubert Maxime 2311
1 grid.1013.3 0000 0004 1936 834X Sydney Southeast Asian Centre, University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales Australia
2 grid.1022.1 0000 0004 0437 5432 Griffith Centre for Social and Cultural Research, Griffith University, Gold Coast, Queensland Australia
3 grid.1022.1 0000 0004 0437 5432 Australian Research Centre for Human Evolution, Griffith University, Nathan, Queensland Australia
4 Research into Deer Genetics and Environment, RIDGE Group Inc, Ascot, Western Australia Australia
5 grid.1012.2 0000 0004 1936 7910 Archaeology, School of Social Sciences, University of Western Australia, Crawley, Western Australia Australia
6 grid.1022.1 0000 0004 0437 5432 School of Humanities, Languages and Social Science, Griffith University, Gold Coast, Queensland Australia
7 BRIN, OR Arkeologi, Bahasa dan Sastra, Pusat Riset Arkeometri, Jakarta, Indonesia
8 grid.434933.a 0000 0004 1808 0563 Faculty of Art and Design, Bandung Institute of Technology, Bandung, Indonesia
9 Balai Pelestarian Cagar Budaya Kalimantan Timur, Samarinda, Indonesia
10 grid.1014.4 0000 0004 0367 2697 Archaeology, College of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences, Flinders University, Bedford Park, South Australia Australia
11 grid.1031.3 0000000121532610 Geoarchaeology and Archaeometry Research Group (GARG), Southern Cross University, Lismore, New South Wales Australia
12 grid.412988.e 0000 0001 0109 131X Palaeo-Research Institute, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, South Africa
15 3 2023
15 3 2023
2023
615 7952 E15E18
© The Author(s) 2023
2023
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Subject terms

Anatomy
Social sciences
issue-copyright-statement© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Limited 2023
==== Body
pmcreply to Murphy et al. Nature 10.1038/s41586-023-05756-8 (2023)

We appreciate the accompanying technical Comment by Murphy et al.1—a group of practicing orthopaedic surgeons—on our original paper2. However, we strongly disagree with their conclusion that a reductionist approach was taken in the diagnosis of surgical amputation in a 31,000-year-old individual (TB1) from Borneo. We note that a complete systematic differential diagnosis was indeed completed (Extended Data Table 1); this process involved careful consideration of the most common and banal conditions first, such as accidental fracture, before considering the possibility of more rare and unusual circumstances. Through this iterative process, fracture was first eliminated as a possibility, followed by natural causes of amputation.

Surgical amputation was the remaining scenario left that completely described the characteristics that we observed in the bone. As is standard for palaeopathological analysis, a detailed description of the pathology was undertaken, including recording of the location and aspect of affected bone, the type of bone affected, the mechanism of injury, the degree of healing, complications to healing, force and fracture type. This detailed analysis means that certain aspects of trauma were excluded from the differential diagnosis due to the specific location of the injury. It was at this stage that physeal fractures, which Murphy et al.1 correctly recognize as common fractures in early adolescence, were disregarded from the differential diagnosis as the affected portion of the bone was at the site of the mid to distal lower third diaphysis and not near to the distal metaphyseal region (Fig. 1). We surmise that Murphy et al.1 may have mistaken the thin cortices of TB1’s tibia and fibula for that at the diaphyseal-to-metaphyseal transition in the bone that is naturally thin. However, with TB1, the cortices in these bones (and indeed also the left femur) are thin due to extreme atrophy that probably occurred over a number of years. We acknowledge that two-dimensional photographs and radiographs can misrepresent to readers injuries that, in reality, occur in three dimensions. Thus, we provide publicly available three-dimensional computed tomography files of the amputation.Fig. 1 A Salter–Harris type II fracture of left tibia and fibula similar to the one presented by Murphy et al. compared with TB1’s amputation.

The amputation site is more proximal (white box) to the region of Salter–Harris physeal fractures (white dashed oval). At minimum, three different angles of force are present in TB1’s amputation (red dashed lines) as opposed to one angle of force in Salter–Harris type II. Medial physis fracture of the tibia is absent in TB1 as is necessary for Salter–Harris type II classification with fibular involvement (see figure 1 of Murphy et al.1). Scale bar, 10.0 mm.

Moreover, the age of 6 to 9 years after surgery is a minimum age based on the minimal timing required for the completion of bone remodelling in the major long bones and, given the size of the lower limb bones, it is probable that the injury occurred in childhood. As Murphy et al.1 are aware, physeal stasis can have diverse traumatic origins as well as stasis of longitudinal growth in general3,4. Experimental animal studies demonstrate the importance for muscular activity to initiate longitudinal growth of bones through biomechanical strain. Thus, the small size of the left limb bones can be readily attributed to the existing evidence for bone atrophy related to muscle wastage5.

We are uncertain what Murphy et al.1 are referring to in their second paragraph when relating the cervical fracture to the force applied to the amputation site. Although it is possible that the cervical vertebral fracture occurred in the same event that led to the need for amputation of the lower limb, the limitations of bone response prevent us from investigating this possibility any further. Owing to the lack of empirical evidence, we refrain from speculating on the motivation or underlying cause that led to the decision to amputate. It is of course possible that the trauma described by Murphy et al.1 was the ultimate mechanism of injury that led to the child’s limb being surgically amputated at the location of the distal diaphysis. We clarify that we are not saying oblique fractures of the long bone shafts do not occur from blunt force trauma but are atypical in cases from an accident (excluding modern situations including transport), particularly one where the fibula and tibia were both fractured.

Murphy et al.1 point out in detail the requirements for their proposed scenario to have occurred but do not see the improbability of such a condition in the context of the Pleistocene tropics of Borneo. They do suggest soft tissue-only surgery as an alternative that would have involved antisepsis and debridement, which is arguably a far more sophisticated (and therefore less parsimonious) form of care that would have required a complex understanding of the anatomical basis for infection to specifically remove the infected tissue (rather than performing an entire amputation). If the fracture was not reduced through fixation, as is the case in modern Western surgical practices, a dead foot would have probably been an extreme impediment for the rugged mountainous terrain, and far more painful than a stump. Moreover, the fractured foot would have been susceptible to repeated infection as it was carried throughout the environment.

Murphy et al.1 incorrectly describe the remodelled bone as osteomyelitis. To support their argument, they report an anecdote in a review on the history of osteomyelitis that is from a single memoir of an American surgeon published in 1831, whose patients received treatment in hospital6. Osteomyelitis in the tropics is more aggressive owing to the greater diversity of the pathogens that cause osteomyelitis, the suitability of Staphylococcus aureus—the most common cause of osteomyelitis—to the humidity in the tropical belt and, potentially, the reduced amount of clothes worn in tropical environments increasing the infection risk of exposed wounds7,8. Although the mortality rate of untreated sepsis is not documented in the tropics, antibiotic-era in-hospital mortality rates in post-amputation contexts are reported to be as high as 10% and, in the Vietnam War, sepsis was attributed to 12% of deaths in surgical patients, the third leading cause of mortality in that conflict9–11. Osteomyelitis, both pyogenic and non-pyogenic, is readily observed in archaeological bone. In pyogenic forms, death of bone leading to sequestrum is readily observable surrounded by a shell of bone known as involucrum. Cloacae—pus draining holes—form to drain the pus from the medullary canal. Although there are circular holes in the bone, these are clearly a result of carnivore puncture and beetle scavenging marks, which are very common causes of post-mortem skeletal damage observed in Southeast Asian archaeological human skeletons (Fig. 2).Fig. 2 Cloacae of the right femur and tibia compared to carnivore puncture holes of the left tibia.

a–c, Comparison of cloacae of the right femur (a) and tibia (b) with the carnivore puncture holes of the left tibia (c). The left tibia holes are clearly caused by punctures in dry bone resulting in square jagged margins to the cavities. By contrast, the margins of the holes in the right tibia and femur are rounded due to the constant remodelling process in the development of the cloacae. The femoral cloaca (a) also presents with a clear lytic channel consistent with infection.

The radiographs of TB1’s amputated limb (Fig. 1) show a lack of bone radiolucency associated with the development of sequestra, and the localization of radiodense bone only intermediate to the tibia and fibula is consistent with myositis ossification, and not with osteomyelitis, which will result in subperiosteal inflammation and subsequent new bone development on a more diffuse scale around the infected site. The complete lack of subperiosteal change to the tibia and fibula away from the ossified region, as well as the initiation of the subperiosteal new bone, from both the tibia and the fibula, to meet intermediately, is consequently not consistent with osteomyelitis. Moreover, chronic osteomyelitis is expected to be associated with some level of continued subperiosteal activity observed as woven bone and, in this case, the bone is entirely lamellar. Evidence of osteomyelitis in the right limb is available for comparison as well as dry bone examples from prehistoric Southeast Asia associated with and without fracture12,13.

We do concede the error that the medial malleolus of the right tibia is not placed in anatomical position in figure 3a of our original paper2. However, the aim of this figure is to represent the general completeness of the skeleton, and the relationship of the size of the left and right limbs, which we believe the figure succeeds in presenting. Given the medial malleolus is barely discernible, we believe the matter of anatomical correctness to be negligible.

Reporting summary

Further information on experimental design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this Article.

Online content

Any methods, additional references, Nature Portfolio reporting summaries, source data, extended data, supplementary information, acknowledgements, peer review information; details of author contributions and competing interests; and statements of data and code availability are available at 10.1038/s41586-023-05757-7.

Supplementary information

Reporting Summary

Extended data figures and tables

Extended Data Table 1 Differential Diagnosis of Tebo 1 Refs. 14–27

Refs. 14–27

Extended data

is available for this paper at 10.1038/s41586-023-05757-7.

Supplementary information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s41586-023-05757-7.

Acknowledgements

We thank H. Rice for his collaboration on producing the CT scan data.

Author contributions

M.V., T.M., I.E.D.-H. and A.A.D.P. conceived and wrote the paper. T.M., I.E.D.-H. and A.A.D.P carried out the excavation of the site and burial. M.A. and A.B. conceived the study and contributed to the paper. Site access, project coordination and field logistics were facilitated by P.S., M.R., A.A.O., F.T.A., I.M.G., M.A.R.E., B.I. and S.A. M.V. conducted the osteological analyses. I.M. conducted the geophysical survey. R.J.-B. conducted the US–ESR dating analyses and the Bayesian modelling. All of the authors contributed to editing the paper.

Data availability

CT data are available at Figshare (https://figshare.com/projects/CT_Data_Tebo_TB1_Borneo_Kalimantan/150765).

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

These authors contributed equally: Melandri Vlok, Tim Maloney, India Ella Dilkes-Hall, Adhi Agus Oktaviana, Andika Arief Drajat Priyatno, Maxime Aubert

Deceased: Pindi Setiawan
==== Refs
References

1. Murphy, J., Davis, J., Tarrant, S. & Balogh, Z. Common orthopaedic trauma may explain 31,000-year-old remains. Nature10.1038/s41586-023-05756-8 (2023).
2. Maloney TR Surgical amputation of a limb 31,000 years ago in Borneo Nature 2022 609 547 551 10.1038/s41586-022-05160-8 36071168
Maloney, T. R. et al. Surgical amputation of a limb 31,000 years ago in Borneo. Nature 609, 547–551 (2022).36071168 10.1038/s41586-022-05160-8
3. Westberry DE Davids JR Pugh LI The Boyd amputation in children: indications and outcomes J. Pediatr. Orthop. 2014 34 86 91 10.1097/BPO.0b013e3182a007a0 23872807
Westberry, D. E., Davids, J. R. & Pugh, L. I. The Boyd amputation in children: indications and outcomes. J. Pediatr. Orthop. 34, 86–91 (2014).23872807 10.1097/BPO.0b013e3182a007a0
4. Krajbich IJ Lower-limb deficiencies and amputations in children JAAOS 1998 6 358 367 10.5435/00124635-199811000-00004 9826419
Krajbich, I. J. Lower-limb deficiencies and amputations in children. JAAOS 6, 358–367 (1998).9826419 10.5435/00124635-199811000-00004
5. Hall BK Herring S Paralysis and growth of the musculoskeletal system in the embryonic chick J. Morphol. 1990 206 45 56 10.1002/jmor.1052060105 2246789
Hall, B. K. & Herring, S. Paralysis and growth of the musculoskeletal system in the embryonic chick. J. Morphol. 206, 45–56 (1990).2246789 10.1002/jmor.1052060105
6. Smith, N. Medical and Surgical Memoirs (WA Francis, 1831).
7. Schaumburg F Alabi A Peters G Becker K New epidemiology of Staphylococcus aureus infection in Africa Clin. Microbiol. Infect. 2014 20 589 596 10.1111/1469-0691.12690 24861767
Schaumburg, F., Alabi, A., Peters, G. & Becker, K. New epidemiology of Staphylococcus aureus infection in Africa. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. 20, 589–596 (2014).24861767 10.1111/1469-0691.12690
8. Munshi B MacFater W Hill AG McCaig EH Paediatric osteomyelitis in Fiji World J. Surg. 2018 42 4118 4122 10.1007/s00268-018-4743-2 30051241
Munshi, B., MacFater, W., Hill, A. G. & McCaig, E. H. Paediatric osteomyelitis in Fiji. World J. Surg. 42, 4118–4122 (2018).30051241 10.1007/s00268-018-4743-2
9. Bickler SW Sanno-Duanda B Bone setter’s gangrene J. Pediatr. Surg. 2000 35 1431 1433 10.1053/jpsu.2000.16406 11051143
Bickler, S. W. & Sanno-Duanda, B. Bone setter’s gangrene. J. Pediatr. Surg. 35, 1431–1433 (2000).11051143 10.1053/jpsu.2000.16406
10. Shittu A Tropical pyomyositis: an update Trop. Med. Int. Health 2020 25 660 665 10.1111/tmi.13395 32219926
Shittu, A. et al. Tropical pyomyositis: an update. Trop. Med. Int. Health 25, 660–665 (2020).32219926 10.1111/tmi.13395
11. Blyth DM Yun HC Tribble DR Murray CK Lessons of war: combat-related injury infections during the Vietnam War and Operation Iraqi and Enduring Freedom J. Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2015 79 S227 S235 10.1097/TA.0000000000000768 26406435
Blyth, D. M., Yun, H. C., Tribble, D. R. & Murray, C. K. Lessons of war: combat-related injury infections during the Vietnam War and Operation Iraqi and Enduring Freedom. J. Trauma Acute Care Surg. 79, S227–S235 (2015).26406435 10.1097/TA.0000000000000768
12. Scott RM Domestication and large animal interactions: skeletal trauma in northern Vietnam during the hunter-gatherer Da But period PLoS ONE 2019 14 e0218777 10.1371/journal.pone.0218777 31483781
Scott, R. M. et al. Domestication and large animal interactions: skeletal trauma in northern Vietnam during the hunter-gatherer Da But period. PLoS ONE 14, e0218777 (2019).31483781 10.1371/journal.pone.0218777
13. Vlok M Paz V Crozier R Oxenham M A new application of the bioarchaeology of care approach: a case study from the metal period, the Philippines Int. J. Osteoarchaeol. 2017 27 662 671 10.1002/oa.2588
Vlok, M., Paz, V., Crozier, R. & Oxenham, M. A new application of the bioarchaeology of care approach: a case study from the metal period, the Philippines. Int. J. Osteoarchaeol. 27, 662–671 (2017).10.1002/oa.2588
14. Rouhani A Elmi A Aghdam HA Panahi F Ghafari YD The role of fibular fixation in the treatment of tibia diaphysis distal third fractures Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 2012 98 868 872 10.1016/j.otsr.2012.09.009 23153666
Rouhani, A., Elmi, A., Aghdam, H. A., Panahi, F. & Ghafari, Y. D. The role of fibular fixation in the treatment of tibia diaphysis distal third fractures. Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 98, 868–872 (2012).23153666 10.1016/j.otsr.2012.09.009
15. Bonnevialle P Distal leg fractures: how critical is the fibular fracture and its fixation? Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 2010 96 667 673 10.1016/j.otsr.2010.07.002 20851076
Bonnevialle, P. et al. Distal leg fractures: how critical is the fibular fracture and its fixation? Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 96, 667–673 (2010).20851076 10.1016/j.otsr.2010.07.002
16. Donnally C Orthopedic injuries associated with jet-skis (personal watercrafts): a review of 127 inpatients Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 2018 104 267 271 10.1016/j.otsr.2018.01.004 29410212
Donnally, C. et al. Orthopedic injuries associated with jet-skis (personal watercrafts): a review of 127 inpatients. Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 104, 267–271 (2018).29410212 10.1016/j.otsr.2018.01.004
17. Pennoyer GP Traumatic amputation of the thigh, complicated by both tetanus and gas gangrene with recovery JAMA 1930 95 342 343 10.1001/jama.1930.27210050001009
Pennoyer, G. P. Traumatic amputation of the thigh, complicated by both tetanus and gas gangrene with recovery. JAMA 95, 342–343 (1930).10.1001/jama.1930.27210050001009
18. Wen APY Successful ankle replantation in two cases with different presentations Arch. Plast. Surg. 2020 47 182 186 10.5999/aps.2018.00514 31462030
Wen, A. P. Y. et al. Successful ankle replantation in two cases with different presentations. Arch. Plast. Surg. 47, 182–186 (2020).31462030 10.5999/aps.2018.00514
19. Pannier S Congenital pseudarthrosis of the tibia Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 2011 97 750 761 10.1016/j.otsr.2011.09.001 21996526
Pannier, S. Congenital pseudarthrosis of the tibia. Orthop. Traumatol. Surg. Res. 97, 750–761 (2011).21996526 10.1016/j.otsr.2011.09.001
20. Abbas ZG Archibald LK Epidemiology of the diabetic foot in Africa Med. Sci. Monit. 2005 11 RA262 RA270 16049394
Abbas, Z. G. & Archibald, L. K. Epidemiology of the diabetic foot in Africa. Med. Sci. Monit. 11, RA262–RA270 (2005).16049394
21. Eisenberg KA Vuillermin CB Management of congenital pseudoarthrosis of the tibia and fibula Curr. Rev. Musculoskelet. Med. 2019 12 356 368 10.1007/s12178-019-09566-2 31228003
Eisenberg, K. A. & Vuillermin, C. B. Management of congenital pseudoarthrosis of the tibia and fibula. Curr. Rev. Musculoskelet. Med. 12, 356–368 (2019).31228003 10.1007/s12178-019-09566-2
22. Anderson E Peluso S Lettice LA Hill RE Human limb abnormalities caused by disruption of hedgehog signaling Trends Genet. 2012 28 364 373 10.1016/j.tig.2012.03.012 22534646
Anderson, E., Peluso, S., Lettice, L. A. & Hill, R. E. Human limb abnormalities caused by disruption of hedgehog signaling. Trends Genet. 28, 364–373 (2012).22534646 10.1016/j.tig.2012.03.012
23. Tadmor O Kreisbe G Achiront R Porat S Yagel S Limb amputation in amniotic band syndrome: serial ultrasonographic and Doppler observations Ultrasound Obstet. Gynecol. 1997 10 312 315 10.1046/j.1469-0705.1997.10050312.x 9444043
Tadmor, O., Kreisbe, G., Achiront, R., Porat, S. & Yagel, S. Limb amputation in amniotic band syndrome: serial ultrasonographic and Doppler observations. Ultrasound Obstet. Gynecol. 10, 312–315 (1997).9444043 10.1046/j.1469-0705.1997.10050312.x
24. Baker CJ Rudolph AJ Congenital ring constrictions and intrauterine amputations Am. J. Dis. Child. 1971 121 393 400 4326366
Baker, C. J. & Rudolph, A. J. Congenital ring constrictions and intrauterine amputations. Am. J. Dis. Child. 121, 393–400 (1971).4326366
25. Fisher R Cremin B Limb defects in the amniotic band syndrome Pediatr. Radiol. 1976 5 24 29 10.1007/BF00988658 1012791
Fisher, R. & Cremin, B. Limb defects in the amniotic band syndrome. Pediatr. Radiol. 5, 24–29 (1976).1012791 10.1007/BF00988658
26. Barber CG Immediate and eventual features of healing in amputated bones Ann. Surg. 1929 90 985 992 10.1097/00000658-192912000-00005 17866233
Barber, C. G. Immediate and eventual features of healing in amputated bones. Ann. Surg. 90, 985–992 (1929).17866233 10.1097/00000658-192912000-00005
27. Burns, K. R. Forensic Anthropology Training Manual (Routledge, 2015).
